You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Luka better than Jedi?
November 16 2026 7.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Luka better than Jedi?


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
joe_cpfc Flag Basingstoke 29 Apr 18 9.54pm

Originally posted by grumpymort

different type of player.

It's like comparing Gerrard to Lampard both play midfield but different type of player with a few over lapping qualities but you expect that from players in top leagues.

Both look to be good captains but again in a different ways.

It would of been good to see both together in the squad.

All this talk about Zaha being big player Luka is massive we really would struggle without him plus I can see clubs trying to get him (remember this guy has played in champions league hes not some nobody coming from low leagues we found)

No it definitely isn't.Its like comparing Gerrard to a lamp shade.

 

PA Flag Bedfordshire 29 Apr 18 10.02pm

I credit Jedi with getting us promoted. Even more so than Zaha, Bolasie, Murray and the others. Just loved the guy and what he did for the team. But he couldn’t pass and Milo can. That is the big advantage Milo has.

But this debate is like having to say whether you prefer your Mum or your Dad!

 

ZIGnZAG Flag Stoke 29 Apr 18 10.07pm

They are both the same type of player.

Both have done an amazing job for Palace.

They couldn't have done it together.

Why choose between them, just admire and appreciate what they do.

Both are unsung heroes.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 29 Apr 18 10.07pm

Originally posted by Jimenez

Why not? He must be close to be hanging up his boots in any case. Would be a perfect fit to come in & learn his trade under Roy for a couple of seasons before Roy retires. A nice smooth transition from manager to manager would be nice for a change.

It takes longer than a couple of years to be good enough to manage successfully in the premier league.

 


COYP

leejaneagles Flag 29 Apr 18 10.18pm

How did De Boer think he would be better at centre back and not good enough for midfield? Then also drop him when he wasn't good at CB.

There are times when a Manager does something frustrating that you can't quite understand like playing Kelly at left back but then there's gross negligence and even a fan could tell Luka is a great midfielder.

FDB should never work again just for that.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 29 Apr 18 10.34pm

Without question for me. I think Luka has been one of our finest signings ever, but we're comparing different players in different times.

Jedi was immense in the situation we were in and was able to step up from the championship to the Premier league, which many players can't.

 


Optimistic as ever

pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 30 Apr 18 12.46am

Originally posted by PA

I credit Jedi with getting us promoted. Even more so than Zaha, Bolasie, Murray and the others. Just loved the guy and what he did for the team. But he couldn’t pass and Milo can. That is the big advantage Milo has.

But this debate is like having to say whether you prefer your Mum or your Dad!

I know what I prefer.

Mile was top Championship quality masquerading as PL quality. He was immense for us and helped our cause no end. However the ability to pass the ball is paramount. Luka doesn’t have to be good in the air as he is so good on the ground.

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

Stirlingsays Flag 30 Apr 18 1.23am

Originally posted by pstrutt

I know what I prefer.

Mile was top Championship quality masquerading as PL quality. He was immense for us and helped our cause no end. However the ability to pass the ball is paramount. Luka doesn’t have to be good in the air as he is so good on the ground.


He might not have been a top passer but he was instrumental in keeping us in the Premiership and he was rarely beaten physically. He was a top quality signing and was released at the right time.....We had the best out of the Jedi.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

The Dolphin Flag 30 Apr 18 5.24am

Originally posted by Stuk

Without question for me. I think Luka has been one of our finest signings ever, but we're comparing different players in different times.

Jedi was immense in the situation we were in and was able to step up from the championship to the Premier league, which many players can't.


This!

 

pssguy Flag 30 Apr 18 7.01am

I think he is more likely to go than Zaha. City will need a replacement for Fernandinho soon. If he starts well next year the rumours will commence

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 30 Apr 18 8.56am

Comparisons are odious. Both are a bit special. These days Luka really shows his quality, a true leader

 

slubglurge Flag welling 30 Apr 18 9.10am

Worried that we will be fighting off bids for him in the summer. I think a fat git in Liverpool will come sniffing for him, he must rate him because he signed him for us

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 30 Apr 18 10.08am

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

Both have their own qualities and when Jedi was on it you couldn’t ask for a better combative / enforcer midfielder and he served us well for many seasons. As for Milo he is growing into the position as Captain, but a very clever player who pops up everywhere on the pitch.

He has been as instrumental in getting us out of the mess as Wilf, but this is only my view....

I suspect many fans subscribe to this view. Don't be shocked if he gets POTY.

 

MabbsWasKing Flag 30 Apr 18 10.59am

Certainly technically a better player than Jedi. I think our best DM since Peter Nicholas. Of the two Nicholas had a better engine and more bite in the tackle, but then again Luka isn’t allowed to tackle as forcefully, is under a lot,lot more pressure when on the ball and still is a great passer, is great with a dead ball and a cool penalty taker.
Fingers crossed he is with us long term.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 30 Apr 18 11.20am

Keep it quiet...... special player, good enough for any top six team in my view, better than Jedi IMO.

He should be made captain permanently ahead of Sakho, he is a natural leader, makes few mistakes and is a very very good player.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 30 Apr 18 1.06pm

Originally posted by slubglurge

Worried that we will be fighting off bids for him in the summer. I think a fat git in Liverpool will come sniffing for him, he must rate him because he signed him for us

I don't think he'll be in the job after May.

Those that are worried about losing him should watch the 10+ minute interview with Luka on the eagles.cpfc site.

 


Optimistic as ever

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Luka better than Jedi?