You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > When Reality Sets In
November 16 2026 8.21am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

When Reality Sets In


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 26 Sep 17 1.03pm

That is the biggest understatement of them all.

And which principles,.....? The one of 3/5 at the back which he barely ever used before? Don't get it wrong there, the system he tried to introduce has NOTHING and NOTHING at all to do with the system Ajax traditionally played and plays but I feel everything with Conte winning the League with it and Holland using it at the Worldcup in Brazil.
With the squad we had it was totally obvious that it was going to be needlessly complicated and difficult and it is unforgivable he did not (want to) see that.


Originally posted by Dixie Eagle


Is that true? He should never have ben hired in the first place then. His philosophy and principles are obviously paramount to him.

Personally, I think we should've just let him get on with it. To replace one of the best footballers of the last 30 years and a young, promising manager with the man who led England to defeat against Iceland is ridiculous!

Edited by DutchEagleJohan (26 Sep 2017 1.04pm)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 26 Sep 17 1.08pm

Originally posted by Dixie Eagle

Is that true? He should never have ben hired in the first place then. His philosophy and principles are obviously paramount to him.

Personally, I think we should've just let him get on with it. To replace one of the best footballers of the last 30 years and a young, promising manager with the man who led England to defeat against Iceland is ridiculous!

Roy is a well respected coach so probably not ridiculous. Deserved a point v Southampton, played well 1st half at Man City. What might do him is lack of points now, games left, striker shambles and any further injuries. He's very studious, methodical and respectful of his privileged position. He and many others are just not cut out to manage England in tournaments. I think the last few opponents all behind the ball we were unable to cope with. Some of the unfit players going instead of in form players he also got wrong, as have many others.

There were hints from what Frank said as to what he was about.

'Gradual' then '3-4-3 suits the players. Fvck off it does. The established clubs it does.

Something about wanting to manage in the prem and ''it just happened to be us'', coinciding with 3-4-3, and that's after that agent rubbish calling Parish to say Frank wasn't interested in Southampton. I believe the phone call. I don't believe Frank or his agent.

All that guff about it being a long term project and the academy. He would've been off talking to a top 6 team in secret before Parish knew about it.

 


COYP

Midlands Eagle Flag 26 Sep 17 1.19pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Roy is a well respected coach so probably not ridiculous. Deserved a point v Southampton, played well 1st half at Man City. What might do him is lack of points now, games left, striker shambles and any further injuries. He's very studious, methodical and respectful of his privileged position.

Yet when Sam walked away Roy Hodgson consistently came bottom of the popularity polls on here and stood out as the one candidate that almost no-one wanted

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 26 Sep 17 1.26pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Yet when Sam walked away Roy Hodgson consistently came bottom of the popularity polls on here and stood out as the one candidate that almost no-one wanted

Maybe but aside from the fact he's the only unemployed and cheaper option left and willing, his strategy is more comparable to what's worked before. I also don't buy this opinion that all of Pulis, Pardew's (when successful) and Sam's football was awful to watch. It wasn't just lump it to the penalty spot. It became that 2nd half v Southampton but in the 1st half and without wilf there was some decent play between Ruben and Benteke. And then in the 1st half v Man City some more decent play. I said at ht it was good it the same needed in the 2nd half. So going on that the 1st halves have been promising, but it's the sh1t out of his control he could do without.

 


COYP

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 26 Sep 17 2.00pm

The realty may very well be that in 3 weeks time we are played 8 lost 8 scored 0. This would likely mean we have 30 games and a -10 points difference to make up. Logic says if that is the position we are dead but miracles can happen and escape would be the greatest achievement ever by a Palace team.

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

dreamwaverider Flag London 26 Sep 17 2.11pm

Our defence in theory is now good. What we are crying out for is attack and goals.
We need to give Ladapo a run over the next few games. He certainly can't do worse than Benteke.......) goals.

 

palacebob Flag melton mowbray 26 Sep 17 2.40pm

There has to be something fundamentally wrong at the club too many managers too quickly, good managers running out the door though some not too honestly,ive lots of time for sp but it don't add up, it ain't right, and if Roy can do it any differently I will be surprised
Add a forward add a defender add a play maker none will take too long to see it ain't just Wayne, puncheons or bentekes fault slate them all u like but it's a bigger problem than them.
Love to know what really is happening on second thoughts sometimes best to be a mushroom

 

est1905 Flag 26 Sep 17 5.11pm

Originally posted by Croydonlad

Now after 6 games the reality of our season is slowly sinking in
It seems that my calling of FDB sacking after the Huddersfield game wasn't so " stupid " and " idiotic " as it was claimed at the time
Make no mistake
Any other system with the squad we had and we would have got at least 5 points from those opening 4 games
By not playing it simple , we lost the lot , ruined confidence and now barring a miracle we are down

I think Parish employing someone, asking them to change the way we play, giving them zero support in the transfer market and then sacking him after 4 games without giving any chance for changes to work could be described as stupid and idiotic yes.
Who knows how many points we'd have now if FDB were still in charge. One things for 100% certain. We wouldn't have any less!

 

cols123 Flag beckenham 26 Sep 17 5.51pm

Sorry can you please repeat yourself Croydonladypart

I can't hear you over all the menstruation

 

Painter Flag Croydon 26 Sep 17 8.04pm

Originally posted by est1905

I think Parish employing someone, asking them to change the way we play, giving them zero support in [/b]the transfer market

Factually incorrect.

Edited by Painter (26 Sep 2017 8.05pm)

 

est1905 Flag 26 Sep 17 8.19pm

Originally posted by Painter

Factually incorrect.

Edited by Painter (26 Sep 2017 8.05pm)

Er no it isn't.
Reidewald was recommended by de Boer but supposed to be a squad player. Everyone else signed were on the clubs target list BEFORE de Boer arrived including Foss Mensah so how much support would YOU say Parish gave de Boer?
I would say zero. If you are one of those 'the chairman can do no wrong' fans I guess you'll attempt to put some bulls hit spin on it

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 26 Sep 17 8.38pm

Originally posted by est1905

I think Parish employing someone, asking them to change the way we play, giving them zero support in the transfer market and then sacking him after 4 games without giving any chance for changes to work could be described as stupid and idiotic yes.
Who knows how many points we'd have now if FDB were still in charge. One things for 100% certain. We wouldn't have any less!

Both Parish and Frank are at fault on this one. For it to work it would've taken 3, possibly 2 windows. That's essentially where it went disastrously wrong. Either of them thinking our budget could achieve that from where we were was never likely to work.

 


COYP

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 26 Sep 17 9.05pm

Originally posted by est1905

I think Parish employing someone, asking them to change the way we play, giving them zero support in the transfer market and then sacking him after 4 games without giving any chance for changes to work could be described as stupid and idiotic yes.
Who knows how many points we'd have now if FDB were still in charge. One things for 100% certain. We wouldn't have any less!

If you employ someone to SLOWLY bring about a change in style and they immediately go against this agreement. You think it's stupid for sacking them and not backing them with all the clubs money?

Mistake made, and corrected.

To say we should have backed him when you hear all the rumors of unrest and see how out of depth he had players playing.. Really?

Seriously crucify Parish for giving him the job in the first place if you want, but to say he should then compound the mistake by backing him and keeping him in the post, when he's clearly gone rogue. Na, he had to go..

And i very much did want him to be a success, but he absolutely had to go.

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 26 Sep 17 9.06pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Both Parish and Frank are at fault on this one. For it to work it would've taken 3, possibly 2 windows. That's essentially where it went disastrously wrong. Either of them thinking our budget could achieve that from where we were was never likely to work.

Completely agree.

 

Medway Eagle Flag Whitstable Kent 26 Sep 17 9.25pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Both Parish and Frank are at fault on this one. For it to work it would've taken 3, possibly 2 windows. That's essentially where it went disastrously wrong. Either of them thinking our budget could achieve that from where we were was never likely to work.

=========================================================
I disagree I think Parish has now had 9 windows to get the squad right

 

moylerg Flag Cofton Hackett, Worcestershire 26 Sep 17 11.14pm

Originally posted by Croydonlad

Now after 6 games the reality of our season is slowly sinking in
It seems that my calling of FDB sacking after the Huddersfield game wasn't so " stupid " and " idiotic " as it was claimed at the time
Make no mistake
Any other system with the squad we had and we would have got at least 5 points from those opening 4 games
By not playing it simple , we lost the lot , ruined confidence and now barring a miracle we are down

Have you ever been tested for “Narcissistic Personality Disorder”? If not, you should be.

 


Most certainly not European.

Midlands Eagle Flag 27 Sep 17 6.18am

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

. You think it's stupid for sacking them and not backing them with all the clubs money?

To say we should have backed him when you hear all the rumors of unrest and see how out of depth he had players playing.. Really?

Seriously crucify Parish for giving him the job in the first place if you want, but to say he should then If you employ someone to SLOWLY bring about a change in style and they immediately go against this agreement compound the mistake by backing him and keeping him in the post, when he's clearly gone rogue. Na, he had to go..

I find it amusing that a few very carefully orchestrated leaks that may or may not have any basis in truth are now being taken as proof of guilt.

Comments like "If you employ someone to SLOWLY bring about a change in style and they immediately go against this agreement" and "he's clearly gone rogue" are straight out of the clutching straws manual.

Just as in the Pulis leaving fiasco no-one really knows the truth of what went on behind closed doors but peoples' beliefs seem to be more in line with what they want to believe rather than anything based in actual facts.

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 27 Sep 17 8.29am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I find it amusing that a few very carefully orchestrated leaks that may or may not have any basis in truth are now being taken as proof of guilt.

Comments like "If you employ someone to SLOWLY bring about a change in style and they immediately go against this agreement" and "he's clearly gone rogue" are straight out of the clutching straws manual.

Just as in the Pulis leaving fiasco no-one really knows the truth of what went on behind closed doors but peoples' beliefs seem to be more in line with what they want to believe rather than anything based in actual facts.

Crystal Palace won the high court case is that not enough to believe?

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Dixie Eagle Flag Chatham 27 Sep 17 12.38pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I find it amusing that a few very carefully orchestrated leaks that may or may not have any basis in truth are now being taken as proof of guilt.

Comments like "If you employ someone to SLOWLY bring about a change in style and they immediately go against this agreement" and "he's clearly gone rogue" are straight out of the clutching straws manual.

Just as in the Pulis leaving fiasco no-one really knows the truth of what went on behind closed doors but peoples' beliefs seem to be more in line with what they want to believe rather than anything based in actual facts.

Agreed

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 27 Sep 17 12.45pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I find it amusing that a few very carefully orchestrated leaks that may or may not have any basis in truth are now being taken as proof of guilt.

Comments like "If you employ someone to SLOWLY bring about a change in style and they immediately go against this agreement" and "he's clearly gone rogue" are straight out of the clutching straws manual.

Just as in the Pulis leaving fiasco no-one really knows the truth of what went on behind closed doors but peoples' beliefs seem to be more in line with what they want to believe rather than anything based in actual facts.

I agree with clubs leaking info. I spoke to someone recently who confirmed another club of equal size doing this. Confirmed more by the silence since Benteke's injury.

The 3-4-3 declaration was anything but 'gradual.' That is fact. He said both, he contradicted himself and, after all, I find it hard to believe Parish agreed to something requiring 7 new players, which is what it would've taken.

They're both to blame, and the players really for not getting on with it, although they're right in that it would inevitably fail. Still not for them to decide, although they do.


Edited by Rudi Hedman (27 Sep 2017 3.51pm)

 


COYP

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > When Reality Sets In