You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is Roy brave enough?
November 16 2026 8.21am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Is Roy brave enough?


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
rob1969 Flag Banstead Surrey 21 Sep 17 12.12pm

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

when I hear teams say that I read it as them trying to convince themselves that they're all leaders when in fact they're rudderless. In any team in sport our out of it you need a designated leader who takes control of things when goings are good or bad. If you leave it up to everyone you leave it up to no one. Sakho is captain material, Punch' is not.


Not too sure about that - he does plenty of communicating on the pitch - main problem is he just not playing well enough to continue to get picked each week.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Sep 17 12.15pm

Originally posted by rob1969


Not too sure about that - he does plenty of communicating on the pitch - main problem is he just not playing well enough to continue to get picked each week.

Calvin Andrew did plenty of pointing where people should be too.

 


COYP

Samjohnb Flag Selsdon 21 Sep 17 12.26pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Calvin Andrew did plenty of pointing where people should be too.

Against Southampton the bloke was pointing when they we're taking a throw in he's clueless. I don't understand why some people still rate him

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 21 Sep 17 1.14pm

Originally posted by Samjohnb

Against Southampton the bloke was pointing when they we're taking a throw in he's clueless. I don't understand why some people still rate him

He may do a lot of talking and pointing, but does anyone actually take any notice? Think it was the Swansea game where we had a free kick just outside the box. Cabaye picked the ball up but puncheon told townsend to take it. They both ignored him and cabaye took it....

 

chateauferret Flag 21 Sep 17 2.16pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

He may do a lot of talking and pointing, but does anyone actually take any notice? Think it was the Swansea game where we had a free kick just outside the box. Cabaye picked the ball up but puncheon told townsend to take it. They both ignored him and cabaye took it....

Zat right? In which case he's even less use than I thought.

The real problem with that free kick was that Milivojevic was not on the pitch.

Edited by chateauferret (21 Sep 2017 2.17pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

Dean_CPFC Flag South london 21 Sep 17 2.49pm

I feel sorry for Punch, he's putting in 100% and you can see he's desperate to put in a good performance but you can see the pressure to deliver is just heaping more pressure on him...its a negative downward spiral.

Bloke desperately needs a goal to take that pressure off, sure we'll see a different player after that.

 

Osvaldo Flag Epsom 21 Sep 17 3.49pm

First thing he should have done when he signed Sakho was to appoint him as captain and drop the out of form captain.
Give one or two of the youngsters a go, so far, they haven't let us down.
Is there an out of contract striker to partner Benteke in a 4-4-2 formation. We will not score goals with the big man on his own up front. Some has got to feed off him, what about the other Sako who scored the other night? We can't wait until January, I fear it will be too late. Sorry for my negativity!!!

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 21 Sep 17 4.04pm

Originally posted by Dean_CPFC

I feel sorry for Punch, he's putting in 100% and you can see he's desperate to put in a good performance but you can see the pressure to deliver is just heaping more pressure on him...its a negative downward spiral.

Bloke desperately needs a goal to take that pressure off, sure we'll see a different player after that.

How long have wd been saying that and how much longer does he get.....

 

Username Flag Horsham 22 Sep 17 7.32pm

Originally posted by Dean_CPFC

I feel sorry for Punch, he's putting in 100% and you can see he's desperate to put in a good performance but you can see the pressure to deliver is just heaping more pressure on him...its a negative downward spiral.

Bloke desperately needs a goal to take that pressure off, sure we'll see a different player after that.

The more he plays the worse it will get I think right now.

We'd be better off taking him out of the side for a few weeks. I reckon Punch is far more likely to get a goal coming off the bench after a break.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Palace_Guard Flag Kyiv 22 Sep 17 9.09pm

no thanks, captaincy is a poisoned chalice. i would rather Mama concentrate on his own game naturally, than take on the whole teams responsibility.

Maybe Dann or McArthur ?

 


Live in Melbourne or Victoria, Australia?
Support Crystal Palace?

Well join the Crystal Palace Melbourne Supporters Club:
[Link]

Adelaide, South Australia? Join here:
[Link]

VinceHilaire Flag London 23 Sep 17 2.34pm

Yes he is btrave enough!

You have my total respect ROY!

 

Palace_Guard Flag Kyiv 23 Sep 17 6.40pm

Puncheon is still club captain. But it was good he was dropped finally.

 


Live in Melbourne or Victoria, Australia?
Support Crystal Palace?

Well join the Crystal Palace Melbourne Supporters Club:
[Link]

Adelaide, South Australia? Join here:
[Link]

Mr. Talons Flag Southampton 23 Sep 17 9.30pm

Originally posted by Osvaldo

First thing he should have done when he signed Sakho was to appoint him as captain..

I completely disagree.

I've seen this situation many times throughout my life, not only in football but in other businesses too.

A new boss gets hired and makes a new signing the captain, leading to resentment among the incumbent players, especially the older and more experienced ones, who feel that they have been looked over, the result of which is discontent in the dressing room.

Think about it - how would YOU feel?

I always plump for the senior defender as captain, so if Delaney's not in the first XI, then it has to be Dann.

Let Sakho put a few years in, before he's even considered.


 

boo909 Flag Figeac 23 Sep 17 10.45pm

Originally posted by Mr. Talons

I completely disagree.

I've seen this situation many times throughout my life, not only in football but in other businesses too.

A new boss gets hired and makes a new signing the captain, leading to resentment among the incumbent players, especially the older and more experienced ones, who feel that they have been looked over, the result of which is discontent in the dressing room.

Think about it - how would YOU feel?

I always plump for the senior defender as captain, so if Delaney's not in the first XI, then it has to be Dann.

Let Sakho put a few years in, before he's even considered.


I'm not sure who should be captain but definitely not Dann, it totally destroyed his game last time and he's still not recovered.

 


Bangell - If Camus wrote The Myth of Sisyphus today, it would be about Jason Puncheon eternally trying and failing to pass with his right foot.

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 23 Sep 17 10.53pm

Originally posted by Mr. Talons

I completely disagree.

I've seen this situation many times throughout my life, not only in football but in other businesses too.

A new boss gets hired and makes a new signing the captain, leading to resentment among the incumbent players, especially the older and more experienced ones, who feel that they have been looked over, the result of which is discontent in the dressing room.

Think about it - how would YOU feel?

I always plump for the senior defender as captain, so if Delaney's not in the first XI, then it has to be Dann.

Let Sakho put a few years in, before he's even considered.


For real? we've been there and Dann melted as Captain, even Dann i'm sure would agree, the arm band shouldn't go to him.

Lets remember the players did apparently beg for Sakho to be signed, they know and respect his class. Don't think it would put any noses out of joint.

Also we're talking about a player who was captain of PSG first team at the age of 17! He's a born leader.. People only get pissed when they think someone has taken there job, in this instance theres clearly a vacancy that so far none of them have been able to occupy.

Sakho, nailed on captain material in my mind.

 

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 23 Sep 17 11.15pm

Roy is the right man for the job

#keepthefaith

 

eagleincroydon Flag 24 Sep 17 3.15pm

from media outlets like talksport theres former players talking positives about hodgeson, with hes hands on approach and organisation skills as examples
getting best out of players

 

Selhurstboys Flag Basel 24 Sep 17 3.57pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

For real? we've been there and Dann melted as Captain, even Dann i'm sure would agree, the arm band shouldn't go to him.

Lets remember the players did apparently beg for Sakho to be signed, they know and respect his class. Don't think it would put any noses out of joint.

Also we're talking about a player who was captain of PSG first team at the age of 17! He's a born leader.. People only get pissed when they think someone has taken there job, in this instance theres clearly a vacancy that so far none of them have been able to occupy.

Sakho, nailed on captain material in my mind.

I completely agree. We need someone with natural leadership ability (if not a bit of a psycho) to get these players performing. Let's be honest not much is going to come from the kind gentleman on the touchline so we need a really strong personality on the pitch. Dann is not the right character imo...I'm not even sure he's good enough to be in the starting xi.

 

Mr. Talons Flag Southampton 01 Oct 17 12.13am

Originally posted by Selhurstboys We need someone with natural leadership ability (if not a bit of a psycho) to get these players performing. Let's be honest not much is going to come from the kind gentleman on the touchline so we need a really strong personality on the pitch. Dann is not the right character imo...I'm not even sure he's good enough to be in the starting xi.

I'm bumping this thread to stick my head above the parapet.

Is Roy brave enough? I think that today's selections would prove so.

Delaney is the natural leader of this squad: a gung-ho type with a dose of psycho, who rolls his sleeves up and rallies those around him, always ready with the arm around the shoulder. Yes, he may not be the most stylish of players, but sometimes you need players like him in the trenches.. and we are in the trenches. He's got the bottle for it and I don't get that feeling from any other player in the squad.

Regarding Sakho: he had a poor game today imo. His body language was terrible, he didn't communicate with his team mates, he was often caught facing the wrong way and gave away two goals: one with an attempted showboat pass that went wrong, when he should have hoofed it.. and one with a godawful schoolboy header mistake, reminiscent of Birchenall at his worst. It was clear today that he is not the Messiah: he's just another centre half with delusions of grandeur. When defending their attacks, I caught him time and again not marking anyone, just standing facing the wrong way. I also sensed some resentment between him and some team mates, which is to be expected. (See previous posts in this thread). He needs to knuckle down, roll his sleeves up and get on with the job. To be a good professional footballer requires hard work and dedication: all I got from him today was arrogance. He needs to sort out his attitude, which may explain why Liverpool wanted rid and why nobody else seemed that interested in him. He needs a lot of work, in my opinion, in order to become a Beckenbauer, rather than a Balotelli.

And he needs to sort out that injury that he's obviously carrying, too.

Edited by Mr. Talons (01 Oct 2017 12.34am)

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 01 Oct 17 12.24am

Originally posted by Mr. Talons

I'm bumping this thread to stick my head above the parapet.

Is Roy brave enough? I think that today's selections would prove so.

Delaney is the natural leader of this squad: a gung-ho type with a dose of psycho, who rolls his sleeves up and rallies those around him, always ready with the arm around the shoulder. Yes, he may not be the most stylish of players, but sometimes you need players like him in the trenches.. and we are in the trenches. He's got the bottle for it and I don't get that feeling from any other player in the squad.

Regarding Sakho: he had a poor game today imo. His body language was terrible, he didn't communicate with his team mates, he was often caught facing the wrong way and gave away two goals: one with an attempted showboat pass that went wrong, when he should have hoofed it.. and one with a godawful schoolboy header mistake, reminiscent of Birchenall at his worst. It was clear today that he is not the Messiah: he's just another centre half with delusions of grandeur. When defending their attacks, I caught him time and again not marking anyone, just standing facing the wrong way. I also sensed some resentment between him and some team mates, which is to be expected. (See previous posts in this thread). He needs to knuckle down, roll his sleeves up and get on with the job: to be a good professional footballer is hard work and dedication: all I got from him today was arrogance. He needs to sort out his attitude, which may explain why Liverpool wanted rid and why nobody else seemed that interested in him. He needs a lot of work, in my opinion, in order to become a Beckenbauer, rather than a Balotelli.

Edited by Mr. Talons (01 Oct 2017 12.19am)

Jesus , Sako has one bad game and you slag him off. He had to cover for ward, delaney (who whatever you say shouldn't be anywhere near the first team) and PVA, who were all s**t. I was watching him too, and I lost count of the number of times he was pulled out of position to cover one of the fullbacks.

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is Roy brave enough?