You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Safe Standing Bid Rejected By Goverment
November 22 2026 8.03pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Safe Standing Bid Rejected By Goverment


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Lyons550 Flag Shirley 10 Apr 18 12.31pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Just consider that if Hillsborough had been an all seater 96 people would not have died.

Funny how you conveniently ignore the other major factors to the majority of deaths...i.e fans laying others on their backs and not in the recovery positions, the decision to let fans in that didnt have tickets.

So a simplistic and nonsensical conclusion on your part.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 10 Apr 18 12.32pm

This is a good article following on from the decision yesterday..

[Link]

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

jeeagles Flag 10 Apr 18 12.33pm

Originally posted by DutchEagleJohan

Is this your way to push a point? And what point exactly?

It is a fact that in today's game a significant minority of spectators stands up, in spaces that are not designed for that and that certainly do not necessarily make it safer. Are most of those mindless violent hooligans who need protecting from themselves? Or do you want to minimalise risk? You even seem to contribute a "selling one ticket per space" to the all seater policy.

How many people have died due to crushes on terraces not involving Liverpool Football Club? Liverpool 135. Every other English club 0.

Plus Hillsborough didn't have an up to date safety certificate, and the people in charge were underqualified.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 10 Apr 18 1.15pm

The system of safe rail standing at Celtic looks fine.

You have your seat with a key by which you close the seat up and stand instead against secure railing, in a designated area, can't see any problems with it.

Liverpool people understandably opposed now thinking it over after checking it out.


 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 10 Apr 18 1.42pm

So are you saying the Hillborough disaster was due to the behaviour of the Liverpool fans, they brought it upon themselves and the whole aftermath was a PR push from Liverpool? I more often read it between the lines but frankly struggle to see any evidence. I have great respect for what they achieved in the aftermath and how the establishment was taken on and to as far an extent as one can imagine: beaten.

Originally posted by jeeagles

How many people have died due to crushes on terraces not involving Liverpool Football Club? Liverpool 135. Every other English club 0.

Plus Hillsborough didn't have an up to date safety certificate, and the people in charge were underqualified.


 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 10 Apr 18 2.34pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Just consider that if Hillsborough had been an all seater 96 people would not have died.

PZ, you are quite right in what you say. But the new alternative being offered is called safe standing because it is safe. No one is proposing the return to open terracing.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 10 Apr 18 4.15pm

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

PZ, you are quite right in what you say. But the new alternative being offered is called safe standing because it is safe. No one is proposing the return to open terracing.

You are correct but I don't think that all fans understand the concept. I have seen quotes from fans who think they will be able to stand where they like even in a safe standing area. These days I like to sit down but for about 30 years I stood on the Holmesdale Terrace before moving to the Arthur.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Apr 18 5.03pm

Originally posted by dorking

At most Premier League matches, the away end is usually sold out.

90% of people stand.

If you want to sit and watch the game, unless you have been lucky and got a seat in row 1 or 2, you cannot see, so are forced to stand.

And the people standing are doing so with nothing to stop them if someone behind them falls into them, for example after a goal.

Incredible decision to not allow it in the Prem and Championship, yet it is allowed in L1 and L2. Illogical even.

So next season Sunderland (assuming they go down) could have it for example

My views on standing in all-seater stadiums have been well documented.

Dangerous and totally disrespectful to fellow supporters who want to SIT and watch the game but have their view obscured by those who could not give a jot about others.Makes my bloody blood boil.

On the assumption that these "Standers" would gravitate to the 'Safe Standing' at least those who wish to actually SIT would do so without some inconsiderate supporters deeming it is acceptable to stand in front of them.

Edited by Willo (10 Apr 2018 5.16pm)

 

chateauferret Flag 10 Apr 18 5.18pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Nobody would have died without the concentration camp security fences and inept policing and management. To blame this on standing is to still blame the supporters - as the government always has.

Is the correct answer.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 10 Apr 18 7.24pm

Originally posted by Willo

My views on standing in all-seater stadiums have been well documented.

Dangerous and totally disrespectful to fellow supporters who want to SIT and watch the game but have their view obscured by those who could not give a jot about others.Makes my bloody blood boil.

On the assumption that these "Standers" would gravitate to the 'Safe Standing' at least those who wish to actually SIT would do so without some inconsiderate supporters deeming it is acceptable to stand in front of them.

Edited by Willo (10 Apr 2018 5.16pm)

I am against standing but tend to agree if the Premier league can show it is safe. However I would restrict the numbers and areas in the ground. Probably the singing area at each ground would be the logical choice. Oh and the minute there was crowd trouble / safety issue shut it down.

 


One more point

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Apr 18 7.46pm

Originally posted by Badger11

I am against standing but tend to agree if the Premier league can show it is safe. However I would restrict the numbers and areas in the ground. Probably the singing area at each ground would be the logical choice. Oh and the minute there was crowd trouble / safety issue shut it down.

I believe before there is any change in the legislation, there would have to be a very clear demand, and very clear evidence that any such change meets stringent safety standards, presented from all the relevant authorities responsible for stadium safety, including the Police, as well as it being clear that 'Safe Standing' is what all parties want.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 11 Apr 18 11.44am

Originally posted by Willo

I believe before there is any change in the legislation, there would have to be a very clear demand, and very clear evidence that any such change meets stringent safety standards, presented from all the relevant authorities responsible for stadium safety, including the Police, as well as it being clear that 'Safe Standing' is what all parties want.

This is already the case....there is over 20years of evidence across Europe and the demand from fans (even Liverpool ones) is swelling...but you'd know that if you read the articles posted above in the thread..

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

simonmdt Flag x 11 Apr 18 12.41pm

Originally posted by Lyons550

This is already the case....there is over 20years of evidence across Europe and the demand from fans (even Liverpool ones) is swelling...but you'd know that if you read the articles posted above in the thread..

You're wasting your time, mate. Willo just likes to whinge and moan.

Frankly, the best argument for standing at a game is that it makes his blood boil.

Edited by simonmdt (11 Apr 2018 12.41pm)

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 12 Apr 18 9.45am

The strongest argument for any government is that there hasn't been another Hillsborough since stadiums in the top two tiers became all-seater. The argument that some still stand anyway won't influence them as the regulations are as much about controlling numbers in sections of the ground as anything else. Also, if there are injuries as a result of standing in seated stadiums, it's the clubs that will get the blame for failing to properly enforce the regulations.

Neither will they be influenced by what goes on in other countries, including Scotland. No government at Westminster will want to be the one to makes changes, just in case there is another disaster (and no one can guarantee that there won't be). They have the best part of 20 years of evidence that the right decisions were made as a result of the Taylor Report, and few politicians will want to take the flack if something goes wrong as a result of changing those.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 12 Apr 18 10.08am

Originally posted by bexleydave

The strongest argument for any government is that there hasn't been another Hillsborough since stadiums in the top two tiers became all-seater. The argument that some still stand anyway won't influence them as the regulations are as much about controlling numbers in sections of the ground as anything else. Also, if there are injuries as a result of standing in seated stadiums, it's the clubs that will get the blame for failing to properly enforce the regulations.

Neither will they be influenced by what goes on in other countries, including Scotland. No government at Westminster will want to be the one to makes changes, just in case there is another disaster (and no one can guarantee that there won't be). They have the best part of 20 years of evidence that the right decisions were made as a result of the Taylor Report, and few politicians will want to take the flack if something goes wrong as a result of changing those.

I congratulate you on an excellent post.

On the subject of standing in seated areas I was talking to a fellow supporter the other night who like me gets incandescent with rage about inconsiderate fans who stand and don't give a jot about those behend who wish to SIT and watch the game.

He stated that such behaviour is "Illegal" and I respecfully pointed out that it wasn't a criminal offence and hence not illegal.
The ground regulations of a club form a contract between the supporter and the club. Entering the stadium is an agreement to accept the ground regulations.
By standing, the supporter is in breach of that contract so standing is contrary to ground regulations.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 12 Apr 18 10.27am

Originally posted by bexleydave

The strongest argument for any government is that there hasn't been another Hillsborough since stadiums in the top two tiers became all-seater. The argument that some still stand anyway won't influence them as the regulations are as much about controlling numbers in sections of the ground as anything else. Also, if there are injuries as a result of standing in seated stadiums, it's the clubs that will get the blame for failing to properly enforce the regulations.

Neither will they be influenced by what goes on in other countries, including Scotland. No government at Westminster will want to be the one to makes changes, just in case there is another disaster (and no one can guarantee that there won't be). They have the best part of 20 years of evidence that the right decisions were made as a result of the Taylor Report, and few politicians will want to take the flack if something goes wrong as a result of changing those.


All of the above is a fair point and you can certainly see that being the gutless stance that they will hide behind. Whether or not it means that safe standing isn't ....well...safe.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Isley46 Flag Sanderstead 16 Apr 18 12.39pm

Originally posted by Willo

I congratulate you on an excellent post.

On the subject of standing in seated areas I was talking to a fellow supporter the other night who like me gets incandescent with rage about inconsiderate fans who stand and don't give a jot about those behend who wish to SIT and watch the game.

He stated that such behaviour is "Illegal" and I respecfully pointed out that it wasn't a criminal offence and hence not illegal.
The ground regulations of a club form a contract between the supporter and the club. Entering the stadium is an agreement to accept the ground regulations.
By standing, the supporter is in breach of that contract so standing is contrary to ground regulations.

Was in block Y AW on Saturday Row 27 and had to suffer the mugs who from about row 12 decided it was 'cool / tough' to stand for the whole 90 mins. I challenged a few in front of us to sit down but I can only assume that they were fearful of passing the message down - the only response I got was 'we're standing because it's Brighton!' - Made my blood boil. Looking to my right the rest of the AW was seated apart from the usual jump up for excitement.

Kids were so pissed off that one of them said at half time they wished Brighton would score 3 quick goals - then they would all sit down or leave - like the Sunderland match....

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Safe Standing Bid Rejected By Goverment