You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Rate the transfer window (Summer 2018 edition)
November 16 2026 7.06am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Rate the transfer window (Summer 2018 edition)


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
mileend Flag East London 09 Aug 18 11.26pm

sensible

we were on an upward trajectory with Roy and really finding a great and effective style in the last half of the season so best not to mess with that too much and I think the players we have brought in can help improve us

lots of clubs have really bought far too many players

there will be difficulties for some of them making them into a cohesive unit - not all of them will be a success - some teams will find it a struggle despite the big expenditure

there will be lots of other players who aren't happy about their opportunities and we'll be in a good position to strengthen in the next two windows

we'll have enough to entertain and collect sufficient points for mid table until then - because we are lacking depth

last chances for Kai Kai, Williams and Wickham

 

Hudsoneagle Flag 09 Aug 18 11.38pm

Hmm...for me I’d have to say 7/10

While Meyer is the pick of the bunch, he is as yet unproven and only time will tell. If he doesn’t work out we will be lacking creativity and it seems we won’t have the money to buy it in Jan. 8/10 potentially 10/10 excited to find out

Kouyate is a good player who can also fill in at centre back. Good purchase but honestly...I’d have much much preferred Livermore from West Brom. 6/10

Guaita has a great record. Always thought this was a fantastic signing. Perhaps the only concern is, will he settle? I hope so and if he does he could be a Palace favourite. 7.5/10

Ayew is actually pretty good. Watched him play for Swansea and my mate is a Swansea fan and I’ve always said he’s a good player and he’s always agreed. Likeable player who tries hard. I think a perfect fit for us. He might not seem like a 1st 11 player but he can play anywhere across a front 3 so I expect him to get a fair few games this year. 7/10

9/10 for SP as the money spent is nearly nothing. I do hope this means there is some wiggle room in Jan if needed.

My main concern is that I would have liked to see a winger. I know Ayew likes to come in from the left and Townsend and Wilf can play either side if needed. Just always seemed for a team like ours that we lack that pacey replacement winger. 1st 11 is top 10 but 3 key injuries and we are bottom 6.

 

CP81 Flag Kent 09 Aug 18 11.48pm

Let's not forget Roy and Ray.

 


Palace 2 Charlton 0 1981

Dan1994 Flag Wallington 09 Aug 18 11.51pm

On the face of it, I am happy with what with done with the limited resources we had. I think for me, it was keeping the core squad together, given our very good run towards the end of the season and will hopefully keep that momentum going.

It's very difficult to say how it will all pan out, obviously, but we will see what each of the new lads have to offer. I am confident with Kouyate and Ayew, and I am eager to see how Guaita (haven't seen him in action, yet) and Meyer perform.

Only improvement for me would've been trying to get another striker, and I think Origi would've been a good alternative to Benteke, and give Benteke something to work against. Ayew is a good addition in this respect, although I feel he'd be deployed on the wing, or next to Benteke.

Overall, I am quite confident going into the new season. Hopefully we'll have a season where we are not worried about relegation, and finish somewhere in with "the best of the rest."

Edited by Dan1994 (09 Aug 2018 11.52pm)

 


[Link]

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 09 Aug 18 11.55pm

Personally I’m very happy -8/10 but if Meyer reaches his potential it’ll be more of a 9.5.

Guaita looks like he could be an excellent pick if he can get an understanding going quickly with the back 4.

Kouyate & Ayew both solid players with PL experience who can play in different positions.

Meyer has the potential to be a game changer & an upgrade on Cabaye.

There’s a bit of me thinking Wickham could be like a new signing if the medical & sports science teams have done the business. IF he can stay fit he’ll be hungry to get back to the top of his game & back to performances like the one against WBA season before last.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

michaelpearce Flag grays 10 Aug 18 6.43am

for me 7 1/2 if signings work well 8 maybe 9, would have liked 1 more signing a striker,
Think we cover just about everywhere else,if Ben,Connor,sorloth, stay fit and score when playing it wont be a problem,
Until a ball is kicked we dont know how good our signings are,all we know is potentially we have a good squad,lets hope so

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 10 Aug 18 8.12am

We wont know until the season is well underway but if the players click and we stay injury free this could be a great season.

On paper the squad is much better with more depth and if they all click it means that for the next few transfer windows we will look for quality over quantity.

 


One more point

Painter Flag Croydon 10 Aug 18 8.18am

8.5 for me. Strengthen where needed, done well in the market we are buying in, we aren't going to be buying the £30m+ rated players for a while.
Brighton, Fulham, Huddersfield, West Ham and Wolves have bought over 6 players each, the challenge they have is getting them to play as a cohesive team. We have a fairly settled side, so easier to slot one or two in.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 10 Aug 18 12.27pm

I think it was the Benteke window I upset a few by giving it a 7, and that seemed great because of Benteke, but wasn’t with no decent left back cover, Jedi leaving and Flamini in as a free agent panic. Freedman apparently pointed out our weakness at def mid on tv during a home match. That turned out to be part of the reason we fvcked up that Autumn.

The Frank, 3-4-3 And Sakho window was definitely worse.

It therefore has to be higher than a 7 but Meyer and obvious gelllng details you just don’t know. Even Pardew’s Townsend and Tomkins signings were terrible under Pardew. And then there’s West Brom who appeared to do good business last summer and got relegated.

Lots of good points made on this thread though and it’s good to see almost everyone contented, confident of survival Parish also said he wanted for a change but cautiously optimistic of better than that. Hopefully we’ll make up for the loss of drum, conductor and flags.

I think the new deadline helps us, our manager and squad with how Parish prefers to do things and the competitiveness lost is only really experienced by teams in European competitions when those prices fall today. Having said that those European clubs will realise that they’re missing out on extra £’s if they don’t sell in time to Prem clubs.

 


COYP

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Rate the transfer window (Summer 2018 edition)