You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Tony Pulis - Opinions
November 16 2026 7.52am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Tony Pulis - Opinions


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Selhurstboys Flag Basel 06 Jan 18 3.43pm

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

He’s a mercenary. Did a great job for us but he never wanted to be here. Didn’t do a good job of hiding that fact either.

This! He did a good job for us and has a great work ethic which rubs off on the players and everyone at the club but was always distant from the fans. He is only interested in himself and never became part of the Palace family.

Edited by Selhurstboys (06 Jan 2018 3.44pm)

 

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 06 Jan 18 3.54pm

He's a mercenary and has no soul. Something devious and sinister about him, and certainly wouldn't trust him. He will stay around as long as it takes to grab the big bag of cash. I wonder if any fans of his previous clubs would welcome him back? He seems quite well presented in the media but doesn't seem the trustworthy type once you're 'up close'. Funnily enough, now I think about it, before he was at Palace someone who knew him from his time around Bournemouth said his son was an absolute w***er. But people always say stuff like that. I didn't really take any notice of him at the time (he said they'd played together) but now I look back that seems quite feasible! I assume he's referring to Anthony Pulis who evidently didn't play for Bournemouth so this may be dog s***.

So in the interests of fairness, I'll paste a Wikipedia fact:

On 1 June 2015, Pulis completed a 450-mile rowing challenge from Tower Bridge in London to the Eiffel Tower in Paris. He once again teamed up with Nick Hancock and other team members for the Donna Louise Hospice in Stoke. The seven-day nautical challenge eventually raised over £250,000 for the charity.

Willo, you're welcome to have that one for free.

Did an incredible job for us though. Jose Mourinho is just a s*** Tony Pulis when you think about it. He just had Didier Drogba and Ibrahimovic instead of Peter Crouch.

Sam Allardyce is the better all round character and manager in my opinion, and that's despite his England debacle.

 

viveasheagle Flag perth 06 Jan 18 4.03pm

Yes he is a great organiser and you can expect your team to tighten up defensively. You can also expect to improve on you set pieces both in terms of scoring from them and defending them. I think ( can someone correct me ) but this season we have scored one goal from a corner but under Pulis we had both the best record defending corners in the league as well as scoring from them.
The way he left us was a disgrace. After having a great season he took his bonus and ran. I was pleased that he lost the court case and was forced to repay the bonus which he had got paid out early before he quit.
No surprise in that Pardew is struggling to improve things at WBA as he runs a tight ship and we struggled after he initially left.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 06 Jan 18 4.36pm

on a personal note...

i can't stand those white trainers on the touchline. Looks really scummy.

the perma-scowl and the frowning does not fit many football clubs.

but i do enjoy the way he got up Arsene Wengers big nose. ''that was not a football match, that was a rugby team''

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 06 Jan 18 5.11pm

He organised us defensively of course, we ceded possession, but he found the best way for us to attack - get the ball as quick as poss to the wingers, and by identifying our most skillful player, Marouane Chamakh, a non-scoring striker, and turning him into a 'number 10' - the football was not boring or route one, although we did basically park the bus and break quickly.

But he took WBA here two seasons back, they sat back did nothing and were ok for an hour b4 we won 2-0. They were dog food but a 0-0 draw and you can justify it, but if you play with no ambition and lose it's unnacceptable for watching fans esp if they've travelled. I went to the Hawthorns last season when we won 2-0 and their team did seem to consist of 30-something navvies who played horrible football. So it's a mixed picture - his football is not all like it was at Stoke, he is a sophisticated intelligent coach, he knows what he's doing and generally buys well. Good choice for you I'd say - he'll get you up if not this year then next year you'll be one of the favourites, and he can keep you up once you get promoted - so it won't be for a fair few seasons that any grumblings will start, already a great win at Preston, so it looks a positive move.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 06 Jan 18 5.18pm

the navy blue baseball hat is tired from all the frequent changes of club logo.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 06 Jan 18 7.08pm

In a way we got lucky. We had him for long enough that he could sort us out, but not so long that he got his signings in too significantly.

We were a team that played on flair and pace, so he had to play with that. As soon as we wanted Zaha, he wasn't interested. Interesting to note where Pulis and Zaha are both now respectively.

He'll do a good job for you. You'll be difficult to beat and provided you've already got some talented players, the football will be fine because he'll have to use it.

That said, I wouldn't be in the slightest bit surprised if your summer signings included Chris Brunt, Fraizer Campbell, Damien Delaney, and that you then picked up Joey Barton after his ban.

As a bloke, terrible.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

Pikester Flag Worthing 06 Jan 18 8.36pm

I really enjoyed his time at the club - didn't he get Manager of the Season?
I was also shocked and pissed off when he left as I thought he'd give us some stability.

He was never really one to talk about 'Us' and seemed a bit distant from the club but I'll always be grateful for the way he took a very poor squad and made us look like we belonged in the Premiership.

I find it hard to dislike him - whereas I can't stand the little ferret-faced Ian Holloway.

 


You fed me, you bred me, I'll remember your name.

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 06 Jan 18 8.59pm

Shouldn't this be in the Bell end of 2018 thread? **Not Pikester**

 


Pro USA & Israel

Pikester Flag Worthing 06 Jan 18 9.01pm

Originally posted by Jimenez

Shouldn't this be in the Bell end of 2018 thread? **Not Pikester**

I dunno Jim - I'd get more votes than Olly Murs.

.... we are talking size though right?

 


You fed me, you bred me, I'll remember your name.

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 06 Jan 18 9.06pm

he organized us and got every drop of what we could be out of us. I think he was very lucky that he had no real choice except to build a team -- offensively at least -- around Bolasie.

if you look at his career, I'm not sure he trusts flair players who do loads of tricks but he had to with Bolasie and it worked.

So he ends up going with sensible and eventually his teams maybe stagnate -- that's what I think happened at stoke and wba anyway.

but if you're disorganised he'll improve you a lot and you'll not be a soft touch if he can get you up.

I'm no fan of him as a man.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 06 Jan 18 9.33pm

I crossed paths with thus bloke on two occasions. I lived in Gillingham and knew quite a few people who worked at the club. Pullis was seen as a professional.,hard character, but he left under a cloud amid suggestions of inappropriate behaviour towards the staff, players and family there. Not much came out, so I'm wary of talking about things I don't know, only what those who worked with him said. Could be a load of bollux, but he left under a cloud after doing a great job with Gillingham, higher than they have ever been.
Then the Palace situation. He came, he saw and he
Left before he could do anything else. There's no point in the op having opinions about his 'bonus'. A court of law settled that. But he certainly knows his stuff and Palace developed a back-bone that served them well after he left. He is obviously a man of his word because he must have said to our chairman what he wanted from the market for the team and threatened if he didn't get what he wanted he would go, irrespective of timing. And go he did.
Could he have managed a Wilf? He knows more about systems and defence I suppose. Will he have the flair to take a well drilled team that little bit further, to gain promotion? I'm not so sure. But in a play-off game you get nowhere with a 0-0 result.
Good luck Macka.

Edited by adrian b (06 Jan 2018 9.35pm)

 

the.universal 06 Jan 18 9.48pm

Decent manager who will organise you well defensively. Likes to play four central defenders across the back and 2 holding midfielders that aren’t allowed to go forwards.

He likes his striker to do a LOT of closing down. He used Cameron Jerome who barely scored but did a lot of running. On the TV you could sometimes hear TP’s dulcet tones imploring him to ‘ROOOOOON CAM’, and Jerome would always respond, because that was the only way he would get Premier League football. A small vignette of life under Pulis.

I don’t have any hatred towards him, but as others have said he is somewhat calculating.

 


Vive le Roy!

BarEagle Flag Monmouth 06 Jan 18 10.26pm

Originally posted by Pikester

I really enjoyed his time at the club - didn't he get Manager of the Season?
I was also shocked and pissed off when he left as I thought he'd give us some stability.

He was never really one to talk about 'Us' and seemed a bit distant from the club but I'll always be grateful for the way he took a very poor squad and made us look like we belonged in the Premiership.

I find it hard to dislike him - whereas I can't stand the little ferret-faced Ian Holloway.

We don't belong in Scotland do we?...

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 06 Jan 18 10.40pm

He did a great job in making us hard to beat and Dann and Ledley were very good signings in his first window but there was a period when when looked as good as down and he lucked a bit on the form of a couple of individuals.

Not sure he’ll set out to win enough games to get automatic promotion but, contrary to the above, would hate to play against one of his sides in the play offs.

Loves tall players and absolute slag of a bloke. Have a google about his departure from Stoke. Very interesting article about this on the Guardian pages if it’s still there.

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 06 Jan 18 11.15pm

It would be difficult to judge him this season, but he could get you back in the PL the following year with a few additions to your squad. I thought it was a strange move for him taking the Boro job, as it is a step down for him, but then again he most probably never thought he would get the sack from WBA.... Good luck!

 

chateauferret Flag 07 Jan 18 1.38am

Originally posted by BarEagle

We don't belong in Scotland do we?...

Is this your new thing? If you type "Premiership" into Google you get the EPL then about half a dozen other real football leagues and the joke that is the SPL comes about seventh.

People here call the SPL "the fitba".

 


============
The Ferret
============

Headbert Flag Mitcham 07 Jan 18 2.22am

The demonization of CPFC fans of TP (based on the infantile notion that a judicial decision against his contractual claims equals his devilishness in all matters pertaining to his tenure at Palace) is one of the most frightening examples of treacherous, ungrateful, murderous, brainless, cultish, Manson-follower-like behaviour I have ever beheld. I am ashamed of these morons.

Edited by Headbert (07 Jan 2018 2.23am)

 

chateauferret Flag 07 Jan 18 2.26am

Originally posted by Headbert

The demonization of CPFC fans of TP (based on the infantile notion that a judicial decision against his contractual claims equals his devilishness in all matters pertaining to his tenure at Palace) is one of the most frightening examples of murderous, brainless, cultish, Manson-follower-like behaviour I have ever beheld. I am ashamed of these morons.

Edited by Headbert (07 Jan 2018 2.22am)

I thought it was based on the notion that he f***ed off two days before the season started and left us in the s***, and tried to rip us off in the process. I also thought I'd made my own mind up about that and used my reasoning faculties to do that. Perhaps I'm deducing that from the fact that the moment I heard it on the radio, and before looking on here or speaking to anyone else, I immediately thought, "B*****d".

Maybe it's just me.

 


============
The Ferret
============

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 07 Jan 18 2.27am

Originally posted by Headbert

The demonization of CPFC fans of TP (based on the infantile notion that a judicial decision against his contractual claims equals his devilishness in all matters pertaining to his tenure at Palace) is one of the most frightening examples of treacherous, ungrateful, murderous, brainless, cultish, Manson-follower-like behaviour I have ever beheld. I am ashamed of these morons.

Edited by Headbert (07 Jan 2018 2.23am)

I’m ashamed of this moron.

Does that help?

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Tony Pulis - Opinions