This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by europalace
Zaha quoted i that article: “I slightly think he should have got a bit more time" Note the words 'slightly' and 'a bit' Maybe you should question your support as you're deliberately mis-quoting one of Palace's best players. Therefore, why don't you change the title of the thread to contain what Zaha actually quoted? doesn't matter the sentiment is the same and he thought he should have had more time. Whatever though it won't change anything
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
Pointless thread. It doesn't matter what any player may of said, de Boer is gone and he isn't coming back. Time for us all to move on. The king is dead, long live the king and all that. The only thing that matters is whether Hodgson can get 40 points on the board by next May
|
|
|
Originally posted by gmostone
Does any of this nonsense you're gibbering away about actually make sense to you?
Bexley Dave Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing! "The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum) |
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Fat chance of that happening. Who did the all conquering Leeds United sack as manager after only 44 days? Most people apart from teenagers will know the answer and that was 43 years ago so no chance any of our unwanted records will be quickly forgotten Southampton sacked Nigel Adkins (who got them in the Premier League) everyone moaned, then it clearly turned out to be the right decision and everyone shut up. More recently Leicester and Chelsea were heavily criticised for dumping their managers (who’d done so much for them), does anyone care now? Nope. This debacle will be easily forgotten, especially if we start getting results.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Fat chance of that happening. Who did the all conquering Leeds United sack as manager after only 44 days? Most people apart from teenagers will know the answer and that was 43 years ago so no chance any of our unwanted records will be quickly forgotten I wonder if Michael Sheen will make a film adaptation about FDB's departure too. FDB could be played by a coma patient strung up like a marionette
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Mstrobez
Well that settles it, the biggest footballing genius at the club by a country mile is on my side of the argument. Anyone who believes he should've gone - your argument has now been made redundant or I would seriously question your support Edited by Mstrobez (21 Sep 2017 11.24pm) Complete and utter bollocks. It is one man's opinion and it's no more his shout than it is yours. There's a bit of a difference between a few doubters and widespread disagreement.
============ |
|
|
Originally posted by europalace
Zaha quoted i that article: “I slightly think he should have got a bit more time" Note the words 'slightly' and 'a bit' Maybe you should question your support as you're deliberately mis-quoting one of Palace's best players. Therefore, why don't you change the title of the thread to contain what Zaha actually quoted? Not at all. That for me means one more game... Which alot have wondered why he didn't after the massive Burnley improvement. If anyone's twisting peoples words it's you
|
|
|
Originally posted by matthau
Not at all. That for me means one more game... Which alot have wondered why he didn't after the massive Burnley improvement. If anyone's twisting peoples words it's you Nope, I've just quoted word for word from the article - fact. The OP changed the words to try and open yet another pointless thread. Edited by europalace (22 Sep 2017 10.49am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
having reflected on it a bit, the decision to fire him before Southampton wasn't great. Dr Boer had found a way to get them playing up at Burnley and, whatever you think of him, Hodgson was always going to change things for Southampton, potentially making us more disjointed, given the radical direction we'd been taken in. If we had beaten the saints, give de Boer the next three. if we lose to the saints, change it. Hodgson then loses three games we were always going to lose -- no harm done. and parish looks a little less impatient. So I too slightly think de Boer should've been given a bit more time. Fair based on football only. I would've monitored it game by game which would've cut his suicidal formations as well. Thing is the decision wasn't made on football/results only.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Crystal_Clear
I wanted FDB to succeed at Palace, and he would have been given more time at Palace, But he caused his own problems. From pre-season he should have see that we did not have players to play a 3-4-3 system. That should have been a gradual change. He picked players that everyone can see are good enough (ie. puncheon & lee) He basically didn't want Ward as he couldn't play as a wing back, but then realised he had non one else. Good player motivation, picking someone you have basically told you don't want. Perhaps he asked for players that did suit the system that he wanted to play but for one reason or another they didn't get signed. You claim that he picked players that everyone could see weren't good enough. Everyone except Hodgson, de Boer, Allardyce and Pardew you mean. Having claimed that he picked players that "everyone could see weren't good enough" you then complain that he tried to sell Ward who is another that "everyone could see wasn't good enough" but then played him when a suitable wing back wasn't signed. Ronald Koeman did exactly the same with Oumar Niasse by trying to sell him to us yet when that fell through he put him in the cup team and Niasse responded by scoring a goal yet there is no mention there of poor player motivation
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Perhaps he asked for players that did suit the system that he wanted to play but for one reason or another they didn't get signed. You claim that he picked players that everyone could see weren't good enough. Everyone except Hodgson, de Boer, Allardyce and Pardew you mean. Having claimed that he picked players that "everyone could see weren't good enough" you then complain that he tried to sell Ward who is another that "everyone could see wasn't good enough" but then played him when a suitable wing back wasn't signed. Ronald Koeman did exactly the same with Oumar Niasse by trying to sell him to us yet when that fell through he put him in the cup team and Niasse responded by scoring a goal yet there is no mention there of poor player motivation None of these managers tried to play players in a formation they simply can't. Frank could've played passing football with 4 at the back but put as at risk with his project and is negligent for doing so. You say about the failures of transfers but he would never have been able to achieve what he wanted with £40 mil net. Maybe in another country, but not here.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
having reflected on it a bit, the decision to fire him before Southampton wasn't great. Dr Boer had found a way to get them playing up at Burnley and, whatever you think of him, Hodgson was always going to change things for Southampton, potentially making us more disjointed, given the radical direction we'd been taken in. If we had beaten the saints, give de Boer the next three. if we lose to the saints, change it. Hodgson then loses three games we were always going to lose -- no harm done. and parish looks a little less impatient. So I too slightly think de Boer should've been given a bit more time. Roy did as Frank should have done , he started with the same team that everyone thought did well at Burnley (one change that was obvious had to be done) , and let them have a go and watched them. Now he will start to make whatever changes he thinks will improve the team.
|
|
|
Originally posted by gmostone
Does any of this nonsense you're gibbering away about actually make sense to you? Yes, because I grew up in the area, and I'm 23. Ask any person locally below the age of 25 what Wilf meant in the context of that sentence coinciding with the way he normally speaks and theyll tell you. People are shooting the messenger because they disagree with the actual statement. I literally just posted what he said. Bexleydave doing his usual brown nosing " Edited by Mstrobez (22 Sep 2017 12.10pm)
We're the Arthur over ere! |
|
|
Originally posted by MKCPFC
Roy did as Frank should have done , he started with the same team that everyone thought did well at Burnley (one change that was obvious had to be done) , and let them have a go and watched them. Now he will start to make whatever changes he thinks will improve the team. Roy was definitely pragmatic (in a good way) v saints. I just think there was something radical about de Boer's whole approach (for better or worse) that meant Roy was always going to struggle to continue with it. he came in on Wednesday and was either sitting and watching how we worked, or changing everything. neither was going to dramatically improve our odds of winning that match. there was a chance that de Boer got us a win with a commanding performance like the one up at Burnley. and if that had happened, it would have been appropriate to persist with him through 3 horrible games, after which the decision to sack him would have been all the more apparent and outwardly fair (which is fairly important for subsequent recruitment). it's water under the bridge now, and I take on board the point it wasn't only about the football. but I do think we've had a terrific amount of disparaging spin about de Boer coming out of the club. de Boer himself has largely kept quiet.
If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities. |
|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
it's water under the bridge now, and I take on board the point it wasn't only about the football. but I do think we've had a terrific amount of disparaging spin about de Boer coming out of the club. de Boer himself has largely kept quiet. Interesting point that. When the club is looking for a new manager or players absolutely nothing leaks out of the club but when something happens that the media and fans feel shows the club and it's chairman in a poor light it becomes leakier than a colander. Personally I view it exactly the same as when friends separate and divorce as you hear both sides of the story yet they are completely different with neither being the whole truth.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.