You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Should we sell PVA?
November 16 2026 6.31am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Should we sell PVA?


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
tonymikejoe Flag UK 21 Dec 18 8.49am

Originally posted by Casual

Can’t see Roma paying 25 mil for the unpredictable fullback pva when they only got 9 mil more for Salah.
If it was a legit bid a sneaky phone call regarding Clyne, who’s twice the player in my opinion, would be in order.

C'mon pal you don't know your right-backs from your left-backs and are contributing no quality to this debate.

Maybe you think Martin Kelly should fill-in there.

How utterly naive is the OP? They claim we could get a "decent" left-back for under £10m.

Schlupp cost £15m! and that was when the market was half the price.

When you sell your first-team starters you kill the team.

A big: 'No' from me.

 

steven_t92 Flag Orpington 21 Dec 18 8.53am

Can't believe some of the responses on here, we will not replace PVA even with 25mil. He is wanted by Juventus and Roma for a reason. Schlupp isn't half the player and Souare is done. Get a grip people, if we start cashing in on players in January we are going down. You cannot afford to try starting a buy and sell business when you are trying to stay up.

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 21 Dec 18 9.30am

For £25m yes. But only is we invest that money in a couple of attacking players.

He's certainly one of our better players but LB is one of our stronger positions. Schlupp could drop in with Souare as cover.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 21 Dec 18 9.35am

What a daft question. Why would you sell anyone good when you are bottom of the league. Attracting quality players is tough for a club like Palace. If you have one, keep them.
It's not rocket science.

 

LeeG Flag London 21 Dec 18 9.57am

Big fan of PvA, both as a player and a person. But for £25m we'd be mad not to sell. Schlupp is not as good a left back but would be adequate, leaving us a good chunk of money to invest elsewhere in the squad.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 21 Dec 18 10.18am

25 million is crazy, we'd have to accept...

However, I think our transfer policy should be to keep every decent player we have, because our recruitment is so crap that we've got to keep hold of the good acquisitions, and we can't rely on our ability to replace anyone that we sell.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 21 Dec 18 10.20am

Originally posted by LeeG

Big fan of PvA, both as a player and a person. But for £25m we'd be mad not to sell. Schlupp is not as good a left back but would be adequate, leaving us a good chunk of money to invest elsewhere in the squad.

So you get 25 million and everyone knows you have got it.
You are scraping around looking for available players in January and everyone will be looking for big money for average players.

No thanks. Our squad is thin enough already. We need to build the squad, not sell our best players for any amount.

 

DeanMiles Flag Telford 21 Dec 18 10.38am

He isn't worth £25 mill. Probably just crap but if true it would be hard to turn down.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 21 Dec 18 10.53am

Originally posted by DeanMiles

He isn't worth £25 mill. Probably just crap but if true it would be hard to turn down.

Uncle Ron's policy was to sell one key player a season normally in the summer. We should not be selling any first team players until then. It will be hard to hold onto PVA, AWB or Zaha. I would be OK with one of them going no more than that and only for a good price.

 


One more point

taylors lovechild Flag 21 Dec 18 11.01am

If we need to sell in order to buy, then arguably it is a position we have more cover for with Schlupp, Souare and Ward (and even Riedewald?) capable of filling in. If it meant we could buy Moses and have another £12m to put towards another attacking player I think that would be good business.


I don't want PvA to be sold btw, but if a choice has to be made we don't have many players we would get a significant fee for, especially not in positions we have good cover for.

 

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 21 Dec 18 11.11am

It it really was £25 million and we need the money to pay for a new striker and keep within FFP I'd say yes.

PVA was brilliant last season but hasn't been as good this and really isn't worth that amount.

I'd be happier if he didn't get sold and returned to his last season best.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

chris123 Flag hove actually 21 Dec 18 11.14am

It's a sticky one.

 

thechaddyboy Flag Peterborough 21 Dec 18 11.24am

PVA's quality most of the time & I'd rather he stayed but, if someone's putting 25 million on the table we'd be mad to refuse, that said it's silly season & can't see it happening

 


Red & Blue since 73'

TheBigToePunt Flag 21 Dec 18 11.51am

If it's just for the money alone then no way should we sell him. If, on the other hand, we have a deal in place for a goalscorer and need the money to proceed then I'll drive PVA to the airport myself.

I've grown to like him due to his energy and enthusiasm, but fundamentally he remains very average at his principal job, which is defending. We have Schlupp, Riedewald and Souare to replace him with.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 21 Dec 18 12.43pm

Originally posted by tonymikejoe

C'mon pal you don't know your right-backs from your left-backs and are contributing no quality to this debate.

Maybe you think Martin Kelly should fill-in there.

How utterly naive is the OP? They claim we could get a "decent" left-back for under £10m.

Schlupp cost £15m! and that was when the market was half the price.

When you sell your first-team starters you kill the team.

A big: 'No' from me.

F*ck me mate you’ve told me haven’t you!
Don’t mind PVA but he’s not consistent, I never know who’s going to turn up each week, the pva that right fancies it and is busting a gut to attack, or the other one that couldn’t trap a bag of cement. Decent enough player for our level though.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 21 Dec 18 12.45pm

Originally posted by chris123

It's a sticky one.

Most fans have correctly bonded with him, some haven't a glue what he does.

 

tonymikejoe Flag UK 21 Dec 18 3.35pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

If it's just for the money alone then no way should we sell him. If, on the other hand, we have a deal in place for a goalscorer and need the money to proceed then I'll drive PVA to the airport myself.

I've grown to like him due to his energy and enthusiasm, but fundamentally he remains very average at his principal job, which is defending. We have Schlupp, Riedewald and Souare to replace him with.


Thanks TheBigToePunt for putting so succinctly in just three words why it would be madness to sell.

Good job. It negates the need to look elsewhere on this thread.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 21 Dec 18 5.00pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Most fans have correctly bonded with him, some haven't a glue what he does.

Suspect the person who started this rumour is more likely glueless.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 21 Dec 18 5.36pm

Originally posted by tonymikejoe


Thanks TheBigToePunt for putting so succinctly in just three words why it would be madness to sell.

Good job. It negates the need to look elsewhere on this thread.

Are you sure you have thought this through?

If you look at what PVA brings to the side, his greatest attribute is intercepting the ball and instigating quick attacks. His downside and I think it is s big downside is that he gets caught out of position way too often and often leaves his man totally unmarked. If you were to weigh up his contribution to the team in terms of goals created and scored, to goals scored by the opposition attacking down his flank I think you will find his stats are not that great. If you consider our alternatives without a January purchase then you have the 3 you were so quick to criticise and dismiss.

Souare is a very similar player to PVA or was before his accident, he is quick, likes to get forward but at his best I would say he was probably better than PVA defensively, but worse going forward. Whether he ever returns to his best we are unable to say,

Schlupp is quick, sticks to his task when he plays at fullback and worries me far less than PVA when the opposition have a decent right winger.

Reidewald, as with both Souare and Schlupp is a natural left footer, reads the game well and can pass. He can defend as well as his natural position is defensive midfielder. So, we have 3 players who can step into that position which means it is covered better than any other position on the pitch.

Whilst I don’t necessarily want to sell PVA, I think that if we want to spend big money this window and have to sell to buy then we would be foolish to not accept a big money offer. Personally if we got £25m for him I would offer that straight to Chelsea for RLC. I would then wait until the summer to find the correct replacement left back as we can survive the season in that position with who we have.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 21 Dec 18 7.42pm

Sell PVA for 25m.

This is an absolute no brainer.

He is a left back, and hasnt been any good coming forward this year. Schlupp could easily do a job at left back, with Pape covering. PVA is hardly irreplaceable.

That 25m could go direct towards a striker, plus the wages.

I would even deal at 17.5 ish.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Should we sell PVA?