You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why we got our tails kicked this transfer window?
November 16 2026 7.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Why we got our tails kicked this transfer window?


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
victor43 Flag St. Albans 30 Jan 18 10.33am

Originally posted by tpuffpendants

Agree with all, buttttt..... those teams are getting players that can help them avoid relegation, and so far we arent. I just Dont see Jach or Rakip being impact players this season

The thing with us is that our first 11 is playing well enough to keep us up, they've shown that the last 15 games or so.

We just need some additional depth for the squad - particularly striker.

Comparing to other team's signings:
- Ulloa - not as good as Benteke, plus a loan which we can't do
- Sturridge - loan, and injury prone
- Locadia - big big gamble from the Eredivise. Brighton need someone to come in and make an immediate impact
- Carrillo - has hardly played any football in the last 2 seasons

Basically - it's tough to get someone good in in January.

 


Blog: Andy Johnson's Magic Hat [Link]

Twitter:

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 30 Jan 18 10.54am

Originally posted by victor43

The thing with us is that our first 11 is playing well enough to keep us up, they've shown that the last 15 games or so.

We just need some additional depth for the squad - particularly striker.

Comparing to other team's signings:
- Ulloa - not as good as Benteke, plus a loan which we can't do
- Sturridge - loan, and injury prone
- Locadia - big big gamble from the Eredivise. Brighton need someone to come in and make an immediate impact
- Carrillo - has hardly played any football in the last 2 seasons

Basically - it's tough to get someone good in in January.

And why it should've been done in August, or even better, July. But the sun did rise in September the day we sacked Frank so I suppose it's all good and the luck on this kerplunk with the squad will never run out.

 


COYP

ItsCPFCforme Flag 30 Jan 18 11.23am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

That must be the daftest excuse of the week otherwise all London born footballers would be queuing up at our door

He is only on loan there... why relocate to somewhere he doesn’t know for a few months?

Why do you think Puncheon joined us initially? Was it because we were an extremely attractive place to be? Don’t be daft.

 

ItsCPFCforme Flag 30 Jan 18 11.27am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Agreed to an extent, but you can't deny the attraction of a return home, especially if you still regularly visit the area for family etc. I think that's all he meant.

Thank you. That is what I meant. He chose West Brom over Newcastle. It’s not for footballing reasons i’d Imagine.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 30 Jan 18 11.52am

Originally posted by ItsCPFCforme

Why do you think Puncheon joined us initially? Was it because we were an extremely attractive place to be? Don’t be daft.

Probably because he wanted play football for us rather than warm the bench at Southampton.

Let's not forget that Sturridge was supposed to be going to Inter Milan on loan which is somewhat further than Birmingham but that fell through because Inter couldn't shift one of their players out.

Quite possibly west Brom were the only club that was interested in signing him on loan

 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 30 Jan 18 12.52pm

Yes and we can not add another loan player unless we would sent RLC back. Or TM, but that would be madness as he is just coming good at this stage.

Sturridge is one of those players who play all for himself anyway. He may have some class, but would not have liked him at ours

 

The Dolphin Flag 30 Jan 18 1.09pm

West Brom are starting to wind me up.
They seem to be bolstering their squad right now - just saying!

 

Username Flag Horsham 30 Jan 18 1.11pm

Originally posted by ItsCPFCforme

Thank you. That is what I meant. He chose West Brom over Newcastle. It’s not for footballing reasons i’d Imagine.

I think it's more likely that WBA is more convenient for him because he won't have to move into a hotel for four months. He can pretty easily just drive down from where he currently lives I'd imagine.

Newcastle, London or Milan, even if teams were interested none of us could have offered that.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 30 Jan 18 1.17pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

West Brom are starting to wind me up.
They seem to be bolstering their squad right now - just saying!

Might play every game or about 3.

 


COYP

The Dolphin Flag 30 Jan 18 1.23pm

Schurrle as well apparently?

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 30 Jan 18 1.57pm

I'm expecting Parish to agree terms on a return for Clinton, only for freedman to kick up a stink as it's well known they don't get on, freedman to demand he's in the 25 and not Clinton, Roy to have had enough and claim he's repaired his reputation and freedman to take over as player-manager.

We'll struggle but with Benteke out with a headache, Dougie's hat trick v Brighton including juggling the ball into the net at the Holmesdale end and beating Pardew's West Brom 6-5 is enough to keep us up on the final day, just, above Brighton.

 


COYP

ItsCPFCforme Flag 30 Jan 18 2.03pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Probably because he wanted play football for us rather than warm the bench at Southampton.

Let's not forget that Sturridge was supposed to be going to Inter Milan on loan which is somewhat further than Birmingham but that fell through because Inter couldn't shift one of their players out.

Quite possibly west Brom were the only club that was interested in signing him on loan

The fact Puncheon is a local lad was pivotal to us getting him on loan in 2013 (or was it 2014?). He was definitely good enough then to have gone elsewhere.

Same situation with Sturridge: he wants to play, and knows he can get a game with a club who are based near where his mother and other family members live. He may well have been tempted by the Inter loan because of the size of the club but he wouldn’t have picked us over West Brom say. That was my whole initial point. I was questioning the idea we were ever in for Sturridge we ‘lost’ him to West Brom.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 30 Jan 18 5.29pm

Originally posted by tpuffpendants

Who's spot are they taking to help in the defense dept.? Sakho is back Ward is back luka healthy

healthy for now, but yeah, last 20 mins, stick them on, preserve a lead, clean sheet etc. don't want burn out now.

 


This was once a quality forum....

The Dolphin Flag 31 Jan 18 8.04am

I have just posted this under the Amadou thread in transfers -
None of us know what is really going on behind the scenes but there is one thing I do not and will never understand.
If the selling club wants a certain figure and you definitely want their player just pay up.
If they want £20m for this guy and we want him then do the deal - why bother trying to save a few sheckles here and there.
Get the job done.
If another Club hijacks this deal then we will again look really silly.

It is like buying a house - if you want it and you can afford it then buy it because if you muck around for too long then you will lose the deal!

 

homes Flag New Eltham 31 Jan 18 8.30am

Originally posted by tpuffpendants

Thoughts on why we've been losing our targets to other bottom clubs? I was fine with/expecting Ulloa to go to Brighton as he once played there and is a bit s***e for us. But after seeing pards and wb end up with Sturridge, I was a bit livid. Perhaps this will be a good thing for us when he gets injured for them, but still shakin in my boots a bit without us sealing down a 2nd striker as of yet

you do know that the transfer window hasn't shut yet? also were we ever in for Sturridge?

 


IH: "I thought Jonny and Wilf were brilliant but it took a 39 year old master to watch the ball and keep his eye on it to finish it".

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why we got our tails kicked this transfer window?