You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Southgate - Best England Manager since Hoddle
November 22 2026 7.46pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Southgate - Best England Manager since Hoddle


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
the_mcanuff_stuff Flag Caterham 04 Jul 18 12.15pm

Originally posted by Pussay Patrol

Although slightly fortuitous in the end tonight, I felt all tournament our shape, tactics, discipline and togetherness of the squad has been exemplarary. It wasn't a sparkling performance but we didn't rise to provocation and we managed the game well

Ironically our tactics are the same as those deployed by Hoddle , 3 at the back, playing a wing back system. It plays to our strengths

Also destroys the myth there were no decent English managers to lead the England team. All the wasted years under Stupid Sven and Clueless Capello

Do you mean the England manager with the best win % of all time (discounting Big Sam's one win)?

Agree though, that Southgate has done a great job. If England make the final, which is certainly possible, that would make him the most successful England WC manager after Sir Alf.

Can't picture a win against France, Brazil or Belgium in the final, but if they have the rub of the green, who knows. One can hope but not expect, I think.

P.S. And Sven managed to get England into the quarter finals (including Euros) in all of his 3 attempts.

I'm pleased Southgate is doing well, but let's keep some perspective on previous managers. Except McLaren, he really was awful

Edited by the_mcanuff_stuff (04 Jul 2018 12.24pm)

 

Pussay Patrol Flag 04 Jul 18 12.41pm

Originally posted by the_mcanuff_stuff

Do you mean the England manager with the best win % of all time (discounting Big Sam's one win)?

Agree though, that Southgate has done a great job. If England make the final, which is certainly possible, that would make him the most successful England WC manager after Sir Alf.

Can't picture a win against France, Brazil or Belgium in the final, but if they have the rub of the green, who knows. One can hope but not expect, I think.

P.S. And Sven managed to get England into the quarter finals (including Euros) in all of his 3 attempts.

I'm pleased Southgate is doing well, but let's keep some perspective on previous managers. Except McLaren, he really was awful

Edited by the_mcanuff_stuff (04 Jul 2018 12.24pm)

No you need your head testing if you think the 2 foreigners were successful, the 2010 WC was a farce, Algeria game was as an inept performance as you'll ever see, then we were humiliated by Germany. Total Shambles. Sven had an abundance of world class players but the only teams we beat beyond the groups were Paraguay and Denmark. Again, if that's your idea of success, we'll have to agree to differ

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 04 Jul 18 12.55pm

Originally posted by Pussay Patrol

No you need your head testing if you think the 2 foreigners were successful, the 2010 WC was a farce, Algeria game was as an inept performance as you'll ever see, then we were humiliated by Germany. Total Shambles. Sven had an abundance of world class players but the only teams we beat beyond the groups were Paraguay and Denmark. Again, if that's your idea of success, we'll have to agree to differ

And here we've only beaten Columbia and could quite easily lose to Sweden. Let's not get carried away.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 04 Jul 18 1.53pm

Originally posted by Pussay Patrol

But Southgate said we practiced penalties and we prepared for that situation, we won.

Previous managers never practiced penalties saying that you cannot recreate the same scenario, we lost

Just sayin'

And it wasn't just about practicing the taking of penalties either.

Southgate talked about getting his players to own the whole process i.e. being composed and doing things in your own time e.g. the walk from the centre circle to take the penalty, not hurrying with the kick, not allowing yourself to be distracted and, having a clear mind as to where you are going to place it.


 

Painter Flag Croydon 04 Jul 18 1.59pm

Originally posted by Pussay Patrol

Although slightly fortuitous in the end tonight, I felt all tournament our shape, tactics, discipline and togetherness of the squad has been exemplarary. It wasn't a sparkling performance but we didn't rise to provocation and we managed the game well

Ironically our tactics are the same as those deployed by Hoddle , 3 at the back, playing a wing back system. It plays to our strengths

Also destroys the myth there were no decent English managers to lead the England team. All the wasted years under Stupid Sven and Clueless Capello

We have beaten Tunisia, Panama and Columbia ( on pens ) let’s not get carried away, we lost to Belgium second string.
Southgate is excellent at PR, not sure about best manager. The team tactics and coaching are sorted out by Steve Holland.

 

johnno42000 Flag 04 Jul 18 2.02pm

I think Southgate, unlike Hoddle, probably doesn't believe the disabled are being punished for sins in a previous like, which is nice.

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

Stuk Flag Top half 04 Jul 18 2.31pm

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle

Once Dier came on we suddenly ceased to have a midfield. I understand the thinking but it wasn't the right tactic IMO as it invited pressure and broke the link between defence and attack, especially given we play it out from the back. RLC, Delph or Rashford would have been better options than Dier, or even with Dier but taking Lingard off, whose first touch last night was awful. Apart from one link up behind their left back Lingard may as well have been a brick wall for all the control, link up and threat he offered.

I do think he's quite limited in his options, with Vardy and Sterling both offering little. Could have started Rashford though.

But in Southgate's defence he at least has a plan A that is reasonably solid and helps ball retention and picks players to suit the system rather than trying to shoehorn as many Manure or Liverpool players in as possible. He also has clearly managed to create a good atmosphere in the camp and made the right call against Belgium by throwing the game.

Was he going to fly back to England and get him?

 


Optimistic as ever

Stirlingsays Flag 04 Jul 18 3.05pm

Originally posted by johnno42000

I think Southgate, unlike Hoddle, probably doesn't believe the disabled are being punished for sins in a previous like, which is nice.

Can't see how it's any worse than believing that you're going to roast in hell for all time for sins in this one.

Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Jul 2018 3.05pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Pussay Patrol Flag 04 Jul 18 3.39pm

Originally posted by Painter

We have beaten Tunisia, Panama and Columbia ( on pens ) let’s not get carried away, we lost to Belgium second string.
Southgate is excellent at PR, not sure about best manager. The team tactics and coaching are sorted out by Steve Holland.

Okay if you want to look at it that way, I just felt we kept the ball well, defended well as a team and weren't as naive as previous teams, we used to panic and revert to long ball and let the opposition wind us up. Funny how it's a much younger team but a much maturer performance

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

johnno42000 Flag 04 Jul 18 3.46pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Can't see how it's any worse than believing that you're going to roast in hell for all time for sins in this one.

Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Jul 2018 3.05pm)

It is as it makes a living person's disability seem like a punishment, which it isn't.

Edited by johnno42000 (04 Jul 2018 3.46pm)

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

Stirlingsays Flag 04 Jul 18 8.07pm

Originally posted by johnno42000

It is as it makes a living person's disability seem like a punishment, which it isn't.

Edited by johnno42000 (04 Jul 2018 3.46pm)

A punishment that they consciously played no part in, so it's not a punishment they had a choice in (it's all b0llocks of course)

Again, it's actually far worse to say to someone that the actions you take in this life.....actions that you do have a choice in.....those actions will see you roasted alive for all eternity.

I regarded the hyperbolic reaction to Hoddle's nonsense as more emotive hysteria. Treating the disabled as a 'protected class' from concepts some might object to.

That idea of the 'protected class' has become far far worse since that episode and regularly and consistently grinds my gears.

Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Jul 2018 8.08pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

chateauferret Flag 04 Jul 18 9.29pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Can't see how it's any worse than believing that you're going to roast in hell for all time for sins in this one.

Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Jul 2018 3.05pm)

Can you really not? Good Grief.

 


============
The Ferret
============

chateauferret Flag 04 Jul 18 9.31pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

A punishment that they consciously played no part in, so it's not a punishment they had a choice in (it's all b0llocks of course)

Again, it's actually far worse to say to someone that the actions you take in this life.....actions that you do have a choice in.....those actions will see you roasted alive for all eternity.

I regarded the hyperbolic reaction to Hoddle's nonsense as more emotive hysteria. Treating the disabled as a 'protected class' from concepts some might object to.

That idea of the 'protected class' has become far far worse since that episode and regularly and consistently grinds my gears.

Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Jul 2018 8.08pm)

Sometimes I think that some people who are not in what you call a "protected class" would benefit from spending some time in one to see what it's really like. But then I do know what it's really like and it's not something you should wish on anyone.

 


============
The Ferret
============

johnno42000 Flag 04 Jul 18 9.56pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Can you really not? Good Grief.

That was my reaction but thought I'd try and explain it. Just leave him to it.

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

YT Flag Oxford 05 Jul 18 8.25am

Alan Smith on 5Live this morning spoke very nicely about Gareth Southgate, with whom he’s clearly still friendly.

Asked about ‘that penalty’ etc, he said that Gareth is well used to facing adversity in his life and career. An example he gave was ‘being relegated at Palace on 48 points’. He was, of course, wrong. It was 49 points

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

silvertop Flag Portishead 05 Jul 18 4.37pm

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle

Once Dier came on we suddenly ceased to have a midfield. I understand the thinking but it wasn't the right tactic IMO as it invited pressure and broke the link between defence and attack, especially given we play it out from the back. RLC, Delph or Rashford would have been better options than Dier, or even with Dier but taking Lingard off, whose first touch last night was awful. Apart from one link up behind their left back Lingard may as well have been a brick wall for all the control, link up and threat he offered.

I do think he's quite limited in his options, with Vardy and Sterling both offering little. Could have started Rashford though.

But in Southgate's defence he at least has a plan A that is reasonably solid and helps ball retention and picks players to suit the system rather than trying to shoehorn as many Manure or Liverpool players in as possible. He also has clearly managed to create a good atmosphere in the camp and made the right call against Belgium by throwing the game.

My guess:

Score the odd goal without 100% commitment; then control the game and give them nothing; and let them collect cards as their frustrations mount.

That way we would go into the next round with a complete team; give little clues to opponents on tactics; and suffer as minimal fatigue as possible.

Dier fitted that plan.

Clearly a risk; and only 3 minutes from coming off.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 05 Jul 18 4.42pm

Originally posted by Painter

We have beaten Tunisia, Panama and Columbia ( on pens ) let’s not get carried away, we lost to Belgium second string.
Southgate is excellent at PR, not sure about best manager. The team tactics and coaching are sorted out by Steve Holland.

Our 2nd string lost to their 2nd string in a game it wasn't necessary to win.

Message to team (guess): play well, don't bust a gut, enjoy yourself, no yellow cards, don't embarrass us.

All boxes ticked.

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 05 Jul 18 6.02pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Our 2nd string lost to their 2nd string in a game it wasn't necessary to win.

Message to team (guess): play well, don't bust a gut, enjoy yourself, no yellow cards, don't embarrass us.

All boxes ticked.

myself would like us to keep winning,but your right coming second wasnt end of the world.
The one thing about this site is if they can find fault they will,they always look down never up

 

TomThePalaceFanatic Flag 05 Jul 18 6.12pm

Southgate has started to change the culture of England's first team, with a focus on possession and changing the mentality i.e keeping a calm head, relaxed environment off the pitch etc

I think this says more about the dinosaurs previously employed by the FA, as Southgate isn't a great manager by any stretch of the imagination. He has good solid ideas on how to bring the national team forward but some of the specific decisions he has made haven't been spot on

It's just good to have an England team that the country can get behind for once, and a lot of that is down to Southgate

 

Pussay Patrol Flag 08 Jul 18 11.38am

I want to change the title of this thread to best manager since Robson

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Southgate - Best England Manager since Hoddle