You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Scotland's 21% tax band on over £24k
November 21 2026 11.02pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Scotland's 21% tax band on over £24k


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 14 Dec 17 8.26pm

Originally posted by europalace

In my experience of living in several EU countries, no more than anywhere else and often much less. The UK really does have an 'us and them' mentaity, one of the reasons I decided to move my family away all those years ago. My friends who still live there say it's much, much worse now. Still, you obviously fit in very well there and like it

Thank goodness you still post on here.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Dec 17 8.42pm

I half think this could be good and I think Scotland is more in favour of redistribution of income, but I also cannot stop thinking that a major factor of this is down to sturgeon and the SNP's poor governance. Over £30k in Scotland and you're probably considered a toff lord.

Strange choice of middle class tax payers by a Scottish Tory mp today using a school head paying £600 more a year but not mentioning their teacher staff or nurses paying less. We'll see how this goes.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Dec 17 8.44pm

Originally posted by hedgehog50

I haven't been in Thornton Heath for 20 years (apart from some Palace games). Any journalists been murdered by the local mafia lately?

More kissing of teef than of a Don's ring in TH gangs.

 


COYP

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 14 Dec 17 11.30pm

Originally posted by DanH

Cash flow is huge for the self-employed; would kill a lot.

Agree 100% cash flow is king especially if people you invoice are late payers.

 


Pro USA & Israel

Beanyboysmd Flag 15 Dec 17 1.46am

Hang on, Ive just realised that ours is 20%! Tax is 0 in both up to £11.5k, and then both are 20% up to £24k. So if I have done the maths here, if you are on £25k a year, we would pay £2'700 a year and they would pay £2'710 (83p per month more). Even bigger numbers say £45k (I think thats the border for the next tax bracket, we would pay £6'700 per year and they would pay £7'120 (£35 a month more). If I have got any maths wrong, feel free to pull me up on it.

Nobody on £25k a year argues over 83p a month and nobody on £45k a year argues over £35 a month, not when you look at all the cool stuff they get for free that we get so annoyed about. Also they have to keep infrastructure running in some of the most remote places in Europe. I can imagine the people of the Orkney islands probably dont mind a little extra so they dont lose their hospital when the nearest one is a 300 mile boat ride away...

 

hedgehog50 Flag Croydon 15 Dec 17 8.10am

Originally posted by Beanyboysmd

Hang on, Ive just realised that ours is 20%! Tax is 0 in both up to £11.5k, and then both are 20% up to £24k. So if I have done the maths here, if you are on £25k a year, we would pay £2'700 a year and they would pay £2'710 (83p per month more). Even bigger numbers say £45k (I think thats the border for the next tax bracket, we would pay £6'700 per year and they would pay £7'120 (£35 a month more). If I have got any maths wrong, feel free to pull me up on it.

Nobody on £25k a year argues over 83p a month and nobody on £45k a year argues over £35 a month, not when you look at all the cool stuff they get for free that we get so annoyed about. Also they have to keep infrastructure running in some of the most remote places in Europe. I can imagine the people of the Orkney islands probably dont mind a little extra so they dont lose their hospital when the nearest one is a 300 mile boat ride away...

Well I guess the tax goes to pay for the £414 million that their parliament building cost, along with the £72 million a year it costs to run their parliament. Just what the UK needs, yet more government alongside Whitehall, the EU, various regional assemblies and mayors. Just what we need, yet more politicians and officials telling us how to run our lives, how they know best, and their need to regulate everything we do. All accompanied by massive inefficiency, waste and stupid 'projects' and 'initiatives'. Giving more tax to governments is like giving more whiskey to an alcoholic.

 


We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell]

chris123 Flag hove actually 15 Dec 17 8.41am

Originally posted by Beanyboysmd

Hang on, Ive just realised that ours is 20%! Tax is 0 in both up to £11.5k, and then both are 20% up to £24k. So if I have done the maths here, if you are on £25k a year, we would pay £2'700 a year and they would pay £2'710 (83p per month more). Even bigger numbers say £45k (I think thats the border for the next tax bracket, we would pay £6'700 per year and they would pay £7'120 (£35 a month more). If I have got any maths wrong, feel free to pull me up on it.

Nobody on £25k a year argues over 83p a month and nobody on £45k a year argues over £35 a month, not when you look at all the cool stuff they get for free that we get so annoyed about. Also they have to keep infrastructure running in some of the most remote places in Europe. I can imagine the people of the Orkney islands probably dont mind a little extra so they dont lose their hospital when the nearest one is a 300 mile boat ride away...

Far from losing - a new hospital is being built just outside Kirkwall.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 15 Dec 17 8.47am

Originally posted by Beanyboysmd

Hang on, Ive just realised that ours is 20%! Tax is 0 in both up to £11.5k, and then both are 20% up to £24k. So if I have done the maths here, if you are on £25k a year, we would pay £2'700 a year and they would pay £2'710 (83p per month more). Even bigger numbers say £45k (I think thats the border for the next tax bracket, we would pay £6'700 per year and they would pay £7'120 (£35 a month more). If I have got any maths wrong, feel free to pull me up on it.

Nobody on £25k a year argues over 83p a month and nobody on £45k a year argues over £35 a month, not when you look at all the cool stuff they get for free that we get so annoyed about. Also they have to keep infrastructure running in some of the most remote places in Europe. I can imagine the people of the Orkney islands probably dont mind a little extra so they dont lose their hospital when the nearest one is a 300 mile boat ride away...

The effect on peoples' pockets can swing elections. But I see your point, if it's actually put to use and not to prop up a poor performing SNP Scottish parliament.

 


COYP

djcpfc Flag Within a 5 minute walk 15 Dec 17 10.39am

I'd be in favour of this. I'm glad the thread finally got back on topic. With the national deficit at it's current levels, how far to do cut services to balance the books?

Going with Rudi's figures the money isn't crippling and it only targets those earning decent money. It isn't a stealth tax of which there are far too many that in the implementation are costly, and of little benefit to all and aggressive to the few.

 

Beanyboysmd Flag 15 Dec 17 11.13am

Originally posted by hedgehog50

Well I guess the tax goes to pay for the £414 million that their parliament building cost, along with the £72 million a year it costs to run their parliament. Just what the UK needs, yet more government alongside Whitehall, the EU, various regional assemblies and mayors. Just what we need, yet more politicians and officials telling us how to run our lives, how they know best, and their need to regulate everything we do. All accompanied by massive inefficiency, waste and stupid 'projects' and 'initiatives'. Giving more tax to governments is like giving more whiskey to an alcoholic.

£72m a year to run the scottish government? How much is ours? I only say that because I have heard a few people mention that the HOP and house of lords are a little bit extravagant. I have a feeling that scotlands one is a hell of a lot more efficient than ours...

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 15 Dec 17 11.33am

Scotlands government building is modern but Westminster has been falling to bits for years and will close soon to prevent the roof falling in.

And that's so much like the tories running of the economy keep spending for short-term gain someone else will just have to fix it later.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 15 Dec 17 12.13pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Scotlands government building is modern but Westminster has been falling to bits for years and will close soon to prevent the roof falling in.

And that's so much like the tories running of the economy keep spending for short-term gain someone else will just have to fix it later.

Excuse me? Where have you been for the last 5 decades?

 


COYP

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 15 Dec 17 1.45pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Excuse me? Where have you been for the last 5 decades?

Thanks for flagging up my post.

 

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 16 Dec 17 1.27pm

Originally posted by europalace

In my experience of living in several EU countries, no more than anywhere else and often much less. The UK really does have an 'us and them' mentaity, one of the reasons I decided to move my family away all those years ago. My friends who still live there say it's much, much worse now. Still, you obviously fit in very well there and like it

Austria is now the only Western European state with a governing far-right party, which is opposed to migration and the European Union. [Link] Fit it well there and like it?

 

doublesuited77 Flag London (Camden) 16 Dec 17 1.31pm

council taxes need to be part of the discussion. These are getting out of control. Mine alone have risen 35% in past 3 years

 


Be Loud, Be Proud, Be Palace

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 16 Dec 17 1.47pm

Originally posted by Penge Eagle

Austria is now the only Western European state with a governing far-right party, which is opposed to migration and the European Union. [Link] Fit it well there and like it?

It is a coalition they are part of the new government under the existing PM.

The new government is both pro-EU and committed to the European convention on human rights.


 

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 16 Dec 17 2.46pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

It is a coalition they are part of the new government under the existing PM.

The new government is both pro-EU and committed to the European convention on human rights.


Not with the far right party there. I know it's a coalition but still pretty significant.

Edited by Penge Eagle (16 Dec 2017 2.51pm)

 

europalace Flag Europe 17 Dec 17 8.05am

Originally posted by Penge Eagle

Austria is now the only Western European state with a governing far-right party, which is opposed to migration and the European Union. [Link] Fit it well there and like it?

yep, fantastic country and people. I lived a worked here for 5 years between 2000 and 2005, so I know the country and people well, clearly unlike yourself who views the rest of the world through the media rather than in real life.

Off snowboarding for xmas and new year, just a 3hr drive away

Edited by europalace (17 Dec 2017 8.26am)

 

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 17 Dec 17 8.15am

Originally posted by europalace

yep, fantastic country and people. I lived a worked here for 5 years between 2000 and 2005, so I know the country and people well, clearly unlike yourself who views the rest of the world through the media rather than in real life.

I thought you live there, hence the reason you have an Austrian flag next to your name to signify your location?

I never said I knew Austria (would go there one day but it's quite low down my list) just seeing your thoughts on the new government. I bet you are thrilled for your old friends who live there.

 

europalace Flag Europe 17 Dec 17 8.27am

Originally posted by Penge Eagle

I thought you live there, hence the reason you have an Austrian flag next to your name to signify your location?

I never said I knew Austria (would go there one day but it's quite low down my list) just seeing your thoughts on the new government. I bet you are thrilled for your old friends who live there.

I do live here for part of my time until we get everything organised. I also lived here before, hence wanting to come back.

Governments come and go but life changes little here. Still have lots of friends here, who like being within the EU as it's given them great opportunities and a good life.

Edited by europalace (17 Dec 2017 8.30am)

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Scotland's 21% tax band on over £24k