You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > And I thought Roy was a kindly old fella
November 16 2026 2.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

And I thought Roy was a kindly old fella


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Pete53 Flag Hassocks 17 Apr 18 1.03pm

For starters, you don't survive in the top flight of professional football without being tough, and having a bit of fight and grit in your personality, so although Roy generally comes across as a gent there is obviously more to him than that.

Yes, it must be hard on occasions to have to face the press immediately after a game and to calmly talk about decisions that have gone against you. But, that is part of the deal, and if you are happy to go on TV/radio and freely chat about an impressive victory for your side you have to be man enough to do the same when things have gone against you and handle it with dignity.

On occasions interviewers can ask inane questions, but, putting that aside, I think managers sometimes behave as if the interviewer is being personal and operating on their own agenda, rather than asking questions to elicit the opinion of the manager so that the fans/public get an idea of their take on the matter - in other words the interviewer is acting as a conduit between the manager and fans.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 17 Apr 18 1.19pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

What software has she been using?

Euphanism?

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Apr 18 2.08pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Perhaps she has been forensically assessing you over the years.

I think she forensically assessed me when we first met in 1982 and she will probably admit that her assessment was awry !

Edited by Willo (17 Apr 2018 2.09pm)

 

regal_eagle Flag somewhere 17 Apr 18 2.09pm

"Get out, you're nothing but a lot of talk and a press-pass"

RoyCapone.jpg Attachment: RoyCapone.jpg (61.00Kb)

 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 17 Apr 18 2.40pm

My goodness, if that is "making a fool of himself" I wonder how you rate the average interview with Mourinho, Wenger, Hughes, Big Sam to name but a few. There is nearly a constant referring and moaning about decisions against them, something that Roy refrains from. And do remember: the footage may not show the very beginning of the conversation. Apart from that: is it appropriate to start an interview inviting criticism about refereeing decisions ?

Originally posted by bexleydave

For a start that was when he was West Brom manager, following a win against Bolton, and my view is that Hodgson makes a bit of a fool of himself. Ivan Gaskell wants to ask him about the refereeing decisions, but without leading the interview, hence the general question. There was no justification for that intemperate response. Roy's come close to this type of behaviour in a couple of interviews since he's been with us. Being able to deal with questions from the media politely and calmly is part of his job, but if with age he's turning into an irascible old git, perhaps someone else from the management team should do the post-match interviews.


 

babylonjohn Flag St Leonards-on-Sea 17 Apr 18 4.12pm

Personally Id like to see more of this kind of honesty and frankness (no pun intended) in Roys interviews. He always seems far too laboured and predictable and I don't usually bother watching.

 

chateauferret Flag 17 Apr 18 4.58pm

Originally posted by babylonjohn

Personally Id like to see more of this kind of honesty and frankness (no pun intended) in Roys interviews. He always seems far too laboured and predictable and I don't usually bother watching.

His interviews are generally excellent, insighttful without giving much away, honest but positive, tactful where brain-dead officials are concerned, and sensitive to morale and club unity. A far cry from the poor fellow who had to defend England 1 Iceland 2 to the Press.

Of course he had better have in his locker the full-on no-holds-barred Anglo-Saxon complete bonkers Kevin Keegan-style rant because from time to time they ask for this.

 


============
The Ferret
============

OhthisbloodyPC Flag 17 Apr 18 9.45pm

Commentators always ask, "how important was that first goal?"

What possible range of responses are they expecting?

Also: why do they need to pay an experienced 'professional' broadcaster to ask these dumb questions?

TV presenters cost a fortune. At least £150,000 a year.

They could anyone to ask them. Even a Netbot.

Then they could sack the TV presenter


Edited by OhthisbloodyPC (17 Apr 2018 9.47pm)

 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 17 Apr 18 9.53pm

TV rights add to over 11 million per match (not for the beeb I know, but they still pay over 60m a year for highlights) and you call 150 grand a year a fortune.........


Originally posted by OhthisbloodyPC

Commentators always ask, "how important was that first goal?"

What possible range of responses are they expecting?

Also: why do they need to pay an experienced 'professional' broadcaster to ask these dumb questions?

TV presenters cost a fortune. At least £150,000 a year.

They could anyone to ask them. Even a Netbot.

Then they could sack the TV presenter


Edited by OhthisbloodyPC (17 Apr 2018 9.47pm)

 

The Dolphin Flag 17 Apr 18 10.41pm

Top man Roy!!!
How many stupid questions should an intelligent Man have to answer.
Respect!!!!!

 

Deabo2030 Flag Ipswich. Suffolk 18 Apr 18 10.38am

I think Roy was right to say what he said, as the presenters do ask some stupid questions at times.
I didnt want Roy to be manager because I thought (wrongly) that he was too soft in his approach to questions and is 'dullness', but can see that he is skilled at answering questions... even stupid ones.

Does he lose it? We all do he is after all only human, but he has done a good job with the team in the current situation. Also in dealing with the press.

Edited by Deabo2030 (18 Apr 2018 10.39am)

Edited by Deabo2030 (18 Apr 2018 10.40am)

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 18 Apr 18 8.18pm

I didn't think Gaskill was being tricky, he was just just trying to prompt the answer without putting too many words in Roy's mouth, but well done Roy for showing a bit of Croydon, seemed like one of the cast of The Long Good Friday there, maybe the interviewer should have just said "the penalty", but who bloody cares, a bad mood, a misunderstanding, does show Roy is no soft touch, and I quite liked the way he wasn't really interested when they were talking about other matches at the start - there was a sense that they didn't realise that Roy's knowledge is several levels above theirs - doesn't mean you have to grovel, but don't get too casual either.

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 18 Apr 18 8.34pm

Originally posted by OhthisbloodyPC

Commentators always ask, "how important was that first goal?"

What possible range of responses are they expecting?

Also: why do they need to pay an experienced 'professional' broadcaster to ask these dumb questions?

TV presenters cost a fortune. At least £150,000 a year.

They could anyone to ask them. Even a Netbot.

Then they could sack the TV presenter


Edited by OhthisbloodyPC (17 Apr 2018 9.47pm)

In my opinion, that's the best contribution to this thread (not that it has anything to do with Roy). I'm old enough to have seen the earliest days of MOTD, or whatever it was called in the sixties. None of these inane "interviews" that we now have to waste time on, no puerile "analysis" by superannuated ex-players, just excerpts from the day's football matches - at a fraction of the cost to the TV licence payer that now gets shelled out on these parasites.

 

Eustace H. Plimsoll Flag Aldershot 18 Apr 18 8.49pm

Originally posted by bexleydave

Being able to deal with questions from the media politely and calmly is part of his job, but if with age he's turning into an irascible old git, perhaps someone else from the management team should do the post-match interviews.

Leave some irony for the rest of us...

 


As a woman, I can step aside, or step up my game...

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 18 Apr 18 10.09pm

Originally posted by Eustace H. Plimsoll

Leave some irony for the rest of us...

wanna see an impressionist do Roy when he managed England ? rather irreverent, so i will just say :

'Roy Hodgson - Ecuador verdict! - Darren Farley youtube'

and a truly outrageous one ...
'the dark side of roy hodgson' youtube.. same comedian.

its all in the public domain, been on the telly and all.... so get cross with the comedian if you are incensed.

ps. his 'harry rednapp on mastermind' is funny.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

chateauferret Flag 19 Apr 18 12.44am

Originally posted by JRW2

In my opinion, that's the best contribution to this thread (not that it has anything to do with Roy). I'm old enough to have seen the earliest days of MOTD, or whatever it was called in the sixties. None of these inane "interviews" that we now have to waste time on, no puerile "analysis" by superannuated ex-players, just excerpts from the day's football matches - at a fraction of the cost to the TV licence payer that now gets shelled out on these parasites.

I don't know who the BBC is paying these days but I was just reading this:

[Link]

Real Madrid 1 Athletic Bilbao 1.

Apparently Athletic Bilbao were leading 0 - 2 at half time.

What's more, Real Madrid had 66% of the possession, whereas Athletic Bilbao had 65%.

Spot on reporting there, then.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Jamesrichards8 Flag 19 Apr 18 12.51am

Without doubt my favorite manager we’ve had in many years. Since i’ve been alive actually. Mixture of kindness, sensibility and a bit of grit

 


When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop...

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 13 Aug 23 1.42pm

Croydon Roy , King of the castle

[Link]

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Teddy Eagle Flag 13 Aug 23 1.49pm


Roys in order of willingness to right have it.

Hodgson
Shaw
Jones, jnr.
Keane

 

YT Flag Oxford 13 Aug 23 1.58pm

Well done, Roy. The Sheff Utd player was a right knobber.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > And I thought Roy was a kindly old fella