This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Texas Eagle
Sorry , there are better options for England. He's had an average season at best. Looks good going forward but a little too predicable. Can't cross with his right foot and defenders know it. Loses procession too easily too IMO. As for defending, oh please! He is one of the last players, along with Wilf and any centre forward we play, we should expect to be up there for defending. He is an attacking player after all and has been playing in a two man attack of late, and he's left footed. I've always rated him when playing for England, since his Spurs days, as he's one of a few England players to at least have a crack at having a shot rather than passing the ball, and thus the buck.
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
Andros has never let England down in the past. A good natural wide option.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Texas Eagle
Sorry , there are better options for England. He's had an average season at best. Looks good going forward but a little too predicable. Can't cross with his right foot and defenders know it. Loses procession too easily too IMO. As for defending, oh please!
Better options in what way? The guy works very hard both defensive duties and attack He also has international experience and shown he can play at that level
|
|
|
Originally posted by grumpymort
Better options in what way? The guy works very hard both defensive duties and attack He also has international experience and shown he can play at that level I'm not having a go at him because of his striking abilities as he's an out and out winger. If RH wants to play him up front ... well we're stuck with it! He is such a left sided player it's not funny, it's not gonna cut at international level these days. And I stick by my claim that he can't cross with his right foot! He is effective on some dead ball situations and I'd rather have him take our corners that Cabaye! Again, I don't rate his defending as time and time again he fails to support the fullback in getting back.
"Billy Gilbert really is God" |
|
|
Originally posted by Aray
High time he got a song. Works super hard for the team. His press is immense too - shame he lacks a little bit of quality in his final ball Agree 100%
|
|
|
Originally posted by Dean_CPFC
My own opinion is we may have burned him out last season! there was very little creative cover and because of that he played almost thefull 90 in every game, I honestly think we may have over played him due to our small squad And it worryingly says a lot that given the likelihood we will at some point sell Zaha... we seem to have had zero anticipation at ever needing another winger, zero succession planning for 2 wingers now into their mid twenties, zero backup for injuries... Daniel James was an affordable candidate for us, he very nearly joined Leeds United last year. These players are out there, why don't we pre-empt anything? We certainly didn't have a right-back lined up, we've just resorted to the one we had be AWB came along.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Dean_CPFC
My own opinion is we may have burned him out last season! there was very little creative cover and because of that he played almost thefull 90 in every game, I honestly think we may have over played him due to our small squad You could be right. Roy and the coaching staff have the stats from training so these days they know if a player is not 100% fit. I like Andros he always puts in a shift but that has to take a toll and it's a long season. Maybe Roy is resting him until he has recovered? I don't doubt he will play an important role through the season. When he came on to replace Schlupp he was smiling so hopefully that is a good sign.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by JohnB
I've thought for a while that if we were going to get the best out of the players we had then we would have to change formation and a casualty of that would have been someone like Townsend unless he played up top. I did, however, think that the change wouldn't have been for Schlupp but more Meyer and Camarasa and playing a bit narrower with those two trying to pull the strings whilst Luka, & Kouyate, JMac or McCarthy sat deeper across the middle to give them more freedom, almost a 4-2-2-2 with Zaha and a striker next to him as the top 2. I'm sure he will get his chance again, but given we have 40 central midfield players and we don't play with much width, something was going to have to change. I have never been Schlupp's biggest fan as he is the biggest reason for me wanting to throw myself off a bridge when watching Palace, mainly due to his inability to pass a simple ball to a team mate. But I must admit I have seen improvement in him this year and I also think PVA is a lot better with Schlupp in front of him. Townsend for all his effort lacks quality in a lot of departments, especially his end product and the defensive side of his game is not good. It looks to me like Schlupp will become a regular in that position now with Townsend facing a batttle to get back in and Meyer staying where he belongs (firmly on the bench)
|
|
|
Originally posted by EddieMac
I have never been Schlupp's biggest fan as he is the biggest reason for me wanting to throw myself off a bridge when watching Palace, mainly due to his inability to pass a simple ball to a team mate. But I must admit I have seen improvement in him this year and I also think PVA is a lot better with Schlupp in front of him. Townsend for all his effort lacks quality in a lot of departments, especially his end product and the defensive side of his game is not good. It looks to me like Schlupp will become a regular in that position now with Townsend facing a batttle to get back in and Meyer staying where he belongs (firmly on the bench) He doesn’t always cover and assist the full back as well as he should. That was happening at Sheffield, when on the right side in front of Ward. It’s always been in Schlupp,s game to defend, Wilf, isn’t perfect in that area by any means, but we can only afford one Wilf. Townsend, does get it right on occasion, so he won’t be out permanent
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.