You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Cant see the wood for the trees, SP on transfers
November 16 2026 6.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Cant see the wood for the trees, SP on transfers


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 16 Oct 18 4.55pm

Underpants on head, pencils up the nose and say wibble


Originally posted by Jacey

Poor deluded Steve also quoted as saying we will be OK in the next five fixtures and will surprise a few people.
It will truly surprise me if we get one point against those top sides.

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

The Dolphin Flag 17 Oct 18 5.15am

Our transfer policy is at best random and worst chaotic and as a Premier League Club of some years (not for much longer I fear) we should be ashamed of ourselves.
I didn't hear the interview but it sounds pretty bad.
I am a Parish fan but he should know not to try and defend the indefensible!

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 17 Oct 18 7.29am

Originally posted by HKOwen

Underpants on head, pencils up the nose and say wibble


 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 17 Oct 18 9.49am

Overall I think our squad is decent enough and capable of staying up - with the exception of our forwards.

And those that we currently have are all good examples of the varied transfer policy that we have.

Spend big ? - We did that with Benteke. Has that been a success ?

Unearth a hitherto unknown ' gem ' - we tried that with Sorloth. Has that been a success ?

Ayew - Premier League experience with a modest goalscoring record. Has that been a success ?

Wickham - on his day he looked the part, but he can't be relied upon given his injury record. So - has that been a success ?


I don't know what the answer is, but this club have struggled to sign forwards that can deliver consistently and also seem unable to develop one from the youth set up as well.

As for SP's thoughts on this subject, I sometimes wonder if he has regular conversations with Ian Holloway....

Anyway, if you look at our ' friends ' from the South Coast, they have spent big on three forwards, none of whom are even close to removing their dependence on Glenn Murray.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

southnorwoodhill Flag 17 Oct 18 1.09pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Couldnt agree more. Listening to the chairman of a Premier League side say we sign players to make the numbers in training, and try to make it sound as if Sorloth is doing really well for us, all sounds a bit deluded.

Seems to be going around lately. RH keeps saying we are putting in good performances, when it seems pretty clear we are totally unable to break down moderately well drilled defenses. If you get a goal at Selhurst, its game over, even if its in the first minute.

Listen carefully to what SP said when asked about our overall strategy on transfers, and its kind of clear; we dont have one.

Lack of "joined up thinking" runs through our club all over the place. Benteke had an abysmal season last year (not a few games, an entire season), Wickham is questionable to get back to his former levels, and Sako walked. So we sign Alex Sorloth, who couldnt cut it in the Eredivisie in Holland, and Ayew who has had about 1 shot on goal in 5 games.

Our second biggest goal threat after Zaha is our left back. And some folks wonder why we cant score any goals at home.

January will be a big window for us to solve our striker issues, unless Wickham can miraculously come good. Solving issues in transfer windows is not Steve's forte however. Seem to remember Freddie Ladapo being the only fit striker at the club not so long ago.

Top post, and it's not like it is an overnight thing - this has been going on for seasons now!

 

A89M Flag Streatham 17 Oct 18 2.04pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Overall I think our squad is decent enough and capable of staying up - with the exception of our forwards.

And those that we currently have are all good examples of the varied transfer policy that we have.

Spend big ? - We did that with Benteke. Has that been a success ?

Unearth a hitherto unknown ' gem ' - we tried that with Sorloth. Has that been a success ?

Ayew - Premier League experience with a modest goalscoring record. Has that been a success ?

Wickham - on his day he looked the part, but he can't be relied upon given his injury record. So - has that been a success ?


I don't know what the answer is, but this club have struggled to sign forwards that can deliver consistently and also seem unable to develop one from the youth set up as well.

As for SP's thoughts on this subject, I sometimes wonder if he has regular conversations with Ian Holloway....

Anyway, if you look at our ' friends ' from the South Coast, they have spent big on three forwards, none of whom are even close to removing their dependence on Glenn Murray.

It just proves how difficult it is to find a proven goalscorer in a difficult league. Spending loads of money isn't guaranteed e.g Benteke.

This constant moaning about SP since we've been in the Premier League has to be exhausting surely?! Every window apart from last years, i'm sure we have been pleased with our transfers and this years no exception.

Ayew was a shrewd transfer on loan with a view to permanent in Jan. Scored goals in the Prem in the past and a backup/replacement for Benteke.
Kouyate - another proven Prem player.
Meyer - Signing of the summer for a team like Palace. Just needs more game time and could be creative spark we need.
Guiata - Replacement for Hennessey, another good signing.

How can there be complaints, where else could we have improved?..

Edited by A89M (17 Oct 2018 2.04pm)

 

crvenaeagle Flag 17 Oct 18 2.15pm

Since the era of Tony Pulis the only effective additions to the club were Yohan Cabaye and the one January window under Sam. Prior to Pulis we had Ian Holloway in charge and we all remember his window (at least he admitted it was a f*** up though.) Before that our last effective dealings were under Dougie Freedman. Golly gosh.

I'll be corrected one a couple of things I'm sure, but who doesn't enjoy a good whinge?

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 17 Oct 18 2.17pm

Originally posted by A89M

Ayew was a shrewd transfer on loan with a view to permanent in Jan.

Shrewd or stroke of luck?

Ayew was supposed to be a purchase funded by the sale of Jaïro Riedewald whom we allegedly paid £8m for

The purchase of Ayew broke down as Riedewald refused to sign for Swansea so we just loaned Ayew as we couldn't afford to buy him outright

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 17 Oct 18 2.44pm

Originally posted by A89M

It just proves how difficult it is to find a proven goalscorer in a difficult league. Spending loads of money isn't guaranteed e.g Benteke.

This constant moaning about SP since we've been in the Premier League has to be exhausting surely?! Every window apart from last years, i'm sure we have been pleased with our transfers and this years no exception.

Ayew was a shrewd transfer on loan with a view to permanent in Jan. Scored goals in the Prem in the past and a backup/replacement for Benteke.
Kouyate - another proven Prem player.
Meyer - Signing of the summer for a team like Palace. Just needs more game time and could be creative spark we need.
Guiata - Replacement for Hennessey, another good signing.

How can there be complaints, where else could we have improved?..

Edited by A89M (17 Oct 2018 2.04pm)


Kouyate has not played enough to show anything.
The only reason why we signed the others is that they were cheap options.
That is fine if you get what you need but we haven't done that.
We have no viable alternative for Zaha and we have no quality striker. It did not take a genius to see where that would go.
It all just smacks of the usual wing it mentality.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 17 Oct 18 2.56pm

Originally posted by A89M

It just proves how difficult it is to find a proven goalscorer in a difficult league. Spending loads of money isn't guaranteed e.g Benteke.

This constant moaning about SP since we've been in the Premier League has to be exhausting surely?! Every window apart from last years, i'm sure we have been pleased with our transfers and this years no exception.

Ayew was a shrewd transfer on loan with a view to permanent in Jan. Scored goals in the Prem in the past and a backup/replacement for Benteke.
Kouyate - another proven Prem player.
Meyer - Signing of the summer for a team like Palace. Just needs more game time and could be creative spark we need.
Guiata - Replacement for Hennessey, another good signing.

How can there be complaints, where else could we have improved?..

Edited by A89M (17 Oct 2018 2.04pm)

As I said, the answer to your question is up front.

Scoring goals and not conceding goals is important in this game.

Ayew did indeed score goals in the past, operating in completely different systems. Did you notice how Ayew hasnt even really had a decent effort on goal in multiple games in the league? Shrewd? He is not really a Benteke replacement, he is a totally different player?

You forgot to list Alex Sorloth, who wasn't good enough in the Dutch top flight. He is the supposed Benteke replacement, but lo and behold when Benteke goes down, we play Ayew. Shows you what the manager thinks about Sorloth.

Meanwhile we let Glenn Murray just walk away. Slightly galling isnt it?

Even Bakary Sako would be started now, but he walked also.

Our options up front are poor. Hence the lack of goals. Now I read Zaha is injured, we may aswell play PVA up front. The fact that this is a serious suggestion tells you exactly how we could have improved - signing a proper centre forward who can operate in our system. Maybe Parish is banking on Wickham. Given the last 2 years that is a pretty risky gamble.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Oct 18 3.06pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger


Kouyate has not played enough to show anything.
The only reason why we signed the others is that they were cheap options.
That is fine if you get what you need but we haven't done that.
We have no viable alternative for Zaha and we have no quality striker. It did not take a genius to see where that would go.
It all just smacks of the usual wing it mentality.

We were certainly frugal in the summer window with a spend of some £10 Mill but one suspects this was out of necessity on account of past excesses which of course includes wages.

In terms of our results thus far this season, I happen to believe that we are well below-par in terms of points gained against the teams we have played and the early season optimism following the win at newly-prooted and high-spending Fulham seems to have dissipated.In actual fact when one considers Fulham's results this season, our win on the opening day doesn't really seem that brilliant !

 

A89M Flag Streatham 17 Oct 18 5.24pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

As I said, the answer to your question is up front.

Scoring goals and not conceding goals is important in this game.

Ayew did indeed score goals in the past, operating in completely different systems. Did you notice how Ayew hasnt even really had a decent effort on goal in multiple games in the league? Shrewd? He is not really a Benteke replacement, he is a totally different player?

You forgot to list Alex Sorloth, who wasn't good enough in the Dutch top flight. He is the supposed Benteke replacement, but lo and behold when Benteke goes down, we play Ayew. Shows you what the manager thinks about Sorloth.

Meanwhile we let Glenn Murray just walk away. Slightly galling isnt it?

Even Bakary Sako would be started now, but he walked also.

Our options up front are poor. Hence the lack of goals. Now I read Zaha is injured, we may aswell play PVA up front. The fact that this is a serious suggestion tells you exactly how we could have improved - signing a proper centre forward who can operate in our system. Maybe Parish is banking on Wickham. Given the last 2 years that is a pretty risky gamble.

Of course it's important it's also the most difficult, how many clubs below the top 6 have a prolific goalscorer? They may have better than us but that's not really saying a lot.
My point is unless you're buying Premier League proven goalscorers who cost fortunes, it's a gamble on whoever you buy from outside the league. Ayew was a worthwhile gamble because he's at least scored and played in the Prem for a couple of years. In terms of replacement, we proved last season we could play good football without Benteke with smaller attackers up top so as I said back up/replacement. At the time it was a good signing.

Sorloth was apart of last years window which I agreed in my last post was not a great season for transfers apart from Sakho, who again at the time, was a great signing considering what he did for us under Allardyce.

Our Goalkeeper has his confidence back seemingly because of the push Guaita has given him. Our back line is fairly solid, midfield as well (defensively). All we're lacking in is creativity and hopefully Meyer is that player once he gets regular game time - this is not SP's fault.
All is not quite as bad as it seems.

Edited by A89M (17 Oct 2018 5.25pm)

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 17 Oct 18 5.39pm

Originally posted by crvenaeagle

Since the era of Tony Pulis the only effective additions to the club were Yohan Cabaye and the one January window under Sam. Prior to Pulis we had Ian Holloway in charge and we all remember his window (at least he admitted it was a f*** up though.) Before that our last effective dealings were under Dougie Freedman. Golly gosh.

I'll be corrected one a couple of things I'm sure, but who doesn't enjoy a good whinge?

PVA, Schlupp and Luka joined not shy of £35 million and the Beast came on loan. If we can get RLC back on loan then we need to spend at least £25-30 million on a striker.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Wilbraham413 Flag 18 Oct 18 1.47am

Forget about the signings, just look at the players that are gone from last year's team: Cabaye, RLC, Sako.

Cabaye and RLC would be starting every game this year, and Sako would be starting most.

People were talking like Cabaye was crap and easily replaceable, but he has been our biggest loss in my opinion.

When Sako was healthy, which wasn't often, he was always a threat to score. We let him go in favor of Ayew? Sorloth?

When we have average Premier league quality players, we think they aren't good enough, then we let them walk and replace them with new players who are championship caliber at best.

I don't get it. Without Zaha, we are Cardiff.

 


2017 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Middlesboro
2018 Jan. (Sako) Palace 1 - 0 Burnley
2019 May (Batshuayi, Batshuayi, OG, Van Aanholt, Townsend) Palace 5 - 3 Bournemouth
2020 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Newcastle

Joe Bloggs Flag Nr Norwich 18 Oct 18 9.12am

As a former senior buyer not related to football I have spent a lot more money that Steve Parish but conventional
skills are not transferable when assessing football teams. I have always suspected that he has surrounded himself with some individuals, some now departed not up to the required level.

To my mind we get into this situation time and time again which indicates that he fails to learn from his mistakes.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 18 Oct 18 9.24am

Originally posted by Wilbraham413

Forget about the signings, just look at the players that are gone from last year's team: Cabaye, RLC, Sako.

Cabaye and RLC would be starting every game this year, and Sako would be starting most.

People were talking like Cabaye was crap and easily replaceable, but he has been our biggest loss in my opinion.

When Sako was healthy, which wasn't often, he was always a threat to score. We let him go in favor of Ayew? Sorloth?

When we have average Premier league quality players, we think they aren't good enough, then we let them walk and replace them with new players who are championship caliber at best.

I don't get it. Without Zaha, we are Cardiff.

I fully appreciate Cabaye's contribution for us but towards the end he was really in the twilight of his career and wasn't lasting the 90 mins and when one takes into consideration all the factors, including his wages, one can understand his departure.

Apropos Sako, he was available on a 'Free' in pre-season but I don't recall any great clamour for his services.After a trial he has recently signed for WBA but I don't think he has actually played for them.

With regard to Ayew, he hasn't been a prolific scorer in the PL but he did score 11 goals for Swansea last season, a team that got relegated, so one can understand why he was signed on a Loan deal.He is a totally different player to Benteke so we cannot play the same way with him up top.

RLC's departure was out of our control but should he be available on loan in January I suspect we might well make moves to try and lure him back.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 18 Oct 18 10.21am

Originally posted by Booted Eagle

PVA, Schlupp and Luka joined not shy of £35 million and the Beast came on loan. If we can get RLC back on loan then we need to spend at least £25-30 million on a striker.

I believe the initial fees for PVA,Schlupp and Luka are approaching £30 Mill.If all the add-ons kick in then this figure goes up to just short of £39 Mill.Add on the fee paid to Sakho and this figure rises to £65 Mill.

 

aashman12 Flag 25 Oct 18 7.45am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Did anyone else listen to Parish on FYP speak about the transfer policy and recent signings?

Someone rolled out a stat about the 7 most recent signings basically not playing for the club regularly yet. Jach, Rakip, Sorloth, Meyer, Guaita, Kouyate, Ayew.

First thing he said was we sometimes sign players to make sure we have an 11 on 11 in training.........

I was wondering if I heard that correctly, but he actually said that.

He initially stated he was absolutely thrilled with recent transfer business, that we couldnt have done any better. Old Steve then backed off a bit and said that some mistakes were made.

Most comedic moment was when he was listed all the positives behind each player, and said about Sorloth after a short pause "he had a good game at West Brom". Says it all really. Sorloth should have gone out on loan immediately, he is absolutely nowhere near Premier League level.

How anyone can look at our attacking options and think we did well on that front in recent transfer windows is beyond my comprehension. Kouyate and Meyer were good signings, make no bones about it, but in terms of forwards we are seriously lacking, again.

Never thought I would say this but I think we really could use Bakary Sako right now, he would definitely be starting.

When oh when will we properly manage our squad and ensure the manager has quality and diverse options in all areas of the pitch?

Sako, the perma injured player???

 

cardiff eagle Flag 26 Oct 18 7.45am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The reason why we’re doing badly is simple ' by Midlands Eagle

Surely this reason isn’t to do with making subs earlier (although that is f***ing annoying) or the system we play but the fact we have replaced first team starters with squad players.

Line up from last home game of last season and indeed majority of our matches that saw us unbeaten in last six:

Hennessy
Wan bissaka
Sakho
Tomkins
PVA
Mccarthur
Luka
RLC
Cabaye
Zaha
Townsend

Since then our lineup has remained largely the same but swapped RLC for schlupp and cabaye for kouyate. Both of these are clear downgrades.

I also feel we never truly recovered from losing bolasie. That season before we lost him we were desperate for another winger to come in and challenge zaha and bolasie and help cover when injured. When we got Townsend I was delighted. Then we sold bolasie and the whole saga continued but with a downgraded player.

If we wish to sustain, let alone progress we need to replace players with equals and then add squad players in behind to challenge them and keep them on their toes. For me this is where we’ve failed monumentally as a club and fear we may pay the price.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 26 Oct 18 1.44pm

Originally posted by cardiff eagle

This post has been merged from a topic called 'The reason why we’re doing badly is simple ' by Midlands Eagle

Surely this reason isn’t to do with making subs earlier (although that is f***ing annoying) or the system we play but the fact we have replaced first team starters with squad players.

Line up from last home game of last season and indeed majority of our matches that saw us unbeaten in last six:

Hennessy
Wan bissaka
Sakho
Tomkins
PVA
Mccarthur
Luka
RLC
Cabaye
Zaha
Townsend

Since then our lineup has remained largely the same but swapped RLC for schlupp and cabaye for kouyate. Both of these are clear downgrades.

I also feel we never truly recovered from losing bolasie. That season before we lost him we were desperate for another winger to come in and challenge zaha and bolasie and help cover when injured. When we got Townsend I was delighted. Then we sold bolasie and the whole saga continued but with a downgraded player.

If we wish to sustain, let alone progress we need to replace players with equals and then add squad players in behind to challenge them and keep them on their toes. For me this is where we’ve failed monumentally as a club and fear we may pay the price.

I think the idea was for Meyer to replace Cabaye. For whatever reason that is not working out too well for us at the minute.

As for RLC it’s a huge loss, and it once again raises the point of the concept of loaning high quality players which you probably cannot sign permanently. When they walk away, you are left with a problem if they became integral.

At least in Ayew we have gone back to loaning players who look awful - normal service resumed,

With a fit and happy Bolasie in the side our fortunes would be different. Defenders hated playing against Bolasie. I can understand cashing in on him but Townsend is not a like for like replacement for what Yannick was actually doing for us towards the end of his Palace career.

At the end of the day we didn’t get someone in like RLC - no easy feat, but the bigger issue is not signing a proper striker.

How you could sit and watch us last year and think that going into this season with Benteke, Sorloth and Ayew on loan was good enough, is hard to understand.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Cant see the wood for the trees, SP on transfers