This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by becky
Lip readers are actually at odds as to whether the culprit called Sterling 'a Manc c...' or a black one, which is not surprising as even skilled lip readers can misunderstand. However....... When you see the photos of Block B when the opposition are taking a corner there, just how different do they look from that Chelsea photo? I know they are not shouting racist abuse at SP, but there's not that much difference in their facial expressions and gesticulations either. This is nothing to do with your dislike of the HF is it, Becky?
|
|
|
John Barnes spoke about this extremely articulately on BBC Breakfast this morning.
|
|
|
Originally posted by becky
I made the comment about Block B as a lot of the press reports and comments are also talking about the fact that there was a row of middle aged men hurling all sorts of abuse (including the racial one)at Sterling in particular and players in general, and that this has been the case in football for a long time. Now no way do I condone racial abuse, it has absolutely no place in football (or anywhere else for that matter), but there seems also to be a condemnation in these articles of ANY sort of abuse towards players, which is what set me off thinking about SP. I don't know exactly what the HF shout at the opposition when they come to take a corner, but Palace Talk has threads where there is much emphasis put on our 'atmosphere' and SP being 'an intimidating place to come to' and a few references to players taking corners being given a hard time, and watching on a stream as I do every match, you get some great shots of Block B, and you know what - yup, there may not be racial abuse going on, but some of the facial expressions and arm gesticulations look very much the same as those seen in the video of the Sterling incident. The question I'm asking (myself and anyone else) is where does passion and making an intimidating atmosphere for the opposition players stop and player abuse begin? The bench mark should be the same level of abuse the players dish out to the refs.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
This is nothing to do with your dislike of the HF is it, Becky? I don't dislike the HF and I've never said that I do. I think their importance is overrated and I don't like what is being done to the E400, but the HF are fine. If you read my later post, I have clarified (I hope) why I drew the parallels between the Chelsea crowd and the people at the front of Block B based solely on videos. Finally, no, calling a c a c is fine if he's behaving like one. I remember leaping out of my seat once and telling Barber (at the top of my voice) that he was a tart and that a big girl's blouse could have done better with the chance he had. That doesn't make me sexist either
A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers |
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
I think Sterling upset people by appearing to have more ability than he has ever fully delivered. Made people wonder if he was a bit up himself and not prepared to put in the right kind of work. That seems to be changing, he has impressed more recently. But then I think some people impute reasons for his perceived lack of delivery and link it to their own prejudices. I do agree that the media has pandered to that, he was an itch they always liked to scratch. Not helped by the immense stupidity of getting 'that' tattoo. It was a brave thing indeed for him to go into the media so directly, well done him. But IMO the way e.g. Clarke Carlisle used this on the TV and had a pop at Piers Morgan this morning is either representative of a very angry man or is self-serving. There is no point trying to drive a wedge between people, we need to take everyone on the journey not find ways to talk down to them, make them feel guilty and alienate them. Mind you, you just have to look at Piers Morgan to feel like punching him. You see, that’s almost the root of the problem. If you dig around or listen to those that know Sterling, much of his reputation was manufactured by the press. Some stuff was just lies & other stories were more about the way they’re told - if you heard what Gary Neville said on MNF this evening it might give some perspective, Giving haters reasons to hate (even if false) will magnify the problem. Chuck in race, religion etc & you might as well be “lighting the blue touch paper and retiring a safe distance.” PS: Piers Morgan’s subsequent ‘joke’ tweet confirms he is part of the problem & a far bigger c#*¥ than Sterling could ever be.
Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five! |
|
|
Originally posted by Pussay Patrol
Well its something that's become more and more prevalent on this forum, people defending racism or at the very least sitting on the fence rather than total condemnation, what's the angle trying to defend the indefensible? That we should somehow turn a blind eye? Or maybe because they are paid so much there must be some balance? I'd love to know
"Deviance is a freedom enjoyed in a city of lightly engaged strangers" |
|
|
Originally posted by soulboy
I don't agree with the lefty commentators on this.....but what's the point? It's just not that interesting. Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Dec 2018 10.48am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by becky
I don't dislike the HF and I've never said that I do. I think their importance is overrated and I don't like what is being done to the E400, but the HF are fine. If you read my later post, I have clarified (I hope) why I drew the parallels between the Chelsea crowd and the people at the front of Block B based solely on videos. Finally, no, calling a c a c is fine if he's behaving like one. I remember leaping out of my seat once and telling Barber (at the top of my voice) that he was a tart and that a big girl's blouse could have done better with the chance he had. That doesn't make me sexist either Haha believe me I called him much worse. Sorry if any of my comments offended you, this was not the intention
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I don't agree with the lefty commentators on this.....but what's the point? It's just not that interesting. Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Dec 2018 10.48am) The fact that you don't want to comment on this when you do on every other bloody thread says a lot more than your actual posts.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
This story highlights what is wrong with modern Britain and it isn't racism. The likes of SSN and other anti racism groups making a big fuss over it and playing the race card when we haven't even established that any racism occurred yet. Sterling has had more than his fair share of abuse in the press, none of it racial, but so have many many others. The press latches on to public perceptions and writes stories to sell papers. It's that simple. No people, 300k people arriving here every year with their terrorism, rape gangs, street crime, sex trafficking, lack of housing, stagnating wages and religious dogma. That is what stirs up tensions. Are you black?
|
|
| Pussay Patrol |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by chris123
Are you black? This contributor is either a racist, a troll or both He does not seem to have any particular standpoint, political persuasion or footballing allegiance, only ever to spout controversial views against other races and jumps on any thread to defend racism. Here trying to argue about papers sensationalising stories, yet when I put the same theory to him the response was: Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Haha, Does it even exist? What manipulation are you referring to? Can you provide specific examples? That's trolling in my book, and seems to get his kicks from pushing the boundaries of racism rather than contributing to forum valuably
Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah |
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
The fact that you don't want to comment on this when you do on every other bloody thread says a lot more than your actual posts. ? What does it say? I've been on this forum for many years and made my opinion on this type of topic clear quite a few times.....I imagine a wally like you can only dream up malicious motivations.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by eagleman13
Just my 'tanners' worth(as long as he who must be obeyed, allows me)
But that's just the point, he hasn't just 'come out very quickly and claimed racism'. He's been subject to treatment like this for years, fueled without question by the perception of him that has been built up in the media. If you haven't done so already I thoroughly recommend watching Gary Neville and Jamie Carragher discuss this in detail on MNF last night, or John Barnes on BBC breakfast yesterday. This has been going on for years; and not just with Raheem. I'm just surprised it's taken this long for him or someone else in his position to speak out. Anyone who doesn't think this is underpinned in racism is being willfully blind to it. It still exists is all walks of society, whether it's casual, covert, or just plainly overt.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Ok I'm going to comment on this because the cringey virtue signalling is something else. Left wing individuals and those playing grievance identity politics have been over playing the race card for decades. Do some arseholes shout and scream nasty words at football matches?.....Yep.....I find it irritating myself....the ones who are always doing it are man babies. Are they racist.....I don't know....why is that important? People say and do nasty stuff all the time. In football these are people looking to put off the opposition. They will often shout anything they can think of to achieve that. It's part of the tribal aspect of football. Millionaires like Raheem Sterling have their pay packets filled by football people. A small proportion of those people shout nasty stuff at other footballers. Is it nice?....nope.....Is it anything more than that?....Not in my opinion and I've yet to hear a convincing argument otherwise. Sterling lives very nicely and is massively overpaid yet these others probably struggle and yet he's the victim.....where does the power really reside here.
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Ok I'm going to comment on this because the cringey virtue signalling is something else. Left wing individuals and those playing grievance identity politics have been over playing the race card for decades. Do some arseholes shout and scream nasty words at football matches?.....Yep.....I find it irritating myself....the ones who are always doing it are man babies. Are they racist.....I don't know....why is that important? People say and do nasty stuff all the time. In football these are people looking to put off the opposition. They will often shout anything they can think of to achieve that. It's part of the tribal aspect of football. Millionaires like Raheem Sterling have their pay packets filled by football people. A small proportion of those people shout nasty stuff at other footballers. Is it nice?....nope.....Is it anything more than that?....Not in my opinion and I've yet to hear a convincing argument otherwise. Sterling lives very nicely and is massively overpaid yet these others probably struggle and yet he's the victim.....where does the power really reside here.
If you spend your whole life on the back foot, feeling like you are going to get picked on all the time, it has an effect When I worked at Ariston Alloys in Beddington or Coca Cola bottling in Coulsdon, I had it the other way around. I had to align myself with the older black guys to give myself protection. On the other hand I note that Manchester City lost. Funny how such issues arise on bad news days, which just happens to shift the attention.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.