You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Penalty takers need to be designated immediately.
November 16 2026 8.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Penalty takers need to be designated immediately.


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
merganser Flag 10 Dec 17 12.34am

Who was captain after Sakai went off if it wasn’t Dann?

Also, why didn’t Roy or one of his lieutenants (or one of our subs) run on to the pitch to instruct who was to take the penalty? Why did they just dither on the sidelines?

Maybe there would have been sanctions from the FA, but probably trivial.

There might yet be a silver lining if Benteke learns a bit of humility and if the rest of the team are more fired up than ever for Tuesday’s match.

I hope Benteke plays and scores a hat trick in the most convincing win since Hull last season.

COYP.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 10 Dec 17 12.43am

Instruction should have come from the bench. Benteke is gone, more fool Parish for having only one fit striker.
Roy has a big problem here.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Dec 17 1.05am

Originally posted by merganser

Who was captain after Sakai went off if it wasn’t Dann?

Also, why didn’t Roy or one of his lieutenants (or one of our subs) run on to the pitch to instruct who was to take the penalty? Why did they just dither on the sidelines?

Maybe there would have been sanctions from the FA, but probably trivial.

There might yet be a silver lining if Benteke learns a bit of humility and if the rest of the team are more fired up than ever for Tuesday’s match.

I hope Benteke plays and scores a hat trick in the most convincing win since Hull last season.

COYP.

The players were nearer to Benteke. They should have shown some 'Cojones' and instructed him to allow Milo to take it.

Who the hell does Benteke think he is by over-ruling the management who had decided he was NOT the designated penalty taker ? Absolutely disgraceful.


 

cpfccolin Flag Dorset 10 Dec 17 1.05am

Brighton are talking about our penalty miss on their forum the wan-ers

Edited by cpfccolin (10 Dec 2017 1.06am)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Dec 17 1.08am

Originally posted by cpfccolin

Brighton are talking about our penalty miss on their forum the wan-ers

Edited by cpfccolin (10 Dec 2017 1.06am)

They should concentrate on their abject 2-0 defeat and their lack of goals in recent games.Shame.

 

FairweatherEagle Flag London 10 Dec 17 1.14am

Originally posted by cpfccolin

Brighton are talking about our penalty miss on their forum the wan-ers

Edited by cpfccolin (10 Dec 2017 1.06am)

Honestly, what do you expect? We were riffing them when Dunk scored an OG.....

 

chateauferret Flag 10 Dec 17 2.08am

Originally posted by cpfccolin

Brighton are talking about our penalty miss on their forum the wan-ers

Edited by cpfccolin (10 Dec 2017 1.06am)

Won't it be funny if we knock them out of the Cup on penalties?

 


============
The Ferret
============

Terry Vegetables Flag Forest Hill 10 Dec 17 5.29am

I'd designate any of the half time penalty taking kids over Benteke. Everyone in the ground knew that was never going in ... well everyone except the penalty taker himself !!

Edited by Terry Vegetables (10 Dec 2017 5.29am)

 


catford kid, caught up supporting "team of the 80s" in the 70s..
1st actual Match - PALACE 1-1 LEEDS (Sat 13 Nov 1982)

PhuketEagle Flag Phuket 10 Dec 17 6.31am

Some people have pointed out that Dann wasn't the captain after Sakho went off & indicated that Speroni was. If so, he should have joined the rest of the players & demanded that the ball be given to Luka. There was no leadership at the crucial point - Jules would've been doing the right thing & maybe Benteke would have not overruled him at least.

 

chateauferret Flag 10 Dec 17 11.33am

Originally posted by PhuketEagle

Some people have pointed out that Dann wasn't the captain after Sakho went off & indicated that Speroni was. If so, he should have joined the rest of the players & demanded that the ball be given to Luka. There was no leadership at the crucial point - Jules would've been doing the right thing & maybe Benteke would have not overruled him at least.

Or maybe a) Benteke would have stayed put and defied the others to move him by force; b) the referee would have booked someone for timewasting and given a free kick to Bournemouth; or c) Milivojevic would eventually have taken the penalty and missed it because of Benteke's ridiculous conduct.

No right answers to how you deal with a player openly defying his manager's instructions to the point of requiring physical intervention; and 100% his fault.

 


============
The Ferret
============

steven_t92 Flag Orpington 10 Dec 17 12.18pm

Can't believe the amount of melons blaming Dann for poor captaincy....HE WASN'T THE CAPTAIN!!!

The point isn't over if Luka would have missed it or Not, the whole point is that Benteke has gone against his manager and team mates. Luka is the designated taker, if he missed it then no ond cares. He has put himself before the rest of the club, even if he had scored I would still expect some sort of punishment.

I don't want to see him put the shirt on again.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 10 Dec 17 12.34pm

The question of who takes a penalty should never arise at a professional PL club. It's not Sunday league. The designated taker should be decided and that should be the end of it.
If Bentete wasn't our only available striker, I'd drop him for two games. His selfishness could cost the club millions of pounds and years in the Championship.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 10 Dec 17 12.38pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

The question of who takes a penalty should never arise at a professional PL club. It's not Sunday league. The designated taker should be decided and that should be the end of it.
If Bentete wasn't our only available striker, I'd drop him for two games. His selfishness could cost the club millions of pounds and years in the Championship.

Yep, 100% this is why there is no-one to blame other than Benteke. If Luka had missed then this furore would never have started.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 11 Dec 17 10.24am

Benetke needs to get on the score sheet at Watford that's for certain.

I understand why he wanted to take it, but he at least had to make it 'hard to save'. He needs a goal, badly, and its like a drought for him - and now its even worse.

Needs to man up, and put in a top gear shift for the next game, and make amends.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 Dec 17 11.02am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Yep, 100% this is why there is no-one to blame other than Benteke. If Luka had missed then this furore would never have started.

I understand your thinking.
And IF Benteke had scored there would be no debate at all !

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 Dec 17 11.05am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Benetke needs to get on the score sheet at Watford that's for certain.

I understand why he wanted to take it, but he at least had to make it 'hard to save'. He needs a goal, badly, and its like a drought for him - and now its even worse.

Needs to man up, and put in a top gear shift for the next game, and make amends.

You are very understanding !
I could understand it, if we were 3-0 to the good and not in the situation on Saturday.

As for Benteke's penalties, he is not the cleanest striker of a ball I have seen and I look back at that missed penalty at Watford in Allardyce's first game in charge - same technique,same result and once again cost us maximum points.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 11 Dec 17 11.07am

Originally posted by thechaddyboy

I thought this had all been ironed out after he missed the last one, but, in the dying seconds of a hard fought game where 3 points would take us out of the bottom 3 someone should have stood up to him & said 'No' appreciate he wanted to score after such a lengthy dry spell but that was not the time to pull rank. Blokes a selfish fool. (quote]

Nail and head spring to mind.

Edited by Bexley Eagle (11 Dec 2017 11.08am)

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 11 Dec 17 11.16am

Perhaps one should also ask why a striker who cost c 30 mil is so poor at taking penalties. The penalty itself reminded me of the one taken by the 10 year old girl from Bournemouth in the half time shoot out that was saved by Pete the Eagle.
Actually that isn't fair, she hit hers with more power.

 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 11 Dec 17 12.29pm

Disagree, I missed it at the ground, but seeing Benteke's behavior before the penalty would have been an issue for me even if he had scored it. You don't start fighting about a penalty with the guy who earlier in the game scored a near perfect one. However, you could sense the whole ground almost expected him to miss it just from the change in atmosphere when people started to realize he was taking it.

Originally posted by Willo

I understand your thinking.
And IF Benteke had scored there would be no debate at all !


 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 11 Dec 17 12.33pm

I entirely agree with that and am very puzzled about people genuinely thinking a goalie should come from the other end to get involved, or players getting physical to "see who is boss"

CB is at fault and no one else.

Originally posted by LegalEagle2010

All this talk about 'designated penalty takers' and 'why didn't Luka just grab it off him' and 'why didn't the captain/ the bench tell Benteke to walk away' is (almost) annoying me as much as what actually happened.

Firstly, we clearly do have a designated taker. It is Luka. How can anyone think different. It is the reason why he bloody took the first one despite Benteke being on the pitch.

Secondly, as Roy said in one post match interview I have seen, the bench cannot walk onto the pitch and tell the players what to do ... they have already done that in training before the match where they have already designated Luka as our penalty taker.

So that leaves the players on the pitch. I was at the game. Luka looked almost inconsolable about what was happening. He stood in the box for ages, pleading with Benteke. He was pulling his shirt up almost over his head in panicked frustration. But Benteke simply stood there, not looking at Luka, blinkers on, refusing to move.

So think about what you are saying by stating that Luka/ Dann/ whoever else simply shouldn't have let Benteke take it. Given how it played out, they would have had no option but to PHYSICALLY drag Benteke out of the box.

Think about what that would have looked like. A penalty in the last minute, prefaced by a physical altercation involving our players. It would have had to have been that, Benteke was going nowehere. Think about what effect on morale that would have had, how it would have looked in the press. It is simply inconceivable that one professional would wrestle another one out of the box over a penalty.

Further, think about the effect it would have had on Luka! The pressure that would have been on him having just physically dragged a team mate out of the box (or alternatively watched someone else do it to Benteke).

Even if Benteke had relented to Luka's constant pressure without a physical confrontation (and it was constant pressure -- he demonstratively did not simply acquiesce to Benteke), think about the pressure that would have left on his shoulders. Pressure that would already have been extraordinary given the match situation.

Therefore, it is ENTIRELY Benteke's fault as to what happened. Not anyone else's. As I mentioned, even if he had relented, the damage would have been done (in terms of added pressure to Luka).

It is the most selfish act I have ever witnessed at Selhurst.

I only hope that the journalists and pundits who discuss the incident think about ( a ) the fact that we DO have a penalty taker and not blame it on a false 'confusion'. And ( b ) what they actually mean by saying 'someone should have told Benteke to back off'.

They did. He refused. Would they advocate a wrestling match? surely not, the ramifications are so awful.

One might think, well, the ramifications would be worth it for Luka to score the penalty for the three points. But, of course, he was not guaranteed to score, and especially not if he was taken it after such a furore. So by the time Benteke took it, I can understand the players thinking 'right ... he's got it now ... so let's back him. It's a penalty so he should score.'

I make clear that none of this changes my ultimate view, that how dare Benteke put his own selfish desire to end his drought before his teammates, the club, and the fans. Particularly when he is famously awful at taking bloody penalties in any event.

I am beyond angry. But let's direct it in the right, informed, logical place.


Edited by LegalEagle2010 (09 Dec 2017 8.13pm)


 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Penalty takers need to be designated immediately.