You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hennessey or Guaita v Cardiff?
November 16 2026 6.31am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Hennessey or Guaita v Cardiff?


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
peterg Flag Anerley 26 Dec 18 12.54pm

Agree Guiata should stay. But still concerned that he didn't move for the fluke de Bruyne cross/shot - should he not have judged the flight of the ball and tried to get to the back post?
It's not really a criticism, but a question....

 


The right place at the right time

Plaistow Eagle Flag 26 Dec 18 1.08pm

Originally posted by peterg

Agree Guiata should stay. But still concerned that he didn't move for the fluke de Bruyne cross/shot - should he not have judged the flight of the ball and tried to get to the back post?
It's not really a criticism, but a question....

After 2 good performances if Wayne comes straight back into the side Guaita will be wondering what does he have to do to get "a run"..!!

In this scenario would be concerned that he might start thinking he's future is not at Selhurst Park..!!

Which would not be good, given we have spent the last 2 seasons or so trying to identify/sign a worthy replacement for Speroni.

So definitely Guaita for me..!!

COYP

 

DeanMiles Flag Telford 26 Dec 18 1.20pm

Guaita.

Wayne can't just walk back into the team now. We have a new number 1 until he either gets injured or loses form.

 

dg1937 Flag 26 Dec 18 1.28pm

No dissent from me - Guaita should keep his place.

Re City's 2nd goal - with mis*** crosses it's incredibly difficult to judge the flight of the ball. My feeling is that Guiata slightly lost his bearings which may be why he seemed not to go for it. I don't judge him too harshly for that. I agree that Wayne would have faced serious flak had he conceded such a goal but not from me - it was a fluke goal.

 

MrSydney Flag 26 Dec 18 1.53pm

Guaita....go with who has been "helping" win matches. Sorry Wayne

 

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 26 Dec 18 6.14pm

No question about it now surely? This guy is brilliant

 

chateauferret Flag 26 Dec 18 6.44pm

Originally posted by dg1937

No dissent from me - Guaita should keep his place.

Re City's 2nd goal - with mis*** crosses it's incredibly difficult to judge the flight of the ball.

Mods - another word there for the scunthorpe list I think.

Well Guaita produced another fine save which saved us a point. The guy is class.

But that we required a world-class save to rescue a point at home against these is a disgrace.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Maine Eagle Flag USA 27 Dec 18 3.41am

We may be witnessing the beginning of the end of the Hennessey era.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 27 Dec 18 7.32am

It was a stunning save. Not just the save but the fact he pushed it to his side. The difference, though, is in Guaita's distribution. That's head and shoulders better. Our players need to be looking to take up good positions the second they anticipate him getting the ball.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

michaelpearce Flag grays 27 Dec 18 7.56am

Originally posted by The Royster7

At last we have a keeper who moves off his line . About time too. Has to be Guaita. I've been praying for Hennessey to be replaced for a long time. Let it be.

why what has he done wrong since jan open your eyes and stop the hatred, dont forget VG almost cost us against Leicester and got away with it

 

gbox82 Flag Meols, Wirral 27 Dec 18 9.02am

I think VG keeps his place for now, which is harsh on Wayne because he's been in the form of his life in 2018. And Wayne has received more flak than any other palace player I can remember, most of it unjustified imo

However, there's no way that WH would have made that save against Cardiff yesterday or the one against Vardy that he parried onto the post.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 27 Dec 18 9.28am

Originally posted by michaelpearce

why what has he done wrong since jan open your eyes and stop the hatred, dont forget VG almost cost us against Leicester and got away with it

2 clean sheets in 3 games, beat the champions away from home and you want us all to remember that he ‘almost’ cost us a goal 3 games ago on his debut? Which he never, he was fouled.
Looks like a top keeper.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 27 Dec 18 9.36am

Originally posted by Casual

2 clean sheets in 3 games, beat the champions away from home and you want us all to remember that he ‘almost’ cost us a goal 3 games ago on his debut? Which he never, he was fouled.
Looks like a top keeper.

I endorse these sentiments.

In terms of his goalkeeping prowess, he was one of the best keepers in La Liga last season and was lauded for his efforts.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 27 Dec 18 9.38am

Originally posted by michaelpearce

why what has he done wrong since jan open your eyes and stop the hatred, dont forget VG almost cost us against Leicester and got away with it


He's improved, of that there's no doubt however if you're going to be petty and bring up an 'almost' goal I'll counter with at least 2 goals which WH has parried into a strikers path instead of doing what a keeper should do and push it away at both West Ham and Br13hton.

VG has kept 2 clean sheets out of 3 games and in both of those saved us from conceeding with 2 fantastic saves.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

bifffabazz Flag Highworth, Wiltshire 27 Dec 18 10.13am

It could be argued that VG has already earned us 3 points with his two incredible saves.

At the end of the day, whichever keeper is most likely to make those crucial 'point saving/winning' saves is the one for me. And imho, VG is that man.

 


Spirit of 1974

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 27 Dec 18 10.48am

Originally posted by Casual

2 clean sheets in 3 games, beat the champions away from home and you want us all to remember that he ‘almost’ cost us a goal 3 games ago on his debut? Which he never, he was fouled.
Looks like a top keeper.

Actually he did almost cost us against Leics. Many refs would not have given a foul so think on what VG was doing messing about in his area and allowing Vardy to get that close to take the ball off him.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Casual Flag Orpington 27 Dec 18 10.54am

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Actually he did almost cost us against Leics. Many refs would not have given a foul so think on what VG was doing messing about in his area and allowing Vardy to get that close to take the ball off him.

But the ref did give a foul, 3 games ago, for a clear push in the back.
We almost won 18 nil yesterday. But we never, just the one point, unfortunately.

 

premier fan Flag BR4 27 Dec 18 11.48am

Guaita has pulled off a couple of world class saves but his footwork is a bit slow and clumsy so just needs to improve on this.

I'd keep him in goal - would be unfair to drop him when we're unbeaten in 3.

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 27 Dec 18 1.23pm

I am certain that if Hennessey had let in the De Bruyne 'cross' against City he would have been crucified unmercifully but Guaita given the benefit of the doubt.

Same goes for his aberration with Vardy against
Leicester, many refs would not have seen a foul.

Having said that he has otherwise performed well and deserves to keep his place.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 27 Dec 18 1.36pm

Given Jules was on the bench yesterday, Wayne clearly isn't fit yet. So on that basis VG will continue to start.
Given we have 2 clean sheets in 3 quite rightly so.

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hennessey or Guaita v Cardiff?