You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Biggest player letdown so far this season?
November 16 2026 8.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Biggest player letdown so far this season?


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Nov 17 2.43pm

Originally posted by mattteo

It says Sunderland were idiots and they got relegated exactly because they sold players like PVA. Keep PVA along with Giaccherini, Lens and Khazri and boom....you got another PL relegation avoided. But instead they got in Steven Pienaar at 36. What do you want? It was Moyes......

PVA doesn't cause more problems than he does good. It's like saying Marcelo causes more problems that does good for Real Madrid.
HANDS OFF! He's a darn good player. If anyone doesn't see that then he or she is in the wrong.
Last time this year everyone here except me was saying how terrible Townsend is. And then it was a time when everyone wanted Cabaye out of the team.

Yes, PVA has made a few defensive positioning mistakes. Everybody makes them! EVERY defender in the world. You should watch Aurier from Tottenham more often. Does he not make mistakes? Do you remember the ones from the match with us? He's a fullback, just as PVA. And he's a darn good player, even if he sometimes loses his man or the ball. We judge him by what he does in entire seasons, not by a few bad decisions.
And contributing to the attack that much, actually being the best left back in the PL outside of top 6 teams, makes PVA so great. He brings for the team more points than he loses in an entire season

Edited by mattteo (13 Nov 2017 10.22pm)

Sunderland got relegated because Defoe was injured without any adequate back up. Now where is that happening this season. Luckily our team, not necessarily squad, is just better.

 


COYP

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 14 Nov 17 2.50pm

Originally posted by Kermit8

He was bloody good at Villa when they played it on the floor. And Belgium never used constant high ball tactics when he played. Maybe he is just not as good now? He also couldn't get into Liverpool's team even after Suarez leaving and Sturridge long-term injured.

We didn't buy a pony but we haven't bought a thoroughbred either even though he has cost us £40mill so far.


We always react the same whenever we spend big on a player; talk exclusively about the money for the first two years, before we realise that they are actually very good - same thing happened with Cabaye.

Benteke scored 15 league goals for us last season, in what was a pretty unimpressive team - to put that into perspective, our previous top scorers were;

2015/16 - Bolasie, Dann, Cabaye, Wickham - 5 goals
2014/15 - Murray - 7 goals
2013/14 - Gayle - 7 goals

So he scored more than double what any player has managed for us in a single season since returning to the PL - I find it impossible to consider that a let down, and certainly not the biggest let down in a squad performing as badly as ours.

PVA is certainly a contender, but for me it would be Townsend - 3 goals for someone who has played nearly every game in the year and a bit he's been here, and very little else in terms of game winning contributions - he works hard and puts in a shift, but he offers so little. I expected a hell of a lot more.


Edited by Kermit8 (14 Nov 2017 2.31pm)

Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (14 Nov 2017 2.51pm)

 

aashman12 Flag 15 Nov 17 10.16am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Sunderland got relegated because Defoe was injured without any adequate back up. Now where is that happening this season. Luckily our team, not necessarily squad, is just better.

Defoe played in 37 of their 38 games.

 

mattteo Flag 15 Nov 17 12.07pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow


Benteke scored 15 league goals for us last season, in what was a pretty unimpressive team - to put that into perspective, our previous top scorers were; 2015/16 - Bolasie, Dann, Cabaye, Wickham - 5 goals
2014/15 - Murray - 7 goals
2013/14 - Gayle - 7 goals
So he scored more than double what any player has managed for us


Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (14 Nov 2017 2.51pm)


Yeah, but he played more than triple the number of minutes the others got. Extrapolating, had they gotten Benteke's minutes, Gayle and probably others too would have scored more.

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 15 Nov 17 12.23pm

FDB. Footballing blue blood and a very highly regarded young coach. Turned to s***e.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 15 Nov 17 12.25pm

Phew.

I was beginning to get worried as there hasn't been a scapegoat thread for a few weeks. I thought the standard of HOL bitching was slacking.

 

Hansy Flag 16 Nov 17 4.51pm

Originally posted by Kermit8

He was bloody good at Villa when they played it on the floor. And Belgium never used constant high ball tactics when he played. Maybe he is just not as good now? He also couldn't get into Liverpool's team even after Suarez leaving and Sturridge long-term injured.

We didn't buy a pony but we haven't bought a thoroughbred either even though he has cost us £40mill so far.

Edited by Kermit8 (14 Nov 2017 2.31pm)

How long ago was he at Villa? Don't think the Liverpool scenario got to him? That also played it on the floor

 

mattteo Flag 16 Nov 17 5.46pm

He was never BLOODY GOOD at Villa. He was just an interesting prospect as he was very young

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 16 Nov 17 6.04pm

Originally posted by mattteo

He was never BLOODY GOOD at Villa. He was just an interesting prospect as he was very young

To maintain a 2:1 ratio over 3 seasons, playing for one of the worst teams in the division, whilst being a young player is hugely impressive - to suggest otherwise is just incorrect.

Benteke has more career PL goals than Gayle has PL games; I think that speaks volumes for the gulf in class.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 16 Nov 17 6.06pm

Originally posted by mattteo


Yeah, but he played more than triple the number of minutes the others got. Extrapolating, had they gotten Benteke's minutes, Gayle and probably others too would have scored more.

I prefer to look at what actually happened rather than what could have happened.

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 17 Nov 17 12.54am

If we write off the games up until Chelsea due to Frank's incompetence , and the difficulty of the games until Chelsea.
Then it must be Julian Speroni, as he came into a team that was improving and has not saved anything of note , and based on how we judge our keepers now could be held responsible for costing us 4 points.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 17 Nov 17 12.58am

Originally posted by MKCPFC

If we write off the games up until Chelsea due to Frank's incompetence , and the difficulty of the games until Chelsea.
Then it must be Julian Speroni, as he came into a team that was improving and has not saved anything of note , and based on how we judge our keepers now could be held responsible for costing us 4 points.

Night fishing?

 

mattteo Flag 17 Nov 17 7.00am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

To maintain a 2:1 ratio over 3 seasons, playing for one of the worst teams in the division, whilst being a young player is hugely impressive - to suggest otherwise is just incorrect.

Benteke has more career PL goals than Gayle has PL games; I think that speaks volumes for the gulf in class.


2:1 ratio only if you include his penalty goals. Which were probably a record high for a striker in the PL at that time

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 17 Nov 17 9.07am

Originally posted by mattteo

He was never BLOODY GOOD at Villa. He was just an interesting prospect as he was very young

This confirms what I suspected.

 


COYP

Dubai Eagle Flag 17 Nov 17 9.09am

Quite frankly - ( & maybe I am just too forgiving ) I am completely prepared to write off everything that happened before today - during early season the club / team was in turmoil with the fdb experiment or key players out or we were playing teams that were vastly more experienced / more expensive / top 6 etc - where we would have been lucky to get anything out of those games - for me judgment should be considered from today onward, Roy has now had a few weeks to get his thoughts across & we have a few games in front of us now where points should be considered as a real possibility / probability - I honestly hope that we can collectively come together ( club / team / supporters) & start to perform together as we know we can.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 17 Nov 17 9.12am

Gayle was good at coming off the bench when games opened up for whatever reason, or you went 2 up front. Also good at finishing loose. balls.

Whenever he started he was marked out of the game, never showed himself with his back to goal, never found a space or channel. Totally ineffective as a lone striker in the modern game when you need to be one.

That's why he's a good championship striker and not a good prem striker. Apparently he's not a good trainer and messes about like a school boy with fringe players that know they're not in the frame. Fine if you're doing the business regularly. Not if you aren't or can't.

 


COYP

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 19 Nov 17 10.36am

Originally posted by TheArmaniCode

Benteke. I know he's our only striker, but not ONE goal in six games? That's really disappointing

especially when you consider the megabucks we paid for him. i cannot see anybody wanting to buy him off us.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

wisdom man Flag SURREY 19 Nov 17 10.49am

It’s Luca by a country mile. If he remains in the team, we will go down. He is lost for 60% of every game. His positional sense is woeful and the amount of times yesterday he is not showing for the ball slows everything down and makes other players look inefficient. I am really surprised more people have not picked up on it. I guess like the early days of Ben Watson when you get a fan club like that you just cruise through unnoticed. Any ball over 4 yards he either loses possession or can’t be controlled by our player. It’s more frustrating and damaging than 10 miisses by Benteke!

Edited by wisdom man (19 Nov 2017 10.50am)

 

mattteo Flag 19 Nov 17 11.04am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Gayle was good at coming off the bench when games opened up for whatever reason, or you went 2 up front. Also good at finishing loose. balls.

Whenever he started he was marked out of the game, never showed himself with his back to goal, never found a space or channel. Totally ineffective as a lone striker in the modern game when you need to be one.

That's why he's a good championship striker and not a good prem striker. Apparently he's not a good trainer and messes about like a school boy with fringe players that know they're not in the frame. Fine if you're doing the business regularly. Not if you aren't or can't.


He mostly played as a lone striker last season for Newcastle and was the best in the Championship, if you look at the number of minutes played and goals and assists provided: [Link]

Premier League teams regularly use strikers who weren't as good as him last year: Chris Wood, Glenn Murray, Tammy Abraham.

Good for Gayle that he can also play behind another striker, but he also played as center forward last year, this is all I wanted to say

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 19 Nov 17 11.10am

Originally posted by alaneagle1

[Link]
We need him to do this.

Agree, looks a strongman in that clip but seems sheepish for us.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Biggest player letdown so far this season?