This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Kevin Kilbane
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Elricko Fleet 22 Apr 18 8.51am |
|
|
Quite a lot of deluded comments on hear lol!!!! Thought the pundits comments were completely fair. Wilf doesn’t help himself by pleading for everything and needs to learn.
|
Booted Eagle Bristol 22 Apr 18 8.52am |
|
|
Loved the idea that it was Wilf's "petulance" to place a hand on Decoure when he had run about 40 yards to be involved in the incident. This was "inadvertently" missed by Kilbane.
“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ” —United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld
|
Superhorns3 Harpdenden 22 Apr 18 9.03am |
|
Originally posted by Sayer
Would be intresting if VAR was avalible yesterday, what the pundits would be saying today and how diferent the score would have been?
Something most of the clubs including our own voted against coming in next season so we cannot really complain about that not being used now.
No doubt some managers will though next season - Wenger started it last week!
Edited by Superhorns3 (22 Apr 2018 9.06am)
|
Goal Machine The Cronx 22 Apr 18 9.19am |
|
|
Thought his comments were a bit off. Didn’t quite understand his take on the foul outside the box and falling into the area. The fall looked natural to me and I don’t think he even appealed for a penalty.
The challenge on the keeper was a ball he had to go for, no malice. You’d expect your strikers to go in to try and win that. To call it nasty was over the top.
I didn’t watch the game but the highlights would suggest Wilf was a constant threat. He deserved praise for his performance, not Kilbane sticking his boot in. Had the penalty been correctly awarded he would of probably been hailed for a match winning performance.
The reality is that no one outside Palace likes Zaha and that’s a testement to how good he is. He just needs to accept the hits and not rise to it, he’s an easy target for opposition as he’s so petulant. It’s this behaviour that puts refs and pundits off. He reminds me of a young Christiano Ronaldo
|
chateauferret 22 Apr 18 9.28am |
|
Originally posted by Elricko
Quite a lot of deluded comments on hear lol!!!! Thought the pundits comments were completely fair. Wilf doesn’t help himself by pleading for everything and needs to learn.
He could have made that point without branding the player a liar, a cheat, a diver, and a thug. None of which epithets are remotely justified.
============ The Ferret ============
|
m/k mick milton keynes 22 Apr 18 9.42am |
|
|
I must be quite lucky, i have an on/off switch on my telly, usefull when MOTD, comes on, also have a mute button
|
Gary St.Andrews Kenley 22 Apr 18 9.43am |
|
|
He wasn’t a particularly good footballer, whoever thought he would make a good pundit?
|
heath_eagle haywards heath 22 Apr 18 10.09am |
|
|
I always ff past the motd "pundits". There's too much talk and not enough football on this show.
|
europalace Europe 22 Apr 18 10.12am |
|
Originally posted by heath_eagle
I always ff past the motd "pundits". There's too much talk and not enough football on this show. Yep, it's gone the same way that Top Gear did years ago, hardly anything about the cars and lots about ego boosting the moron presenters.
|
A89M Streatham 22 Apr 18 10.13am |
|
|
Did anyone notice Capoue purposely step on Wilfs calf when he was on the the ground? I hadn’t noticed it at first and couldn’t understand why wilf was getting so mad at him but on the replay it was clear and the commenttators completely missed it.
Watfords plan was to clearly wind wilf up and try and get him sent off, when Dacoure, Marriapa and Capoue for the stamp should have gone. Terrible ref.
|
Lakeview Lincoln 22 Apr 18 10.25am |
|
|
Unfortunately, Wilf is a victim of both types of targetting by the opposition: repeated fouling and winding up. Wilf's tendency to appear sulky followed by moaning at refs, whilst understandable, rarely affects refs positively. "Star" players like Rooney used to nag refs into submission sometimes, but clubs like ours never seem to have that influence. A.J was similarly accused of diving, even on occasions where still images showed him landing on his face after a collision with defenders. As for the pundits, I like Danny Murphy, who seems to like Palace, but couldn't name a BBC one I respect. It seems the BBC have no obvious or valid criteria for choosing pundits.
|
stuckinbristol In the woodwork. 22 Apr 18 10.37am |
|
|
Wilf on goals on Sunday in a bit, could well be interesting.
|
taylors lovechild 22 Apr 18 11.20am |
|
|
The commentary on the NBC link I watched was just as baffling. They decided Wilf had dived in every incident and each time after the replay they had to back track and say that it wasn't a dive. It's bizarre because I don't think there has ever been a case when he has actually dived? There have been the odd occasions when perhaps he could of stayed on his feet, but in each of those he was caught, so it is hard to tell. The media are a bunch of sheep anyway, which is probably because they only really pay attention to the big teams and so will buy into any nonsense thrown at a player in a smaller team
The frustrating thing yesterday was that he repeatedly knocked the ball past a defender only to get unceremoniously pushed or kicked off the pitch. The only way this will ever stop is if other players of ours can carry more of a threat, as this would mean the opposition couldn't take turns to give him rough treatment. Townsend works really hard, but he has lacked confidence in front of goal all season and sometimes he is almost too nice.
I do feel that if Wilf got control of his emotions this would somehow take away from the player he his, the same way Rooney was rubbish when he was calm but when he used to get fired up he could beat a team on his own (now he's just rubbish).
The referee probably could have given out two or three red cards yesterday for double bookings, including one to Ward, but having given out a couple in his last few games I think he was reluctant.
|
Midlands Eagle 22 Apr 18 11.23am |
|
|
Roy Hodgson wasn't a particularly good footballer either, whoever thought he would make a good manager?
|
chateauferret 22 Apr 18 11.34am |
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Roy Hodgson wasn't a particularly good footballer either, whoever thought he would make a good manager?
OTOH Frank de Boer was a world-class footballer. As a manager: s***e.
============ The Ferret ============
|
Mstrobez 22 Apr 18 11.43am |
|
Originally posted by Elricko
Quite a lot of deluded comments on hear lol!!!! Thought the pundits comments were completely fair. Wilf doesn’t help himself by pleading for everything and needs to learn.
So even if you think Zaha should’ve been booked for pushing Doucoure, who ran to push him whilst being booked, which they seemed to conveniently ignore.
And even if you think Zaha, when being hacked down on the edge of the box, should be trying harder to fall in a different direction, just in case people like you think he’s cheating.
Does it not at least bother you that there is a player from another team actually assaulting people in the match prior & they don’t say a single word about it in punditry? And the BBC is supposedly unbiased? Do me a favour, was the most pathetic & blaitant attempt of slander I’ve ever seen. Couldn’t be a more obvious attempt of reigniting the bandwagon if they tried & he wasn’t even subtle about it.
Edited by Mstrobez (22 Apr 2018 11.54am)
We're the Arthur over ere!
|
Dangermouse Hastings 22 Apr 18 3.44pm |
|
Originally posted by spartakev2
To be fair, what he was saying about wilf getting too involved in the game was true. He needs to realise that teams are going to wind him up and foul him, but need to shut up and get on with it. Every time thd cameras were on him he was arguing with one of their players, and if he hadn't gone down and claimed he was fouled in thd first penalty incident (which never was, you only have to look at the palace fans behind him to see that) he may have got the penalty that should have been awarded.
Is shirt pulling legal? If seen does the ref give a free kick? Anywhere else on the pitch is it given? Kammy proved it was two pens on Sky. As for the moaning, you have a point. There is not one single player in Europe who complains to a referee. Only Wilf. If someone kicked you constantly what would you do or say? Nothing? Doubt it?
That's Life And as funny as it may seem Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream. KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!
|
Dangermouse Hastings 22 Apr 18 3.52pm |
|
|
Remember it is the referees that actually insist that players go to ground. They will give nothing if a player stays on his feet, so they have no option.
That's Life And as funny as it may seem Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream. KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!
|
Stuk Top half 22 Apr 18 4.04pm |
|
|
His comments were well out of order. Going for a 50/50 ball isn't "nasty" and I've never heard that a keeper has more right to go for it with his hands than an outfield player does with his feet. One of them only has one option.
BBC radio, Sky commentators and Goals on Sunday all thought it was a penalty. Even Mariappa admitted he caught him.
The two clubs he played for the most both got relegated yesterday, maybe he was just a moody c***.
Optimistic as ever
|
slubglurge welling 22 Apr 18 7.01pm |
|
|
Tony Gale who was commentating on the Sky 30 min highlights backed Wilf all the way. Said the 1st one was a stumble not a dive. Keeper incident he said he had every right to go for the ball and also that it was a definite pen so no booking and most sensible journos shared this view
|