This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by leifandersonshair
Does anyone think that, if Loftus-Cheek had played exactly the same this season but was a Palace player, not a Chelsea player on loan at Palace, he would still be in the England squad? Not a chance Agree
|
|
|
Originally posted by Dan1994
The point was that there is a big club England bias. All those examples were meant to demonstrate that. I never said those were for this squad. Zaha pre-Ivory Coast call up should've been in the squad over Jesse Lingard. Dann at his peak (or any other defender) should have had a shout over Phil Jones who was s***e then. Townsend this time round has been better than some of the players in the squad. It took Defoe ages to get a shout in the England squad, despite bagging loads of goals. Jack Wilshere and Dan Sturridge used to get in the squad despite being injured the majority of the time. Similar to Defoe, Drinkwater should've got more of a look in. Didn't make the final cut of the Euros, despite playing for a team top of the league in the form of his life. Just because they're not all with reference to this squad, doesn't make mentioning them pointless. There are plenty of examples that show this bias.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Casual
Zaha can’t play for England . I don’t think Dann is one of our best 2 center backs. Of course there is a bias - big one as well. BTW, there were 5 Tottenham-players in the team that lost to Iceland as well. You play 2-3 games for any top 6 club and Southgate pick you. Henderson as captain and Wilshire knockin' on England door again...come Russia 2018 and see what they are worth.
|
|
|
Originally posted by thai-eagle
Of course there is a bias - big one as well. BTW, there were 5 Tottenham-players in the team that lost to Iceland as well. You play 2-3 games for any top 6 club and Southgate pick you. Henderson as captain and Wilshire knockin' on England door again...come Russia 2018 and see what they are worth. I think the reason why most of the players come from the top 6 is because they have the best players. You’re right that if someone has a handful of games for a top club, they are put in a squad. How many of ours/West Brom’s/ Burnley etc would get a run of games at city/Chelsea/Tottenham/united etc.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
Well quite. And it seems all too convenient to overlook that a certain J.F.Morris of Barnes Club was called-up by England in 1872. 'Big club'?? I spy a pattern (albeit like one of those funny web ones made by spiders given hallucinogenic drugs.)
As a woman, I can step aside, or step up my game... |
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
So we have to go back to the 70s to find someone that bucks the trend. And by bucking the trend we mean 4 caps, all of which, from what I can gather, were pointless games. I guarantee you, by the time the World Cup squad comes around, players who should be in the squad on performances won't be there, and we'll still have the some of the run-of-the-mill, bang average players who are on the fringes of the top 6 teams. Oh and Ross Barkley, who will be bigged up as England's next big thing until he's 27 a la Theo Walcott. Don't get me wrong, it's best if the majority of them are in the top 6 teams, because that means we'll have good players. It's the top 6 fringe players, with limited game time, that get picked that annoys me. When Wilshere is picked for Euro 2016 over Danny Drinkwater and Daniel Sturridge is picked for Euro 2016 over Jermain Defoe, you know something ain't right. Edited by Dan1994 (04 Nov 2017 10.38am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Dan1994
So we have to go back to the 70s to find someone that bucks the trend. And by bucking the trend we mean 4 caps, all of which, from what I can gather, were pointless games. I guarantee you, by the time the World Cup squad comes around, players who should be in the squad on performances won't be there, and we'll still have the some of the run-of-the-mill, bang average players who are on the fringes of the top 6 teams. Oh and Ross Barkley, who will be bigged up as England's next big thing until he's 27 a la Theo Walcott. Don't get me wrong, it's best if the majority of them are in the top 6 teams, because that means we'll have good players. It's the top 6 fringe players, with limited game time, that get picked that annoys me. When Wilshere is picked for Euro 2016 over Danny Drinkwater and Daniel Sturridge is picked for Euro 2016 over Jermain Defoe, you know something ain't right. Edited by Dan1994 (04 Nov 2017 10.38am) Other than Livermore, Vardy, Maguire, Defoe, Keane etc. who have all been picked in the last few months. If you genuinely believe a 27 year old Andros Townsend, who has played nearly every minute for the worst team in the division and has 0 goals, 0 assists (unless you count winning a penalty), is more deserving of a place than a 24 year old Lingard, who has more club goals in the last two weeks than Townsend has in 2017, then I would suggest you are far more guilty of bias than the England selectors.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Other than Livermore, Vardy, Maguire, Defoe, Keane etc. who have all been picked in the last few months. If you genuinely believe a 27 year old Andros Townsend, who has played nearly every minute for the worst team in the division and has 0 goals, 0 assists (unless you count winning a penalty), is more deserving of a place than a 24 year old Lingard, who has more club goals in the last two weeks than Townsend has in 2017, then I would suggest you are far more guilty of bias than the England selectors. Defoe didn't even make it into the Euros squad, so I don't know how you can count him in that. Vardy was incredibly impressive when he was chosen. How he'd not have been chose would've been criminal. Do you really have to be in that kind of form to be picked over someone like Sturridge? Livermore was picked for a friendly and played against Lithuania - a game which is essentially treated as a friendly by England. Maguire and Keane have been exceptions, but they're only in the squad due to the lack of English defenders in the top 6 teams. What English defenders, who were available, were missing due to Keane or Maguire's inclusion? Okay fine, let's compare the two: Okay, maybe I'm biased with Townsend, but does Lingard deserve a call-up over, say, Demarai Gray? If Lingard played the same for a club like Watford, he would not be in that squad. Edited by Dan1994 (04 Nov 2017 12.25pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Dan1994
So we have to go back to the 70s to find someone that bucks the trend. And by bucking the trend we mean 4 caps, all of which, from what I can gather, were pointless games. I guarantee you, by the time the World Cup squad comes around, players who should be in the squad on performances won't be there, and we'll still have the some of the run-of-the-mill, bang average players who are on the fringes of the top 6 teams. Oh and Ross Barkley, who will be bigged up as England's next big thing until he's 27 a la Theo Walcott. Don't get me wrong, it's best if the majority of them are in the top 6 teams, because that means we'll have good players. It's the top 6 fringe players, with limited game time, that get picked that annoys me. When Wilshere is picked for Euro 2016 over Danny Drinkwater and Daniel Sturridge is picked for Euro 2016 over Jermain Defoe, you know something ain't right. Edited by Dan1994 (04 Nov 2017 10.38am) Taylor was an example that bias doesn't exist.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Dan1994
Defoe didn't even make it into the Euros squad, so I don't know how you can count him in that. Vardy was incredibly impressive when he was chosen. How he'd not have been chose would've been criminal. Do you really have to be in that kind of form to be picked over someone like Sturridge? Livermore was picked for a friendly and played against Lithuania - a game which is essentially treated as a friendly by England. Maguire and Keane have been exceptions, but they're only in the squad due to the lack of English defenders in the top 6 teams. What English defenders, who were available, were missing due to Keane or Maguire's inclusion? Okay fine, let's compare the two: Okay, maybe I'm biased with Townsend, but does Lingard deserve a call-up over, say, Demarai Gray? If Lingard played the same for a club like Watford, he would not be in that squad. Edited by Dan1994 (04 Nov 2017 12.25pm) I listed those players because you suggested you have to go back to the 70s to break the trend, which is not even remotely true, as I suspect you know. There are numerous examples moreorless every season. I couldn't care less that Townsend works his socks offs - look at it objectively and tell me how an attacker who's played every game for a club who failed to score for 7 games in a row can possibly be considered for the England squad. Lingard outscored Townsend last season as well, with considerably less playing time. You cite Lingard's lack of playing time at United, and then suggest Demari Gray, who until recently, couldn't get into the Leicester side over Mark Albrighton - is he international quality as well? As Painter said below, there are 8 players in the current squad from outside the top 6 - proportionally, I think that sounds about right.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Dan1994
@Painter. Jack Wilshere appeared in 3 games all season on the lead up to the Euros, compared to Drinkwater who was in a title winning squad in the form of his life. Sturridge had barely completed a game by the Euros whilst Defoe scored 15 for a diabolical Sunderland side. @EverybodyDannsNow. You're right, there are examples, but they'll rarely play anything more than meaningless competitive games or where there is little no option. Damarai Gray has played 100 more minutes in the PL this season than Lingard, so it can't be the lack of minutes then? If you wanna look at it objectively, Townsend completes more key passes, 3x as many dribbles and gets fouled more per 90 than Lingard, whilst playing for a much inferior team. Source: whoscored.com I've already written about those 8, but I'll summarise: Edited by Dan1994 (04 Nov 2017 2.40pm) You've backed yourself into a corner and are now frantically trying to defend it - using random WhoScored statistics is just clutching at straws. There's always going to be some justification you can come up with as to why certain players are selected, but the facts are that one third of the squad comes from outside the top six - this is more than a reasonable amount IMO. Out of interest, who do you think should have been included in the squad who hasn't?
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
You've backed yourself into a corner and are now frantically trying to defend it - using random WhoScored statistics is just clutching at straws. There's always going to be some justification you can come up with as to why certain players are selected, but the facts are that one third of the squad comes from outside the top six - this is more than a reasonable amount IMO. Out of interest, who do you think should have been included in the squad who hasn't? So being asked to look at it objectively, then providing statistics from a credible source counts as backing into a corner? You can also justify who would be kept in, such as Wilshere and Sturridge. It's not a third though, 3 on loan players (realised Hart is still a City player) (all top 6 players), so that's a fifth. I've already been over how 4 of those five are borderline impossible not to include in the squad. For me, Heaton over Hart, Lascelles over Gomez and Gray/Townsend of Lingard. If the England team had all top 6 players who'd made it there on merit, then I wouldn't care. But the I think some of the fringe players are chosen based on their club rather than actual merit. Edited by Dan1994 (04 Nov 2017 4.20pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Dan1994
So being asked to look at it objectively, then providing statistics from a credible source counts as backing into a corner? You can also justify who would be kept in, such as Wilshere and Sturridge. It's not a third though, 3 on loan players (realised Hart is still a City player) (all top 6 players), so that's a fifth. I've already been over how 4 of those five are borderline impossible not to include in the squad. For me, Heaton over Hart, Lascelles over Gomez and Gray/Townsend of Lingard. If the England team had all top 6 players who'd made it there on merit, then I wouldn't care. But the I think some of the fringe players are chosen based on their club rather than actual merit. Edited by Dan1994 (04 Nov 2017 4.20pm) 'Key passes' and 'fouls' are hardly telling statistics though - trying to define what constitutes a key pass alone is sketchy at best. It's certainly not convincing in comparing players , particularly when you were so quick to dismiss goals and assists. Hart isn't playing for a top 6 club, and Heaton is injured, so that's a bit redundant. Gomez' inclusion has more to do with his versatility I suspect - he has never been deployed much as a centre back at club football, so comparing him and Lascelles is difficult. The Lingard question is certainly tighter, more so with Gray than Townsend - Townsend has been pretty unimpressive in the year and a bit he's been here, admittedly not helped by playing in an underperforming side, but his personal contribution hasn't been particularly impressive. Lingard has made an impact for England previously, particularly off the bench in the recent qualifiers, so I still think it's justifiable that he edges Gray. I think your overarching point has certainly been true in England's recent history, but I think they've been reasonably open minded in the last few squads.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
'Key passes' and 'fouls' are hardly telling statistics though - trying to define what constitutes a key pass alone is sketchy at best. It's certainly not convincing in comparing players , particularly when you were so quick to dismiss goals and assists. Hart isn't playing for a top 6 club, and Heaton is injured, so that's a bit redundant. Gomez' inclusion has more to do with his versatility I suspect - he has never been deployed much as a centre back at club football, so comparing him and Lascelles is difficult. The Lingard question is certainly tighter, more so with Gray than Townsend - Townsend has been pretty unimpressive in the year and a bit he's been here, admittedly not helped by playing in an underperforming side, but his personal contribution hasn't been particularly impressive. Lingard has made an impact for England previously, particularly off the bench in the recent qualifiers, so I still think it's justifiable that he edges Gray. I think your overarching point has certainly been true in England's recent history, but I think they've been reasonably open minded in the last few squads. Key passes are pretty well defined, and similar, if not the same, throughout any proper football statistics site. They are defined as the final pass before a shot. So in theory, Townsend produces more chances and wins more free kicks. They were just examples, but my point was that looking at it objectively, the only things Lingard is better at is controlling the ball (first touch) and keeping possession. Obviously, context plays a big importance as well, and both can have cases in that sense: we play a much more direct, counter-attacking type of play, whilst Man Utd will tend to close out games when Lingard is likely to be playing (off the bench at the end). It's not a full-proof science by any stretch of the imagination, but you can begin to picture what they are like as a player. Hart is on loan from Man City, and I realised Heaton was injured when watching SSN yesterday. So, I'd probably keep him. Yeah possibly, as not including him would mean only potential 4 CBs. But then (possible unpopular opinion), but I don't know how Ben Mee hasn't been in contention for a place despite being statistically better than Keane and carrying on that form to this season. I don't remember Jesse Lingard making any real impact for me in any qualifiers. I agree that it has become better, but I think that will pale away once it gets to the World Cup, and we will be selecting the same old. For me, this is more of a frustration of England than anything else. In an ideal world, our whole squad would play for the best clubs in the world a la Spain or Germany.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.