This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Having just watched the match highlights on Palace site, the first incident where Wilf runs into the box with the Watford player then tumbles over, while there is contact it is nothing like a penalty and the commentator says 'that is never a penalty'. However Wilf begged and pleaded for one. So further decisions did not go his way....... He is not a serial diver or cheat that is extreme, but doesn't help himself. Anywhere else on the pitch being pulled back by the shirt is a free kick. In the laws of football I'm sure you'll find shirt pulling is an offence punished by a free kick. If you stay upright will you be given anything? No. It's referee's that actually insist that you have to hit the floor before they will take any notice at all. I'll let you finish the sentence.
That's Life |
|
|
Originally posted by braunstoneagle
to be fair, watford arnt filthy c***s, they are just physical team & we were a bunch of pussys 1st half. 2nd half we stepped up & matched them. a draw was a fair result in the end I'd agree with this..the reason they hate Wilf so much is because they are s*** scared of him and the only way they know how to deal with him is foul him and make accusations about diving. Clearly he goes down relatively easily... however he only gets 60% of the fouls he should based on the treatment he gets from players on the opposition...can you really tell me they wouldn't love to have him in their side... Because of the had him they'd change their stance on wether he's a diver or not 180 degrees!
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World |
|
|
Originally posted by Dangermouse
Anywhere else on the pitch being pulled back by the shirt is a free kick. In the laws of football I'm sure you'll find shirt pulling is an offence punished by a free kick. If you stay upright will you be given anything? No. It's referee's that actually insist that you have to hit the floor before they will take any notice at all. I'll let you finish the sentence. The highlights video doesn't show any shirt pull and the referee clearly hasn't seen one from his position. Don't beg and whine at the referee it is working against him.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
The highlights video doesn't show any shirt pull and the referee clearly hasn't seen one from his position. Don't beg and whine at the referee it is working against him.
Left back position is on the linesman's side, so clearly bottled as usual. Referee was a total prick and missed practically everything, but sure you back the guy. You have no problem with half a dozen Watford players calling for a card every time they fouled him though I see.
That's Life |
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
The highlights video doesn't show any shirt pull and the referee clearly hasn't seen one from his position. Don't beg and whine at the referee it is working against him.
Actually there was so a tug on his shirt but not an almighty yank. I'd have been surprised if a pen were given for it but it certainly wasn't a dive.
============ |
|
|
Originally posted by Dangermouse
Left back position is on the linesman's side, so clearly bottled as usual. Referee was a total prick and missed practically everything, but sure you back the guy. You have no problem with half a dozen Watford players calling for a card every time they fouled him though I see. I don't see how a ref can tolerate that constant abuse from players. It has crept in and is a serious problem. I thought only a captain could talk to the ref. As if the refs job is not difficult enough !!
|
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
I actually got a dignified and candid reply from this guy so thought it probably only fair to share it. *Milivojevic free-kick: A simple case of mistaken identity from about 80 yards away. I should have known better, because I was at Bournemouth a couple of weeks ago when he scored from a set piece. *Penalties: The report I filed to Mirror Online, just before the final whistle, is not blessed with any benefits of hindsight. Like the referee, I had to call each incident as I saw it without poring forensically over replays. The first penalty claim looked spurious at best - until evidence later came to light that Kabasele grabbed a handful of Zaha's shirt momentarily, although it probably wasn't the reason Wilf went down. Unlike the Milivojevic free-kick, I should have trusted the evidence of my own eyes for the penalty shout resulting in a yellow card for simulation: as I wrote, on the spur of the moment, it looked like a penalty in real time, but the only replay I saw on a monitor did not suggest a Watford player had committed a foul. On review, later on Saturday evening, there was definite contact so it was NOT a dive. Zaha chose not to speak straight after the game, which is his prerogative, but he has spoken this morning and his comments - which I shall be reporting online and in print later - are self-explanatory. For the record, I have covered five Palace games this season, and in all but one Zaha penalty claims have been a source of controversy. In some cases the referees awarded penalties; in others, his claims were ignored. I would respectfully suggest he, like Palace fans, must accept the rough with the smooth. At the home game with Bournemouth, for instance, in my opoinion he went down looking for a penalty in the first half (not given), but the one awarded in the last minute (and missed by Benteke) was a definite foul. In any event, he is a terrific player, probably the most influential at any club outside the top five. Yours in sport, Edited by chateauferret (22 Apr 2018 7.28pm) So basically a report published in a National newspaper with outrageous headlines are not based on what he sees with his own eyes but what a monitor shows or should I say what suits his agenda. Presumably his next report will have a headline ZAHA IS NOT A CHEAT I GOT IT WRONG!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
So basically a report published in a National newspaper with outrageous headlines are not based on what he sees with his own eyes but what a monitor shows or should I say what suits his agenda. Presumably his next report will have a headline ZAHA IS NOT A CHEAT I GOT IT WRONG! A 'journalist' admit publicly they were totally wrong, that'll be the day. He is a Watford fan and was totally biased in his report.
'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more' |
|
|
Originally posted by peterg
The Independent report said that Wilf dived and was rightly booked. The Independent has so little money that the reporter may not even have been at the match. Wonder if it will report that Mariappa owned up to Wilf after the match that it should have been a pen. I checked the byline for this report and it says: "Sports Staff". Which means they had no-one at the match and made it up on the office. And yes, they published a later report on Roy's interview conference comments that Wilf was not a diver, so maybe someone at the Independent had a guilty conscience about the original piece.
The right place at the right time |
|
|
Originally posted by peterg
I checked the byline for this report and it says: "Sports Staff". Which means they had no-one at the match and made it up on the office. In a previous life I used to own a local newspaper and can assure you that "Sports Staff" doesn't mean that at all. In all likelihood it refers to a freelancer
|
|
|
Originally posted by OhthisbloodyPC
We should make up accounts of conversations we've had with journalists. Brian Glanville agrees with me. So does Piers Morgan. And Kenneth Wolstenholme. if I may insert a Willoism at this point I used to go to school with Kenneth Wolstenholme's daughter
|
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
I actually got a dignified and candid reply from this guy so thought it probably only fair to share it. *Milivojevic free-kick: A simple case of mistaken identity from about 80 yards away. I should have known better, because I was at Bournemouth a couple of weeks ago when he scored from a set piece. *Penalties: The report I filed to Mirror Online, just before the final whistle, is not blessed with any benefits of hindsight. Like the referee, I had to call each incident as I saw it without poring forensically over replays. The first penalty claim looked spurious at best - until evidence later came to light that Kabasele grabbed a handful of Zaha's shirt momentarily, although it probably wasn't the reason Wilf went down. Unlike the Milivojevic free-kick, I should have trusted the evidence of my own eyes for the penalty shout resulting in a yellow card for simulation: as I wrote, on the spur of the moment, it looked like a penalty in real time, but the only replay I saw on a monitor did not suggest a Watford player had committed a foul. On review, later on Saturday evening, there was definite contact so it was NOT a dive. Zaha chose not to speak straight after the game, which is his prerogative, but he has spoken this morning and his comments - which I shall be reporting online and in print later - are self-explanatory. For the record, I have covered five Palace games this season, and in all but one Zaha penalty claims have been a source of controversy. In some cases the referees awarded penalties; in others, his claims were ignored. I would respectfully suggest he, like Palace fans, must accept the rough with the smooth. At the home game with Bournemouth, for instance, in my opoinion he went down looking for a penalty in the first half (not given), but the one awarded in the last minute (and missed by Benteke) was a definite foul. In any event, he is a terrific player, probably the most influential at any club outside the top five. Yours in sport, Edited by chateauferret (22 Apr 2018 7.28pm) This is just an excuse for getting it so wrong and pre judging zaha of diving, where is the appolagy, not even a "sorry"
|
|
|
Originally posted by OhthisbloodyPC
I like this idea of reporting on events when you weren't there There was a journalist in the Independent who constantly wrote up these fascinating conversations he had with great statesman, peppered with unbelievably punchy, poignant quotes. All of which were made up. (Johann Hari was his name) We should make up accounts of conversations we've had with journalists. Brian Glanville agrees with me. So does Piers Morgan. And Kenneth Wolstenholme. Not quite right. Hari was fired for lifting quotes from other reporters' interviews so that it appeared he had conducted the interviews himself. One man who fabricated quotes outright was none other than the great chancer Boris Johnson, who was sacked from The Times in 1988 for doing just that.
The right place at the right time |
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER
This is just an excuse for getting it so wrong and pre judging zaha of diving, where is the appolagy, not even a "sorry" For a journalist that's as near to an apology anyone's going to get, I'm afraid. Not that it makes any difference, once it's out there it's out there and those wishing to persue an agenda will obviously recycle the bits that support their spurious argument.
============ |
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by peterg
Not quite right. Hari was fired for lifting quotes from other reporters' interviews so that it appeared he had conducted the interviews himself. One man who fabricated quotes outright was none other than the great chancer Boris Johnson, who was sacked from The Times in 1988 for doing just that. Was it not he that coined the phrase "(inverted) pyramid of piffle"? There's only one other person I've ever known use that phrase and you all know who it is.
============ |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.