You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Should / could we be a bit more attacking?
November 16 2026 6.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Should / could we be a bit more attacking?


Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 03 Oct 18 6.21pm

I think Roy should gamble more, especially when Meyer has got fully match fit.

AWB and PVA are probably amomg the top attacking full backs in the division, but not so hot defensively*.

Push them on, play a pressing game (Ayew Wilf, Townsend can all press from the front and I think our midfielders & wing backs can back them up). Luka drops a little further back if teams break against us, Tomkins or Sakho then push wide if our wing backs get caught too far forward.

Quite often I think this would mean their(PVA and AWB's) defending would amount to a foot race, rather than being up against a couple of players trying to break down a banked defence. They're both lightning fast.

I just feel we're capable of being a bit more attack minded whereas, to me, Roy likes to have that defensive shape at all times and maybe even to invite teams on to us.

**Just to be clear, I'm still a huge fan of Roy and what he's done.**

*AWB Is great 1 on 1 but pretty vulnerable when teams try to play around him, as is to be expected for such an inexperienced player

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

.TUX. Flag 03 Oct 18 6.50pm

Yes

 


Buy Litecoin.

PatrickA Flag London 03 Oct 18 7.24pm

Interesting point about AWB.
I noted that Bournemouth didn’t seek to engage him one in one (where he excels) and instead played 1-2s around him and on occasions he looked uncomfortable.
For me it is interesting that the three better performances of the team this season we’re in the first three games where 4-4-2 was employed with Townsend and Schlupp in natural positions for them and Benteke and Zaha up front.
The balance looked better and we defended and attacked as a unit.
I am not necessarily advocating this going forward and it is difficult to accommodate Meyer and Kouyate in this way of playing if Luka and Mcarthur play.
Sometimes the best players don’t feature in the best balanced teams, however, so the coming weeks will be interesting as Roy seeks to mould the team.


 

YT Flag Oxford 03 Oct 18 7.58pm

I want to come away from a game thinking that we gave it a go and the players gave everything. Then if we happen to lose; so be it. At the moment I never think this.

Ergo “yes”.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

ZIGnZAG Flag Stoke 03 Oct 18 8.55pm

Possibly?

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 04 Oct 18 11.04am

I would certainly be happy to see us play the ball forward with more pace rather than our often painfully slow build-ups that entail lots of backwards and sideways passes, by which time the opposition have had ample opportunity to get all 10 outfielders back behind the ball and into position.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 04 Oct 18 11.20am

Originally posted by Pete53

I would certainly be happy to see us play the ball forward with more pace rather than our often painfully slow build-ups that entail lots of backwards and sideways passes,

On Monday after we had conceded the penalty we had four minutes to try and score an equaliser but half of that time was taken up with our defence passing the ball sideways to each other with no effort made to move it up the pitch at all until we had almost run out of time

 

johnno42000 Flag 04 Oct 18 12.48pm

---------------------Hennessey--------------------

Ward------------Tomkins----------Sakho---------Schlupp

AWB----------------Meyer------Luka----------------PVA

Townsend--------------------------------------------Wilf

Plenty of defensive cover on the wings as well as plenty of threat from pace.

Let loose the dogs of war

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 04 Oct 18 3.07pm

You can attack all you want. But if you haven't got a centre forward who's going to put the ball in the net at thecend of it, it won't make much difference.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 04 Oct 18 3.12pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Interesting point about AWB.
I noted that Bournemouth didn’t seek to engage him one in one (where he excels) and instead played 1-2s around him and on occasions he looked uncomfortable.
For me it is interesting that the three better performances of the team this season we’re in the first three games where 4-4-2 was employed with Townsend and Schlupp in natural positions for them and Benteke and Zaha up front.
The balance looked better and we defended and attacked as a unit.
I am not necessarily advocating this going forward and it is difficult to accommodate Meyer and Kouyate in this way of playing if Luka and Mcarthur play.
Sometimes the best players don’t feature in the best balanced teams, however, so the coming weeks will be interesting as Roy seeks to mould the team.


I've been saying for a while that we played better with schlupp in the team. Him, pva and wilf had a great understanding and with schlupp in the team, pva gets forward more. Recently we've been playing macarthur left midfield, which in my opinion unbalances the side .

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 05 Oct 18 5.01pm

Unfortunately Wilf has been a shadow of the player before he did that interview. We need him back to his best. The other obvious deficiency is up front. It does not matter what formation we play if we do not have anyone capable of sticking it in the back of the net. Time to start Sorloth for 3/4 games to see if he can cut the mustard. Ayew looks like Campbell. Benteke looks like an immobile Calvin Andrew and getting worse every time he plays. If Sorloth doesn’t come good revert to Wilf and Androids up front until we can buy someone in January

 

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 06 Oct 18 5.36am

Roy is never going to drop his mid block and start pressing high collectively, forget that. I think we do need to play faster though, all this season our football has been slow ponderous s***e easy to defend and we've lost our edge

 

becky Flag over the moon 06 Oct 18 7.42am

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

Unfortunately Wilf has been a shadow of the player before he did that interview. We need him back to his best. The other obvious deficiency is up front. It does not matter what formation we play if we do not have anyone capable of sticking it in the back of the net. Time to start Sorloth for 3/4 games to see if he can cut the mustard. Ayew looks like Campbell. Benteke looks like an immobile Calvin Andrew and getting worse every time he plays. If Sorloth doesn’t come good revert to Wilf and Androids up front until we can buy someone in January

Now there's a solution! Sign a few androids and get them programmed right and we could rule Europe - they'd be unstoppable!

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

bifffabazz Flag Highworth, Wiltshire 06 Oct 18 7.58am

I am so tired of the debate. Roy and the players seem so out of sorts. He insists on playing from the back and quick passing but lacks the option of mixing it up.
If all our squad was fit and my dreams came true, this radical team would work perfectly:


Guaita

AWB Tomkins Dann Soaré

Luka

Zaha Meyer Schlupp PVA

Wickham

...it won't ever happen though!

Edited by bifffabazz (06 Oct 2018 7.58am)

 


Spirit of 1974

Rainforest Flag London England 06 Oct 18 12.03pm

To be more attack minded we will need more rapid forward passing and balls into the oppo danger areas. Most of the time we like to pass the ball sideways or back thus allowing the oppo to regroup.

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Should / could we be a bit more attacking?