You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > 2 Questions
November 16 2026 6.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

2 Questions


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Plaistow Eagle Flag 16 Sep 18 11.26am

I agree on Meyer.

I'd like to see Meyer in for Ayew with Zaha and Townsend playing up front against Newcastle.

COYP

 

Mstrobez Flag 16 Sep 18 11.33am

Like others have said, the problem is with the midfield and not the back 4. As back 4s go we genuinely have as good of a combination as you could hope for as a club of our size.

Problem is, Lukas playing like a donkey this season. Jimmy Mac is a fantastic engine and so important in our squad, but he’s not much more than an engine. Kouyate, again, seems to be decent as a solid physical presence but his passing looks abysmal.

We do have the answers to this in our squad, but it will mean being bold in the sense that we sacrifice some of our destroyer type midfielders for more creative presences. Still not on board with the idea that Meyer is a like for like replacement for Cabaye because he’s not. But a mix of Riedewald (yes, Riedewald) and Meyer being introduced could really see us have a really nice balance in the squad.

I think that the Meyer situation is showing early signs of an all to familiar tale at Palace, which is just so disappointing. That’s just how it feels. “Not physical enough” or whatever the reason will be not to make him a key player in our team. And I’ll continue banging the Riedewald drum whilst he’s here as he can play but also has good defensive awareness.

We do have the solutions to the nonsense we’ve played in the last couple of weeks. Whether or not management is brave enough to switch it up is yet to be seen.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

sheffieldgabor Flag Cardiff 16 Sep 18 11.38am

Originally posted by JusticeToad

I think a large part of the problem is actually the midfield. Without Luka and Cabaye it's getting overrun and leaving our back 4 exposed.

Luka was playing.

 

FinchleyEagle Flag 16 Sep 18 11.40am

It's not unreasonable to say it's a clean sheet so what's the problem. Of course if we play Huddersfield every week AND they are as unlucky as they were yesterday then yes of course that logic is fine. In my opinion there are very few, if any teams in the prem who will score less goals than Huddersfield. The time to fix the hole in the roof is when the sun is shining, not when the rain is pouring through. What can do it though? They're all good players but the organisation seems woeful at times. If you can't successfully mark Huddersfield players in the box, then you sure as s*** can't do against all the better strikers in the prem.

A decent point about maybe Meyer is being eased in - after all he is young - but him and Zaha could be so destructive and really help our forwards get amongst the goals. The balance is is also crucial of course and I wonder if it has to be Luka or Kouyate. Some healthy competition for places would be excellent - I think we do have the players for a strong midfield, in fact I think we have the players to be a top ten team - but the discipline and organisation is vital and appears to be missing at the moment.

 


You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue
Yours sincerely
Mile Jedinak

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 16 Sep 18 12.25pm

I think the OP makes fair point(s). My take on it is:

1. As long as we defend badly against all the sides that can’t score, and well against all the sides that can then we will do OK.

You can also go through 99% of clean sheets and find examples of how it might have been different.

Wasn’t it Tomkins first game back? It is not surprising that there might have been a bit of an issue at the back.

2. It is interesting that most people are focusing on 1 and not the Meyer issue. I don’t know why he isn’t in the team now. Perhaps it is because the incumbents are doing much better because of the depth of the squad.

I have a similar question regarding Guitia. When will Guitia be given a change?

 

Username Flag Horsham 16 Sep 18 1.59pm

Originally posted by dp

I think the OP makes fair point(s). My take on it is:

1. As long as we defend badly against all the sides that can’t score, and well against all the sides that can then we will do OK.

You can also go through 99% of clean sheets and find examples of how it might have been different.

Wasn’t it Tomkins first game back? It is not surprising that there might have been a bit of an issue at the back.

2. It is interesting that most people are focusing on 1 and not the Meyer issue. I don’t know why he isn’t in the team now. Perhaps it is because the incumbents are doing much better because of the depth of the squad.

I have a similar question regarding Guitia. When will Guitia be given a change?

Guita will get a chance when Wayne gives him one, but he's had a very good few months now across the end of last season and the start of this one.

Meyer has looked good but I can completely understand why, after the shambles of a midfield against Southampton, Roy's first priority was to get Kouyate in there and be a bit more solid and have more of a presence. Particularly against a team we KNOW can get very physical.

Can see Meyer coming in more over the next month or so, but even with the international break it would have been asking a lot to change the system and bring in an entirely new midfield for this game.

It's still a work in progress.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 16 Sep 18 2.21pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Thought pva was awful yestetday, but thd other 3 played well, especially tompkins.
What I don't like is thd way we play so narrow. Seems to be s tactic of ours. There wide players had so much space and got some really good crosses in. Don't really understand why we play like that.

Interesting point. I mentioned this after the Scousers with Alexander Arnold popping in crosses at will even with PVA and Schlupp. The replies were it could of been tactical as you suggest. Fair point against them but if it occurred against Huddersfield then that is a problem. As you say I don't understand how we can't get tighter on the wings.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 16 Sep 18 2.30pm

Originally posted by Username

Guita will get a chance when Wayne gives him one, but he's had a very good few months now across the end of last season and the start of this one.

Meyer has looked good but I can completely understand why, after the shambles of a midfield against Southampton, Roy's first priority was to get Kouyate in there and be a bit more solid and have more of a presence. Particularly against a team we KNOW can get very physical.

Can see Meyer coming in more over the next month or so, but even with the international break it would have been asking a lot to change the system and bring in an entirely new midfield for this game.

It's still a work in progress.

Think Roy doesn't wish to drop JMac or Luka from the midfield, leaving only one other, even as you say they were in the shambles against the Saints. When both Meyer and Kouyate came on we looked better. Meyer is definitely needed against the Toon next week from the off based on Torreira's impact yesterday. Expect Kouyate to make way if anybody.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 16 Sep 18 2.34pm

It’s nice to have options.

Hopefully we are already working on a striker for January. I am not sure what else we need.

 

PatrickA Flag London 16 Sep 18 3.21pm

I do think we have a vulnerability to high crosses and this was demonstrated yesterday against Huddersfield even though fortunately they didn’t take their chances.
The good thing is not many Premier teams put high crosses into the box.
With regard to Meyer, at the moment Luka, MacArthur and Kouyate seem be ahead of him for midfield roles.
Personally, and this may prove unpopular, I would play him instead of Townsend who increasingly seems to be playing in midfield anyway.
He works hard but poses no real attacking threat.
Meyer would hopefully assist us in controlling the midfield and enable us to create more opportunities.

 

chateauferret Flag 17 Sep 18 9.35pm

Originally posted by sheffieldgabor

Luka was playing.

Poorly (for him).

 


============
The Ferret
============

Loz83 Flag Crawley 17 Sep 18 11.04pm

Originally posted by JusticeToad

I think a large part of the problem is actually the midfield. Without Luka and Cabaye it's getting overrun and leaving our back 4 exposed.

So so true, our midfield has been bossed in every game to far, I would start Meyer next game 100%.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Sep 18 11.20pm

Originally posted by Loz83

So so true, our midfield has been bossed in every game to far, I would start Meyer next game 100%.

I will be surprised if Meyer comes in for Kouyate for the Newcastle game.

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 18 Sep 18 11.29am


Well at least we have hard and honest realism about the performance in Thuggersfield. But three poihts does mean the sun is shining and confidence will have improved. The Magpies do well at Selhurst but if Palace put Ward in directly against Shelvey and Meyer replaces Ayew with Wilf pulling right back to expose the opposition to runs by Van Man and AWB I can see some goals on the way. Mac will have to make way for Ward.

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > 2 Questions