This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Beanyboysmd
He has the righr to an opinion, he does has the right to air it, nobody has an obligation to buy him a loudspeaker. Mmmm....So I guess this is you telling us that you agree that a cake shop has the right to refuse to make cakes with messages they don't like then. As I've said, these positions hold true but these social media companies hold a monopoly position in the market. I look forward to them enacting a price now. Originally posted by Beanyboysmd
To be fair people get kicked off YouTube for bugger all anyway, he has got away with breaking community guidelines on every medium he has been on. He needs to just stick to his website and spout his entertaining nonscence from there, that way everyone is happy.. Which left wing commentators have been kicked off of Youtube then?
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
What I am struggling with is trying to understand how the left seem to be failing to grasp that the narrative that is grabbing the attention of many people with regards to the likes of TR and now Infowars, is that they dare to speak the truth which the establishment wants to ignore. And that by jailing TR and now banning info-wars, adds a genuine credibility to that. Yet the left cheer it on. Are they really that stupid? Banning info-wars will make it even more popular. And able to genuinely claim that the Establishment is terrified of them. Banning them across these media platforms actually makes their claims about them true. Effectively these platforms are political and must be treated accordingly. Now I accept that many of the criticisms of Infowars have a genuine credibility and it has not been on my own political radar but now, I have to give it some respect because of those cheering on its demise. And that effect will resonate for a long time to come. But it really, really isn't. That's the whole point. It's half truths (at best) dressed up to suit an agenda. The left are equally as bad at this as well, for the sake of balance.
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
But it really, really isn't. That's the whole point. It's half truths (at best) dressed up to suit an agenda. The left are equally as bad at this as well, for the sake of balance. It does not matter whether it is the truth or not. By banning somebody for speaking what they claim as a truth you merely give them a credibility that they do not deserve. Because otherwise, why ban them in the first place? Why not humiliate them instead? Show them up as liars? And the reality is, at least in the case of TR, in terms of the grooming gangs, our establishment did, at the very best interpretation, chose to ignore the warnings from the likes of the EDL and the BNP and even now, seek to stop people talking about what happened for a variety of reasons. Bloody hell, you have a Labour Party who demotes one of its MP's for her refusal to stop talking about the cover ups and promotes one who 'liked' a tweet that essentially said the victims should keep their mouths shut in the interest of diversity. Many on the left talk about wanting to decriminalise drug use because they claim that it is the illegality of them that acts in part to attract people to use them and yet seem blind to the fact that by banning people from expressing opinions actually gives them a credibility that their claims do not deserve. Edited by Matov (07 Aug 2018 3.16pm) Edited by Matov (07 Aug 2018 3.16pm)
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
It does matter whether it is the truth or not. By banning somebody for speaking what they claim as a truth you merely give them a credibility that they do not deserve. Because otherwise, why ban them in the first place? Why not humiliate them instead? Show them up as liars? And the reality is, at least in the case of TR, in terms of the grooming gangs, our establishment did, at the very best interpretation, chose to ignore the warnings from the likes of the EDL and the BNP and even now, seek to stop people talking about what happened for a variety of reasons. Bloody hell, you have a Labour Party who demotes one of its MP's for her refusal to stop talking about the cover ups and promotes one who 'liked' a tweet that essentially said the victims should keep their mouths shut in the interest of diversity. Many on the left talk about wanting to decriminalise drug use because they claim that it is the illegality of them that acts in part to attract people to use them and yet seem blind to the fact that by banning people from expressing opinions actually gives them a credibility that their claims do not deserve. Edited by Matov (07 Aug 2018 3.16pm) I think it i always better to confront and challenge someone with a reasoned argument rather than banning them. I have never heard of Infowars but unless they are calling for acts of violence they should not be silenced. Nick Griffin was shown to be a complete idiot when he appeared on Question Time and he rapidly disappeared after that. He was probably hoping that the BBC would ban him from appearing so he could play the victim.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Nick Griffin was shown to be a complete idiot when he appeared on Question Time and he rapidly disappeared after that. He was probably hoping that the BBC would ban him from appearing so he could play the victim. A reasonable example. Although it must also be remembered that he was taken to court because of comments he made in a private meeting that was filmed by an undercover documentary film crew and was subsequently found innocent. Infowars had no real credibility with many people on the right for a variety of reasons. I think its host even admitted in a court case that he saw himself primarily as an entertainer rather than a serious political commentator. But now its been effectively banned, and in the run up to the November elections in the US, you actually have to give it a credibility. Because if it was just hysteria and bulls***, then why take such a step? Complete over-kill. And why I struggle to get why the left are cheering it on beyond not being very bright themselves. Perhaps the majority really are the naive virtue signalling morons that I am increasingly beginning to think they are? Idiots unable to actually counter any opinions they disagree with?
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
But it really, really isn't. That's the whole point. It's half truths (at best) dressed up to suit an agenda. The left are equally as bad at this as well, for the sake of balance. And yet they do so with the blessing of the platforms that purport to provide a voice to all. Downside for them - by banning (or de-blue-tickmarking) certain people, they implicitly condone those they have not banned. Thus we see the stunning level of double-standards and hypocrisy when people like Jeong rear their heads. These platforms really need to define what to them is "acceptable", and absolutely, that should include political inclination. Just let us know our voices are not welcome in their echo chambers. Then everyone is clear that they are little more than left-wing propaganda engines. I would like to see that in law in some way. Such that removal from a platform has severe legal implications where content was not found to violate conditions. Conditions that are not so all-encompassing that the platform has discretion and latitude to ban anyone they like. The mastery of that legal system will be to encode those conditions in a non-ambiguous way that provides end-users with genuine legal remediation for what is currently political censorship.
|
|
|
Now LinkedIn has blocked Alex Jones' account. Big tech have become political activists.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Beanyboysmd
Sorry Stirling, it wont let me quote the thing im replying too! In regards to the crap with the cake, I actually think the company have the right to refuse customers on whatever grounds they want, we as a public have the right to tell them they are scumbags for doing it and destroy their reputation though. I kinda strafe left and right when it comes to freedom of speech. If Alex Jones is unhappy, he is welcome to go to speakers corner and have the right to exorcise any free speech he feels like, but nobody owes him airtime anywhere... Well, I respect your viewpoint as consistent then even if our views are kind of in opposite directions. Well, I say that, but in reality I found the cake thing a really hard issue, which I've advocated both ways on.....I see problems with both issues....I'm not really comfortable with either answer but....I suppose it's easy to go with the view which annoys my political opponents the most.....but that's not very grown up. If I gave it some very serious thought I could probably find some mish mash compromise solution but that's what we pay judges to do....even if some of them suck at it. As for big tech....I view them as a monopoly....which, in my view, is interfering in the mid terms elections.....which is an abuse of their power.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by davenotamonkey
Owned by Microsoft. I'm sure he was "spreading hate" on there too. I have to say, I think these platforms are a bit cringe. I won't be sad when they hit saturation and can't offer much more than currently. I don't really know anyone that enthusiastically uses FB these days, other than to indulge in cheap virtue signaling. I think we're growing past it. That said, I'd love it if Trump moved to Gab and took his huge following with him. Anyone, incidentally, know why you can't get on Gab via Google play / Apple store? You'll never guess... If Trump wins in 2020, I'd be surprised if he didn't move off Twitter....well at the very least after 2022. He has to take action on them anyway.....as we can see these companies doing this crap to him once the campaign starts. Edited by Stirlingsays (07 Aug 2018 11.36pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by davenotamonkey
Anyone, incidentally, know why you can't get on Gab via Google play / Apple store? You'll never guess... Yeah, it's because Gab is a rival of Twitter and promotes free speech... er, actually, I mean, we all know Gab 'spreads hate', that's why! But you are right. Trump moving to Gab would be 'yuge'! Edited by Penge Eagle (08 Aug 2018 12.11am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
What, over and above highlighting the need for one? Why would you ask that? These are events happening in the US. As for here, I have written to my MP recently over my concerns about MPs pushing for Internet censorship. I've also recently joined the only party who seems interested in free speech anymore, Ukip. Edited by Stirlingsays (07 Aug 2018 11.47am) Thanks for clarifying.
|
|
| .TUX. |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Penge Eagle
Now LinkedIn has blocked Alex Jones' account. Big tech have become political activists. .....are owned by the 'political elite' that have led us down this path of economic/social s***ness for decades now.
Buy Litecoin. |
|
|
Originally posted by .TUX.
.....are owned by the 'political elite' that have led us down this path of economic/social s***ness for decades now. All of Sillicon Valley (bar one company I think) donated to the Democrats in the last election. It seems they are planning to go all out to ensure a Republican victory never happens again. Edited by Penge Eagle (08 Aug 2018 9.37pm)
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.