You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > oh dear
November 21 2026 10.42pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

oh dear


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 26 Oct 18 8.16am

Originally posted by DanH

This news has put a right spring in my step.

That Philip’s tempted to stray (for turning), or that his missus may be on the market?

 


COYP

beagle Flag pom tiddly om pom pom 26 Oct 18 8.23am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

He has made a mockery of the appeal court

Agreed. But I think he's made a mockery of the NDA law, not the Court.

And in this case, not a bad thing.

The Appeal court applies the law as it stands.

If this was a case of a NDA being signed to protect, for example, the copyright infringement of the next fashion line then I'd say Hain was 'bang out of order'. But its not. These NDAs protect him from serious, serious allegations.

I maintain that an NDA should not be used to protect those accused of doing something that is currently illegal (like racial abuse for example). What else should an NDA protect a person from? Fraud? Embezzlement? Murder? (ok, Im overdoing it here )

As I say , the appeal court are correct in their application of the law. But I think Hain (as a representative of the body that makes those laws) is, in this case, right to shine a light on the law the Court was applying.

 


When the time comes, I want die just like my Dad - at peace and asleep.
Not screaming and terrified.
Like his passengers.

Mapletree Flag Croydon 26 Oct 18 9.45am

Originally posted by beagle

Agreed. But I think he's made a mockery of the NDA law, not the Court.

And in this case, not a bad thing.

The Appeal court applies the law as it stands.

If this was a case of a NDA being signed to protect, for example, the copyright infringement of the next fashion line then I'd say Hain was 'bang out of order'. But its not. These NDAs protect him from serious, serious allegations.

I maintain that an NDA should not be used to protect those accused of doing something that is currently illegal (like racial abuse for example). What else should an NDA protect a person from? Fraud? Embezzlement? Murder? (ok, Im overdoing it here )

As I say , the appeal court are correct in their application of the law. But I think Hain (as a representative of the body that makes those laws) is, in this case, right to shine a light on the law the Court was applying.

An NDA is not binding where it relates to criminal activity.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 26 Oct 18 10.18am

Originally posted by beagle

NDAs were originally designed to protect companies and their 'trade secrets'. However, that morphed into them being used by the fantastically rich to keep the less well off quiet.

The fact someone may sign an NDA and take a payment, to my mind, holds little significance if the NDA is being used to to cover up an act that is illegal under law. Like, for example, sexual assault.

If someone was being repeated bullied by him in the workplace their seems little recourse for action apart from the HR Dept. Anything legal (if you can afford it) puts them up against, in this case, Greens top notch lawyers. What evidence could you get to support it? So options-wise taking a payment in exchange for an NDA is maybe the only real option.

The fact they signed them doesn't make them complicit in whatever Green is being accused of.

So good for Peter Hain.

A Labour MP has called Hain a hero, I would call him a coward for hiding behind immunity. If he really wanted to make a stand he should have stepped outside Parliament. This smacks of party politics.

I agree with your assessment on what NDA's should be used for however it is for Parliament to make law and the PM has previously indicated that this will be looked at.

The court was at pains to point out that the victims had taken independent legal advice before accepting large sums and that this will impact on their creditability.

The real issue here is that the press feel empowered to name and same any public figure who has allegations thrown against them and don't like it when they can't. As with Cliff Richard and other celebrities falsely accused their names should be private until they are charged by the police.

 


One more point

cryrst Flag The garden of England 26 Oct 18 10.42am

So the payed off 'victims' will now be asked for the money back and have to go through the courts i guess.
Im sure that there are people who didnt want it in the public eye whatever it was.if it was!
Also their mortgage provider as an example might not give the money back so where would they stand now.
Irony would be that green purely could do without the headache of court hearings and if innocent it puts the victims in the spot light.
What if it was just a #metoo exercise.
I feel that hains motiffs were political due to the present climate of wanting to share out wealth.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 26 Oct 18 11.02am

Originally posted by cryrst

So the payed off 'victims' will now be asked for the money back and have to go through the courts i guess.
Im sure that there are people who didnt want it in the public eye whatever it was.if it was!
Also their mortgage provider as an example might not give the money back so where would they stand now.
Irony would be that green purely could do without the headache of court hearings and if innocent it puts the victims in the spot light.
What if it was just a #metoo exercise.
I feel that hains motiffs were political due to the present climate of wanting to share out wealth.

But he's rich and a Tory so most be guilty the evidence is just one of those awkward formalities.

On a serious note Charlie Sheen was forced to go public because he was being blackmailed about his HIV status. There are some despicable people out that and not all of them are rich white billionaires.

If you are a public figure some people see you as a pinata so do you face your life being trashed by the tabloids like Sir Cliff or do you try and pay hush money like Sheen.

As I said in an earlier post these are complicated scenarios and if the law needs to change then Parliament needs to do with after prober consideration not 1 unelected Lord taking the law into his own hands.

 


One more point

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 27 Oct 18 9.58am

So the "hero" Peter Hain has financial links to the law firm which is representing the Telegraph.

You can read this 2 ways:

1. That Hain is furthering his financial interests under the guise of natural justice in which case he joins a long list of many other politicians.

2. He genuinely did not realise the links which goes to my argument that he shouldn't have spoken out because he doesn't know the full facts and the judges do. All Hain has now done is muddy the waters and generate some sympathy for Green (not much I give you).

Interestedly a number of politicians including some Labour have condemned him (Hain). The most telling comment being that the judges have upheld a temporary ban which means that the legal process is still continuing and the Telegraph may yet win their case. So why didn't Hain wait until this process had exhausted itself.

 


One more point

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > oh dear