You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Wow Silva sacked!!
November 22 2026 8.03pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Wow Silva sacked!!


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Jan 18 12.39pm

Originally posted by MKCPFC

He is so over rated. Won a few games at Hull then took them on a terrible run that sent them down.

I am disappointed as I was hoping he would do the double , we probably have just lost a relegation rival to aim for.

He didn't take them on a terrible run last season. We finished them off. That's what happened and I remember the tension for a matter of minutes before Wilf was gifted goal 1 of 4.

He did a remarkable job getting such a shyte team into the position he did from nowhere and the 3 players they were missing killed them versus us with us only missing Sakho I think.

 


COYP

phillanth Flag London 21 Jan 18 12.44pm

Originally posted by kenbarr

Two things strike me. One is that the highly touted Marco Silva is over-rated. Watford, as they usually have done since coming up, won a few games early then settled into midseason mediocrity. Silva did nothing to change that pattern. However, the Pozzo's let the two previous managers finish the season. Has Watfords form been so bad under Silva that he deserved to go before the transfer window shut? Since the only time I care about Watford is when they play Palace, I really don't know the answer to that question.

The second is that there has been a whole lot of front running by pundits when it comes to Silva. Yes, he did improve Hull's form last year but not nearly enough to avoid the drop. His demeanour at Selhurst last spring was one of complete resignation when Zaha's goal went in for 1-0. He did nothing to rally his players and just became a spectator while we ended up thrashing them 4-0. I saw the same resignation when Palace came back on Watford earlier this season. Yes, they had a sending off. However, Palace in recent years haven't normally been able to take advantage when up a player. Not this time. Hodgson made tactical changes, the players responded and Palace stormed back for the win. Silva, on the other hand, just sat in his dugout seemingly bemoaning his side's fate. No tactical realignment, no words of encouragement for his players, nothing. However, the TV commentators continued their paeans of praise for him until the Palace goals went in.

Last night I met a retired PL ref at a party in Manhattan who works for MLS HQ. I wish I could remember his name but I had a couple of gin on the rocks and wasn't feeling much pain. He is a West Brom supporter and had nothing but praise and admiration for Roy Hodgson. The word that he kept using to describe him was "classy." On the other hand, from what I've seen of him, admittedly all on TV, Marco Silva just doesn't seem to have the grit and determination it takes to succeed in English football, either as a player or coach/manager. Couple that with an ownership that keeps changing managers at the drop of a hat and then coming up with lame excuses for the changes and the seeds of disaster have definitely been sown. Would someone please tell me how it is Everton's fault that Silva didn't meet expectations at Watford? Are they saying that Silva was so distracted he couldn't keep his attention on his job to manage the Hornets? That seems terribly lame to me.

Palace had a miserable start with RdB but Hodgson is clearly an inspired choice. Marco Silva, who has been the flavor of the month for some, clearly was not. I believe his next job will be on the continent. He wasn't made to be a manager of an English club. Unless, of course, Ashley decides to fire Rafa or Rafa gets fed up and leaves. Then Silva certainly fits in with the drama that is The Toon.

Edited by kenbarr (21 Jan 2018 11.52am)

My son and I got chatting to a couple of Baggies fans before our recent game up there and they were full of praise for Roy. Must admit that at the time I thought we had made a mistake by not going for Silva when BFS resigned. Looks like I was dead wrong. Still think he would have done a better job than de Boer though!

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Jan 18 12.50pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

I like the side-swipe at the Toffees for tapping him up. If he were any good he would have just ignored it and carried on.

It looks like there's something in this 'distraction' reason when you also consider he didn't look too concerned Hill were done at Selhurst, he knew Watford were interested, he could move on from Watford after just 1 year without problems and Everton plus probably others might be courting him.

Silva is not sh1t but there's certainly this poaching and distraction weakness surrounding him in this ruthless business.

Frank de Boer was absolutely sh1t. Silva is in infant school whereas Roy is studying a PhD in lower half premier league management.

I wouldn't say Silva was a bullet dodged. More like it would've been alright at least, certainly better than Frank's shyte, but then this sort of thing would've happened at any time. We at least wouldn't have lost 7, not scored a goal in 11, played our best player out of position, dropped him and others, ruined the form of our striker and completely turned the chairman to get him out asap. Oh no.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Jan 18 12.54pm

Originally posted by phillanth

My son and I got chatting to a couple of Baggies fans before our recent game up there and they were full of praise for Roy. Must admit that at the time I thought we had made a mistake by not going for Silva when BFS resigned. Looks like I was dead wrong. Still think he would have done a better job than de Boer though!

Exactly. So you weren't dead wrong we should've gone for Silva as he was the best younger manager available. And Frank should never have been considered unless we had £80 or £100 mil to spend, which I shudder to think of Frank spending that.

Near on nobody wanted Roy and he's turned out to be the best. The job now is us keeping him with backing, rather than him needing us.

 


COYP

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 21 Jan 18 12.55pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

He didn't take them on a terrible run last season. We finished them off. That's what happened and I remember the tension for a matter of minutes before Wilf was gifted goal 1 of 4.

He did a remarkable job getting such a shyte team into the position he did from nowhere and the 3 players they were missing killed them versus us with us only missing Sakho I think.

Won 1 of last seven games.
You do not think that is a bad run.
He did well at first , the new manager bounce I think it's called , then his influence came over the team.
Just like Watford really.

 

chateauferret Flag 21 Jan 18 12.56pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

"Sky sources understand that Watford already have a new manager lined up and that he will be a newcomer to English football."

That augurs well. Who could it be?

I know. Let's go and have a look at Sky Bet :-)

Jose Lopez.

Edited by chateauferret (21 Jan 2018 11.16am)

And now

"Sky sources: Javi Gracia will be named Watford head coach in the next 24 hours after agreeing a two-year deal".

 


============
The Ferret
============

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Jan 18 1.05pm

Originally posted by MKCPFC

Won 1 of last seven games.
You do not think that is a bad run.
He did well at first , the new manager bounce I think it's called , then his influence came over the team.
Just like Watford really.

The last 2 were us and Spurs. We killed them off.

Did you watch the Hull v Sunderland match the week before us and hull all over them before 2 goals against the run of play? Reverse that result which was looking highly likely and it would've been 7 points from 15 just after 2 back to back wins. That game at Selhurst would've been a bit more nervy I would think. But it wasn't to be for them. Big effort, not enough players.

 


COYP

Jacey Flag 21 Jan 18 1.13pm

Cannot believe this sacking as he was lauded in some quarters as the new messiah!!

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 21 Jan 18 1.26pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

The last 2 were us and Spurs. We killed them off.

Did you watch the Hull v Sunderland match the week before us and hull all over them before 2 goals against the run of play? Reverse that result which was looking highly likely and it would've been 7 points from 15 just after 2 back to back wins. That game at Selhurst would've been a bit more nervy I would think. But it wasn't to be for them. Big effort, not enough players.

Well I never thought of changing what actually happened to make him better. You are right if we say he could have won the games they lost they would have stayed up. When Watford realise that if they won the games they lost they would be above City they will regret the decision to sack him.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 21 Jan 18 1.30pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Marco Silva' by Midlands Eagle

I remember in the summer many on here were adamant we should have got Silva before Watford when it was clear he was leaving Hull.

Think we dodged a bullet as he has just been sacked by Watford.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Jan 18 1.40pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Marco Silva' by Midlands Eagle

I remember in the summer many on here were adamant we should have got Silva before Watford when it was clear he was leaving Hull.

Think we dodged a bullet as he has just been sacked by Watford.

If you call not hiring a manager who's likely to have an equipped team nowhere near bottom with no points or goals and instead hiring a manager who did whose akin to hiring an atom bomb at the training ground then I guess you're right it's a bullet dodged.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Jan 18 1.46pm

Originally posted by MKCPFC

Well I never thought of changing what actually happened to make him better. You are right if we say he could have won the games they lost they would have stayed up. When Watford realise that if they won the games they lost they would be above City they will regret the decision to sack him.

So you didn't watch the hull 0-2 Sunderland match the week before hull played us then. Any one of those however many chances they had makes it 1-0 to hull and more than likely we'd be relegated.

That's how close it was but some have forgotten that, and have even forgotten the tension before the 4-0. Their 3 injuries and the 1-0 gift swayed it massively in our favour.

 


COYP

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 21 Jan 18 1.50pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

So you didn't watch the hull 0-2 Sunderland match the week before hull played us then. Any one of those however many chances they had makes it 1-0 to hull and more than likely we'd be relegated.

That's how close it was but some have forgotten that, and have even forgotten the tension before the 4-0. Their 3 injuries and the 1-0 gift swayed it massively in our favour.

This^^^

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 21 Jan 18 2.06pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

So you didn't watch the hull 0-2 Sunderland match the week before hull played us then. Any one of those however many chances they had makes it 1-0 to hull and more than likely we'd be relegated.

That's how close it was but some have forgotten that, and have even forgotten the tension before the 4-0. Their 3 injuries and the 1-0 gift swayed it massively in our favour.

I have seen many games Palace should have won but lost. Although we should have won we still lost, nothing changes that.
You could say that after he got them their two wins which gave them a shout, suddenly the pressure was really on and the pressure got to his team and hI'm and could not help them beat Sunderland a team already down.
Injuries? Speak to Roy about dealing with them.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Jan 18 2.13pm

Originally posted by MKCPFC

I have seen many games Palace should have won but lost. Although we should have won we still lost, nothing changes that.
You could say that after he got them their two wins which gave them a shout, suddenly the pressure was really on and the pressure got to his team and hI'm and could not help them beat Sunderland a team already down.
Injuries? Speak to Roy about dealing with them.

Silva's hull injuries and Roy's have nothing to do with this. And the 11 players Roy has been able to play p1ss all over that 11 at Selhurst last season, as they should and did on the day.

The pressure didn't look on v Sunderland. They were all over them. The pressure was on for them at Selhurst because the chances didn't go in v Sunderland and they lost.

 


COYP

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 21 Jan 18 2.26pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Silva's hull injuries and Roy's have nothing to do with this. And the 11 players Roy has been able to play p1ss all over that 11 at Selhurst last season, as they should and did on the day.

The pressure didn't look on v Sunderland. They were all over them. The pressure was on for them at Selhurst because the chances didn't go in v Sunderland and they lost.

Hull under Silva were shocking away from home and were terrible at defending set pieces. He was incapable of even basic organisation at set pieces. Look at what Pulis did with us and compare that with Silva at Hull.

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 21 Jan 18 6.10pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Silva's hull injuries and Roy's have nothing to do with this. And the 11 players Roy has been able to play p1ss all over that 11 at Selhurst last season, as they should and did on the day.

The pressure didn't look on v Sunderland. They were all over them. The pressure was on for them at Selhurst because the chances didn't go in v Sunderland and they lost.


But it was Rudi , it had become a must win game and they were expected to win it , that's when the pressure in on , you cannot see it. It's the pressure that makes you miss those chances and lose games you should have won. Silva obviously could not take the pressure off his team.
Anyway his pattern of good start bad finish was mirrored at Watford from a Palace point of view it's a shame they got rid.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Jan 18 6.13pm

Originally posted by MKCPFC


But it was Rudi , it had become a must win game and they were expected to win it , that's when the pressure in on , you cannot see it. It's the pressure that makes you miss those chances and lose games you should have won. Silva obviously could not take the pressure off his team.
Anyway his pattern of good start bad finish was mirrored at Watford from a Palace point of view it's a shame they got rid.

Sometimes chances just don't go in.

The bad results at Watford have come after the Everton approach and £10 mil offer of compensation.

 


COYP

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 21 Jan 18 6.42pm

I do not subscribe to this Everton approach being the reason for their demise.
He is paid professional manager, unless he went in every day in an Everton shirt and said you lot are rubbish I deserve to be at Everton , what problems could it cause? If he lost the trust and confidence of his players it's down to him.
Anyway not sure why I am discussing a failed premier manager , he is minted and He will probably do well in another country's league where there are only three orooms four teams to compete with.

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 21 Jan 18 6.47pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops


Do you genuinely think that or do you think its just the Watford way? They seem to dump managers after very short periods. To be fair most of our recent managers just left rather than were sacked!

I genuinely mean it and I thought it at the time. He’s a man of questionable loayalty.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Wow Silva sacked!!