You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Forward line
November 16 2026 6.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Forward line


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
EssexEagle16 Flag Essex 21 Aug 18 5.15pm

Really don't get the issue with Sorloth. Guy has had very limited minutes, even less in his preferred position, and has been completely written off already.

Personally thought he looked ok when he came on last night, didn't shine but how could he in the circumstances?

 

Master Coin Flag 21 Aug 18 5.39pm

Originally posted by EssexEagle16

Really don't get the issue with Sorloth. Guy has had very limited minutes, even less in his preferred position, and has been completely written off already.

Personally thought he looked ok when he came on last night, didn't shine but how could he in the circumstances?

Did you watch much of pre-season? Sorloth played plenty with Benteke out injured and looked complete pony (even against lesser opposition). Its also pretty telling that Roy constantly keeps faith with a misfiring Benteke. If Sorloth were any good then he'd get the opportunity to start

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 21 Aug 18 6.23pm

Originally posted by Master Coin

Did you watch much of pre-season? Sorloth played plenty with Benteke out injured and looked complete pony (even against lesser opposition). Its also pretty telling that Roy constantly keeps faith with a misfiring Benteke. If Sorloth were any good then he'd get the opportunity to start

Agreed, went to many of the pre season games and he did indeed look pony then to

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 21 Aug 18 7.08pm

Originally posted by benmccarthy

Benteke's shot that hit the FanZone was the final straw. Sorloth came on and even ran like Benteke. Get Zaha and Townsend up front ASAP.

Ultimately I would like to see Townsend Zaha up top, Meyer, Kouyate, Milivojevic and Ayew in midfield and the normal back 4, with Ayew and Meyer chopping and changing/overlapping with Zaha and Townsend during the game. Keep the ball on the deck and fizz it about. That would make for an exciting line up - all in my humble opinion.

 

pssguy Flag 21 Aug 18 8.01pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

WTF are you on about. I'm talking about our centre forwards.

The subject is forward LINE

 

theshezla Flag wibble 21 Aug 18 9.31pm

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

I got a clue to his attitude when he tried a shot from outside the box (when he had two better options) and ballooned it into the heavens. When was the last time he score from outside the box? Lewington had his head in his hands and Hodgson kicked the air when he did it then he was subbed.

Similarly, in the Fulham game, there was a ball be could have easily kept in in an attacking position but he let it run out. Zaha was visibly annoyed with him. So was I.

I don't expect him to chase everything. But I don't see much difference to games last season where he let the ball run out of play because he couldn't be bothered or when he grossly overestimated his ability and had his own cause in mind rather than the team.

I don't think fans are on his back and he had support - but it won't last if he continues like this. I hope I'm wrong, but these are my observations so far. I hope that answers your question.

Ps, his record of late is terrible.

Edited by Frickin Saweet (21 Aug 2018 4.48pm)

Sorry fella, but you ain’t uttered a single word in your response that justifies your comment regarding his attitude

The guy is trying his best, whether it’s food enough at times is a separate subject but you can’t question his effort or attitude

 


Yep

babylonjohn Flag St Leonards-on-Sea 21 Aug 18 9.59pm

There is a reason Liverpool paid 75M for Van Dyke .... he showed it last night and made sure Benteke hardly got a sniff of a chance. We will not face many other teams as good as Liverpool. We cannot afford for Benteke not to come good again we have invested massively in him. Yes we have options now up front but we have to keep supporting Benteke. He will get his mojo back.

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 21 Aug 18 10.02pm

Originally posted by theshezla

How on earth are you judging his attitude? Are you in the dressing room and at all of the training sessions, can you hear what he is saying to his team mates, the ref etc

Again, I'm not saying he was great last night, but what specifically do you mean? He aint gonna chase everything down like Cameron Jerome used to, that's not him nor is it our style under Roy, especially against the top sides

The fact of the matter is, we have him until at least January probably the rest of the season. He has a better track record than any other striker in the squad and his confidence will only get better if fans get off his back and actually support him

Our next run of games are perfect for him and I for one will be hope (believe) he will find the back of the net

I will say benteke needs more aggression to his game. He always looks depressed or short of confidence. More aggression is what he needs. That counts as attitude- so he’s right in that sense, imo

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 21 Aug 18 11.28pm

Originally posted by benmccarthy

Benteke's shot that hit the FanZone was the final straw. Sorloth came on and even ran like Benteke. Get Zaha and Townsend up front ASAP.

I guess Geoff Thomas knows how Tekkers must feel after that "wayward" shot!

 

pssguy Flag 22 Aug 18 1.29am

Originally posted by babylonjohn

There is a reason Liverpool paid 75M for Van Dyke .... he showed it last night and made sure Benteke hardly got a sniff of a chance. We will not face many other teams as good as Liverpool. We cannot afford for Benteke not to come good again we have invested massively in him. Yes we have options now up front but we have to keep supporting Benteke. He will get his mojo back.

True. It will probably neither get any harder for him than Liverpool nor easier than Fulham. I'm not that optimistic

 

pssguy Flag 22 Aug 18 1.32am

Originally posted by benmccarthy

Benteke's shot that hit the FanZone was the final straw. Sorloth came on and even ran like Benteke. Get Zaha and Townsend up front ASAP.

I would hope training is concentrating on seeing how Zaha and Ayew can work together; keeping Townsend and Wan-Bissaka together on the right

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 22 Aug 18 7.14am

Originally posted by theshezla

Sorry fella, but you ain’t uttered a single word in your response that justifies your comment regarding his attitude

The guy is trying his best, whether it’s food enough at times is a separate subject but you can’t question his effort or attitude

An intelligent 9 year old could understand what I'm talking about. You keep burying your head in the sand pal.

 

theshezla Flag wibble 22 Aug 18 7.29am

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet
An intelligent 9 year old could understand what I'm talking about. You keep burying your head in the sand pal.

Another sound argument, you are right, I apologise

 


Yep

michaelpearce Flag grays 22 Aug 18 7.36am

Tekes attitude is ok just watch him defending but sadly as a attacker its gone,
have said this on another post kouyate is better in a more advance role, this come from a westspam fan so we can change and try, also he his faster than Teke,
Ayew another one, Wickham if fit,and young mr daley so we have options

 

Painter Flag Croydon 22 Aug 18 8.11am

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

WTF are you on about. I'm talking about our centre forwards.

Stop trying to make a petty point.

Zaha is not the reason for our lack of goals which I'm sure you would agree.

Now go do one

We are commenting on the forward line, when you can work out what that is, feel free to comment.

Back peddling making out Zaha isn't a forward shows how much you seem to know.

Do one what?

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 22 Aug 18 8.36am

Any hopes we had of Benteke being a 'new man' this season have been blown out the water in these first 2 games where he has shown that he's just as s*** as he was last season... Watching Murray for Brighton against Man Utd the other day makes it worse as he was ours and does everything Benteke doesn't!!

I'm sorry but the guy is shot to pieces... Take the hit in January, sell him and get his huge wages off the bill.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 22 Aug 18 12.38pm

Originally posted by theshezla

Another sound argument, you are right, I apologise

no worries old chum, you got there in the end.

 

stayloa Flag Beckenham 22 Aug 18 1.16pm

Originally posted by Pete53

I guess Geoff Thomas knows how Tekkers must feel after that "wayward" shot!

Reminded me of a Gareth Taylor effort from outside the box shooting towards the Whitehorse Lane end that ended up on the roof...

 

General Flag 22 Aug 18 9.31pm

Again I'm lost and confused.
As someone said Zaha gets so much freedom because of Benteke.
If you watch them two for a while you will see.
Cannot possibly expect Sorloth to have the same impact or usefulness over 90 mins coming from the Norwegian league are you serious. He's clearly not a superstar.
Watch Benteke best games and you will see how he was quite lucky at Villa with who supplied him balls. We are just not that team.
I'm not sure if you expect Kane for £30 million but Sorloth is a third of the price and clearly a third of the player.
Wickham about half the cost and half the player.
Benteke has more class than plenty of the strikers we have had. Murray included. Murray was super at his work rate and making the absolute maximum of his opportunities and obviously did have class moments I'm not denying that but come on he was a notch below Benteke overall.
I can agree a little more confidence and you'll see him chest a ball down perfect, lay it off perfect, and move into a super position where defenders are retreating thus creating more space for midfielder driving forward or Zaha run etc etc but I'm still hopeful Roy can work it out of him..

 

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 22 Aug 18 9.50pm

Originally posted by General

Again I'm lost and confused.
As someone said Zaha gets so much freedom because of Benteke.
If you watch them two for a while you will see.
Cannot possibly expect Sorloth to have the same impact or usefulness over 90 mins coming from the Norwegian league are you serious. He's clearly not a superstar.
Watch Benteke best games and you will see how he was quite lucky at Villa with who supplied him balls. We are just not that team.
I'm not sure if you expect Kane for £30 million but Sorloth is a third of the price and clearly a third of the player.
Wickham about half the cost and half the player.
Benteke has more class than plenty of the strikers we have had. Murray included. Murray was super at his work rate and making the absolute maximum of his opportunities and obviously did have class moments I'm not denying that but come on he was a notch below Benteke overall.
I can agree a little more confidence and you'll see him chest a ball down perfect, lay it off perfect, and move into a super position where defenders are retreating thus creating more space for midfielder driving forward or Zaha run etc etc but I'm still hopeful Roy can work it out of him..

I think I agree with this. If we want to play a number 9 Benteke has to be the one. Ayew is a different type of player which is probably why we bought him as an alternative style should we need it.

 

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Forward line