This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by mattteo
Think again. And he's contributed to a lot of goals this year, though he has hardly been sent on the pitch. The OP's question has a no-brainer answer. Obviously, Batshuayi will be a class football player for 6-7 years to come. 1 back flick doesn't prove much. CB is having an awful season but watch the build up to Luca's goal against Southampton. CB started the move on the halfway line with excellent skill.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
1 back flick doesn't prove much. CB is having an awful season but watch the build up to Luca's goal against Southampton. CB started the move on the halfway line with excellent skill.
24 yo vs 27 yo What are we talking about?
|
|
|
Originally posted by mattteo
24 yo vs 27 yo What are we talking about? Beneteke is having a bad season, everyone knows that. He is, however, a proven Premier league striker more than capable of scoring double figures and regardless of whether he is scoring or not he is quite pivotal to the way we play. He has scored the majority of his goals playing for a team fighting relegation or lower down the table with players around him that are nowhere near the ilk of the Chelsea team. I am not sure that Batshuayi would be able to do the job Benteke does for us, he is a different type of striker and we have tried that many times and almost always revert back to a target man. People call Benteke lazy but I don't really think he is, his problem is the pricetag over his head. When he was out the team we had a couple of decent games with Andros and Wilf up top but that got quickly found out and left us very wanting with creativity when it was. He lacks confidence big time at the moment, key is the miss against Arsenal one on one, look back to the game against Chelsea last season where he had a much harder chance but because he was scoring he calmly lifted it over the keeper. We need options to challenge him and give us the ability to mix it up but I don't think getting rid of him is the answer, especially a swap for a player who really is still pretty inexperienced in this league. Rashford banged them in for fun when he first got in the Utd. side but it's not been the same since. 'one swallow doesn't make a summer'.. Benteke has hit double figures every season bar the season with Liverpool which he got 9 and mainly off the bench, I wouldn't write him off just yet.
"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway |
|
|
Originally posted by Icepick Tony
Beneteke is having a bad season, everyone knows that. He is, however, a proven Premier league striker more than capable of scoring double figures and regardless of whether he is scoring or not he is quite pivotal to the way we play. He has scored the majority of his goals playing for a team fighting relegation or lower down the table with players around him that are nowhere near the ilk of the Chelsea team. I am not sure that Batshuayi would be able to do the job Benteke does for us, he is a different type of striker and we have tried that many times and almost always revert back to a target man. People call Benteke lazy but I don't really think he is, his problem is the pricetag over his head. When he was out the team we had a couple of decent games with Andros and Wilf up top but that got quickly found out and left us very wanting with creativity when it was. He lacks confidence big time at the moment, key is the miss against Arsenal one on one, look back to the game against Chelsea last season where he had a much harder chance but because he was scoring he calmly lifted it over the keeper. We need options to challenge him and give us the ability to mix it up but I don't think getting rid of him is the answer, especially a swap for a player who really is still pretty inexperienced in this league. Rashford banged them in for fun when he first got in the Utd. side but it's not been the same since. 'one swallow doesn't make a summer'.. Benteke has hit double figures every season bar the season with Liverpool which he got 9 and mainly off the bench, I wouldn't write him off just yet. Matteo: this is what we are talking about... summed up very well. Maybe watching on TV you don't see everything regarding his contribution. Don't get me wrong he is not having a good season but he does contribute.
|
|
|
Originally posted by mattteo
24 yo vs 27 yo What are we talking about? Yet more pointless stats that prove absolutely nothing. If Benteke was at Chelsea & Batshuayi at Palace from the start of the season those numbers would be completely different. FWIW the Chelski ST holders I know think Batshuayi lacks positional sense, can’t seem to hold the ball up & his decision making is suspect. Much of that could be addressed with some good coaching & plenty of match time but, right now, we don’t have the time to get him firing.
Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five! |
|
|
Originally posted by Icepick Tony
You see- this is what I have a problem with. Tricking football. When you take a gazzillion penalties for your team, you'll surely hit double figures. Doesn't mean you'd have hit those figures if you weren't the designed penalty taker. Let's have all strikers as penalty takers and then say that Benteke hit double figures and others didn't! Without taking penalties, he'd have: Total playing time: 13.500 minutes. Edited by mattteo (23 Jan 2018 8.21pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by mattteo
You see- this is what I have a problem with. Tricking football. When you take a gazzillion penalties for your team, you'll surely hit double figures. Doesn't mean you'd have hit those figures if you weren't the designed penalty taker. Let's have all strikers as penalty takers and then say that Benteke hit double figures and others didn't! Without taking penalties, he'd have: Total playing time: 13.500 minutes. Edited by mattteo (23 Jan 2018 8.21pm) Like I said, Benteke has more about his game than just goals which fits our system-Cameron Jerome the season we came up hardly scored but was pivitol to our survival with his tenacious work from the front and ability to hold the ball up. scoring wasnt part of that. The team has let Beneteke down as much as he has let us down with goals this season. Failing to read flick ons and no one else really stepping up to get goals have been our sticking point. Your goals per minute stats don't paint the full picture about fit for a team. Someone is always going to have better stats, doesn't mean they can do the job required. Could we upgrade Benteke? Not without paying through the nose, could we help him by adding competition and someone else to ease the burdon? Sure we can which is what we should be looking to do.
"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway |
|
|
Originally posted by Icepick Tony
Like I said, Benteke has more about his game than just goals which fits our system-Cameron Jerome the season we came up hardly scored but was pivitol to our survival with his tenacious work from the front and ability to hold the ball up. scoring wasnt part of that. The team has let Beneteke down as much as he has let us down with goals this season. If Benteke is better at hold-up play can only be assessed by a more qualified eye than you or I or even Ray Wilkins. It's subjective. It's not quantifiable, like how many goals they scored. Some people at Chelsea thought Batshuayi is better than Benteke 1 year ago when they decided to pay 30 million for him and not Benteke. Others at Liverpool thought Benteke is better at holding the ball and building up attacks a few years back and gambled on him. You see something more in Benteke, I see something more in Batshuayi. It's subjective. And on the subject of the team letting Benteke down.....I think Zaha and Townsend are really good assisters, PVA is a great crosser. He has players to work with, better than in 7-8 other PL teams. He has let himself down
|
|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
Swap with 10m to us but a buy back option for them (at 42.5m) and I'd do it. I think money is tight and this would help elsewhere. Batshuayi may be worse at holding it up, but I see him as much more mobile...and just needing to be loved. 10 m to us? More like 20 million to them. Benteke's value is around 20 million at this point. Batshuayi's is at more than 30, probably 40. Borussia Dortmund and Sevilla would gladly pay 30 million for him if Chelsea was willing to sell, they've been monitoring the situation. On the other hand, I don't see many clubs lining up to pay even 20 million for Benteke if Palace said he was available.
|
|
|
Originally posted by mattteo
10 m to us? More like 20 million to them. Benteke's value is around 20 million at this point. Batshuayi's is at more than 30, probably 40. Borussia Dortmund and Sevilla would gladly pay 30 million for him if Chelsea was willing to sell, they've been monitoring the situation. On the other hand, I don't see many clubs lining up to pay even 20 million for Benteke if Palace said he was available.
We are reasonably happy to keep Benteke though, and what he brings. So the demand in this transaction may be one-sided, I reckon. Which is why I think your valuation is out (regardless of market prices). And with the Chinese spending in the game, 20m for Benteke is just too low. He's assisting quite nicely now, and there's every chance he'll hit a vein of scoring form.
If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities. |
|
|
Originally posted by Belgian Eagle
Whilst I agree Benteke is performing way below par (at least in terms of end product), we can't deny that he's still an important part of our current team, which is now consistently picking up points. I think it would be a huge gamble to offload Benteke and replace him with an (let's face it) unproven striker like Batshuayi, even though the latter is probably more talented. Which is why, if Chelsea wanted it to happen, the net flow of cash would need to be from them to us. And a reasonable dollop of the stuff. But it aint THAT much of a gamble. I think Batshuayi brings better mobility and defending from the front, he's probably similar in terms of goal scoring/assisting, and with games I think he'd catch up in terms of hold up play. Which is a vital component for a club like us, and the main worry of swapping.
If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities. |
|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
We are reasonably happy to keep Benteke though, and what he brings. So the demand in this transaction may be one-sided, I reckon. Which is why I think your valuation is out (regardless of market prices). And with the Chinese spending in the game, 20m for Benteke is just too low. He's assisting quite nicely now, and there's every chance he'll hit a vein of scoring form. A large pink pig has for some unknown reason just flown
Bring back Brolin |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.