You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > FDB or Roy?
November 16 2026 8.34am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

FDB or Roy?


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Jaha Flag 17 Sep 17 8.48am

Originally posted by manwitheagletattoo

What went on behind the scenes is anyone's guest, but De Boer was willing to change the 3 at the back style, be it pressure from above or what. The way we played against Burnley was a step in the right direction. I really think if De Boer was in charge today we would have got some points out of it.

Hodgson tried to play it safe today with the team and subs ( apart from Lee ) I would like to see over the next few matches a couple of the younger lads on the bench Ladapo and Lumeka

Edited by manwitheagletattoo (16 Sep 2017 8.32pm)

I think you can say goodbye to any youth making it into the team. Woy is a boring old fart, doesn't like to take risks


Edited by Jaha (17 Sep 2017 8.48am)

 

Dodger Lane Flag Merstham 17 Sep 17 8.58am

Sick of hearing the same old thing " we have a good squad on paper " We need a f***ing good squad on the pitch ,not on bloody paper .
At the very best we have 4 or 5 good players of premier league standard . The rest are either long term sick notes who are earning wages under false pretences or of championship standard at best.

The rot set in when pardew was given to long to win a game,
Again another Parish blunder , he just can not help himself,

It's for the good of the club, it's not , its for the good of Parish and always has been .
It's about time he made a statement and explained about what's been happening on and off the field at Palace , we supporters deserve that much. He is a not God as some on here seem to think.
Come on Parish we are waiting ?

 


A Lie travels round the world quicker than a man can put his trousers on

[Link]

manwitheagletattoo Flag Somewhere in England 17 Sep 17 9.03am

We are now in our fifth year in the Premiership and we should be up there with the like's of WBA, Southampton, Stoke, but we are not, every year its a relegation fight. The harsh reality is that we come up to quick with very little in the foundations. We do not have the infrastructure in the club to move forward and I believe that why manager's are coming and going and the reason why Sam left. We hardly have any scouting, our training ground needs updating as with the ground, and that all takes time.

Its a case were we are in the top league and we are doing everything possible to keep our heads above water and we are now seeing the results. The Sakho signing as it has been mentioned, to keep the fans happy, Yes we all wanted Sakho, but in reality there are our players out there that could have come in and done the same job at a lower price, Our priority was a striker and other area's.

All this pundit talk is very good, but most of them have never managed a football club in their life, and won't do because it is easier to stand there and tell everybody where thing are going wrong with clubs.

 


South London & Proud
Sometimes I really wonder if family are really worth it.
Because it doesn’t matter how time and affection you give
It’s never enough

Midlands Eagle Flag 17 Sep 17 9.06am

Originally posted by manwitheagletattoo

<snip>

All this pundit talk is very good, but most of them have never managed a football club in their life, and won't do because it is easier to stand there and tell everybody where thing are going wrong with clubs.

A bit like HOL posters you mean

 

Sportyteacher Flag London 17 Sep 17 9.08am

Originally posted by Tipp_Eagle

What do you reckon guys team Frank or Team Roy. Will Roy get the door after 4 losses in a row ? Dougie next ? On the revolving managerial door at palace .

What about Harry Redknapp now that he has time on his hands?

[Link]

Only joking...

 

pompeyeagle Flag Relocated to Shropshire 17 Sep 17 9.15am

Originally posted by manwitheagletattoo

What went on behind the scenes is anyone's guest, but De Boer was willing to change the 3 at the back style, be it pressure from above or what. The way we played against Burnley was a step in the right direction. I really think if De Boer was in charge today we would have got some points out of it.

Hodgson tried to play it safe today with the team and subs ( apart from Lee ) I would like to see over the next few matches a couple of the younger lads on the bench Ladapo and Lumeka

Edited by manwitheagletattoo (16 Sep 2017 8.32pm)

I can't see any of the young players getting a look in now unfortunately which is a shame because they can't do any worse.

 

Tipp_Eagle Flag Tipperary 17 Sep 17 9.40am

Originally posted by pompeyeagle

I can't see any of the young players getting a look in now unfortunately which is a shame because they can't do any worse.

We were a lot better last week against Burnley than we were against Southampton. I was a big Frank out man but it looked like he was bending towards a back 4 . In hindsight we should be careful what you wish for. Can't see a way out of the situation we are in at the. Moment. I don't think we are a worse team than last year . I think though other teams have gotten better because of their recruitment of better players. Where as we stood still virtually . Ok we got an injured sackho and rideaweld. They have not improved the team and no amount of changing managers is going to change that.

 


oh yeah ,fcuk off brighton.

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 17 Sep 17 10.00am

Parrish has made his bed, so we have to ride it out, and if Roy cant save us so be it. You have to give him the season now and if we are sunk by Christmas start planning a re-building, like Newcastle.

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

Painter Flag Croydon 17 Sep 17 10.15am

Originally posted by Croydonlad

No , every professional pundit and his brother thought it was a joke that anyone would want to try and change our playing DNA with the players we had , consequently we lost 4 on the trot and couldn't score in a brothel , and yesterday we lost number 5 .
Cant mess about with stupid experiments in the Premier League
Last week fans were like should have given him more time
Today after losing game 5 those same fans realise that those 4 games actually counted , and lo and behold we are adrift at the bottom !!!

I thought you were harsh on FDB, but you ultimately were proved right.
I find this blaming of Parish and the board difficult to understand, they employ people to do a job, who on past record should be able to achieve this. Then Parish and Co get let down by the entire coaching team and players, how on earth is it their fault, they have purchased players in every window.
The board have become a victim of their own success, let down by supposed football professionals.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Sep 17 10.22am

Once you appoint a manager and then get rid of him so soon, perhaps it is an admission that it was the wrong appointment in the first instance.But we all make mistakes.

Thing is we have gone from FDB with a plan of evolving the club and playing more the Ajax way over time, straight into "Firefighting" mode with Hodgson, playing a style people have said is in our DNA.

 

StrangerThing Flag Brisbane 17 Sep 17 11.22am

There us no such thing as DNA in this sense.These are vastly paid professional sports people who should be able to adapt.
We have a new manager, the old formation, the old style and the same result.
At least FDB was throwing youth at it. I'd take Hodgson now though, he is here and thats all that matters.
Its the squad, short and simple, needed an overhaul and didnt get it.

Makes we wonder if Sam decided it wasnt going to happen when we resigned Speroni and Delaney.

 

Pigglelet Flag Deepest Darkest Sussex 17 Sep 17 11.27am

It's our scouting and recruitment that needs to be brought up to Premier League standard PDQ - and that includes recruitment of managers.

 


"Better to keep your mouth shut and appear stupid than to open it and remove all doubt."
Mark Twain.

ger20 Flag London 17 Sep 17 11.31am

To be blunt we have a championship side playing in the EPL. Here are some facts to digest, if we take the last five games of last season, Spurs, Burnley, City, Hull and United, we lost four and did not score a goal, add to that the first five games of this season and the stark reality is that in the last ten games we have lost 9 and failed to score in any of them. Apart from the four goals against Hull who basically threw in the towel we are / were hopelessly. In the last ten games we have also had 3 managers. Sam looked at the squad and decided to quit while he was ahead. FDB realised half of the team was crap and told them so (he wasn't showing off, he was letting them know that at 47 he was still better than them). Roy is there for one last big pay day. Kelly, Ward, Dann, Punch, Chung, Mutch, PVA, Sahko, Hennessy are championship players at best. Tomkins, Cabye, Lula, Wickham would be squad players in most mid level EPL.teams. Which, Leaves Wilf, Townsend and Sahko as three players of genuine EPL qualify

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Sep 17 11.31am

Originally posted by StrangerThing

There us no such thing as DNA in this sense.These are vastly paid professional sports people who should be able to adapt.
We have a new manager, the old formation, the old style and the same result.
At least FDB was throwing youth at it. I'd take Hodgson now though, he is here and thats all that matters.
Its the squad, short and simple, needed an overhaul and didnt get it.

Makes we wonder if Sam decided it wasnt going to happen when we resigned Speroni and Delaney.

I understand what you are saying in the strict sense.

That said, the narrative in terms of teams seems to be the "West Ham way", "Wingers at Man Utd" etc etc and pundits and supporters use the word "DNA" to describe what has traditionally been the way the teams play.

In terms of "New manager,old formation...." he has only been in charge for 1 game, was only appointed a few days prior to it and I believe the team only had 2 training sessions during that time.

 

StrangerThing Flag Brisbane 17 Sep 17 11.49am

...but hasnt he returned to what they know...what they trained in under Sam. Or is the line now that they need time to adjust to what they couldn't adjust to.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Sep 17 11.52am

Originally posted by StrangerThing

...but hasnt he returned to what they know...what they trained in under Sam. Or is the line now that they need time to adjust to what they couldn't adjust to.

When you have lost 9 out of 10 games, confidence is a real factor and Hodgson cannot just wave a magic wand after a few days.

 

Pigglelet Flag Deepest Darkest Sussex 17 Sep 17 11.54am

Originally posted by StrangerThing

...but hasnt he returned to what they know...what they trained in under Sam. Or is the line now that they need time to adjust to what they couldn't adjust to.

Yes they have to unlearn what they learned under Sam and unlearn what they didn’t learn under FdB so they can learn again what they learned under Sam which is roughly what they’ll be learning under RH – if they can learn.

 


"Better to keep your mouth shut and appear stupid than to open it and remove all doubt."
Mark Twain.

est1905 Flag 17 Sep 17 1.55pm

Originally posted by Tipp_Eagle

What do you reckon guys team Frank or Team Roy. Will Roy get the door after 4 losses in a row ? Dougie next ? On the revolving managerial door at palace .


I think either will/would have done OK in their first season. The point is Hodgson should not be getting this opportunity because FdB should have been given much more time.
We probably would have won yesterday if FdB were still in charge as the signs at Burnley were we were very close to turning the corner. Now he's gone and RH comes in its rip up all the plans and start again. Square one.
This is why we'll go down if we end up doing so. Because Parish is a coward

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 17 Sep 17 1.57pm

Originally posted by manwitheagletattoo

We are now in our fifth year in the Premiership and we should be up there with the like's of WBA, Southampton, Stoke, but we are not, every year its a relegation fight. The harsh reality is that we come up to quick with very little in the foundations. We do not have the infrastructure in the club to move forward and I believe that why manager's are coming and going and the reason why Sam left. We hardly have any scouting, our training ground needs updating as with the ground, and that all takes time.

You make some good points. I think all of us would have hoped that by now, entering our 5th season in the top division, we would have found some stability and would not be embarking on yet another desperate fight to stave off relegation again.

Each season we have escaped the drop has given us another opportunity to build and progress but for various reasons, some avoidable others not so, we seem to end up back at square one. The position we are now in is pretty well identical to the one we were in 4 years ago during Holloway's short stay with us in our first season back in the Premier League.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 17 Sep 17 2.05pm

Originally posted by Painter

I thought you were harsh on FDB, but you ultimately were proved right.
I find this blaming of Parish and the board difficult to understand, they employ people to do a job, who on past record should be able to achieve this. Then Parish and Co get let down by the entire coaching team and players, how on earth is it their fault, they have purchased players in every window.
The board have become a victim of their own success, let down by supposed football professionals.

Managing Ajax does not make you qualified or able to manage us, especially in our condition. In addition to actual managing of the team there's more input, effort and opinion needed on transfers, which he hadn't done before, and in some cases it sounds like he didn't do here, but Parish was on yachts, water boarding and singing in karaoke. All on social media. That'll be our memory of this summer. Steve having a smashing time, not around face to face with Frank. But I suppose when you prefer to sign most of them on 31st August I can see why he was away the whole time.

Big errors.

 


COYP

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > FDB or Roy?