You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Negative talk
November 16 2026 6.32am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Negative talk


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
PALACE FOR EVER Flag London 04 Jan 19 6.01pm

Originally posted by Username

'Not much has changed' - when are you comparing it to?

Since 2010 took over, at Selhurst we've upgraded the floodlights, the pitch (a couple of times) and drainage/heating, the TV/broadcasting/media facilities, the hospitality in the main stand (Speroni's/lounges etc) have all been updated, as have the exec boxes in the Whitehorse, we've got rid of all the old wooden seats and I think the dressing rooms etc have been sorted as well?

We've brought in electronic turnstiles which (despite much moaning on day one) seem to work well, and we have tried new catering options (in the upper tier at least) even if people aren't still that happy with them.

We've just acquired a long-term lease for the academy site, and while the main stand development is still in limbo, we have at least put together and submitted proper plans?

I agree there are still major issues with things like scouting in particular, but I imagine this is where we've been a bit hamstrung by not having a settled manager and DoF for a proper period of time. Hopefully that is changing, but it can't help when Pardew comes in and says he wants to change everything and then we have to get rid of him, Allardyce comes in and then leaves within six months etc.

I do think it's very, very unfair to say that nothing has changed though.

Anfield an interesting comparison given a) some people's experiences of it: [Link]

and b) the years (decades?) of planning a new stadium that then didn't happen before building the new main stand there.

These things don't just happen overnight, and I do think Palace have definitely been ticking things off where we can.

A very good write up.

Good at looking at both sides and realising what the club has done since 2010.

 


The pyramid to beat all pyramids!!

[Link]

Find out what team is in which division, eg which division is Coppull United in?

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 04 Jan 19 6.21pm

Originally posted by johnmcormick8

Its not its is down to IMO the hype of the prem, we should be doing this, we should buying him etc. We are punching way above our weight by staying in the prem we are not unlike west brom, cardiff,dare i say it brighton. A Family locally based non global team un like man u liverpool arsenal etc etc. Enjoy the rollercoast ride and be done with it.

Any team outside the top six can go down, very easily.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 04 Jan 19 6.24pm

Originally posted by dp

I am glad that your experience is wholly positive.

The comparative cost angle may be a good point, but I don’t really look at the expense when I am taking clients to football matches. I have an annual budget and first and foremost, I look at whether my clients are going to be looked after and have a nice experience, and whether I have to worry about “mother henning” them the whole time.

From my personal experience, there would be an issue on 2 of every 10 visits. 1 was so bad that my relationship with my client was lost. Nothing to do with cost, free drink, quality of food. Just things that should not happen at corporate events.

You are right that I pay more to watch Palace elsewhere, but I am always sure that the experience will be good, and if it is not then the right things will be done.

So we will have to agree to disagree.

You've got to tell us!

 

johnmcormick8 Flag Brundish 04 Jan 19 6.53pm

aye

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Any team outside the top six can go down, very easily.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 04 Jan 19 7.48pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

You've got to tell us!

Probably poor staff and/or service, poor communication skills and probably being left without regular checking to see if anything is required. It doesn’t take much for something like this to be spoilt so I wouldn’t be surprised if we couldn’t get it right. Imagine if the car parking wasn’t allocated or the car park hi viz jacket doesn’t or can’t let someone in with their car or there’s a foul up at reception and it doesn’t get any better from there. Don’t be surprised, there’s never any hot food or cold drinks for us normal ticket plebs at the first match of the season.,

 


COYP

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 04 Jan 19 8.18pm

Originally posted by bexleydave

We certainly are. They have a new stadium, a top class academy, superior facilities and a wealthy owner who's prepared to put his hand in his pocket. They aren't maxed out on wages and their team didn't cost anywhere near what ours has cost.

They also hand out free clappers to make an atmosphere and about 50% of them support Brighton as their second team. Let’s see if they finish above us this season.

Palace are doing well. The books are a little unbalanced with some salaries too high, but we are holding our own and are a solid mid table team. We have some major assets with Zaha and Wan Bissaka.

How about looking at all the teams who have actually gone backwards since we returned to the Premier League - Sunderland, Hull, Villa, Middlesborough, Swansea....

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 04 Jan 19 8.29pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

They also hand out free clappers to make an atmosphere and about 50% of them support Brighton as their second team. Let’s see if they finish above us this season.

Palace are doing well. The books are a little unbalanced with some salaries too high, but we are holding our own and are a solid mid table team. We have some major assets with Zaha and Wan Bissaka.

How about looking at all the teams who have actually gone backwards since we returned to the Premier League - Sunderland, Hull, Villa, Middlesborough, Swansea....

Seeing as we’re always saying how any of 13-14 teams can go down then we really should be measuring ourselves on what we’d be and what we’d do if or when we’re relegated. I’m not confident in how we’d do once the mega Prem bucks have vanished.

 


COYP

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 04 Jan 19 8.36pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Probably poor staff and/or service, poor communication skills and probably being left without regular checking to see if anything is required. It doesn’t take much for something like this to be spoilt so I wouldn’t be surprised if we couldn’t get it right. Imagine if the car parking wasn’t allocated or the car park hi viz jacket doesn’t or can’t let someone in with their car or there’s a foul up at reception and it doesn’t get any better from there. Don’t be surprised, there’s never any hot food or cold drinks for us normal ticket plebs at the first match of the season.,

All I can say is that some of my guests were taken to the wrong place, then accused of trespassing and threatened with arrest. It was a year or two ago now, but it was terrible.

The problem, as far as I see it, is that we spend loads of money on some things, get lovely facilities and free drink and then cut corners on others. It is the bits we cut corners on that lets everything else down. I would rather pay another £25 per head and get a proper corporate experience.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 04 Jan 19 9.33pm

Originally posted by Username

'Not much has changed' - when are you comparing it to?

Since 2010 took over, at Selhurst we've upgraded the floodlights, the pitch (a couple of times) and drainage/heating, the TV/broadcasting/media facilities, the hospitality in the main stand (Speroni's/lounges etc) have all been updated, as have the exec boxes in the Whitehorse, we've got rid of all the old wooden seats and I think the dressing rooms etc have been sorted as well?

We've brought in electronic turnstiles which (despite much moaning on day one) seem to work well, and we have tried new catering options (in the upper tier at least) even if people aren't still that happy with them.

We've just acquired a long-term lease for the academy site, and while the main stand development is still in limbo, we have at least put together and submitted proper plans?

I agree there are still major issues with things like scouting in particular, but I imagine this is where we've been a bit hamstrung by not having a settled manager and DoF for a proper period of time. Hopefully that is changing, but it can't help when Pardew comes in and says he wants to change everything and then we have to get rid of him, Allardyce comes in and then leaves within six months etc.

I do think it's very, very unfair to say that nothing has changed though.

Anfield an interesting comparison given a) some people's experiences of it: [Link]

and b) the years (decades?) of planning a new stadium that then didn't happen before building the new main stand there.

These things don't just happen overnight, and I do think Palace have definitely been ticking things off where we can.

You forgot the gates. Frankly all minor things that should have been done years ago. Comparing it to always since my first match in 79. In fact, it used to be better for tea, Bovril and pies and higher attendances with the standing.
I'm talking about the s*** match day experience and poor food and drink that many have already posted about on this forum several times.
And yes, I use Anfield as a comparison. Their US owners have hugely improved availability of food and drink and toilets and also paid for the new main stand - which I have never been in but looks great.
We have improved small things but if we got relegated next season, one of the first threads on here would be 'The Premiership what did we gain?', the answers would be very little.
We have barely improved any infrastructure currently.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 04 Jan 19 10.44pm

Originally posted by dp

All I can say is that some of my guests were taken to the wrong place, then accused of trespassing and threatened with arrest. It was a year or two ago now, but it was terrible.

The problem, as far as I see it, is that we spend loads of money on some things, get lovely facilities and free drink and then cut corners on others. It is the bits we cut corners on that lets everything else down. I would rather pay another £25 per head and get a proper corporate experience.

That’s terrible. Still, we’ve got a nice office we rent off Parish’s company called ‘Smoke and Mirrors.’

 


COYP

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 04 Jan 19 11.51pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

That’s terrible. Still, we’ve got a nice office we rent off Parish’s company called ‘Smoke and Mirrors.’

Ah. Not getting into any Parish bashing.

The fact is that I can’t trust Palace to look after my clients, but it was not Parish’s fault. Parish has done wonders for Palace, but they are failing at the basics.

I now go to Wembley where the football is sterile but the hospitality is decent, and to away games where the football is decent and I can support Palace.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 05 Jan 19 12.33am

Originally posted by dp

Ah. Not getting into any Parish bashing.

The fact is that I can’t trust Palace to look after my clients, but it was not Parish’s fault. Parish has done wonders for Palace, but they are failing at the basics.

I now go to Wembley where the football is sterile but the hospitality is decent, and to away games where the football is decent and I can support Palace.

He couldn’t stress enough how corporates is the way forward, it’s up to him to make others make sure they deliver. I can forgive it happening on The Apprentice given its their first day, but not us. But it is us so what do we expect?

 


COYP

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 05 Jan 19 1.19am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

He couldn’t stress enough how corporates is the way forward, it’s up to him to make others make sure they deliver. I can forgive it happening on The Apprentice given its their first day, but not us. But it is us so what do we expect?

Perhaps he feels that, but everyone is important. How difficult is it to serve cold beer? Or hot food? We are Premier League and we should strive to be Premier League in all that we do.

However, we would not be Premier League at all without 2010, and it is a good point well made that they are correcting years of under investment. So we should not be too critical.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 05 Jan 19 3.34am

If we went down this season, what would it have been all for? Are we any better off than August 2012?

The wage bill would have to be slashed big time, the playing staff - a lot would be asking to move or give us one season chance, even then, we would need to slash the wage bill again if we didn't go up.

6 years in prem didn't get us a better academy set up, training ground/facilities or stadium.

We are, however, 9th highest for out goings - wages.

Whilst i do not expect us to be 18th - 20th in regards to wages, 13-16th would be practical with us finishing the season around 10-12th, due to smart investment and youth.

Once Pardew came in, Benteke then Sakho - no doubt they are quality signings, well, Sakho is still showing this.. but honestly, were they the only answers? Did we really need Sakho, was there no one else out there?

anyways, it's all hearsay, it is what it is and i personally think we are wasting, again, glorious oppertunities to move the club forward

 


This was once a quality forum....

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 05 Jan 19 7.40am


The 'upgrades' have been the bare minimum mandated by the league (the gantry and pitch) or a figurative lick of paint (gates and seats).

Our lads at the top are taking high salaries until our time in the premier League is up and then they'll asset strip from there. The main stand, I suspect, will never happen. Smoke and mirrors is absolutely spot on.

Edited by ChrisGC (05 Jan 2019 9.07am)

 

uncleneal Flag Croydon 05 Jan 19 10.00am

Can not believe Mutch turned out so badly.

He was decent at Cardiff but clearly QPR took our pants down

 

uncleneal Flag Croydon 05 Jan 19 10.01am

Sorry wrong thread

 

Username Flag Horsham 05 Jan 19 10.29am

Originally posted by ASCPFC

You forgot the gates. Frankly all minor things that should have been done years ago. Comparing it to always since my first match in 79. In fact, it used to be better for tea, Bovril and pies and higher attendances with the standing.
I'm talking about the s*** match day experience and poor food and drink that many have already posted about on this forum several times.
And yes, I use Anfield as a comparison. Their US owners have hugely improved availability of food and drink and toilets and also paid for the new main stand - which I have never been in but looks great.
We have improved small things but if we got relegated next season, one of the first threads on here would be 'The Premiership what did we gain?', the answers would be very little.
We have barely improved any infrastructure currently.

The fact that they were long overdue doesn't change the fact that it is 2010 who have made the changes.

Our stadium is old and difficult to modernise but it is happening where they can.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 05 Jan 19 10.58am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

That’s terrible. Still, we’ve got a nice office we rent off Parish’s company called ‘Smoke and Mirrors.’

You mean the office our web/media/marketing teams are based in which, until recently, we only paid a ‘peppercorn’ rent for (changed to ‘market rate’ once new auditors appointed)? There are several companies in those offices which all appear to be paying the going rate for their share of the space & the building itself seems to be owned by a middle-eastern property co.

Smoke & Mirrors is a video production co working mainly in the marketing sector (SP’s background) yet people seem to like to play on the name as if it’s something suspicious. It’s not like he’s the only director/shareholder either.

If I understood what was said at the new stand launch correctly, our offices would all relocate there when (ok, if) it’s built.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Midlands Eagle Flag 05 Jan 19 11.13am

Originally posted by Nobbybm


Smoke & Mirrors is a video production co working mainly in the marketing sector (SP’s background) yet people seem to like to play on the name as if it’s something suspicious. It’s not like he’s the only director/shareholder either.

According to the accounts there are two directors with Parish owning 85% of the shares.

Again according to the accounts Smoke & Mirrors Film Productions Ltd is now dormant and the parent company Smoke & Mirrors Group Ltd is an investment company with it's main asset being a property

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Negative talk