You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Local Elections
November 21 2026 10.42pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Local Elections


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 04 May 18 8.49am

Originally posted by Sportyteacher

You're right. The system was easy to follow given the extensive promotion provided for the scheme and the wide range of personal I.D to choose from e.g. driving licence. Only complaint that I've picked up on via radio analysis has been dubious argument of infringement of civil liberties when there clearly needs to be a system established to beat voter identity fraud.

As the results continue to come in, I have to agree with comments of Corbyn power having peaked given that Labour, as main opposition party, should've put The Conservatives to the sword. None of the parties can really claim to have made sweeping gains when noteworthy losses have been made as well. Lib Dems have made several gains however they have hardly set the political world alight as a result.

What do others think?

I agree that Labour hierarchy will be disappointed with results so far, despite winning most seats. I think they got a bit ahead of themselves with their expectations.

I think Brexit is clearly still having an impact on how people vote and with there being such polarity on this issue but little change since a year ago, it's not surprising that not much changed in the electoral maths. UKIP vote has largely gone to Tories for this reason.

Things will probably evolve more once Brexit actually happens and if/when a recession rolls around.

Without Brexit I'm sure the Tories would have done a lot lot worse given austerity, Windrush, general incompetence etc.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 May 18 9.39am

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle

I agree that Labour hierarchy will be disappointed with results so far, despite winning most seats. I think they got a bit ahead of themselves with their expectations.

I think Brexit is clearly still having an impact on how people vote and with there being such polarity on this issue but little change since a year ago, it's not surprising that not much changed in the electoral maths. UKIP vote has largely gone to Tories for this reason.

Things will probably evolve more once Brexit actually happens and if/when a recession rolls around.

Without Brexit I'm sure the Tories would have done a lot lot worse given austerity, Windrush, general incompetence etc.

Hugely disappointed - and they never won "Most seats" !!!!

Labour expected to rout the Conservatives but they can't show the kind of progress they would be shouting about if they were truly convinced they were on a rapid march to Number 10.

It was generally felt that the Conservatives would take a pummelling at the polls but we have done far better than was expected.A very disappointing night for Labour.

 

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 04 May 18 9.50am

Originally posted by Willo

Hugely disappointed - and they never won "Most seats" !!!!

Labour expected to rout the Conservatives but they can't show the kind of progress they would be shouting about if they were truly convinced they were on a rapid march to Number 10.

It was generally felt that the Conservatives would take a pummelling at the polls but we have done far better than was expected.A very disappointing night for Labour.

Currently on 1,467 with Tories on 884. Labour up 37 Tories down 2...

1,467 is more than any other party, commonly referred to as "the most".


I'm not sure they did expect the kind of rout you're talking about, but they will be disappointed with having not done better given some polls showing they could win councils not held for a long time/ever. They've done poorly in places like Walsall and Derby where UKIP vote has moved to the Tories. This looks to be a Brexit effect. In Richmond the Tories had a poor result for similar reasons.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 May 18 10.03am

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle

Currently on 1,467 with Tories on 884. Labour up 37 Tories down 2...

1,467 is more than any other party, commonly referred to as "the most".


I'm not sure they did expect the kind of rout you're talking about, but they will be disappointed with having not done better given some polls showing they could win councils not held for a long time/ever. They've done poorly in places like Walsall and Derby where UKIP vote has moved to the Tories. This looks to be a Brexit effect. In Richmond the Tories had a poor result for similar reasons.

One can introduce semantics but my interpretation of "Most Seats" gives a message of a total rout when this hasn't been the case.

In terms of the numbers you provided, 1467 and 884, Labour went into this election defending far more seats than the Conservatives.

One can mention the "Brexit effect" but there are probably a number of factors which influenced voting patterns not least local issues.

Edited by Willo (04 May 2018 10.07am)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 04 May 18 10.05am

I voted Lib Dem because they do more locally and the Tory candidate is a complete pr&t and probably more out of touch than you can believe. It has no bearing on how I’ll vote in future.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (04 May 2018 10.06am)

 


COYP

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 04 May 18 10.17am

Originally posted by Willo

One can introduce semantics but my interpretation of "Most Seats" gives a message of a total rout when this hasn't been the case.

In terms of the numbers you provided, 1467 and 884, Labour went into this election defending far more seats than the Conservatives.

One can mention the "Brexit effect" but there are probably a number of factors which influenced voting patterns not least local issues.

Edited by Willo (04 May 2018 10.07am)

Your interpretation of the word "most" was wrong in that respect then as I was referring to most meaning more than anyone else (e.g. I have the most sweets, Man City have the most points in the PL etc). You "correcting" me on this was an error on your part. I recall you saying the Tories won the most seats in the GE (which they did). It seems you "flip flop" to suit your "narrative".

Also they may have been defending more seats but so far they have also gained 37 and the Tories have lost 2 (net).

I agree local issues will have had an impact.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 May 18 10.35am

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle

Your interpretation of the word "most" was wrong in that respect then as I was referring to most meaning more than anyone else (e.g. I have the most sweets, Man City have the most points in the PL etc). You "correcting" me on this was an error on your part. I recall you saying the Tories won the most seats in the GE (which they did). It seems you "flip flop" to suit your "narrative".

Also they may have been defending more seats but so far they have also gained 37 and the Tories have lost 2 (net).

I agree local issues will have had an impact.

We could get into a protracted debate about interpretation of words and semantics etc etc but this would only result in a de-railing of this thread as accusations would be met by counter-accusations, besides I happen to believe the great and good would find this all rather tedious.Accordingly I believe that in the interests of HOL we should draw a line under this.

Overall, Labour have certainly not achieved the results they expected and this must be a major disappointment for them.

 

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 04 May 18 11.15am

Originally posted by Willo

We could get into a protracted debate about interpretation of words and semantics etc etc but this would only result in a de-railing of this thread as accusations would be met by counter-accusations, besides I happen to believe the great and good would find this all rather tedious.Accordingly I believe that in the interests of HOL we should draw a line under this.

Overall, Labour have certainly not achieved the results they expected and this must be a major disappointment for them.

[Link]

This is a good analysis of why the results were as they were.

I imagine a GE would result in much the same result as it did a year ago.

 

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 04 May 18 11.16am

Originally posted by Willo

We could get into a protracted debate about interpretation of words and semantics etc etc but this would only result in a de-railing of this thread as accusations would be met by counter-accusations, besides I happen to believe the great and good would find this all rather tedious.Accordingly I believe that in the interests of HOL we should draw a line under this.

Overall, Labour have certainly not achieved the results they expected and this must be a major disappointment for them.

There is no need. You were wrong. End of.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 04 May 18 11.24am

My take on the election results. Hugely disappointing if you are a Labour / Corbyn supporter.

Governments don't usually do well in mid term local elections as the voters punish them for perceived mistakes or broken promises. If you are the opposition party you would expect significant gains and would use this momentum (geddit) to push forward at the next GE.
Labour have made some gains but the Tories have held their ground and I am sure they are delighted.

Labour was hoping for some shock Tory scalps such as Westminster (due to Grenfall)and it never happened. If I was a Labour party strategist I would be worried. This is not a great Tory government and the election has been held only days after the Windrush and Breast Cancer scandals and still the vote stood firm.

Corbyn is going to have to do a lot more to win over floating voters and shy Tories. Right now if we held another GE I suspect the results would be broadly the same as the last one. Sooner or later the Tories will get their act together, so how much longer can Labour keep letting them off the hook.

At the last GE much was made of Labour's performance because so little was expected of Corbyn. However if you step back and look at the actual result if that had been Ed Milliband it would have been called a failure.

As for the other parties UKIP are finished. The Lib Dems made some minor prgress but where was the Pro EU / Remain protest vote? It never happened.

Edited by Badger11 (04 May 2018 11.26am)

Edited by Badger11 (04 May 2018 11.31am)

 


One more point

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 04 May 18 11.41am

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle

There is no need. You were wrong. End of.

In essence Willo is saying he expected the Tories to be decimated, and is relieved that the UKIP racists switched back to save a tonking.

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

Matov Flag 04 May 18 12.00pm

My initial reaction is that the Tories will be more relieved this morning, whilst Labour must be gritting their teeth.

Yes, Labour ended up with more seats but must have expected to do much better but what matters more to them is the specifics of how they lost certain seats and failed to gain control of specific councils that they had poured a lot of resources into.

Corbyn now faces the reality that those from within his own party can continue to attack him from a variety of directions with both the antisemitism accusations along with not being able to regain the core white working class vote having even more of a validity.

In boxing terms, you might be able to claim the round as a draw but the Tories must harbour hopes that they have weathered the best Labour can throw, along with regaining some confidence that they can get back into the fight whilst Corbyn is looking over his shoulder at those in his own corner looking to stab him in the back and wondering if they might be more successful now.

Edited by Matov (04 May 2018 12.00pm)

Edited by Matov (04 May 2018 12.16pm)

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 May 18 12.07pm

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle


There is no need. You were wrong. End of.

That's your viewpoint - as I have stated, let's move this debate on and not turn this thread into a spat between 'Yours Truly' and your good self.I have expressed my opinion, you have expressed yours - no further comment from me on this matter.


 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 May 18 12.13pm

Originally posted by pefwin

In essence Willo is saying he expected the Tories to be decimated, and is relieved that the UKIP racists switched back to save a tonking.

Never expected a decimation at all - It was Labour who expected such an outcome and they have been hugely disappointed.

As for UKIP,I know a number of UKIP supporters, quite a few who switched allegiance from the Conservatives, and they are certainly NOT racists at all.I don't hold the view that being pro UK and controlling immigration is "Racist" at all but this is another debate.Let's concentrate on the local elections.

 

Matov Flag 04 May 18 12.20pm

People need to stop getting so het up about the accusation of being called 'racist' because you believe a nation state should be able to decide who can or who cannot come and live in it.

Wear it as a badge of honour because it is now so devalued as a term that it is not worth even playing the game of reacting to it.

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 04 May 18 12.55pm

I did like the Conservatives' plans to treat knife crime as a mental health and public health problem, in conjunction with usual crime stuff. That approach worked really well in Glasgow whose knife problem has reduced drastically.

That tipped my vote for them.

 

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 04 May 18 12.58pm

Originally posted by Matov

My initial reaction is that the Tories will be more relieved this morning, whilst Labour must be gritting their teeth.

Yes, Labour ended up with more seats but must have expected to do much better but what matters more to them is the specifics of how they lost certain seats and failed to gain control of specific councils that they had poured a lot of resources into.

Corbyn now faces the reality that those from within his own party can continue to attack him from a variety of directions with both the antisemitism accusations along with not being able to regain the core white working class vote having even more of a validity.

In boxing terms, you might be able to claim the round as a draw but the Tories must harbour hopes that they have weathered the best Labour can throw, along with regaining some confidence that they can get back into the fight whilst Corbyn is looking over his shoulder at those in his own corner looking to stab him in the back and wondering if they might be more successful now.

Edited by Matov (04 May 2018 12.00pm)

Edited by Matov (04 May 2018 12.16pm)

A fair post. I still think the main thing to take away is turnout, which is hideously low for any election yet understandable and depressingly expected.

From a Labour perspective, we need to find new means of bypassing the oppressive negativity of the media and get people motivated and engaged, which ultimately will be the difference between us winning or losing.

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 04 May 18 1.00pm

Originally posted by Matov

People need to stop getting so het up about the accusation of being called 'racist' because you believe a nation state should be able to decide who can or who cannot come and live in it.

Wear it as a badge of honour because it is now so devalued as a term that it is not worth even playing the game of reacting to it.

Clever but not the same thing.

A person who is against immigration is not necessarily racist, immigrants can come from anywhere.

It is in your make-up your personality if you are 'racist'.

'A badge of honour' being racist.

Yuk.

 

Matov Flag 04 May 18 1.07pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Clever but not the same thing.

A person who is against immigration is not necessarily racist, immigrants can come from anywhere.

It is in your make-up your personality if you are 'racist'.

'A badge of honour' being racist.

Yuk.

All well and good, but the reality is that the label 'racist' is now so thoroughly discredited as to be almost pitiful.

A Racist is somebody who believes that a persons skin colour/national heritage is a predeterminer for specific behavioral traits and actions. Daft beyond belief although it has to be noted that there are biological differences between races, as evidenced by the inability for a lot of cross racial potential organ transplant options.

But in modern terms, many on the left throw the accusation at people whose arguments they cannot counter or deny. Its almost a default reaction to being proven wrong.

And to waste any energy in refuting such insults is now simply not worth the energy. Better to own the label as an acknowledgement that those who oppose you cannot counter your arguements and treat it with the disdain in deserves in almost 99% of cases.

Edited by Matov (04 May 2018 1.10pm)

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 04 May 18 1.15pm

Originally posted by Matov

All well and good, but the reality is that the label 'racist' is now so thoroughly discredited as to be almost pitiful.

A Racist is somebody who believes that a persons skin colour/national heritage is a predeterminer for specific behavioral traits and actions. Daft beyond belief although it has to be noted that there are biological differences between races, as evidenced by the inability for a lot of cross racial potential organ transplant options.

But in modern terms, many on the left throw the accusation at people whose arguments they cannot counter or deny. Its almost a default reaction to being proven wrong.

And to waste any energy in refuting such insults is now simply not worth the energy. Better to own the label as an acknowledgement that those who oppose you cannot counter your arguements and treat it with the disdain in deserves in almost 99% of cases.

Edited by Matov (04 May 2018 1.10pm)

No definitely not.

There must be instances where people have been called racist wrongly, but it is not usual and you would be very offended if it happened to you.

No actual evidence for your opinion, 99% of cases, what cases you give no examples at all.

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Local Elections