This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
'Just a bunch of nazis'........ Quote from another PM, David Cameron.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
OK, I'll see if I can run with this. I think technically you may be right if you're talking specifically about the increase in immigration causing problems (nothing new here, but in the interest of balance it of course also brings benefits). You could also argue, if you were to be picky, that there is little that is overtly racist about the words themselves. However that is of course to take it all at face value. What is clear, is that the speech was a great exercise in scaremongering, and bringing personal points of view, some emotional and not substantiated, into the public realm, from a respected, public figure. It was clearly designed to start turning a large part of the population at the time against all immigrants irrespective of whether they were 'good' or 'bad'. It also took one step towards normalising not just this point of view, but also the attitude in which it was expressed. Attitude is also very important here. At worst you could say it was racist. At best, it's irresponsible, not for the opinion, but for the way it was delivered. Also, when you consider that immigration and race are very closely linked, what could also be said is that his main angle was not just anti-immigrant, but also anti-race – to quote his own words, specifically 'the black man'. Therefore, by extension, the words themselves might not be overtly racist, but you could argue that its intent was. HOWEVER Bringing things back on topic, I see no reason why this should not be broadcast and discussed again. Someone earlier made the point around censorship being dangerous and I agree. But if it's broadcast in a balanced way and in the right context, then I see no issue. Edited by SW19 CPFC (13 Apr 2018 12.57pm)
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
OK, I'll see if I can run with this. I think technically you may be right if you're talking specifically about the increase in immigration causing problems (nothing new here, but in the interest of balance it of course also brings benefits). You could also argue, if you were to be picky, that there is little that is overtly racist about the words themselves. However that is of course to take it all at face value. What is clear, is that the speech was a great exercise in scaremongering, and bringing personal points of view, some emotional and not substantiated, into the public realm, from a respected, public figure. It was clearly designed to start turning a large part of the population at the time against all immigrants irrespective of whether they were 'good' or 'bad'. It also took one step towards normalising not just this point of view, but also the attitude in which it was expressed. Attitude is also very important here. At worst you could say it was racist. At best, it's irresponsible, not for the opinion, but for the way it was delivered. Also, when you consider that immigration and race are very closely linked, what could also be said is that his main angle was not just anti-immigrant, but also anti-race – to quote his own words, specifically 'the black man'. Therefore, by extension, the words themselves might not be overtly racist, but you could argue that its intent was. HOWEVER Bringing things back on topic, I see no reason why this should not be broadcast and discussed again. Someone earlier made the point around censorship being dangerous and I agree. But if it's broadcast in a balanced way and in the right context, then I see no issue. Edited by SW19 CPFC (13 Apr 2018 12.57pm) The entire speech, without censorship, made by Enoch Powell at Birmingham in 1968, is on youtube. You don't need the new BBC version, you can see the real thing by the man himself.
|
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
OK, I'll see if I can run with this. I think technically you may be right if you're talking specifically about the increase in immigration causing problems (nothing new here, but in the interest of balance it of course also brings benefits). You could also argue, if you were to be picky, that there is little that is overtly racist about the words themselves. However that is of course to take it all at face value. What is clear, is that the speech was a great exercise in scaremongering, and bringing personal points of view, some emotional and not substantiated, into the public realm, from a respected, public figure. It was clearly designed to start turning a large part of the population at the time against all immigrants irrespective of whether they were 'good' or 'bad'. It also took one step towards normalising not just this point of view, but also the attitude in which it was expressed. Attitude is also very important here. At worst you could say it was racist. At best, it's irresponsible, not for the opinion, but for the way it was delivered. Also, when you consider that immigration and race are very closely linked, what could also be said is that his main angle was not just anti-immigrant, but also anti-race – to quote his own words, specifically 'the black man'. Therefore, by extension, the words themselves might not be overtly racist, but you could argue that its intent was. HOWEVER Bringing things back on topic, I see no reason why this should not be broadcast and discussed again. Someone earlier made the point around censorship being dangerous and I agree. But if it's broadcast in a balanced way and in the right context, then I see no issue. Edited by SW19 CPFC (13 Apr 2018 12.57pm) The two are linked because most immigrants were not White. Nothing more or less. It is also clear that the 'culture' of immigrants is often related to their 'race' and or religion. I would find it insulting to the intelligence to discuss one aspect of immigration without acknowledging the others.
|
|
|
Originally posted by chris123
It was intended as a foreboding.
However, he wasn't wrong about the damage to identity and social cohesion. The left with their promotion of multiculturalism caused and continue to cause huge problems in the country. The 'blind eyes' that were turned towards group rape victims is entirely the fault of the progressive left for example. Their culture of activism over racism turned into political actions during the Blair/Brown years completely took anyone with any balls out of the Police service. The modern day Tory party did nothing to change this ruinous culture. No one with any standing in the Police or indeed the council institutions was prepared to be called a 'racist' by the various victim card players.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Ok. This could be inflammatory I see no issue with BBC Radio 4 broadcasting a rerun of Powell’s speech interspersed with comment and critique. There does seem to be a fair bit of pushback to this being broadcast - I say as long as it’s in the context of critical evaluation and not just shameless promotion then why not? Why hide history just because it doesn’t fit with the current accepted point of view? Go Because people have to feel the need to be outraged against something it seems. Those statues in the USA or South Africa for example, the names of certain houses at various universities, or more recently the case in Germany where someone broke into a church to angle grind a swastika off of the bell, that no one could even see as it was in a bell tower.
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
The two are linked because most immigrants were not White. Nothing more or less. It is also clear that the 'culture' of immigrants is often related to their 'race' and or religion. I would find it insulting to the intelligence to discuss one aspect of immigration without acknowledging the others. • At the time most immigrants were not white, yes. Not so much now. But I'm not sure how you can definitively say 'nothing more or less', that's representing opinion as fact, and that is never very helpful. • I'm not dismissing its content out of hand and being over simplistic by labelling it all racist, therefore irrelevant. Just debating the opinion that race had nothing to do with it. • I think it's disingenuous to say he was only talking about 'immigration' as a concept, exclusive to race. I think some of his own words and opinions, especially about black people make that a hard one to accept as unchallenged fact. • In my opinion, the delivery, attitude and intent was irresponsible, as outlined above. People are free to express what they like, I just think the way it was delivered in a very sensationalist, hyperbolic fashion was not well considered. The same points could have been made more powerfully, intelligently and probably carried more weight as a result. HOWEVER Getting back to topic again, do you have an issue with the speech being replayed, in the right context, on the BBC?
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
However, he wasn't wrong about the damage to identity and social cohesion. The left with their promotion of multiculturalism caused and continue to cause huge problems in the country. The 'blind eyes' that were turned towards group rape victims is entirely the fault of the progressive left for example. Their culture of activism over racism turned into political actions during the Blair/Brown years completely took anyone with any balls out of the Police service. The modern day Tory party did nothing to change this ruinous culture. No one with any standing in the Police or indeed the council institutions was prepared to be called a 'racist' by the various victim card players.
Fair, but again for balance it's a fact that there have also been many positives as well as negatives. I would agree damage has of course been caused by immigration, especially the speed and volume of it. But a lot of that could have been mitigated by a proper plan for it in the first place – e.g. control, vetting etc. and an attempt to encourage social cohesion rather than marginalise. This is also the case now. Also if your view is binary (not sure if it is or not) – no immigration at all, then I'm not sure that's the answer. It's also not really realistic. Globalisation is and will continue to erode nationalism and the whole idea of 'countries'. As you know, we are not the only ones wrestling with this issue. However do away with it, and there are arguably more negatives than positives.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Fair, but again for balance it's a fact that there have also been many positives as well as negatives. I would agree damage has of course been caused by immigration, especially the speed and volume of it. But a lot of that could have been mitigated by a proper plan for it in the first place – e.g. control, vetting etc. and an attempt to encourage social cohesion rather than marginalise. This is also the case now. Also if your view is binary (not sure if it is or not) – no immigration at all, then I'm not sure that's the answer. It's also not really realistic. Globalisation is and will continue to erode nationalism and the whole idea of 'countries'. As you know, we are not the only ones wrestling with this issue. However do away with it, and there are arguably more negatives than positives. I like the Japanese model on immigration. Japan has little permanent immigration and has both a larger GDP than us and a higher standard of living.....with a population of 120 million, which is significantly higher than ours. Economists have been predicting its downfall for decades and have always been incorrect. It's also currently buying up its debt. Japan deals with globalisation without accepting a large contingent of nationals from other countries who are abetted by left wing activists who continually moan and play the victim card for them. When I last checked few in Japan are sobbing over the lack of cultural enrichment. Large scale immigration increases nationalism not erodes it. I would have thought that was obvious. I live in Wisbech and my town has been taken over by eastern Europeans....Apparently the message that half the country weren't too chuffed about them being here hasn't bothered them too much. Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Apr 2018 2.57pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by baldeagle73
Another case of the left wanting to silence debate and And censor anything doesn’t fit their increasingly narrow narrative the speech deserves to be viewed in a historical context let people decide for themselves Not sure I agree, if you're referring to my post. When I say context, I mean presented as you suggest but as 'this happened what do we think about it now' rather than a bias of 'wasn't this great' but the right or 'wasn't this terrible' by the left encouraging debate from all sides, left/right, white, black, immigrant etc. You know, a proper, balanced debate. If it's presented as 'look how correct he was' by the right, or 'look how racist he was' by the left from the start, then that helps no one. To repeat, balanced debate/critique of it would be the best way of bringing it back into the public eye. Hopefully the BBC do this.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I like the Japanese model on immigration. Japan has little permanent immigration and has both a larger GDP than us and a higher standard of living.....with a population of 120 million, which is significantly higher than ours. Economists have been predicting its downfall for decades and have always been incorrect. It's also currently buying up its debt. Japan deals with globalisation without accepting a large contingent of nationals from other countries who are abetted by left wing activists who continually moan and play the victim card for them. When I last checked few in Japan are sobbing over the lack of cultural enrichment. Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Apr 2018 2.54pm) On the surface, this might seem like a no brainer, a classic case of 'if they can do it why can't we'. So simple. So easy! Answers the question and nicely fits into your point of view. As with all things, a little research goes a long way. Japan has a very insular and ageing population right? They're not mad on population growth. So how could this approach actually be sustainable? Turns out it isn't. The Japanese government have been steadily increasing immigration since the 1990s. Apparently, in 2013 the immigration driven workforce grew by 40% in 12 months. They're just having to do all this on the quiet, as (ironically enough) culturally it's not very popular and drawing too much attention to it would probably cost the government it's position of power. So why risk the wrath of your population? Because economic failure is the alternative. This is not a unique scenario, and is why immigration is required for most countries to maintain some form of economic prosperity. 'Why work to foster immigration on the one hand yet refuse to acknowledge such deliberate actions on the other? The answer lies in the particularities of the Japanese context. The society retains a strong perception of ethnic and cultural homogeneity, and immigration remains resoundingly unpopular. Yet demographic realities are forcing policymakers to court immigrants as potential solutions, or at the very least mitigating factors, to address some of the economic problems resulting from aging.' I would say though, that I agree the Japanese have at least got one thing right in having a clear strategy and gradual approach when it comes to immigration. Their insular and protectionist cultural stance though does come at a price – open racism, especially to the Chinese. Not all roses in that garden I'm afraid.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
• At the time most immigrants were not white, yes. Not so much now. But I'm not sure how you can definitively say 'nothing more or less', that's representing opinion as fact, and that is never very helpful. • I'm not dismissing its content out of hand and being over simplistic by labelling it all racist, therefore irrelevant. Just debating the opinion that race had nothing to do with it. • I think it's disingenuous to say he was only talking about 'immigration' as a concept, exclusive to race. I think some of his own words and opinions, especially about black people make that a hard one to accept as unchallenged fact. • In my opinion, the delivery, attitude and intent was irresponsible, as outlined above. People are free to express what they like, I just think the way it was delivered in a very sensationalist, hyperbolic fashion was not well considered. The same points could have been made more powerfully, intelligently and probably carried more weight as a result. HOWEVER Getting back to topic again, do you have an issue with the speech being replayed, in the right context, on the BBC? Obviously no. What is the 'right context'? The one whe everyone can call him a racist no doubt The fact is that he was correct in every prediction. I don't care how people try to defect or disguise that. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (13 Apr 2018 3.10pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by baldeagle73
Another case of the left wanting to silence debate and And censor anything doesn’t fit their increasingly narrow narrative the speech deserves to be viewed in a historical context let people decide for themselves No the speech made in 1968 must be seen in the context of the time it was made. In 1968 racial tensions were stronger than now, fortunately Mr. Heath acted decisively in removing Powell and his poison, in doing so non-white people affected by the speech and social tensions were re-assured that there would not be a system of apartheid, of first and second class citizens in Britain. If you look at events, say in 1945, through the eyes of a 2018 person, you get a 2018 version of what happened in 1945, not the reality of life as it was for people then.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Obviously no. What is the 'right context'? The one whe everyone can call him a racist no doubt The fact is that he was correct in every prediction. I don't care how people try to defect or disguise that. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (13 Apr 2018 3.10pm) No defection here, at least not from me. Also I'd agree that a lot of what he has said came true. But crucially people on both sides never seem to properly look at the issue of immigration in context (left – negatives, right – positives) Another point I was thinking about is the irony that the speech most likely created, enhanced or contributed to the very issues he was talking about. Maybe that was intentional. Maybe it wasn't. Either way it's hard to believe it had no impact at all. The 'right' context is one where all sides points of view can be heard, whatever the platform, be it the BBC or somewhere else. As you're continually fixated on the left/right dynamic, then in a way where both the left and the right points of view can be heard and debated in this case. I'm repeating myself a little, as I just posted about this point. Edited by SW19 CPFC (13 Apr 2018 3.23pm) Edited by SW19 CPFC (13 Apr 2018 3.23pm)
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
On the surface, this might seem like a no brainer, a classic case of 'if they can do it why can't we'. So simple. So easy! Answers the question and nicely fits into your point of view. As with all things, a little research goes a long way. Japan has a very insular and ageing population right? They're not mad on population growth. So how could this approach actually be sustainable? Turns out it isn't. The Japanese government have been steadily increasing immigration since the 1990s. Apparently, in 2013 the immigration driven workforce grew by 40% in 12 months. They're just having to do all this on the quiet, as (ironically enough) culturally it's not very popular and drawing too much attention to it would probably cost the government it's position of power. So why risk the wrath of your population? Because economic failure is the alternative. This is not a unique scenario, and is why immigration is required for most countries to maintain some form of economic prosperity. 'Why work to foster immigration on the one hand yet refuse to acknowledge such deliberate actions on the other? The answer lies in the particularities of the Japanese context. The society retains a strong perception of ethnic and cultural homogeneity, and immigration remains resoundingly unpopular. Yet demographic realities are forcing policymakers to court immigrants as potential solutions, or at the very least mitigating factors, to address some of the economic problems resulting from aging.' I would say though, that I agree the Japanese have at least got one thing right in having a clear strategy and gradual approach when it comes to immigration. Their insular and protectionist cultural stance though does come at a price – open racism, especially to the Chinese. Not all roses in that garden I'm afraid. You are comparing apples with oranges. Japan isn't offering a pathway to citizenship for these workers.....It isn't the same thing. It doesn't even call them immigrants but guest workers. Also the numbers it has incoming are nothing like the same. I have no issues with foreign workers....we have always had them.....I think you are conflating two separate issues. Japan is very protective of its national identity and doesn't treat it like a joke....unlike our own politicians and far left. However, I commend you on your input to the debate as a rational voice of the left on this matter.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
No defection here, at least not from me. Also I'd agree that a lot of what he has said came true. But crucially people on both sides never seem to properly look at the issue of immigration in context (left – negatives, right – positives) Another point I was thinking about is the irony that the speech most likely created, enhanced or contributed to the very issues he was talking about. Maybe that was intentional. Maybe it wasn't. Either way it's hard to believe it had no impact at all. The 'right' context is one where all sides points of view can be heard, whatever the platform, be it the BBC or somewhere else. As you're continually fixated on the left/right dynamic, then in a way where both the left and the right points of view can be heard and debated in this case. I'm repeating myself a little, as I just posted about this point. Edited by SW19 CPFC (13 Apr 2018 3.23pm) Edited by SW19 CPFC (13 Apr 2018 3.23pm) I have no idea how you arrive at that conclusion. All that was described in his speech was present then and is present on a much larger scale now. The politics of the time might have played a part in his motivations for making the speech but that is rather unimportant given that he was correct and we are seeing exactly these effects in 2018.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
You are comparing apples with oranges. Japan isn't offering a pathway to citizenship for these workers.....It isn't the same thing. It doesn't even call them immigrants but guest workers. Also the numbers it has incoming are nothing like the same. I have no issues with foreign workers....we have always had them.....I think you are conflating two separate issues. Japan is very protective of its national identity and doesn't treat it like a joke....unlike our own politicians and far left. However, I commend you on your input to the debate as a rational voice of the left on this matter.
Foreign workers are still immigrants though. Even if they only live in a country for 10 years, then leave, they still live within communities, bring their own culture, etc. etc. On the citizenship point, I'm not up to speed on that, so couldn't really comment. As I said, Japan does a great job of controlling who it lets in, skilled workers etc. and heavily limits 'standard' migrants and refugees. And I'd agree, there is way more that should be done to implement a proper strategy on immigration in this country. That's a given. I already mentioned the fact that Japan is very protective and insular, but their economy is unsustainable without a big change to their immigration policy. This article is very interesting – even suggesting that a referendum on immigration may be needed in the near future as gradually increasing it is fine, but it won't be long before the population become aware of what is happening and rail against it. Hopefully they'll have learnt from our own referendum campaign debacle (on both sides) and make it clear to the less aware amongst us exactly what they are voting for. Essentially they are going to have to deal with larger volumes of people sooner rather than later.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I have no idea how you arrive at that conclusion. All that was described in his speech was present then and is present on a much larger scale now. The politics of the time might have played a part in his motivations for making the speech but that is rather unimportant given that he was correct and we are seeing exactly these effects in 2018. It enhanced the 'them and us' narrative, and was delivered in quite an aggressive, emotive way. Again, I'm not talking about the content of the speech, but who was saying it, how it was said, and a whole range of other factors that are pretty important. That's enough to add to already tense feeling between two groups. To be clear, I'm not necessarily saying it caused the issues, but it might have added to them/created new ones. It can't have had no effect on the situation at all. Do you not appreciate that line of argument?
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
It enhanced the 'them and us' narrative, and was delivered in quite an aggressive, emotive way. Again, I'm not talking about the content of the speech, but who was saying it, how it was said, and a whole range of other factors that are pretty important. That's enough to add to already tense feeling between two groups. To be clear, I'm not necessarily saying it caused the issues, but it might have added to them/created new ones. It can't have had no effect on the situation at all. Do you not appreciate that line of argument? No. Why should the truth be silenced just to maintain docility? Of course, people need to be protected from harm but the whole approach since the speech has been to persecute anyone who objects to government policy regarding immigration.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.