This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Strongest team if....
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
PatrickA London 04 Sep 18 11.43am |
|
|
Now the squad has been named I thought it could be worth debating the strongest team if all the players were fit( unlikely as that is). I would be tempted to play 3-5-2 ( which again I know Roy won’t do). II would play Tomkins,Dann and Sakho as the back 3 with AWB and PVA as wing backs.All are comfortable on the ball and Tomkins and Dann would give us aerial strength in both boxes and chip in with a few goals from set pieces. I would go with Kouyate, Mcarthur and Meyer as the midfield 3. They have e energy and purpose and Meyer could knit the team together. It might seem harsh leaving Luka out but he sometimes looks one paced and am not sure he has the mobility to play in this system. With three at the back his position in front of the defence may be less relevant. Zaha would obviously be one of the two up front. Who would partner him? To show how unlikely this is ever to happen I’m going for a fully fit Wickham (I know - pure fantasy). If this was t working could always revert to a 4-4-2 with Benteke, Townsend and Luka on the bench.
|
maddog Wiltshire 04 Sep 18 12.42pm |
|
|
352 makes sense with our current squad
Ayew upfront with Zaha
Edited by maddog (04 Sep 2018 12.43pm)
|
The_postman Forest Row 04 Sep 18 2.43pm |
|
Originally posted by maddog
352 makes sense with our current squad
Ayew upfront with Zaha
Edited by maddog (04 Sep 2018 12.43pm)
Whilst JT, SD and MS are decent centre-backs in a four man defence, they do not possess all the attributes required to play in a three. The outside CB's have to have great pace as they will be required to cover the wide areas formerly occupied by the full backs. This is one of the weaknesses of the formation as the opposition will target the wide open spaces behind the wing backs. The reason Southgate plays Walker as the right CB in England's 3-5-2 formation is because of his speed. The middle CB has to have good ball playing abilities as his role in possession is to push forward and support the midfield three. I don't think we can describe any of them as ball playing CB's. I still get the jitters when Mama is on the ball. Finally, the three CB's need excellent communication and positional awareness to play as a unit. If they allow themselves to be pulled apart from one another the opposition will exploit the space in between. This is something they would have to practice extensively and bed down in pre season.
|
Bangell Oxford 04 Sep 18 2.51pm |
|
|
No chance we'll play 3-5-2, nor should we.
I imagine we'll persist with 4-4-2, with Meyer taking Schlupp's place and hopefully Ayew taking Benteke's.
Personally I think a 4-2-3-1 would work best:
AWB Tomkins Sakho PVA
Luka McArthur
Townsend Meyer Wilf
Ayew
I think we'd have much more fluency to our play than in that dreadful 'hit and hope to two isolated and uncapable strikers' system we saw against Southampton.
|
ARGILE OLD GEEZER PORTIMAO 04 Sep 18 3.07pm |
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
Now the squad has been named I thought it could be worth debating the strongest team if all the players were fit( unlikely as that is). I would be tempted to play 3-5-2 ( which again I know Roy won’t do). II would play Tomkins,Dann and Sakho as the back 3 with AWB and PVA as wing backs.All are comfortable on the ball and Tomkins and Dann would give us aerial strength in both boxes and chip in with a few goals from set pieces. I would go with Kouyate, Mcarthur and Meyer as the midfield 3. They have e energy and purpose and Meyer could knit the team together. It might seem harsh leaving Luka out but he sometimes looks one paced and am not sure he has the mobility to play in this system. With three at the back his position in front of the defence may be less relevant. Zaha would obviously be one of the two up front. Who would partner him? To show how unlikely this is ever to happen I’m going for a fully fit Wickham (I know - pure fantasy). If this was t working could always revert to a 4-4-2 with Benteke, Townsend and Luka on the bench.
I wish you was our manager apart from leaving Luka out, but i admit i don't know were to fit him in your team, maybe in place of Jimmy Mac, if he gets over his present poor form, he defiantly has to play.
|
taylors lovechild 04 Sep 18 3.10pm |
|
|
Having seen a few cameos from Kouyate I feel like he could be a more important figure than Meyer for us. He is a proper box-to-box midfielder and he can shoot from distance, win tackles, win headers and has physicality.
Hennessey
AWB Tomkins Sakho PvA
Kouyate Luka Meyer
Townsend Ayew Zaha
Edit: I realise this leaves McArthur out, but I just feel like despite his strong performances this would be a more balanced team.
Edited by taylors lovechild (04 Sep 2018 3.11pm)
|
eagleman13 On The Road To Hell & Alicante 04 Sep 18 3.19pm |
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
Having seen a few cameos from Kouyate I feel like he could be a more important figure than Meyer for us. He is a proper box-to-box midfielder and he can shoot from distance, win tackles, win headers and has physicality.
Hennessey
AWB Tomkins Sakho PvA
Kouyate Luka Meyer
Townsend Ayew Zaha
Edit: I realise this leaves McArthur out, but I just feel like despite his strong performances this would be a more balanced team.
Edited by taylors lovechild (04 Sep 2018 3.11pm)
I do like this team(if all fit).
As you say prob wont happen from RH, but, we can all pick a team from our declared 25(inc kids) & not one of us will get it right. In the end its Roy's choice as he see's fit.
Isnt that the fun of a thread like this 
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.
|
Kingjim26 04 Sep 18 4.25pm |
|
|
Roy likes the 442 with a narrow midfield, width coming from the full backs. so I wouldn't be surprised to see this Wayne Awb. Tomkins sakho. Pva
Meyer. Luka koyate macca
Townsend. Zaha.
|
JohnB 04 Sep 18 4.39pm |
|
|
I'd like to see: ................Guaita
AWB........Tomkins...Sakho....PVA
.........Kouyate..Luka...Meyer
...Townsend...........Zaha
..............Benteke
Edited by JohnB (04 Sep 2018 4.40pm)
|
PatrickA London 04 Sep 18 5.58pm |
|
|
I’m conscious of the fact that against Watford and to a certain extent Liverpool we were outmuscled and there are plenty of other physical,athletic opponents to come. With a back 3 of Tomkins, Dann and Sakho with Kouyate in central midfield there is less concern about being ‘bullied.’ There is still plenty of skill and pace down the sides witth AWB and PVA and the skills of Zaha and Meyer further forward. The glaring gap in the squad is a clinical hard working striker to play alongside Zaha and that is where the system may fail.
|
YT Oxford 04 Sep 18 6.45pm |
|
Originally posted by Bangell
No chance we'll play 3-5-2, nor should we.
I imagine we'll persist with 4-4-2, with Meyer taking Schlupp's place and hopefully Ayew taking Benteke's.
Personally I think a 4-2-3-1 would work best:
AWB Tomkins Sakho PVA
Luka McArthur
Townsend Meyer Wilf
Ayew
I think we'd have much more fluency to our play than in that dreadful ‘hit and hope to two isolated and uncapable strikers' who were meat and drink to two massive if untalented centre-backs system we saw against Southampton.
Seeking your apology, I’ve added a bit in bold.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)
|
Booted Eagle Bristol 04 Sep 18 7.15pm |
|
Originally posted by The_postman
Whilst JT, SD and MS are decent centre-backs in a four man defence, they do not possess all the attributes required to play in a three. The outside CB's have to have great pace as they will be required to cover the wide areas formerly occupied by the full backs. This is one of the weaknesses of the formation as the opposition will target the wide open spaces behind the wing backs. The reason Southgate plays Walker as the right CB in England's 3-5-2 formation is because of his speed. The middle CB has to have good ball playing abilities as his role in possession is to push forward and support the midfield three. I don't think we can describe any of them as ball playing CB's. I still get the jitters when Mama is on the ball. Finally, the three CB's need excellent communication and positional awareness to play as a unit. If they allow themselves to be pulled apart from one another the opposition will exploit the space in between. This is something they would have to practice extensively and bed down in pre season.
Good post. 352 would be very difficult., have to be 4 at the back. Difficult to gauge the likes of Meyer at the moment as haven't seen enough of him.
“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ” —United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld
|
Plaistow Eagle 04 Sep 18 7.35pm |
|
|
Kouyate is reputedly a better central defender than central midfielder.
So with that in mind I'd go; 5, 2, 1, 2 with;
Guaita AWB, Tomkins, Sakho, Kouyate, PVA McArthur, Milo Meyer Townsend, Zaha.
COYP
|
rikz Croydon 04 Sep 18 10.14pm |
|
|
Problem with 3 5 2 is if you lose the ball in attack you have to revert to a back 4 with kouyate dropping to the centre, dann or sakho would be terrible as a full back.
|
Palace Passion Bromley, South London 04 Sep 18 10.33pm |
|
|
Guaita
Wan-Bissaka-Tomkins-Sakho-Van Aanholt
Milivojevic----McArthur
Townsend----Meyer----Zaha
Ayew
Edited by Palace Passion (04 Sep 2018 10.33pm)
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||| |||||||||||P|A|L|A|C|E||||||||||| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
***Oliver Glasner's RED BLUE ARMY*** Be loud.. Be proud.. Be PALACE!
staffie - missed but never forgotten 19/04/15
|
jammyeagle81 Carshalton Beeches 04 Sep 18 10.57pm |
|
|
Assuming everyone is fit ...
I'd give Luka (head's not right last few matches) and Benteke a rest on the bench, and leave Ayew as a substitute option to shake a game up if needed.
Jimmy Mac played a blinder against Southampton and Sørloth needs a couple of full 90 minutes for everyone to decide if he's decent or not.
Zaha is a winger. End of.
-----------Guaita AWB - Tomkins - Sakho - PVA -------Meyer - Kouyate Townsend - MacArthur - Zaha -----------Sørloth
Bench: Hennessey, Kelly, Ward, Milivojevic, Schlupp, Ayew, Benteke
Edited by jammyeagle81 (04 Sep 2018 11.10pm)
Attachment: Screen Shot 2018-09-02 at 17.15.22.png (706.23Kb)
|
The_postman Forest Row 05 Sep 18 11.45am |
|
Originally posted by jammyeagle81
Assuming everyone is fit ...
I'd give Luka (head's not right last few matches) and Benteke a rest on the bench, and leave Ayew as a substitute option to shake a game up if needed.
Jimmy Mac played a blinder against Southampton and Sørloth needs a couple of full 90 minutes for everyone to decide if he's decent or not.
Zaha is a winger. End of.
-----------Guaita AWB - Tomkins - Sakho - PVA -------Meyer - Kouyate Townsend - MacArthur - Zaha -----------Sørloth
Bench: Hennessey, Kelly, Ward, Milivojevic, Schlupp, Ayew, Benteke
Edited by jammyeagle81 (04 Sep 2018 11.10pm)
The two holding midfielders both need to be ball winners and that would suit Luka and Kouyate. The central attacking midfielder is the playmaker and Meyer could do a job there. 4-2-3-1 is a very flexible formation and would suit our counter attacking play. It also has the benefit of ensuring that we are not outnumbered in midfield. However, it does rely on the two wide attacking midfielders (Andros and Wilf) tracking back a lot to support the full backs when out of possession. If they don't, then it becomes very easy for the opposition to overload the fullbacks.
|
Fatherken 05 Sep 18 12.52pm |
|
|
strange how Hennessey [one of our better players this season so far ] heaters dropped him for Guaita [ untried at this level ] the bigger surprise is they have not call for Speroni to be our first choice goalkeeper
|