You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Football officials (Ref's)
November 16 2026 7.52am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Football officials (Ref's)


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 14 Dec 17 12.04am

Originally posted by pompeyeagle

Clearly when we get a video ref 3rd official in matches it's going to make a massive difference. A lot of the decisions referees get wrong are going to be overruled and then we will see which referees are good at their jobs and which aren't.

Problem is, it will be referees checking referees. Not gonna overrule them for anything but blatant mistakes and probably only those mistakes that are detrimental to the top clubs.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 14 Dec 17 12.24am

Originally posted by chateauferret

Your logic is as appalling as ever.

One can of course be assessed and accountable at the same time.

My point was that just because one is assessed doesn't mean one is accountable.

Or can you tell me when a referee has explained his appalling decisions after a match? (Clattenburg doesn't count because he was just using it to get himself back in the limelight).

1. I have already explained how they are accountable.

2. Referees are not permitted to speak to the media after games.


 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 14 Dec 17 12.34am

You mentioned about a "Panel of Premier managers or ex-managers...." as opposed to just former referees carrying out assessments.

Just to inform one and all that 'Match delegates' consisting of former managers and players assess the accuracy and consistency of decision making of the referees and their management of the match.It's the technical aspects that are dealt with by former experienced referees.

Anyway, glad to impart information to those who are not wholly 'Au Fait' with the assessment process.
Off to bed now.Goodnight to one and all.


Edited by Willo (14 Dec 2017 12.36am)

 

chateauferret Flag 14 Dec 17 1.08am

Originally posted by Willo

1. I have already explained how they are accountable.

2. Referees are not permitted to speak to the media after games.

Can you really not see why those two statements themselves are incompatible?

Nothig happens to them when they make mistakes, indeed it isn't even acknowledged that they have made a mistake. They make mistakes week after week after week and keep coming back again and again.

Unaccountable.

 


============
The Ferret
============

leejaneagles Flag 14 Dec 17 1.27am

I think there should be an option for clubs to take if they think a referee is being biased towards their team. It opens up a slight can of worms but you'd need to have a hell of a lot of evidence to backup a claim or face harsh penalties.

If your club win, it should allow that one referee to be at the bottom of a pecking order to ref matches for that team.

Before this season, Palace could legitimately have made a claim against Clattenburg after he cost us the FA Cup and using video evidence from several other games to prove it's not an isolated incident. With this in mind and the fan reaction to the scumbag, FA could agree that it shouldn't be totally random and if his name is drawn to ref a Palace match, it's in the Club's and the Referee's interest to swap him over with someone else.

I also think we fans aren't complete monsters either and the FA can learn a lot from our reaction before a ball has been kicked.

We all love a referee to be a pantomime villain from time to time. Most games we're going to be massively biased in favour of our own players and in the heat of the moment, boo the referee or sing "you don't know what you're doing" if we deem Zaha has been fouled even if he hasn't.

However, we don't subject the referee to abuse at half time/full time and certainly not the next time he refs a home match for us unless he is completely inept or showing clear bias against our team.

Kevin Friend would be a good example of this. He was roundly booed before kick off at Bouremouth and then proceeded to have an awful game. It shows how awful it was when we get awarded 2 penalties and yet we as fans feel he was terrible.

Why should he be given anymore Premier League games? Can't even blame bias for this one, it looked like Bournemouth were just as dumbfounded and furious as we were.

 

chateauferret Flag 14 Dec 17 1.30am

Originally posted by Willo

You mentioned about a "Panel of Premier managers or ex-managers...." as opposed to just former referees carrying out assessments.

Just to inform one and all that 'Match delegates' consisting of former managers and players assess the accuracy and consistency of decision making of the referees and their management of the match.It's the technical aspects that are dealt with by former experienced referees.

Anyway, glad to impart information to those who are not wholly 'Au Fait' with the assessment process.
Off to bed now.Goodnight to one and all.


Edited by Willo (14 Dec 2017 12.36am)

And then they employ the likes of you to go on social media and try to convince everyone that the whole thing doesn't stink to high heaven of incompetence, corruption and scandal.

 


============
The Ferret
============

chateauferret Flag 14 Dec 17 1.34am

Originally posted by leejaneagles

Kevin Friend would be a good example of this. He was roundly booed before kick off at Bouremouth and then proceeded to have an awful game. It shows how awful it was when we get awarded 2 penalties and yet we as fans feel he was terrible.

Why should he be given anymore Premier League games? Can't even blame bias for this one, it looked like Bournemouth were just as dumbfounded and furious as we were.

Their first goal and the blatant foul on Schlupp was as ghastly a piece of incompetence as I've ever seen. Three officials all failed to see King wrestle him away? Seriously?

 


============
The Ferret
============

BarEagle Flag Monmouth 14 Dec 17 5.30am

Originally posted by chateauferret

And then they employ the likes of you to go on social media and try to convince everyone that the whole thing doesn't stink to high heaven of incompetence, corruption and scandal.

Quite.

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Football officials (Ref's)