You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > How good actually is Zaha?!
November 16 2026 7.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

How good actually is Zaha?!


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
chris123 Flag hove actually 12 Apr 18 7.43am

We are a different team when Wilf isn't playing - the relative difference he makes is what will keep us up.

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 12 Apr 18 8.50am

Originally posted by chateauferret

Remind me how many games we've won this season without using Wilf.

More a reflection on how poor our squad is ....

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 12 Apr 18 9.08am

One of wilf's bad traits is that he doesn't centre the ball quickly enough when on the wing.
That extra touch or trick allows the opposition to get set for it.
When playing how we do with a big striker like benteke the ball in quicker counts a lot.
Benteke can muscle in the box and would score more.
Once it's sent in it's mostly up to him to find the ball not the other way round.
in the arthur this is easy to spot and happens regularly.
Taking nothing away from him as a brilliant player generally.

 

VKR1888 Flag London 12 Apr 18 10.10am

Originally posted by davehuggins

I think he really is top draw, if he played in a high-quality team I reckon he would be lethal, The only question mark is his temperament, could he fit in with other high-quality players. IMO he is worth in today's market in excess of 50m.

In a top top team he wouldn't be directly targeted like he is currently. So the temperament issue would be negated to a degree.

He would also get more space and time which arguably would allow him to showcase his talents better.

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 12 Apr 18 10.16am

We'll never know how good he is until he leaves Palace for a better team that is regularly in contention for cups and Europe. That's that sad truth.

 

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 12 Apr 18 10.41am

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

We'll never know how good he is until he leaves Palace for a better team that is regularly in contention for cups and Europe. That's that sad truth.

Have about the club investing in players and pushing for the Europa league.

Wilf is our best player and could easily play for any of the top six.

 

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 12 Apr 18 10.54am

I have always believed that given the right manager/club he can become one of the best players in Europe. I can see him playing for a Liverpool or Spurs and really flourishing. Truth is it's up to Wilf how good he wants to be.

Best player to ever play for Palace and it'll be a very sad day when he leaves.

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 12 Apr 18 10.56am

If Moses can leave us and play for Chelsea then Zaha would have no problems playing for a top team.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 12 Apr 18 12.31pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

If Moses can leave us and play for Chelsea then Zaha would have no problems playing for a top team.

VicMo is a workhorse though and he has more bowser on how to make that breakthrough ball. Better at crosses imho.

Wilf is better being a large fish in a small pond than a small pond in a large fish

Part of me hopes we’ll never know how good he’ll be for another team, but VKR is right in suggesting he’d have more time on the ball at a bigger club. You can’t surround one player when the whole team are a threat. Adversely he’d have more competition for his place.

A good example is Jesus Navas whilst a Citeh. Imho He looked pony by comparison to others in their team and he didn’t score much, but when Wilf does the same I still think he the Golden Bullocks!

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 12 Apr 18 1.42pm

I love watching Wilf play and he brings an extra dimension to our side. Quite how good he is will, I guess, only become clear should he get the chance to play for a top side (again!)

He gets a lot of license at Palace to play his game. We know that he can produce moments of magic and create something out of nothing by turning defenders inside-out. But we also know he can be inconsistent and lose the ball by over-elaborating or by delivering poor crosses.

The question is to what extent would Wilf's indulgences be acceptable at other clubs, particularly the top ones?

I believe he would have to adapt his game somewhat to fit into the quick passing style of the leading clubs where speed and movement are paramount. Actually I am not quite sure how good a first-time passer of the ball Wilf is - it's something we rarely see!

 

Painter Flag Croydon 12 Apr 18 2.03pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

If Moses can leave us and play for Chelsea then Zaha would have no problems playing for a top team.

Moses left us to go to Wigan, Chelsea then bought him, but couldn’t find a place for him, sending him out on loan, until Conti converted him to a wingback.
Zaha never seems to play well against the top 6 on a regular basis, because they have better players. That indicates he isn’t as good as being touted about.
Top player for us, but not a top 6 team, he would be just a squad player for them.

 

McPalace Flag Carshalton Village 12 Apr 18 2.08pm

Normally watch him from the upper tier of the Holmesdale but saw him at close hand at Bournemouth and must say he was amazing
Desperately don’t want him to leave but he is far too good for us

 

chateauferret Flag 12 Apr 18 2.11pm

He'll never get at City or Spurs or the bin dippers and certainly not at the likes of Real Madrid what he gets here which is a) play your own game b) play every week c) the fans worship you and d) agricultural clods in Premier League defences run in terror to the water closet when they see you coming at them with the ball.

He wouldn't be happy sitting on the bench at a team of whatever size and a Champions' League runners-up medal won't mean much if he's played for 20 minutes in a couple of matches and been told to keep the ball near the corner flag and track back when they lose it.

And I think he knows this.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 13 Apr 18 2.58am

Wilf is a good prem player.

There are days where he is great and unplayable, there are days where he is trying too hard and just can't find his groove.

That's why he should stay at palace, have the freedom, the confidence, the fans... it's good money too

 


This was once a quality forum....

nairb75 Flag Baltimore 13 Apr 18 4.22am

he'd definitely start on most top 6 sides. would be a perfect with with klopp. not mourinho - he'd never play him. he's much better than sterling, in every way. ponch would get a lot out of him but spurs will never pay the fee. doesn't fit with the arsenal.

wz is definitely one of the best players in the league. top 6 including. BUT, he requires a freedom that the top 6 don't usually provide.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 13 Apr 18 6.29am

Originally posted by Andy_G

I have always believed that given the right manager/club he can become one of the best players in Europe. I can see him playing for a Liverpool or Spurs and really flourishing. Truth is it's up to Wilf how good he wants to be.

Best player to ever play for Palace and it'll be a very sad day when he leaves.

What about Ian Wright?
As much as I love Wilf, in my book and based on history that mantle is still Wrighty’s.
However, Wilf has a long career ahead , and I am really hoping it is here. He brings soooo much excitement to every game.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 13 Apr 18 8.54am

Originally posted by nairb75

he'd definitely start on most top 6 sides. would be a perfect with with klopp. not mourinho - he'd never play him. he's much better than sterling, in every way. ponch would get a lot out of him but spurs will never pay the fee. doesn't fit with the arsenal.

wz is definitely one of the best players in the league. top 6 including. BUT, he requires a freedom that the top 6 don't usually provide.

Sterling has scored 20 goals this season, admittedly in a good side. Zaha needs to score more, before he can move up a level.
He would be a bench warmer in a top 6 side, not consistent enough.

 

JacksonEagle Flag Croydon 13 Apr 18 1.41pm

Looking at the front 3 of each of the top 6 teams he'd almost definitely be a bench warmer, not that there's any shame in that, some quality players in the list. Would probably have mahrez as the best best of the rest closely followed by wilf.

City - Sane Aguero Sterling
Utd - Sanchez Lukaku Mata/Martial
Liverpool - Mane Firminio Salah
Spurs - Alli Kane Son
Chelsea - Hazard Morata Willian
Arsenal - Ozil Abaunyemang Miki

Cant see him getting ahead of any of those and probably a few of the available replacements either.

 

Croydon Sunset Flag London 13 Apr 18 1.56pm

Any top six side would be very happy to have him in their squad. First name on the team sheet? no way but he could and would make an impact at somewhere like Spurs or the Arse.

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 14 Apr 18 6.47am

In todays game Zaha is the best we have,but best player we ever had, no
Budgie byrne Tormented the life out of the great Real Madrid and others
Peter Taylor England international while playing for a 3rd division team and scored with his first cap, great speed great crosser great dead ball taker
Don Rogers was our George best would leave defenders for dead on ploughed fields god nows how good he would be on todays pitchs
John Salako great crosser great defender great goalkeeper, Wright & Bright scored loads because of him
Ian Wright great finisher chased lost causes
So Zaha has a long way to go needs tobe a better crosser better finisher, and the ones i have highlighted had lumps kicked out of them and just got up and run at them again

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > How good actually is Zaha?!