This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Bert the Head
That "Israel beacon of democracy in the middle east" slogan is PR nonsense. Iran was a democracy in '52 before the USA overthrew it and installed a dictatorship. There have been several democratically elected governments in the middle east that have come under attack by the USA and Israel - HAMAS won a democratic election after all. It is not that Israel is the only democracy it is that it is the only democracy that the west allows. Israel does not allow Palestinians democracy and runs an Apartheid system. It has the same selective and racist approach to democracy as the state of Mississippi in the 1960s. You cannot build a democracy in a land stolen from its inhabitants while you hold them prisoner in pockets of the same land. If you think Israel has religious freedom while it ethnically cleanses its land of Muslims you have a poor understanding of religious freedom.
Edited by Bert the Head (06 Jun 2018 10.37pm) Israeli Arabs vote in Israeli elections. There are Israeli Arab political parties. I don’t get your ‘apartheid’ comment. There are elections in Palestinian Territories. And the ‘stolen land’ argument is disputable. You could argue that the land was stolen from the Jews before being taken back. PS. Instead ofgetting all your political opinion from the Owen Jones column in the Guardian, why don’t you go to Tel Aviv and see how the Israelis and Arabs actually live. They are quite integrated. Edited by matt_himself (07 Jun 2018 6.28am)
"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02 |
|
| Park Road |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Bert the Head
That "Israel beacon of democracy in the middle east" slogan is PR nonsense. Iran was a democracy in '52 before the USA overthrew it and installed a dictatorship. There have been several democratically elected governments in the middle east that have come under attack by the USA and Israel - HAMAS won a democratic election after all. It is not that Israel is the only democracy it is that it is the only democracy that the west allows. Israel does not allow Palestinians democracy and runs an Apartheid system. It has the same selective and racist approach to democracy as the state of Mississippi in the 1960s. You cannot build a democracy in a land stolen from its inhabitants while you hold them prisoner in pockets of the same land. If you think Israel has religious freedom while it ethnically cleanses its land of Muslims you have a poor understanding of religious freedom.
Edited by Bert the Head (06 Jun 2018 10.37pm) Palestinian hero stuns the UN, and mocks those who use apartheid as an excuse for the problems Edited by Park Road (07 Jun 2018 7.26am)
|
|
|
I'm not a massive fan of Israel but there's a line at which some pushback is justified, in my view. Originally posted by Bert the Head
That "Israel beacon of democracy in the middle east" slogan is PR nonsense. Iran was a democracy in '52 before the USA overthrew it and installed a dictatorship. There have been several democratically elected governments in the middle east that have come under attack by the USA and Israel - HAMAS won a democratic election after all. It is not that Israel is the only democracy it is that it is the only democracy that the west allows. Yes it was wrong and the US has apologised for the historical interference. The US backed one group over another and did change the regimes for its own and western self interest.....which ultimately was probably a worse decision long term. However the 'sins of the fathers' argument placed onto present generations is also not valid. Also are you seriously suggesting that these democracies were democratic in the western model? I highly question that suggestion. As for your example of Hamas....yeah they won an election and then promptly banned elections in Gaza....You know who else banned elections after getting elected? Originally posted by Bert the Head
Israel does not allow Palestinians democracy and runs an Apartheid system. It has the same selective and racist approach to democracy as the state of Mississippi in the 1960s. Errrr.....Israel is only Israel if they ensure that Jews are the majority in the country. So this is an illogical expectation. Also Israel have plenty of non Jews living within its country. Far more, as a percent, for example than the anti semitic countries surrounding it. Originally posted by Bert the Head
You cannot build a democracy in a land stolen from its inhabitants while you hold them prisoner in pockets of the same land. Actually, yes you can. It's somewhat amusing to hear the western hating communist rage upon what is and isn't an acceptable democracy. Originally posted by Bert the Head
If you think Israel has religious freedom while it ethnically cleanses its land of Muslims you have a poor understanding of religious freedom. I have mixed feelings about the war Israel pursues against the Palestinians. It isn't fairness, however fairness went out of the window a long time ago. This is a managed disaster. However, your statement is heavily disfigured.....firstly to the hypocrisy of the lands surrounding Israel which are highly antisemitic and prosecute Jews.... these lands have basically cleansed their lands of anything other than Islam. So they are far worse than Israel in this regard. Where is your criticism of these countries for cleansing its lands of non Muslims? Any Jew there is risking their lives and aren't allowed to reach high status. Secondly I point out the fact that 20 percent of Israel is Arab, of which 70 percent are Muslims. Which Arab nation has the same statistics for Jews? Edited by Stirlingsays (07 Jun 2018 8.50am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by matt_himself
Israel is the only beacon of democracy in the Middle East. The only country where you can be gay without fear of being thrown off a roof in the Middle East. The only country where there is religious freedom in the Middle East. He only country with a free press in the Middle East. Good for Israel. You forgot to add-
Touch my coffee and I will slap you so hard even Google won't be able to find you. |
|
|
Originally posted by Cannonball
You forgot to add-
So no....actually, when it comes to prosecution and chasing people out....The Jews are just the same as their neighbours. You just never got to see it in your lifetime and on TV. Oh and they are just the same now. Banning Jewish passports and restricting non Muslims from reaching high status. Being a non Muslim in these countries, outside of tourist areas, is not very safe long term. Edited by Stirlingsays (07 Jun 2018 10.24am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Cannonball
The only country in the middle east that gives the finger to the UN Look at the list of dodgy countries that always veto Israel at the UN and there in lies your answer. Israel needs lectures from them? The UN is a complete joke anyway. I love it when US Ambassador Nikki Haley calls them out. Edited by Penge Eagle (07 Jun 2018 10.52am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Penge Eagle
Look at the list of dodgy countries that always veto Israel at the UN and there in lies your answer. Israel needs lectures from them? The UN is a complete joke anyway. I love it when US Ambassador Nikki Haley calls them out. Edited by Penge Eagle (07 Jun 2018 10.52am) To our credit at least the UK voted for this measure a modest proposal to give the Palestinians some protection. Every other country did likewise apart from the USA who walked out rather than hear the truth.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
To our credit at least the UK voted for this measure a modest proposal to give the Palestinians some protection. Every other country did likewise apart from the USA who walked out rather than hear the truth.
So what is the truth?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
I am not going to defend Israel or Hamas and ultimately it is a matter for Argentina. However I will make some points: 1. Were the Argentinian FA told to cancel by their government? If so that is political interference which is against FIFA rules. 2. How many dodgy countries has Argentina played in the last few years (I don't know the answer but I bet there will few nasty regimes)so why didn't they cancel them? If this was a one off qualifying game for the World Cup would they have refused to play it? 3. Sport is a useful tool for the hypocrites. Look at the sports boycott over South Africa. People were rightly incensed at that regime, meanwhile other African countries were committing genocide and mass murder. Some of the loudest critics of Apartheid were pretty despicable regimes themselves but were allowed to take the moral high ground. One last thing, why is there no boycott of Russia. They have invaded and annexed part of Ukraine shot down a civilian aeroplane and are generally a regime run for the benefit of criminals. Yep, seconded. These push-backs aren't endorsements of what's happening in that part of the world. It's a struggle for survival and it isn't pretty nor fair. The peace makers lost in Clinton's era. I think the creation of Israel was an injustice. A scrambled solution inspired by guilt forced onto an innocent party. However, once you create it, you either accept it or you go to war and see how the chips fall. Compared to their enemies, I'd support Israel everytime....but it's not done with clean hands. It's a sh1t sandwich. The South African point is a salient one.....Look at what the controlling government is doing to the white minority there. Yet silence from the left. I'm still waiting for Peter Gabriel to write a song for them. Edited by Stirlingsays (07 Jun 2018 11.50am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
To our credit at least the UK voted for this measure a modest proposal to give the Palestinians some protection. Every other country did likewise apart from the USA who walked out rather than hear the truth.
Wonder how much money Argentina gives? Edited by Penge Eagle (07 Jun 2018 12.04pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Jimenez
They have form. Wasn't it a few years back they unfurled a Malvinas flag/ banner before a game. Yep, their FA are dicks.
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
I am not going to defend Israel or Hamas and ultimately it is a matter for Argentina. However I will make some points: 1. Were the Argentinian FA told to cancel by their government? If so that is political interference which is against FIFA rules. 2. How many dodgy countries has Argentina played in the last few years (I don't know the answer but I bet there will few nasty regimes)so why didn't they cancel them? If this was a one off qualifying game for the World Cup would they have refused to play it? 3. Sport is a useful tool for the hypocrites. Look at the sports boycott over South Africa. People were rightly incensed at that regime, meanwhile other African countries were committing genocide and mass murder. Some of the loudest critics of Apartheid were pretty despicable regimes themselves but were allowed to take the moral high ground. One last thing, why is there no boycott of Russia. They have invaded and annexed part of Ukraine shot down a civilian aeroplane and are generally a regime run for the benefit of criminals. Venezuela and Bolivia at least.
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
Originally posted by twist
If in the US or UK we had mass protests, and those protesters were throwing rocks and flare and molotofs, and then the US/UK military/police sniped hundreds of them from afar, would that be acceptable ? I dont think so, so why is most of the world turning a blind eye to this ? I am sure there are hardcore Hamas supporters on the borders inciting the violence, but its your average Palestinian, protecting to get back those things they value, that are being shot dead. Hundreds??? The IDF warned them to stay away from the border, so why not protest in good distance? Most of the people killed were Hamas terrorists trying to breach the border. The 'protesters' were regular people paid by Hamas to cause disruption at the border and to be used as human shields. Hamas does this a lot to get sympathy from the rest of the world and you've fallen for its propaganda.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Penge Eagle
Hundreds??? The IDF warned them to stay away from the border, so why not protest in good distance? Most of the people killed were Hamas terrorists trying to breach the border. The 'protesters' were regular people paid by Hamas to cause disruption at the border and to be used as human shields. Hamas does this a lot to get sympathy from the rest of the world and you've fallen for its propaganda. The resolution agreed by all those countries to give the palestinians some measure of protection at the UN was after seeing and hearing the evidence, that's what the UN does, that is what it is for. Your endless reiteration is the only propaganda here.
|
|
| Park Road |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
The resolution agreed by all those countries to give the palestinians some measure of protection at the UN was after seeing and hearing the evidence, that's what the UN does, that is what it is for. Your endless reiteration is the only propaganda here.
Please watch the link I posted on this thread about Palestinian hero who stunned the UN, and told the truth about Hamas before you accuse anybody of propaganda
|
|
|
Originally posted by Park Road
Please watch the link I posted on this thread about Palestinian hero who stunned the UN, and told the truth about Hamas before you accuse anybody of propaganda Don't recognise that, at all. You say you are 'that ex pat bigot' ? Leave it with you.
|
|
| Park Road |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Don't recognise that, at all. You say you are 'that ex pat bigot' ? Leave it with you. Obviously, you missed the point. Look back on your posts, so leave it with you. Edited by Park Road (07 Jun 2018 3.36pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Cannonball
You forgot to add- Name me a country in the Middle East that is a free as Israel? Syria? Saudi Arabia? Qatar? Lebanon? Egypt? Iraq?
"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02 |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.