You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > A thread to itself - that challenge on De Bruyne
November 16 2026 7.52am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

A thread to itself - that challenge on De Bruyne


Page 2 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Elpis Flag In a pub 01 Jan 18 11.04am

Well this simpleton still thinks Punch took one for team . I wouldn't say he injured himself or De Bruyne on purpose though ,that really is a rather stupid thing to suggest .
The tackle was granted poor and probably fuelled by the past month or so that has seen him out of the side but it was a tackle he HAD to attempt regardless .

To be honest I come from a generation when players used to make such tackles without so much as a telling off from the ref ,bookings and sending offs were reserved for really bad tackles and fisticuffs . I would rather have that any day of the week than the cowardly fouls , shirt pulling , faking and simulation that I would call cheating, not an open for all to see attempt (if poor one) to make a tackle .

Get well soon Punch .

 

boo909 Flag Figeac 01 Jan 18 11.05am

There was no real violent intent in it, it was just an awful tackle made in a panic, by a player who's u nfortunately really off his game these days, probably deserved a red even though the ref didn't think so.

And it doesn't help your case coming across as patronising and superior either, have a little respect for posters who have a differing viewpoint to your own.


Edited by boo909 (01 Jan 2018 11.06am)

 


Bangell - If Camus wrote The Myth of Sisyphus today, it would be about Jason Puncheon eternally trying and failing to pass with his right foot.

cpfc1976 Flag Reading 01 Jan 18 11.05am

Originally posted by Glazier#1

Really?

As I say: one- eyed.

Thank goodness that football fans with the view you have expressed are outnumbered by true fans of the game.

If you can't find joy watching the likes of De Bruyne, Wilf and Salah, you need to watch another sport my friend.

Bit puritanical aren’t you? Who are you to tell him to stop watching Palace if he doesn’t get a buzz from watching KDB or other teams players.

I enjoy watching other games, but generally the ones that affect Palace, i.e hoping a team not near the bottom smashes one of our relegation rivals. I have little interest in City, or their oil money team, they have played good football this season and so they should for the money they spend.

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 01 Jan 18 11.07am

Originally posted by Glazier#1

Oh my God.

It does make me chuckle how one-eyed supporters can be at times.

What Puncheon visited on Kevin De Bruyne was an act of violence. A disgrace that should have seen him sent off with a straight red and, in my opinion, result in a six match ban - at least.

Not only was it illegal but downright dangerous. What's more, it didn't even stop the intended pass. It did, though, achieve the desired effect of stopping play and once again, cheating won the day.

I even saw, I think, one simpleton on these boards PRAISING the disgraceful Puncheon for 'taking one for the team' ugh!

De Bruyne has been one of the joys of the first half of season 17-18. It is, surely, talent like his that gives us all pleasure and reminds us that, despite the cheats, this is the beautiful game. I don't care if he plays for us or not. he is a genius and the reason we all watch the game, surely. Players like him and Wilf light up the game and we must all want the geniuses to prosper for the good of the game and the cheats to be outlawed.

Someone on here complains that 'all the talk was about the pen and Punch's tackle'. Not on this site, it isn't. There has been a deafening silence about what Puncheon did.

Rest assured, if such an assault had been carried out on one of ours there would have been an outcry on these pages. Yesterday was different, though, wasn't it. Punch is 'one of ours'

I've been a Palace fan for many, many years and suffered the joys of that. Support them as I do, I'll never have time for what i saw Puncheon do.

Shame on you Jason.

Edited by Glazier#1 (01 Jan 2018 10.13am)

Sorry I just don’t agree it was that bad. Yes he would have been better just grabbing him and/or pulling his shirt but the tackle itself was not from behind, studs up or two footed. It was a professional foul no more. If it wasn’t KDB there wouldn’t be the furore.

 

Glazier#1 Flag 01 Jan 18 11.09am

And that, in itself, is totally wrong. I don't care who the perpetrator is.

I don't think that only 'leg-breakers' should get the full force of the book thrown at them,
in fact.

It is clear, seeing Puncheon preparing his 'challenge', what he intended to do. It could have been achieved with an ankle tap if all he wanted was to stop the player. No, there was more to it than that and both players will now carry the resultant injuries of a reckless and hot-headed, violent surge

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

Yes it was bad, yes it was cynical, but it was never a leg breaker, unlike the Deli Ali tackle on De Bruyne a few weeks ago. Did Ali get a 6 match ban, nope, he only received a yellow...

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 01 Jan 18 11.16am

Originally posted by Glazier#1

And that, in itself, is totally wrong. I don't care who the perpetrator is.

I don't think that only 'leg-breakers' should get the full force of the book thrown at them,
in fact.

It is clear, seeing Puncheon preparing his 'challenge', what he intended to do. It could have been achieved with an ankle tap if all he wanted was to stop the player. No, there was more to it than that and both players will now carry the resultant injuries of a reckless and hot-headed, violent surge

I started off by saying it was bad and cynical. My point is there is no consistency when it comes to dealing out punishments. I take it you never saw the Deli Ali challenge???

 

stujii Flag 01 Jan 18 11.16am

I've seen a lot worse... there was no malice a booking was the correct decision. It was a late tackle by a desperate and rusty player. You are blowing it out of proportion, players like De Bruyne and Zaha will always be at peril from late and clumsy tackles because they are so quick and hard to predict

Move on

 

Glazier#1 Flag 01 Jan 18 11.18am

I come from that generation too,
mate and I'm glad that the thuggery we used to take for granted has been outlawed: the dreaded tackle from behind that was responsible for so many careers ending early.

I agree with you on the cynicism that we see today in terms of what you describe and it seems that cheats will try to prosper no matter in what age.

In my opinion thuggery and cynicism belong in the same category - cheating.

I hate it.

I hope Punch recovers quickly too. De Bruyne too, for that matter.

Originally posted by Elpis

Well this simpleton still thinks Punch took one for team . I wouldn't say he injured himself or De Bruyne on purpose though ,that really is a rather stupid thing to suggest .
The tackle was granted poor and probably fuelled by the past month or so that has seen him out of the side but it was a tackle he HAD to attempt regardless .

To be honest I come from a generation when players used to make such tackles without so much as a telling off from the ref ,bookings and sending offs were reserved for really bad tackles and fisticuffs . I would rather have that any day of the week than the cowardly fouls , shirt pulling , faking and simulation that I would call cheating, not an open for all to see attempt (if poor one) to make a tackle .

Get well soon Punch .

 

Glazier#1 Flag 01 Jan 18 11.21am

No, Gary, I didn't see it but absolutely agree that consistency is the key.

That and stricter FA.

Many people are sick of managers and players breaking the rules because they can. If it wasn't worth it, they wouldn't - end of.

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

I started off by saying it was bad and cynical. My point is there is no consistency when it comes to dealing out punishments. I take it you never saw the Deli Ali challenge???

Edited by Glazier#1 (01 Jan 2018 11.22am)

 

JL85 Flag London,SE9 01 Jan 18 11.23am

Got the ball.

 

johnno42000 Flag 01 Jan 18 11.26am

I have seen an awful lot worse than that tackle. There have been plenty of occasions where players have gone in studs showing directly onto an ankle or the back of a calf, Dele Alli is a prime example of players doing this. Nothing happens to him, why should anything different happen to Puncheon?

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 01 Jan 18 11.27am

Originally posted by johnno42000

I have seen an awful lot worse than that tackle. There have been plenty of occasions where players have gone in studs showing directly onto an ankle or the back of a calf, Dele Alli is a prime example of players doing this. Nothing happens to him, why should anything different happen to Puncheon?

Exactly.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

chateauferret Flag 01 Jan 18 11.33am

Originally posted by johnno42000

I have seen an awful lot worse than that tackle. There have been plenty of occasions where players have gone in studs showing directly onto an ankle or the back of a calf, Dele Alli is a prime example of players doing this. Nothing happens to him, why should anything different happen to Puncheon?

Because Dele Alli is the darling of the World Cup winners elect that are Southgate's fantastic England team whereas Puncheon is considered fair game.

The former incidentally is a nastly little thug who does this again and again apparently with Spurs' full blessing.

Edited by chateauferret (01 Jan 2018 11.34am)

 


============
The Ferret
============

stuckinbristol Flag In the woodwork. 01 Jan 18 11.33am

Can't remember who it was that did basically the same to Tomkins against Liverpool last year, not a peep from the powers that be.

 

chateauferret Flag 01 Jan 18 11.36am

Originally posted by stuckinbristol

Can't remember who it was that did basically the same to Tomkins against Liverpool last year, not a peep from the powers that be.

Grujic. Horrible tackle, blatant straight red. It was worse, studs up into his calf. Tomkins was out for weeks after that and we were right up against it. For the rest of that game he couldn't come off because we'd used all the subs up and Fraizer Campbell had to play in central defence.

Edited by chateauferret (01 Jan 2018 11.37am)

 


============
The Ferret
============

stuckinbristol Flag In the woodwork. 01 Jan 18 11.38am

Originally posted by chateauferret

Grujic. Horrible tackle, blatant straight red. It was worse, studs up into his calf. Tomkins was out for weeks after that and we were right up against it. For the rest of that game he couldn't come off because we'd used all the subs up and Fraizer Campbell had to play in central defence.

Edited by chateauferret (01 Jan 2018 11.37am)

That's the one.
Thinking about it it was worse than Punch's.

 

chateauferret Flag 01 Jan 18 11.44am

Originally posted by stuckinbristol

That's the one.
Thinking about it it was worse than Punch's.

I wouldn't even have been pi""ed off if he had sent Puncheon off because the game was all but over and I'd sooner see Lee or even Mutch come on than Puncheon these days. Those two may not be all that in terms of skills but at least they work.

Edited by chateauferret (01 Jan 2018 11.44am)

 


============
The Ferret
============

mayler/rh13eagle Flag horsham 01 Jan 18 12.15pm

I think a few on here need to get of there soap boxes!!

Punch had an impact yesterday, the change had to happen as cabayes legs had gone and we were being over run. That said we had no jimmy mac or rlc so Roy tried to remain unchanged as long as poss!

I think people allow the nightclub episode to cloud there judgement! I loved that when punch came on we chanted his name and I thought that that in itself gave us something in those last 10 mins which we needed, so not so much punch but more the sub made a difference and had the desired effect.

I’m sure punch will be the first to admit how far down the pecking order he has slipped. But when needed he will always be there to do a job for us, which imo makes him as valuable part of squad as anyone else.

It was a missed timed tackle at best and yes it was made on one of this years leading lights in the pl. but punch isn’t Roy Keane and therefore would not of flown into that tackle to seriously injure kdb! Il be honest I’m far more concerned about Scott Dann and punch’s injuries than I could ever be about a player at another club but then that’s just me - I support palace and not the premier league!

Happy new year peeps!!

 

taylors lovechild Flag 01 Jan 18 12.33pm

Zaha is fouled like that in almost every match. The commentators often refer to it as necessary or taking one for the team. I don't like cynical tackles and that's what Punch's tackle was. However, the OP sounds more like a Man City supporter with their massive over reaction. Save your breath for when our players (regularly) receive the rough treatment. Man City have enough support.

 

Glazier#1 Flag 01 Jan 18 12.33pm

Originally posted by mayler/rh13eagle

I think a few on here need to get of there soap boxes!!

Punch had an impact yesterday, the change had to happen as cabayes legs had gone and we were being over run. That said we had no jimmy mac or rlc so Roy tried to remain unchanged as long as poss!

I think people allow the nightclub episode to cloud there judgement! I loved that when punch came on we chanted his name and I thought that that in itself gave us something in those last 10 mins which we needed, so not so much punch but more the sub made a difference and had the desired effect.

I’m sure punch will be the first to admit how far down the pecking order he has slipped. But when needed he will always be there to do a job for us, which imo makes him as valuable part of squad as anyone else.

It was a missed timed tackle at best and yes it was made on one of this years leading lights in the pl. but punch isn’t Roy Keane and therefore would not of flown into that tackle to seriously injure kdb! Il be honest I’m far more concerned about Scott Dann and punch’s injuries than I could ever be about a player at another club but then that’s just me - I support palace and not the premier league!

Happy new year peeps!!

 

Page 2 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > A thread to itself - that challenge on De Bruyne