You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Loaning players you cannot buy, a fools errand
November 16 2026 6.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Loaning players you cannot buy, a fools errand


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Osvaldo Flag Epsom 08 Oct 18 2.26pm

No problem, We've got some really difficult teams out of the way and now we've got a few easy ones ahead!
By December 2nd we will have less points as at the same stage last season. I thought we were learning lessons. A recent championship team turns us over on Saturday. If Zaha goes, so do we!
Like a lot of us, I'm very worried that at this stage of the season, we haven't picked up 3 points at home yet. Something wrong here!
We've been talking about a decent striker for two seasons and yet we've got a team of mid-fielders who can't score goals either. Please, where is the direction or lack of it coming from?
And to think we've got till January before we can 'solve' the problem. It will be too late by then I'm afraid.
Palace, Cardiff and Huddersfield for the drop based on start of the season showings. Sorry fellow Eagles fans, but lost points thus far will cost us dearly come May. Just think, we got rid of Murry and Gayle, nor great, but a hundred times better than what we've got. Just not good enough for the Eagles loyal fans who pay good prices to see their team perform.
On the other hand we might turn it around against Chelsea as we did last season.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 08 Oct 18 3.01pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

I said at the time we got TFM and RLC in that getting high quality loan players is a double edged sword.

We are missing Cabaye this year but I think we are missing RLC more. Go back and watch the 5-0 against Leicester and you will see just how important and quality the guy was for us.

Getting loan players in that you cannot buy is the ultimate short term move in football. Now we have not only a Cabaye shaped hole, which is impacting Luka big time, but we have a massive gap where RLC was.

Getting these loan players in looks great at face value but when you start to rely on them, and they become integral to your system, you have to expect a hangover when they disappear.

Loaning players from big clubs is great for the player and the big club, but If we don’t have an option to buy it’s a short term move for us that can then bite us hard.

Watch that Leicester game again.


I would agree to a certain extent; especially if there was NO CHANCE of getting said player afterwards. What I would say though is by targeting players on the fringes of the top 4 squads, they at least will have a better understanding of our club should a chance that they would move come up (as I think is the case with RLC)

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 08 Oct 18 3.04pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

We looked hopeless against Wolves,

...only in the final 3rd.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 08 Oct 18 5.43pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

I definitely get that sentiment but how often do managers, players and ex-players talk about familiarity with teammates being a huge factor.

When you get someone like RLC in you basically have a 10% chance of getting them permanently, if that. Hoping for such a player to be really successful at the club seems totally counter intuitive to me.

Its the ultimate in short term, lack of "joined up" thinking. If the guy does well, especially in the opponents half, then he disappears there is going to be a hangover period.

Just watch that Leicester game, I know its only 1 game, and their heads dropped and they went down to 10, but the way we passed and moved in that game was a million miles from what we saw yesterday.

We havent replaced Cabaye which is criminal (we have some career criminals working in our player recruitment dept) but the lack of power, dynamism, great passing and forward thinking from RLC is really hurting us.

We had so long to replace both players and we failed, based on how things look currently. I would rather just have 1 hole in midfield, rather than a 2nd one which is self inflicted.

Time to have a long term strategy at our club, and that should not include loaning world class players we cannot buy IMHO.

but things move so fast in football nowadays squads never really stay the same, we couldav purchased him for 20m instead of loaning and had to sell him in the summer because his stock had risen...as it happens the majority of the squad has stayed the same.

have you been watching a different max mayer to me this season as i would say he is a cabaye replacement in my eyes, with the potential to be a better player than cabaye was in his pomp.

there is a lot of negativity recently due to our average start, for a while now we have always struggled against the teams who are happy to sit in & go compact, you cite leicester as an example but they arnt one of those teams, we always seem to do better against the teams who dont set up to contain us but set up to play their game.

i completely agree we need a long term strategy, but for that we need a long term manager and a “les reed” like at southampton, we also need a conveyer belt of academy graduates, because this transfer market is utterly f***ed up & .: i still think its ok to take the big boys boy wonders as it helps us & it helps them!

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 08 Oct 18 5.52pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

i dont agree with your stance.

loans usually suit all parties, but nowadays were just doing it on a larger scale, we used to get james vaughan & forsell. now we get players like RLC. max meyer will be filling the cabaye role when he gets his slot full time.

i agree we miss RLC, but i would rather have had him for a season & miss him when he leaves than never having seen him play in red & blue.

the mistake fans made was pinning their hopes on RLC coming back.

Max Meyer isn't a loan, he was sighed free as out of contract, just saying

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 08 Oct 18 6.15pm

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER

Max Meyer isn't a loan, he was sighed free as out of contract, just saying

thanks for letting me know, i assumed he was on loan from “free transfer fc”

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


essetwentyone Flag london 09 Oct 18 4.37am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

I fully support loans with an option to buy.


Man U bought Wilf then loaned him back to us for half a season roughly - not an option to buy deal !

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Loaning players you cannot buy, a fools errand