You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Cabaye
November 16 2026 7.38am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Cabaye


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Loz83 Flag Crawley 12 Feb 18 7.45am

Originally posted by MKCPFC

Cabaye as far as I can recall was our first stella signing . (In this era)
Has never lived up to what we hoped he would be.
Can't shoot , dead ball kicks all poor, just disappointing.

I have to agree, he’s had a few great game for us but not enough. I’ve never thought wow he’s bossing the game, he’s just an average prem midfielder , but an average prem midfielder cost 15-20 mill to replace these days!

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 12 Feb 18 9.14am

Originally posted by Wilbraham413

He's one of the few players we have who is decent at maintaining possession and rarely gives the ball away stupidly.

We have a lot of problems, but Cabaye isn't one of them.

But I agree his set pieces are so bad, I have no idea why he keeps taking them. He hasn't kicked a decent corner all year. Get someone else to do it.

Pretty much how I view it - I think he's our best passer in nearly every game - the floated ball to Benteke on Saturday was class, and leads to a goal 90% of the time.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 12 Feb 18 9.43am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Pretty much how I view it - I think he's our best passer in nearly every game - the floated ball to Benteke on Saturday was class, and leads to a goal 90% of the time.

Cabaye at this stage of his career would be very useful for us coming off the bench with say 15 mins to go when we perhaps needed to get a goal against opponents who might be flagging.At the present, our injury situation means there is no alternative but to start him.

He has that ability to pick a pass but at 31 I'm not sure about his effectiveness over 90 mins.

Edited by Willo (12 Feb 2018 9.45am)

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 12 Feb 18 9.45am

Originally posted by Willo

There has much been mentioned in this post about passing the ball.For a while I have been singing the praises of Shelvey who would be very effective for us.I accept he has his problems on the pitch with discipline but my goodness his range of passing is to be admired.He was MOM against Man Utd today !

I totally agree that we needed to strengthen the midfield 'Engine Room' - we signed Rakip but he hasn't played since November/December.


Problem is that i guess all the clubs around us know how good he is and would love to sign him, absolutely no chance N.U would sell him to a relegation rival unfortunately, even if we had money.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 12 Feb 18 9.47am

Cabaye is good enough to start any Palace game, but his corners are hopeless. Just don't understand why he keeps taking them....Townsend & Luka a lot better.

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 12 Feb 18 9.47am

Originally posted by MKCPFC

Do I care what you think ? No. Same as what you care what I think.

The guy has just been disappointing .

Christ, what side of the bed did you get out of.

 

mattteo Flag 12 Feb 18 9.58am

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

Not been as effective as the player he initially replaced in Jedinak really has he?

What do you mean by effectiveness??????

Cabaye has scored 9 times and assisted 5 for Palace in 3 PL seasons. And has a background of scoring and assisting from his Newcastle days.
Jedinak (who now is 33, so you can't possibly say he'd still have been good) has scored twice and assisted 5 times in just as many seasons in the PL, disregarding penalties. Yes, he was more of a defensive midfielder, but why make a comparison based on effectiveness?


As I agree age doesn't eventually forgive anyone, I think Cabaye is still one of the fastest playmakers in the league. Cabaye is faster than:
Tom Davies
Adrien Silva
Dembele
Joe Allen (as much as you'd think he's fast, his height doesn't help him keep up anymore and they are signalling the exact same thing on their forums as you are about Cabaye)
Shelvey
Aaron Mooy


So I don't think he's past it at all. I wouldn't like Cabaye gone and replaced with someone like Shelvey at all. Similar players in technical ability (maestros with the ball), but there would be a real loss in stamina and movement and recoveries.
Yes, Cabaye is not in his 20s anymore, but he is still one of the fastest 31 year old players out there who play in the playmaker position.

Edited by mattteo (12 Feb 2018 9.58am)

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 12 Feb 18 10.05am

Originally posted by adrian b

I think Cabaye is the best passer in the squad. Nothing elaborate, just continual give and go. He keeps it tidy. Palace are in a dodgy patch do we need to pull together

he is OK - decent - but not much more than that and rather less than the Newcastle version - on Cabaye, Townsend and Benteke we have spent £57 million - other teams have lesser names with better quality - Everton spent fortunes in the summer but some of their best players the other day Gueye, Davies and Kenny cost £7 million in total - getting proven qualiy is one thing, buying at the top of the market (like Everton did for Bolasie) or past its sell by date is another.

 

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 12 Feb 18 11.11am

Originally posted by adrian b

I think Cabaye is the best passer in the squad. Nothing elaborate, just continual give and go. He keeps it tidy. Palace are in a dodgy patch do we need to pull together

I agree with this,he rarely gives the ball away.

Brilliant passer.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 12 Feb 18 11.34am

Originally posted by alexdyoung87

I accept that I might get pelters for getting this off my chest but it’s been on my mind for a fair while...what does Cabaye actually do to benefit the team?

I don’t actually know what his best position is after 2.5 seasons with us. He doesn’t seem to be a defensive midfielder-strong in the tackle and protecting the back four. Nor does he appear to be an effective attacking midfielder- creating chances, grabbing assists and/or goals. I’m regularly left disappointed by his set piece deliveries.

Yes, he does appear to have a decent stamina and can seemingly hassle opponents but I’d expect no less from a Premier League footballer and I’m continuously left asking myself, ‘what DOES he actually do?!’ When we signed him, he was our elite, supposedly world class player who stood out above the rest however I feel he’s fading into complete insignificance.

Any comments much appreciated.

You wont get any pelters from me...he's been chasing shadows for much of the last 18months bar the odd game (most noticeably Chelski at home this season). He only has the fitness for 30mins max of what is required nowadays...which is a shame.

I'd sooner see Jimmy Mac dropped alongside Luka now and Rakip given a chance in the 'hole'.

Even then I dont see Jimmy Mac being the answer...just that he'd have more energy than Cabaye in that position until the end of the season. Reidewald would be my preferred option as his probably the best passer of the ball we have...but he needs to be a little more physical.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 12 Feb 18 11.36am

Originally posted by adrian b

I think Cabaye is the best passer in the squad. Nothing elaborate, just continual give and go. He keeps it tidy. Palace are in a dodgy patch do we need to pull together

I'd have to respectfully disagree...he's fine passing sideways...but nowhere the quality of feeding penetrative balls in between the lines that Reidewald and Mama are. Cabaye simply plays the safe ball 80% of the time.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 12 Feb 18 11.41am

Originally posted by mattteo

What do you mean by effectiveness??????

Cabaye has scored 9 times and assisted 5 for Palace in 3 PL seasons. And has a background of scoring and assisting from his Newcastle days.
Jedinak (who now is 33, so you can't possibly say he'd still have been good) has scored twice and assisted 5 times in just as many seasons in the PL, disregarding penalties. Yes, he was more of a defensive midfielder, but why make a comparison based on effectiveness?


As I agree age doesn't eventually forgive anyone, I think Cabaye is still one of the fastest playmakers in the league. Cabaye is faster than:
Tom Davies
Adrien Silva
Dembele
Joe Allen (as much as you'd think he's fast, his height doesn't help him keep up anymore and they are signalling the exact same thing on their forums as you are about Cabaye)
Shelvey
Aaron Mooy


So I don't think he's past it at all. I wouldn't like Cabaye gone and replaced with someone like Shelvey at all. Similar players in technical ability (maestros with the ball), but there would be a real loss in stamina and movement and recoveries.
Yes, Cabaye is not in his 20s anymore, but he is still one of the fastest 31 year old players out there who play in the playmaker position.

Edited by mattteo (12 Feb 2018 9.58am)

Just not been as effective in the role he was brought in to do. And Jedi was basically outed to make way for him. Looks like Jedi will be be back in the PL with Villa next season. We’ll see then if he’s too old to do what he does best then. We have become quite ageist at CPFC to our detriment.
Back to Cabaye, he’s been okay for us but can’t say he has done much worth writing home about. Like Benteke he isn’t the player he was when he was with his other PL employer. He has however helped raise the profile of the club and I would suggest has helped other high profile players consider joining us. For that I am grateful. He took a risk joining us at the time and that should not be overlooked.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 12 Feb 18 11.45am

Not ready for the scrapheap yet. Still appears to have more time on the ball than most which is a sign of a class player. See him as a 60 minute player now though rather than the full 90.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 12 Feb 18 11.46am

Originally posted by Lyons550

I'd have to respectfully disagree...he's fine passing sideways...but nowhere the quality of feeding penetrative balls in between the lines that Reidewald and Mama are. Cabaye simply plays the safe ball 80% of the time.

His pass accuracy in terms of % might be impressive but stats can be misleading.

I recall the Cabaye of old at Newcastle and admired his ability. Im afraid the passing of time has blunted his effectiveness when playing over 90 mins and I suspect that in the main our supporters will conclude that he hasn't lived up to expectations.

A recent post mentioned that he only had the fitness to last 30 mins - I can understand where this is coming from and I did mention that he would be useful coming off the bench in the last 20 mins against flagging opposition.At the moment Hodgson has no option but to start Cabaye.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 12 Feb 18 12.32pm

Originally posted by Willo

His pass accuracy in terms of % might be impressive but stats can be misleading.

I recall the Cabaye of old at Newcastle and admired his ability. Im afraid the passing of time has blunted his effectiveness when playing over 90 mins and I suspect that in the main our supporters will conclude that he hasn't lived up to expectations.

A recent post mentioned that he only had the fitness to last 30 mins - I can understand where this is coming from and I did mention that he would be useful coming off the bench in the last 20 mins against flagging opposition.At the moment Hodgson has no option but to start Cabaye.

Exactly the point I'm making...

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Trollo Flag 12 Feb 18 12.42pm

His pass accuracy in terms of % might be impressive but stats can be misleading.

I recall the Cabaye of old at Newcastle and admired his ability. Im afraid the passing of time has blunted his effectiveness when playing over 90 mins and I suspect that in the main our supporters will conclude that he hasn't lived up to expectations.

A recent post mentioned that he only had the fitness to last 30 mins - I can understand where this is coming from and I did mention that he would be useful coming off the bench in the last 20 mins against flagging opposition.At the moment Hodgson has no option but to start Cabaye.


Yes I was discussing Cabaye on my allotment this morning with Fred who grows the best runner beans in Brighton & he said, Cabaye can`t kick with his left foot, he can`t head the ball, he can`t tackle & he doesn`t score many goals. Apart from that he`s all right.

 

mattteo Flag 12 Feb 18 12.48pm

IF he is getting slower in his old days, he would benefit from playing in a more more backwards position, in front of the defense, like Pirlo played in his old days. Pick up the balls and distribute them instead of defenders sending long balls without purpose.

But for that he'd need a box-to-box midfielder, if not 2, slightly in front of him, like Pirlo had Vidal and Pogba. And Milivojevic just can't cut it. I'm not saying I want him to be Vidal or Pogba level, but he's no box-to-box. In fact, Milivojevic and Cabaye are pretty much the same type of "brain" player in midfield. If they can play together and if they need a faster player next to them in midfield or if they can't play together ans 2 faster player are required there remains to be seen.

There are plenty of cheap box-to-box options out there: Onazi (Trabzonspor, formerly Lazio), Alex Song (free), Jonathan de Guzman (Eintracht), Kozielo (Koln), Wakaso (Alaves), Andrea Poli (Bologna, formerly Milan).

 

JtCpfc Flag 12 Feb 18 12.52pm

give it a rest...

cabaye has been a great player for us. He still is. A lot of work that central midfielders do goes un noticed. He covers a lot of ground and makes a lot of interceptions.

 

eag-les Flag Coulsdon 12 Feb 18 12.55pm

Great player but sadly his legs have gone for 90 mins of Prem football

 


If I agreed with you we'd both be wrong

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 12 Feb 18 12.57pm

Originally posted by JtCpfc

give it a rest...

cabaye has been a great player for us. He still is. A lot of work that central midfielders do goes un noticed. He covers a lot of ground and makes a lot of interceptions.

Agreed, you actually notice more when he's not in the team and you realise then how much we need him.

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Cabaye