You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is Zaha the best player outside the top 6?
November 16 2026 7.52am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Is Zaha the best player outside the top 6?


victor43 Flag St. Albans 12 Jan 18 5.19pm

I have written a (fairly long) blog post looking at whether the numbers support mine and many others beliefs that Wilf is the best player outside the top six Premier League clubs.

[Link]

Pretty number heavy but hopefully you will enjoy. He has certainly taken a big step forward this season, even though he hasn't quite scored the goals/ got the assists he has deserved yet.

Enjoy!

 


Blog: Andy Johnson's Magic Hat [Link]

Twitter:

pssguy Flag 12 Jan 18 5.23pm

Probably him, Richarlson and Mahrez are in the mix

 

victor43 Flag St. Albans 12 Jan 18 5.31pm

Originally posted by pssguy

Probably him, Richarlson and Mahrez are in the mix

Yep, those are 3 of the 4 I come to the conclusion of at the end from their contributions this season.

The last 1 is Arnautovic who was a surprise to me but is consistently very effective in the Prem.

 


Blog: Andy Johnson's Magic Hat [Link]

Twitter:

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 12 Jan 18 5.35pm

Originally posted by victor43

I have written a (fairly long) blog post looking at whether the numbers support mine and many others beliefs that Wilf is the best player outside the top six Premier League clubs.

[Link]

Pretty number heavy but hopefully you will enjoy. He has certainly taken a big step forward this season, even though he hasn't quite scored the goals/ got the assists he has deserved yet.

Enjoy!


Blimey mate - did you write all that stuff just for fun?

You want to get out more lad lol

Its actually very well written and spot on.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

victor43 Flag St. Albans 12 Jan 18 5.51pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle


Blimey mate - did you write all that stuff just for fun?

You want to get out more lad lol

Its actually very well written and spot on.

Haha you might be right, I enjoy it though so what can I say!

Cheers

 


Blog: Andy Johnson's Magic Hat [Link]

Twitter:

Casual Flag Orpington 12 Jan 18 6.17pm

Sigurdsson and vardy are both very good.

 

victor43 Flag St. Albans 12 Jan 18 6.46pm

Originally posted by Casual

Sigurdsson and vardy are both very good.

Agree, although Sigurdsson is very reliant on his set pieces and has struggled to contribute much so far this season.

Vardy is great but he’s not producing at the same level as previously

 


Blog: Andy Johnson's Magic Hat [Link]

Twitter:

SeagullHunter Flag Reading 12 Jan 18 7.57pm

agree with all above suggested. I do think Shaqiri is up there perhaps, along with Tarkowski at Burnley

 


Dont let Cabaye go

mattteo Flag 12 Jan 18 8.07pm

I'd rank Michail Antonio right up there with Zaha, despite his bad 17/18 season so far. In fact, I'd bid 15 million for Antonio rather than 10 for Matt Phillips. Moyes might just be stupid enough to sell him.

Mahrez and Vardy are obviously up there cause they've won a league, which Zaha hasn't.

Tadic from Southampon is a really good left footed player as long as he plays on the wing and not in the center. Best assister in the Eredivisie years in a row, good at Southampton last seasons on the wing.

Lanzini is a younger and less known Coutinho, plays both central and attacking midfielder, no wonder Tottenham wants him.

Shaqiri is the only reason Stoke is still up. As others have said, Sigurdsson kept Swansea up mostly by himself.

Bolasie used to be a promise, but with the injury.....

As for defenders, there are Michael Keane, Ryan Bertrand, Harry Maguire, even Sakho.

One player who I think will really prove himself i the following years is Knockaert.

These are pretty much all.

Edited by mattteo (12 Jan 2018 8.24pm)

 

mattteo Flag 12 Jan 18 8.12pm

Originally posted by victor43


The last 1 is Arnautovic who was a surprise to me but is consistently very effective in the Prem.

Arnautovic scores a lot but also does 0 defensive contribution. He is pretty slow and hardly recovers or drops back

 

pssguy Flag 12 Jan 18 9.52pm

Originally posted by mattteo

I'd rank Michail Antonio right up there with Zaha, despite his bad 17/18 season so far. In fact, I'd bid 15 million for Antonio rather than 10 for Matt Phillips. Moyes might just be stupid enough to sell him.

Mahrez and Vardy are obviously up there cause they've won a league, which Zaha hasn't.

Tadic from Southampon is a really good left footed player as long as he plays on the wing and not in the center. Best assister in the Eredivisie years in a row, good at Southampton last seasons on the wing.

Lanzini is a younger and less known Coutinho, plays both central and attacking midfielder, no wonder Tottenham wants him.

Shaqiri is the only reason Stoke is still up. As others have said, Sigurdsson kept Swansea up mostly by himself.

Bolasie used to be a promise, but with the injury.....

As for defenders, there are Michael Keane, Ryan Bertrand, Harry Maguire, even Sakho.

One player who I think will really prove himself i the following years is Knockaert.

These are pretty much all.

Edited by mattteo (12 Jan 2018 8.24pm)


Some good suggestions there but if you think Antonio is as good as Zaha, I'm guessing 15m wouldn't cut it

Pickford is also a good young goalie

 

pssguy Flag 12 Jan 18 9.54pm

Actually, given that winning the league has been pretty much a procession the last 3 years and the top 6 look set to be same indefinitely how about 2 teams voted in as the best from the rest and an 8 team knock-out to determine champs

 

mattteo Flag 12 Jan 18 10.01pm

Originally posted by pssguy


Some good suggestions there but if you think Antonio is as good as Zaha, I'm guessing 15m wouldn't cut it

We're talking about Moyes here. He's just come as manager. Didn't get the wonderful displays Antonio put up in the last 2 years. Has only used the man as a center forward.
And Moyes is known for doing these sort of things. At Sunderland, he let Lens and Giaccherini go before the season started.
Didn't play Khazri, the team's best player the previous year, at all.
Sold van Aanholt in the winter, the league's left back with most assists.
Needless to say these were the guys who had kept Sunderland up the last 2 seasons, together with Borini and Vito Mannone. Sunderland went down bottom last.

Now Moyes is at West Ham. I can't wait to see what wonderful transfers he's going to make here!!! He already has it against Chicharito and Andre Ayew and is seeking a backup for Michail Antonio. Oh, Boy

Edited by mattteo (12 Jan 2018 10.02pm)

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 12 Jan 18 10.05pm

Ive always love Palace, but you lot and many more have gone to a level of knowledge that I am lost at.
Its all to do with the internet in my view.
But whatever if you enjoy it then great.
Palace has been part of my life for many years and I'm proud of that.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 12 Jan 18 10.34pm

Zaha is our star and he thrives at this level.
Where would he be at Barcelona say?

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 12 Jan 18 11.19pm

i dont know if your right or wrong

i do know that IMO wilf is more than good enough for a top club

if coutinho is worth £146m, then wilf is worth at least half of that.

£75m and i wont argue with him being sold

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Painter Flag Croydon 13 Jan 18 4.53am

Originally posted by pssguy

Actually, given that winning the league has been pretty much a procession the last 3 years and the top 6 look set to be same indefinitely how about 2 teams voted in as the best from the rest and an 8 team knock-out to determine champs

How do you class Leicesters winning the Premier a procession, they had never been anywhere near the top 6 for years, then won it from nowhere.

Mahrez and Vardy are better than Zaha at this point in time.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 13 Jan 18 9.20am

Originally posted by Painter

How do you class Leicesters winning the Premier a procession, they had never been anywhere near the top 6 for years, then won it from nowhere.

Mahrez and Vardy are better than Zaha at this point in time.

Schlupp also won the Premier League

Some of the players mentioned have been poor or average this season. Southampton fans seem ready to pack Tadic's bags saying he is a lazy waste of space. Arnautovic was being described as a massive waste of money until a return to form under Moyes. Keane has not performed as well as expected since his move and Vardy is not what he was.

Zaha has been consistently one of the best players on the pitch in nearly every game he's played this season, and has had a direct hand in a large share of our goals (directly or indirectly). For me he is definitely right up there and for entertainment alone he is worth more than any club could offer (unless Barcelona want to swap us Messi plus cash).

 

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 13 Jan 18 12.27pm

With a rational head, you'd say that, as a complete player, there are a few who are better than Wilf.

But I don't think there are many players, at any club in this league, who are as exciting as Wilf, and as enjoyable to watch.

It's also worth remembering how consistently he is putting in game changing contributions. Take out Southampton where I thought he was noticeably shattered, our recent games have included:

City: wins a pen which should've won us the game
Arsenal: assist for Townsend goal
Swansea: played in RLC to get the pen
Leicester: scored
Watford: set up both goals
Bournemouth: won a pen

That's not including how many times he's layed it on a plate for Benteke. I know we play in a way where everything runs through him, but how many other players in the league are creating, scoring, or influencing goals week in, week out? De Bruyne? Salah? Mahrez? There's not a lot.

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is Zaha the best player outside the top 6?