You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > James O'Brien
November 21 2026 10.42pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

James O'Brien


Page 2 of 11 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 26 Jun 18 7.18pm

Originally posted by Lofty3rgj


This 100%, listened to him for many years, but about a year ago enough was enough.
Switched to BBC Radio London, Robert Elms show is fantastic.

Brilliant show. Robert Elms is one cool man. Very knowledgeable about all things London and music.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Pussay Patrol Flag 26 Jun 18 9.58pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Socialism is meant to be about equality.

Do you believe in equality?

I don't.

So I'm hypocrite free on this one.

Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Jun 2018 2.35pm)

So you believe in inequality?

I still don't see the hypocrisy, if he was trying to portray himself as something he isn't, I would be inclined to agree, but he openly admits to his background.

I don't have a problem with his socialist principles, unlike you I don't buy into class divide.

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

Stirlingsays Flag 26 Jun 18 11.28pm

Originally posted by Pussay Patrol

So you believe in inequality?

I still don't see the hypocrisy, if he was trying to portray himself as something he isn't, I would be inclined to agree, but he openly admits to his background.

I don't have a problem with his socialist principles, unlike you I don't buy into class divide.


I believe in meritocracy. Equality is the enemy of meritocracy.

If you fail to see the hypocrisy I can't really help you.

'Class divide'? I'm not the socialist!

It's frustrating communicating with you. You don't answer a question put to you and instead reply with a question and then waffle about not seeing a point I made very clearly.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Pussay Patrol Flag 27 Jun 18 6.05am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays


I believe in meritocracy. Equality is the enemy of meritocracy.

If you fail to see the hypocrisy I can't really help you.

'Class divide'? I'm not the socialist!

It's frustrating communicating with you. You don't answer a question put to you and instead reply with a question and then waffle about not seeing a point I made very clearly.

Okay but meritocracy isn't to do with wealth and priveledge although it could be argued it goes hand in hand but you were referring to what he earns and how much wealth he has, which was kind of pigeon holing. You don't accept that anyone can have decent socialist principles whatever their background or lifestyle, instead leaning towards stereotypes

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

Sportyteacher Flag London 27 Jun 18 7.06am

Originally posted by pefwin

Never understood how Champagne could be considered derogatory. Surely a "Prosecco Socialist" is worse that truly is the chattering classes.

Cava Conservatives by comparison just seems flat...like their manifesto pledges!

 

DanH Flag SW2 27 Jun 18 7.52am

If you believe in a pure meritocracy does that mean you advocate a high level of inheritance tax?

 

Stirlingsays Flag 27 Jun 18 8.09am

Originally posted by Pussay Patrol

Okay but meritocracy isn't to do with wealth and priveledge although it could be argued it goes hand in hand but you were referring to what he earns and how much wealth he has, which was kind of pigeon holing. You don't accept that anyone can have decent socialist principles whatever their background or lifestyle, instead leaning towards stereotypes

Again, meritocracy is the enemy of equality. They can't co-exist truthfully as the end goal of a society: one compromises the other. It's why I prefer the word 'fairness' to equality.

You keep deflecting away from the central reality in regards to O'Brien. A person who calls themselves a socialist but lives a wealthy lifestyle is a hypocrite. It's really quite simple. A socialist is meant to believe in equality.

Sure they can have 'socialist principles' but that doesn't change the fact that they themselves are hypocrites....as in 'champagne socialist'.

Like I originally stated, 'equality for thee, but not for me'.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 27 Jun 18 8.10am

Originally posted by DanH

If you believe in a pure meritocracy does that mean you advocate a high level of inheritance tax?

It's not something I've ever really thought about.

What's your thinking on this?

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

DanH Flag SW2 27 Jun 18 9.09am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

It's not something I've ever really thought about.

What's your thinking on this?

Despite being quite comfortable with higher levels of income tax for higher earners, high levels of IHT do not sit too easily with me. A 'death tax' on assets obtained from (in most cases) taxed income and gains that flow directly to close family members seems a bit much.

When you speak of people wanting 'equality' I think you sometimes go a bit too far in thinking that some people want everyone to have exactly the same and any differentiation from the median is a outrage. Obviously I don't speak for others, but to me 'equality' means equal opportunity in life, not everyone having the same. Whether people choose to take that opportunity is down to them.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 27 Jun 18 9.31am

Originally posted by DanH

Despite being quite comfortable with higher levels of income tax for higher earners, high levels of IHT do not sit too easily with me. A 'death tax' on assets obtained from (in most cases) taxed income and gains that flow directly to close family members seems a bit much.

I think it's a matter of scale. That said, it isn't something I've thought about and there's definitely an argument that income that's already been taxed shouldn't be taxed again.

That said, while meritocratic systems are vital for a successful society they also tend to produce extremes of inequality.

That's not a good or bad outcome, it's just the outcome of a meritocratic system. The best people are going to be rewarded far better. Still, high rewards from society is symbiotic. In other words these rewards are dependent upon society so there's a responsibility to the hand that feeds you.

So I suppose I fall down on scale. It shouldn't be a concern for the vast majority of people.


 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 27 Jun 18 9.37am

Originally posted by DanH

When you speak of people wanting 'equality' I think you sometimes go a bit too far in thinking that some people want everyone to have exactly the same and any differentiation from the median is a outrage. Obviously I don't speak for others, but to me 'equality' means equal opportunity in life, not everyone having the same. Whether people choose to take that opportunity is down to them.


From my perspective the culture of society always has to be encouraged to be meritocratic rather than equal. For example, you want the best surgeon for your hospital operation.

How this is implemented however can have elements of fairness....as long as that doesn't result in ultimately not having the best people performing the important functions in life.

For example, I agree with you that a system where opportunity is open for 'everyone' to succeed ability wise independent of class is important.

That's why I don't believe in grammar schools and I would probably end private schools. Then again, I wouldn't be soft on poor behaviour and politically correct on performance. Rigor shouldn't be the buzz word it is and discipline and the caine would be back in my system. Activists would be shown the door.

I would still have our universities but I would end any form of affirmative action and ensure that only the brightest went to them.

This doesn't end the specter of inequality of course as better families educate their own people and rich ones pay for it.....but it does make the system fairer. I would come down hard on cronyism. I want the brightest, not the best connected.

A difference from you however is probably that you would have this open to everyone whereas I would only have the British educational systems open to the British, with the exception of paid for foreign students.

Edited by Stirlingsays (27 Jun 2018 9.43am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

cryrst Flag The garden of England 27 Jun 18 9.54am

Originally posted by DanH

Despite being quite comfortable with higher levels of income tax for higher earners, high levels of IHT do not sit too easily with me. A 'death tax' on assets obtained from (in most cases) taxed income and gains that flow directly to close family members seems a bit much.

When you speak of people wanting 'equality' I think you sometimes go a bit too far in thinking that some people want everyone to have exactly the same and any differentiation from the median is a outrage. Obviously I don't speak for others, but to me 'equality' means equal opportunity in life, not everyone having the same. Whether people choose to take that opportunity is down to them.

I am not a high earner all the time
Ie above the 20% tax threshold only in years where OT is good.
I do believe though that the more you earn the less tax you should pay.
Ie the mega earners.
They take the same out of the social system if not less due to private health etc.
A mega earner say over a million, in one year will pay what I will pay in a lifetime. Give or take so why should they be shafted to give more and more without getting more out.
I can see why they leave and try all ways to pay less.
I reckon after a while a majority of us would think the same and rightly so.
There is a group in the working environment who avoid the correct tax regularly and still get rebates.
I know a few and it's blatant but untraceable as earnings as they get paid in cash a lot of the time.
Once they get to state pension age it will come to fruition for some I'm sure.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 27 Jun 18 10.13am

Originally posted by cryrst

I am not a high earner all the time
Ie above the 20% tax threshold only in years where OT is good.
I do believe though that the more you earn the less tax you should pay.
Ie the mega earners.
They take the same out of the social system if not less due to private health etc.
A mega earner say over a million, in one year will pay what I will pay in a lifetime. Give or take so why should they be shafted to give more and more without getting more out.
I can see why they leave and try all ways to pay less.
I reckon after a while a majority of us would think the same and rightly so.
There is a group in the working environment who avoid the correct tax regularly and still get rebates.
I know a few and it's blatant but untraceable as earnings as they get paid in cash a lot of the time.
Once they get to state pension age it will come to fruition for some I'm sure.

You know what other societies on the planet don't have the rich paying back into the system on scale?

Corrupt ones.

Look around the world at the state of countries and their cities where money earnt from society isn't reinvested back into it.

Look at the Victorian societies and the slums.

Even after Trump's massive tax reductions the top rate of income tax is 35 percent. The recognition that sh1t needs paying should be self evident.

Institutions and infrastructure needs to be paid for. Pensioners and children provision needs paying for. Security, the army and Police need paying for....I could go on of course.

Anyone who ever made it here....benefited from this. They wouldn't have what they have without the society that enabled them.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

DanH Flag SW2 27 Jun 18 10.38am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

You know what other societies on the planet don't have the rich paying back into the system on scale?

Corrupt ones.

Look around the world at the state of countries and their cities where money earnt from society isn't reinvested back into it.

Look at the Victorian societies and the slums.

Even after Trump's massive tax reductions the top rate of income tax is 35 percent. The recognition that sh1t needs paying should be self evident.

Institutions and infrastructure needs to be paid for. Pensioners and children provision needs paying for. Security, the army and Police need paying for....I could go on of course.

Anyone who ever made it here....benefited from this. They wouldn't have what they have without the society that enabled them.

I don't know whether it's just because it's nice weather and I'm of a sunnier disposition but I find myself agreeing with a lot of (well, some of) your posts over the last few days

 

Stirlingsays Flag 27 Jun 18 11.00am

Originally posted by DanH

I don't know whether it's just because it's nice weather and I'm of a sunnier disposition but I find myself agreeing with a lot of (well, some of) your posts over the last few days

I think polarization can be over stated.

I enjoy blunt language and people because I tend to find they get stuff done. In my view intellectual confrontation is development and is a tide that raises all boats and something that few healthy people should be allowed to shy away from. However, one of its downsides is that people can take things personally.

Still, rather like the differences between male and female, we are more similar than different (but this isn't a reason to attack those natural differences). A lot of the end aims will be the same but the paths to those destinations are what will differ.

We like to argue about the differences because that is of course relevant. However, in reality people may agree on many things.....but what's the point of a circle jerk. Political reach arounds soon get boring and stale.

Edited by Stirlingsays (27 Jun 2018 11.03am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

cryrst Flag The garden of England 27 Jun 18 11.49am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

You know what other societies on the planet don't have the rich paying back into the system on scale?

Corrupt ones.

Look around the world at the state of countries and their cities where money earnt from society isn't reinvested back into it.

Look at the Victorian societies and the slums.

Even after Trump's massive tax reductions the top rate of income tax is 35 percent. The recognition that sh1t needs paying should be self evident.

Institutions and infrastructure needs to be paid for. Pensioners and children provision needs paying for. Security, the army and Police need paying for....I could go on of course.

Anyone who ever made it here....benefited from this. They wouldn't have what they have without the society that enabled them.

Get that Stirling but I'm not advocating not paying
What I'm sure would work better is a ceiling on the tax an individual pays in one year.
If someone (the mega earners I might stress) was for example told that once they had contributed a set amount then that's it for the year.
Everything else is theirs. What better way to inspire a contribution than to keep banging them.
Of course they will use clever accounting to pay nish if that's the case.
It does stink of envy when the minions like us keep giving it to the rich.
You may know this but what % is the tax take from wages and what is it from business and services and sales.
That gives an idea of what figures would be earnt with fixed tax compared to them swerving paying and not contributing.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 27 Jun 18 12.28pm

Originally posted by cryrst

Get that Stirling but I'm not advocating not paying
What I'm sure would work better is a ceiling on the tax an individual pays in one year.
If someone (the mega earners I might stress) was for example told that once they had contributed a set amount then that's it for the year.
Everything else is theirs. What better way to inspire a contribution than to keep banging them.
Of course they will use clever accounting to pay nish if that's the case.
It does stink of envy when the minions like us keep giving it to the rich.
You may know this but what % is the tax take from wages and what is it from business and services and sales.
That gives an idea of what figures would be earnt with fixed tax compared to them swerving paying and not contributing.

I'm sure we would probably agree on a lot of this.

I'm certainly not against the rich. Indeed they are an essential sign of a healthy society. I just think that both state and individual are intertwined and both have an interest in ensuring the success of the other.

The state needs to ensure an environment exists to enable individuals to succeed on their merits and the individual needs to ensure that society keeps doing that.....Those arseh0les who pull the ladder up feck it all up.

The strong need to protect the weak but not be taken for granted.

The weak should not demonise the strong but celebrate them.

Edited by Stirlingsays (27 Jun 2018 1.40pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

dannyboy1978 Flag 27 Jun 18 12.53pm

Can't stand the bloke. Thinks all brexiteers are racist and only his view is correct.

 

Sportyteacher Flag London 27 Jun 18 1.32pm

Originally posted by dannyboy1978

Can't stand the bloke. Thinks all brexiteers are racist and only his view is correct.

Not like Nigel Farage with Remoaners then...

 

.TUX. Flag 27 Jun 18 5.20pm

Originally posted by DanH

Despite being quite comfortable with higher levels of income tax for higher earners, high levels of IHT do not sit too easily with me. A 'death tax' on assets obtained from (in most cases) taxed income and gains that flow directly to close family members seems a bit much.

When you speak of people wanting 'equality' I think you sometimes go a bit too far in thinking that some people want everyone to have exactly the same and any differentiation from the median is a outrage. Obviously I don't speak for others, but to me 'equality' means equal opportunity in life, not everyone having the same. Whether people choose to take that opportunity is down to them.

This ''speaks'' for me.

 


Buy Litecoin.

Page 2 of 11 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > James O'Brien