You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Selling one player - at a price
November 16 2026 7.52am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Selling one player - at a price


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
cpfc&proud Flag 25 Dec 17 7.05am

Originally posted by cpfccolin

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Yes but when you are a great International keeper who has played in World Cup Finals it's a little bit different.

Back in Speroni younger days playing for us the only reason he didn't get picked to play for Argentina is because they didn't pick players that played outside of Argentina

And that, as we all know is why Leo Messi has never played a game for Argentina.... oh wait

Edited by cpfccolin (25 Dec 2017 12.21am)

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 25 Dec 17 9.22am

Originally posted by pssguy

If we had to, who would it be

These are all players that there has been some speculation about. Numbers in million pounds

Townsend 15
Tomkins 20
Benteke 30
Zaha 50

I'm not putting PvA in there as he would be obvious choice!

No idea why we'd be forced to sell Townsend for just £15m? He's a vital part of our play and can't see us selling him unless we're offered close to double that.

If anyone offered £30m plus I think we'd have to think about it. Yes he's good on his day and yes he's getting better. But £30m could go a long way to revamping our foward line if the right players where identified.

Tomkins? I doubt we'd sell him, I also doubt we'd get a £20m offer for him. But even in today's market £20m is good money for a CB.

We'd still have a injury prone Sakho and Dann so would need to buy good to replace. Wonder how good the lad in the development squad is also.

Maybe Tomkins for £20m would have legs if an offer that high came in.

Zaha is 6 months in to a 5 year deal. He's the sole reason we're still up and therefor bags the club £100m plus a season. He won't be sold this window or in the summer. Potentially the following summer when he'd be on 3 years to run. But it's pipe dreams of any club to think they can buy one of the best players outside the top six for £50m when he has such a long contract. Won't be sold.

So Tomkins and Benteke if sky high prices come in and PVA for £10m to city.

£60m war chest could be spent fairly well at replacing those three IMO.

 

mattteo Flag 25 Dec 17 9.37am

LOL 30 mil for Benteke.
I'd sell him for 10.

Nobody is going to offer 30 million for a striker who has scored 1 time in 6 months.

The other players on the list are good players I wouldn't let go, even PVA (though he's hidden on the OP's list, I think he is one of the best left backs).


Edited by mattteo (25 Dec 2017 9.40am)

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 25 Dec 17 10.53am

Originally posted by rollercoaster

Cannot see how we can do without Tomkins. Has to be players not in the first eleven. PVA is a good shout.

The only reason I mentioned hat was because Sam is said to be interested and we apparently said double what we paid so 20 m


If of course true

You never know eh


Well, we will in a week

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 25 Dec 17 11.13am

Originally posted by MKCPFC

We have a good chairman ,
We are no longer desperate , or a selling club unless of course to the top 6 English Prem or Europe Giants.
Mr Parish we sell who he wants as and when he wants when price is right.

Is the correct answer and we can throw in Mutch as a Bruce Bonus.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Jimmy Flag Balham 26 Dec 17 10.28am

For me it would be a case of looking at what position we can afford to lose a player the most, without weakening the team too much. assuming that we cannot replace that player but use cash to strengthen other parts of the team in more need.

Of course with one striker fit, that means lose Tekkers. Then we are a lot weaker.

In mid, it's similar for me, we have in my eyes enough players to cover injuries. But not huge strength in depth.

In defence however I think it's a different matter. We bought a lot of defenders over the last 2 Windows, especially with de boers desire for 3 at the back. So we have most cover there. Jairo is young so odd to let go, however all of Sako, Dann, Tompkins and Jairo could commend a decent fee without weakening the team massively. Should mutliple injuries occur the likes of Kelly and tfm can definitely cover for a game or 2.

Same at left back, you could argue we need 2 with a ward to cover if both get injured, so I think we can allow one to go.

 


Happy happy JOY, JOY!

Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 26 Dec 17 11.48am

I'd be glad if we could cash in on PVA and reinvest some of that in a young left back with potential.

I'd want to keep Jairo, as he's young with good technique and is likely to develop into a first-teamer with more development.

Tomkins has proved himself to be the second-best central defender at the club and, with Sakho's ability to get injured, I think it would be insanity to sell him without a like for like replacement lined up and some profit on the deal on our side.

Obviously, if we could get at least a bag of magic beans and a few training bibs for Mutch, that would be a bonus.

I wonder if KaiKai has a future here, or will become the next Sean Scannell?

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

Pierre Flag Purley 26 Dec 17 12.49pm

What would be the point of looking to sell in January some of the players mentioned in this thread? £20m for Tomkins.
It would cost at least that or north of £20m to replace him!
Ideally If there is genuine interest and not just press speculation over PVA that one might be worth looking into. but would then leave the squad thinly covered again.

Prime objective has to be bringing a goal keeper and possibly a striker but with Wickham back training now he will hopefully have some game-time in a reserve match in the next couple of weeks and on from there.

If TFM went back could we initially loan a decent striker to complement Benteke would that be an option?

Cannot see the club making any wholesale changes or even considering selling Wilf, Townsend, Benteke or Cabaye until the the summer.
This squad can compete and is very capable. Just needs to show it more often!

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 26 Dec 17 12.52pm

Buy that Southampton LB we been linked with and sell pva and ask for lookman in part ex or full swap

Spend rest of kitty on a pacey striker and gk

 

Sportyteacher Flag London 26 Dec 17 1.45pm

Reality is that nobody should be sold UNTIL we have replacements confirmed to cover that position. Can't help but think that to lose Zaha in January transfer window would equate to football suicide by way of staying up.

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 26 Dec 17 2.15pm

Originally posted by Sportyteacher

Reality is that nobody should be sold UNTIL we have replacements confirmed to cover that position. Can't help but think that to lose Zaha in January transfer window would equate to football suicide by way of staying up.

I don’t think we have any intention on selling Zaha in January but Roy no doubt has said a lot of things in the press recently.

I believe this is to gain a bid to be rejected out of hand so to increase the bids that will come in the summer

If we officially refuse a 38m bid in two weeks we know we will expect more come June


 

General Flag 26 Dec 17 2.21pm

Sell Tompkins is just silly. who plays there now if we don't have Tompkins?

Kelly? Nope playing RB.. Timothy..nope injured. Ward..nope injured/suspended etc etc etc etc at any time in next 25 games and training sessions.

let's get Damian back in? Love the guy but could/should have replaced him a season back.

Sell Andros. And play who? Sako..great for 30/45 mins. Not a whole match tracking back like Andros does. KaiKai..nope. RLC? He's covering Luka suspension. So... hmmm Ok.

Sell /Release: Lee. Mutch. Wayne. Profit: 1m. 1m. 6m.

Buy: first choice GK. first choice striker. Cover for CB,cover for CM and cover for wing. Cost: 15m. 20m. 10m. 10m. 10m.

Example: fabianski. Holgate. Redmond. Coquelin. Ward-Prowse. Clukas.

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 26 Dec 17 4.40pm

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

Hennessey £2

you just dont stop do you?

bless.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


chateauferret Flag 26 Dec 17 7.12pm

Originally posted by Sportyteacher

Reality is that nobody should be sold UNTIL we have replacements confirmed to cover that position. Can't help but think that to lose Zaha in January transfer window would equate to football suicide by way of staying up.

It would be complete stupidity to entertain offers for Wilf until the question "Who will we get in to replace him?" has a satisfactory answer. And as far as I can see at the moment the only response to that question that's forthcoming is "F*** knows".

The only possible replacements I can think of a) play at a higher level b) cost stupid amounts of money and c) won't function alongside players in other positions that aren't of similarly stratospheric quality.

If he can't be replaced directly then it's a matter of far-reaching changes to our game and a whole series of other signings which would be highly disruptive and risky - especially in January.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Sportyteacher Flag London 26 Dec 17 7.32pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

It would be complete stupidity to entertain offers for Wilf until the question "Who will we get in to replace him?" has a satisfactory answer. And as far as I can see at the moment the only response to that question that's forthcoming is "F*** knows".

The only possible replacements I can think of a) play at a higher level b) cost stupid amounts of money and c) won't function alongside players in other positions that aren't of similarly stratospheric quality.

If he can't be replaced directly then it's a matter of far-reaching changes to our game and a whole series of other signings which would be highly disruptive and risky - especially in January.

Well said, Chateauferret!

 

gerry theagle Flag newbury 26 Dec 17 8.48pm

Sell nobody,we need to strengthen not sell our prized assets,to do so would be premier league suicide.

 

Daddyorc Flag Atlantic Highlands, NJ 26 Dec 17 9.04pm

Sell:
Mutch (<1mm)
Lee (2-4mm)
PVA (7-12mm)
Kaikai (2-4mm)

I just can't see Kaikai making it into the first team. He's been given a few chances over the years and a few loan spells, with very poor to mixed results.

Bring In:
No one from the premier league - only internationals or a lower league player.

Quite simply everyone in the PL is way too expensive in the January window (and in summer). You can get much better players from overseas for a fraction of the cost. There are also a few lower league players worth the cost. This is the only way we can improve the team without spending gobs of money on mediocre players (PVA, Schlupp, etc.).

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 26 Dec 17 9.11pm

Originally posted by matthau

Got a feeling Tompkins will go for good money. We’ll brIng in a promising cb and we’ll use excess along with kitty to fund two attack minded players and a gk

Pva may go but with Souare we are still not sure if he’s the same level as before so if pva goes Roy must know of a cheaper lb with some quality to take his spot

Pretty sure Schlupp has already taken his spot, if Souare is declared fit I’d be happy with those 2. Frees up a squad space and gets us a fair bit of money.

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 26 Dec 17 9.13pm

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

Pretty sure Schlupp has already taken his spot, if Souare is declared fit I’d be happy with those 2. Frees up a squad space and gets us a fair bit of money.

Would be a real shame. He’s a decent player and too professional. Seems to have really bought into the Palace cause as well.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

tpuffpendants Flag 26 Dec 17 9.36pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

No idea why we'd be forced to sell Townsend for just £15m? He's a vital part of our play and can't see us selling him unless we're offered close to double that.

If anyone offered £30m plus I think we'd have to think about it. Yes he's good on his day and yes he's getting better. But £30m could go a long way to revamping our foward line if the right players where identified.

Tomkins? I doubt we'd sell him, I also doubt we'd get a £20m offer for him. But even in today's market £20m is good money for a CB.

We'd still have a injury prone Sakho and Dann so would need to buy good to replace. Wonder how good the lad in the development squad is also.

Maybe Tomkins for £20m would have legs if an offer that high came in.

Zaha is 6 months in to a 5 year deal. He's the sole reason we're still up and therefor bags the club £100m plus a season. He won't be sold this window or in the summer. Potentially the following summer when he'd be on 3 years to run. But it's pipe dreams of any club to think they can buy one of the best players outside the top six for £50m when he has such a long contract. Won't be sold.

So Tomkins and Benteke if sky high prices come in and PVA for £10m to city.

£60m war chest could be spent fairly well at replacing those three IMO.


How on earth is the worst shooter in the prem worth 30m?

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Selling one player - at a price