You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What is it letting us down?
November 16 2026 8.21am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

What is it letting us down?


Page 2 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 21 Oct 17 10.27pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Not scouting players enough is a recipe for overspending.

The left back fiasco means you have to buy 2 for more than you would've done to correct the mistake.

Not having a striker guarantees failure and is a repeat of LB.

I've been supporting Palace a long time and I know when it's cyclically inevitable we're going down due to our size and/or squad ageing, not being able to do this or that and this is not one of those occasions. At least it's not down to investing in golf clubs and personal wealth but it's the complete opposite from being clever over the rest of the football community. Thinking you can get away with that kind of thinking is only going to take you one way, which parish will feel the pain over and probably the only way he'll learn in this sport because he sure as hell hasn't before.


I agree our scouting hasn't been good enough and should have been addressed by now. Seems harder these days with the big clubs mopping up loads of players and loaning them out. I also agree that we've made the same mistake and that ultimately Parish is responsible. Would be nice to know what really happened as I do not, for one minute, think he is as naive as it looks to us. I suspect it was a complicated set of circumstances that put us in this position without a striker.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Oct 17 10.39pm

Originally posted by rollercoaster


I agree our scouting hasn't been good enough and should have been addressed by now. Seems harder these days with the big clubs mopping up loads of players and loaning them out. I also agree that we've made the same mistake and that ultimately Parish is responsible. Would be nice to know what really happened as I do not, for one minute, think he is as naive as it looks to us. I suspect it was a complicated set of circumstances that put us in this position without a striker.

This is the kind of thing I'm talking about. Doesn't happen anywhere else yet it's quite understandable or excusable for Palace. And with a mute sporting director for 10 days before deadline day as well. We knew about this issue when Wickham last got injured and that Campbell regret is the naive you claim Parish definitely is not.

He'll have to take his championship medicine and so will we. For how many years with the cladding and fanzone as a reminder of what could've been we'll find out. I hope freedman is preparing for the championship as well as looking at the out of reach Cenk because if it's left to Parish we're relying on again the very best championship manager to be available and to want to come and do it.

 


COYP

The Dolphin Flag 22 Oct 17 8.33am

We arrived in the Premiership with -
1. Ian Holloway then had
2. Keith Millen temporarily who sat back for
3. Tony Pulis who was a silly arse (in the end) and left so that
4. Keith Millen could take charge again until
5. Neil Warnock arrived but he was apparently only warming the seat for
6. Alan Pardew (who was preceded temporarily by Millen again) who far outstayed his welcome and did untold damage to CPFC until he was sacked and
7. Sam Allardyce stepped in to keep us up but left so we spent months interviewing people until we employed
8. Frank De Boer who was sacked so fast it was ridiculous so we then employed
9. Roy Hodgson - to be continued.........
No stability or continuity is letting us down.
Circumstance and poor judgement at the top of the pile are to blame in equal measure but the list above will probably do for us this Season.
Hodgson is really only short term as well so we never learn.

 

beak Flag croydon 22 Oct 17 10.22am

This season the awful start has made us very edgy, luck Is not going our way and other teams feed shark like from our air of nervousness,It is nothing that three wins will not put right but that needs to be now and not then.

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 22 Oct 17 10.37am

Originally posted by spartakev2

A centre forward please. ...

we have a striker, he cost £32m and scored 17 goals last season.

we have another decent striker who is also injured but back soon. Come january we will have 1 top class proven PL striker, and 1 decent backup PL quality striker.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


spartakev2 Flag Anerley 22 Oct 17 10.50am

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

we have a striker, he cost £32m and scored 17 goals last season.

we have another decent striker who is also injured but back soon. Come january we will have 1 top class proven PL striker, and 1 decent backup PL quality striker.

As I'm sure you realise our 32m striker, is injured and I won't go on about how ridiculous it is we have no back up, as I'm sure you realise that too. As for our decent backup, how long do you think he'll last once he starts playing again. And sadly I have a feeling we could be cut adrift by January. The teams we expected to struggle , Huddersfield, Brighton Newcastle, Watford, burnley, are doing well and looking good. The teams just above us, West ham, Bournemouth, stoke, everton will start picking up points soon. While we are loosing games because we don't have a centre forward. ..

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 22 Oct 17 11.17am

Originally posted by spartakev2

As I'm sure you realise our 32m striker, is injured and I won't go on about how ridiculous it is we have no back up, as I'm sure you realise that too. As for our decent backup, how long do you think he'll last once he starts playing again. And sadly I have a feeling we could be cut adrift by January. The teams we expected to struggle , Huddersfield, Brighton Newcastle, Watford, burnley, are doing well and looking good. The teams just above us, West ham, Bournemouth, stoke, everton will start picking up points soon. While we are loosing games because we don't have a centre forward. ..

i am well aware both are injured, but bentekkers wasnt injured, do we just keep on spending £20m on strikers everytime one gets injured? its not a sustainable model is it.

basically the clubs damned if it does & damned if it doesnt.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


chris123 Flag hove actually 22 Oct 17 11.46am

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

i am well aware both are injured, but bentekkers wasnt injured, do we just keep on spending £20m on strikers everytime one gets injured? its not a sustainable model is it.

basically the clubs damned if it does & damned if it doesnt.

Well SP saying we should have kept Frazier Campbell was indicative for me. I like Frazier and he always gave everything, but not the kind of player we needed in my view. And as others have highlighted, poor scouting left us short of options in areas we are weak.

 

pompeyeagle Flag Relocated to Shropshire 22 Oct 17 12.08pm

I can't believe you're seriously asking this question. If we had had a decent striker on the pitch yesterday we would have won comfortably. But we didn't so we didn't. That's what's letting us down.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 22 Oct 17 12.22pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

i am well aware both are injured, but bentekkers wasnt injured, do we just keep on spending £20m on strikers everytime one gets injured? its not a sustainable model is it.

basically the clubs damned if it does & damned if it doesnt.

Are you for real? You truly believe it's right for a team starting their 5th season in the premiership, to start with only one recognised striker, knowing that if he gets injured we're f****d. It was a huge gamble, and it's one that will probably get us relegated.

 

cpj Flag Kent 22 Oct 17 1.14pm

The problem scoring goals started well before Benteke got injured. The facts are that we have only scored in 2 of our last 14 PL games, and none in our last 7 away games, and Benteke played in 11 of those games. That really is appalling.

I know Parish and co saved us from administration etc etc, but the club seems to have been badly managed in recent years. We seem to have no scouting system to find these good players that other teams seem to unearth - we just seem to go for expensive big-name players who seem more interested in the money. We've never done well with big-money signings. We used to sign players from lower-leagues or reserve teams and make them good - Bright, Thomas, AJ, Gray, Wright etc. Same for managers - we did best when going for untried or relatively young managers - Coppell, Bruce, Freedman. Now we have a clueless 70 year old who couldn't motivate an England team to beat Iceland.

 

Welsh Eagle Flag 22 Oct 17 1.43pm

1)Not having a fit decent striker.

2)Having Frankie in charge for 4 matches.

3)Wilf getting injured in the Huddersfield match & being out until recently.

4)Sahko only getting fit until recently.

5)Not investing in a decent keeper in the summer.

6)Not being able to retain managers who do a great job for us.

7)Poor scouting system


Edited by Welsh Eagle (22 Oct 2017 1.45pm)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Oct 17 2.40pm

Originally posted by cpj

The problem scoring goals started well before Benteke got injured. The facts are that we have only scored in 2 of our last 14 PL games, and none in our last 7 away games, and Benteke played in 11 of those games. That really is appalling.

I know Parish and co saved us from administration etc etc, but the club seems to have been badly managed in recent years. We seem to have no scouting system to find these good players that other teams seem to unearth - we just seem to go for expensive big-name players who seem more interested in the money. We've never done well with big-money signings. We used to sign players from lower-leagues or reserve teams and make them good - Bright, Thomas, AJ, Gray, Wright etc. Same for managers - we did best when going for untried or relatively young managers - Coppell, Bruce, Freedman. Now we have a clueless 70 year old who couldn't motivate an England team to beat Iceland.

It's a fair post apart from Roy. He's highly qualified at our level. England is a different proposition and it's not his fault for the shower of sh1t this summer and last summer and season actually.

 


COYP

cpj Flag Kent 22 Oct 17 2.51pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

It's a fair post apart from Roy. He's highly qualified at our level. England is a different proposition and it's not his fault for the shower of sh1t this summer and last summer and season actually.

Lewington admitted they couldn't get the players motivated for the Iceland game. If you can't do that for a Euros q-final, then what hope for a struggling side who cannot score a goal?

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 22 Oct 17 2.54pm

Roy is very generous and Palace are not a bad team.

However when I tuned in and saw it was 0-0 with 20 minutes to go I just knew it wasn't going to be a win.

With Jedinak and co Palace were not the greatest but had strength and character.

Warnock's description of us as softies is a bit strong but not far off the mark.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 22 Oct 17 3.04pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

we have a striker, he cost £32m and scored 17 goals last season.

we have another decent striker who is also injured but back soon. Come january we will have 1 top class proven PL striker, and 1 decent backup PL quality striker.

We could be relegated by January. "Come January" is not good enough at this level. Come "having a proper squad of players when the season starts" is what is missing here. Parish royally screwed up the transfer window with his last minute nonsense strategy, and now we have no strikers, its simple really. Sod January, I would like to have a fit striker now, Mr Parish, so that we aren't playing wingers up front every game.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Oct 17 3.05pm

Originally posted by cpj

Lewington admitted they couldn't get the players motivated for the Iceland game. If you can't do that for a Euros q-final, then what hope for a struggling side who cannot score a goal?

He did in the premier league at clubs of similar size.

 


COYP

Icepick Tony Flag Chester 22 Oct 17 3.07pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

i am well aware both are injured, but bentekkers wasnt injured, do we just keep on spending £20m on strikers everytime one gets injured? its not a sustainable model is it.

basically the clubs damned if it does & damned if it doesnt.

We didn't have enough backup last season, we then let the only other fit striker go. Whilst we spent big on Benteke, relying on that is absolutely crazy. Our recruitment has been pretty farcical since we came up, massive expenditure on mediocre players bar one or two. Holloway called it early doors that the infrastructure wasn't there and lessons should have been learned but haven't been.
A premier league team cannot start a season with 1 fit striker, 1 injured and 1 who has never played above league 1 standard on their books and not expect to be in serious trouble. As always we left it to deadline day to try and fix the issue but as usual failed.

We are in this position because we have not moved on as a club, we have not recruited in the right areas at the right time and have relied heavily, season upon season, for a messiah to drag us out the brown stuff at the last minute. Sadly I think it has all caught up with us and when we go down, our top players will leave and the squad that is left will be championship standard, just like the one that got lucky promotion.

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

Maine Eagle Flag USA 22 Oct 17 3.14pm

Originally posted by Icepick Tony

We didn't have enough backup last season, we then let the only other fit striker go. Whilst we spent big on Benteke, relying on that is absolutely crazy. Our recruitment has been pretty farcical since we came up, massive expenditure on mediocre players bar one or two. Holloway called it early doors that the infrastructure wasn't there and lessons should have been learned but haven't been.
A premier league team cannot start a season with 1 fit striker, 1 injured and 1 who has never played above league 1 standard on their books and not expect to be in serious trouble. As always we left it to deadline day to try and fix the issue but as usual failed.

We are in this position because we have not moved on as a club, we have not recruited in the right areas at the right time and have relied heavily, season upon season, for a messiah to drag us out the brown stuff at the last minute. Sadly I think it has all caught up with us and when we go down, our top players will leave and the squad that is left will be championship standard, just like the one that got lucky promotion.

You are bang on, but we are not down yet. Still in the mire by Christmas and it could be curtains for sure. One thing Parish has shown is he is seriously jammy - he has ballsed loads of things up for years and always somehow we seem to stay up. But this is the biggest test to his lucky streak, he really, really ballsed things up this time, with the transfer window, and FDB, its a huge body blow but maybe his jammy streak will continue. He is hopeless at transfers. We cant seem to sell our dead wood, and we foul up pursuits of players like no one else. He is pretty hopeless at hiring managers too, see De Boer, Frank. If you cant be good at recruiting players or managers, or selling players, thats a pretty crap chairman isnt it.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 22 Oct 17 3.29pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

You are bang on, but we are not down yet. Still in the mire by Christmas and it could be curtains for sure. One thing Parish has shown is he is seriously jammy - he has ballsed loads of things up for years and always somehow we seem to stay up. But this is the biggest test to his lucky streak, he really, really ballsed things up this time, with the transfer window, and FDB, its a huge body blow but maybe his jammy streak will continue. He is hopeless at transfers. We cant seem to sell our dead wood, and we foul up pursuits of players like no one else. He is pretty hopeless at hiring managers too, see De Boer, Frank. If you cant be good at recruiting players or managers, or selling players, thats a pretty crap chairman isnt it.

We have been saying for years that SP is out of his depth but the only person who doesn't realise it is SP himself. Not an easy thing to run a PL club but we've survived by luck rather than from his expertise. I still can't believe so many mistakes were made over the summer.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

Page 2 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What is it letting us down?