You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Gaffer
November 16 2026 6.32am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Gaffer


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
ChrisGC Flag Wantage 22 Feb 19 6.36pm

Originally posted by dg1937

I was chatting to a Charlton fan last night and he could see the funny side of the thought that sacking Curbishley had indeed taken them to another a level.

We are lucky to have Roy, some of the football this season has been excellent (and some of it hasn't) but I can remember times when the football was consistently dreadful to watch - Freedman anyone?

As to his use of subs, many times there has been no quality on the bench, that's changing now and, surprise, surprise, he is making more use of subs. I seem to recall Pardew being slated for his use of subs - basically managers can't win.

Yes, that's about the size of it.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards andyachtie Flag Monte Giberto 22 Feb 19 7.04pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Haha, no pal: I was neither bullied nor a bully. Were you bullied by any chance?

Not that having left school nearly 20 years ago and now existing in the adult world do I really care about your feelings or the fact that you were the school punchbag to be fair.

Bit odd to accuse someone else of being a bully after insulting them just because you disagree with their opinion, but there you go. I'm sure the irony is lost on you.

Edited by ChrisGC (22 Feb 2019 4.53pm)

You really are a fool. I did not say you could not air your opinion.... I just said that you were probably a bully and you so obviously are. Crawl under the stone you came from and f*** off.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 22 Feb 19 7.10pm

Originally posted by andyachtie

You really are a fool. I did not say you could not air your opinion.... I just said that you were probably a bully and you so obviously are. Crawl under the stone you came from and f*** off.


Swearing, ad hominem with no argument....and you are moaning about bullying?

Why don't you just take your own advice.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 22 Feb 19 7.17pm

Originally posted by dg1937

I was chatting to a Charlton fan last night and he could see the funny side of the thought that sacking Curbishley had indeed taken them to another a level.

We are lucky to have Roy, some of the football this season has been excellent (and some of it hasn't) but I can remember times when the football was consistently dreadful to watch - Freedman anyone?

As to his use of subs, many times there has been no quality on the bench, that's changing now and, surprise, surprise, he is making more use of subs. I seem to recall Pardew being slated for his use of subs - basically managers can't win.

Peter Taylor as well, Trevor Francis, although he did give us 5-0 win against the weed and he did sign Andy Johnson, so I’ll let him off

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 22 Feb 19 7.23pm

I found Sutton's comments interesting about training and how Roy was ahead of his time.

With most things in life, and people, there are highs and lows (cue me mentioning Harry Kane on corners).

There are many things I dont agree with regarding RH but he has us playing some excellent football lately. He is mostly not to blame that from games where have 28, 30, 25 shots we only score 1 goal or even none. His job is to deploy players and a system to create chances and limit them at the other end.

He has failed to improve some players like Sorloth, but has succeeded with others, such as Schlupp.

He is finally making subs and it is now patently clear that the lack of substitutions was sitting squarely and Parish's door, not Roy's.

All in all it is mightily disappointing that his speech at the end of last season has not come to pass (kicking on) but I think this is more down to the losses in our midfield ranks, coupled with abysmal finishing, than anything else.

If he is still around next season and assuming we have a strike force who can score goals this will be the best squad of players ever seen at Selhurst Park.

With those players another relegation fight would be inexcusable.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Stirlingsays Flag 22 Feb 19 7.24pm

Originally posted by monkey

Peter Taylor as well, Trevor Francis, although he did give us 5-0 win against the weed and he did sign Andy Johnson, so I’ll let him off

Plus he was a legend of a player.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

PatrickA Flag London 22 Feb 19 7.32pm

Roy has done a sound job.
The team looks well drilled and is always competitive and you can see evidence of the work on the training field.
However, we are only three points outside the relegation zone and there is a nagging feeling that we should be doing better with the available squad, which is up there with the best we have had in recent times.
I think it’s too easy to point to a lack of obvious goalscorer and feel that in many games we have been too defensive and not got enough players into the box as we are so rigid in maintaining our shape.
The perception for example that we can’t play Meyer with Zaha in the same team as it leaves us short defensively is bizarre.
Even assuming that the striker( whoever that is) does not defend, we would still have eight players in defensive positions as the other midfielders and Townsend are very disciplined in this regard.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 22 Feb 19 8.06pm

Originally posted by cryrst

Im sure that doesnt go unoticed and is appreciated.
Some games are boring though and in game management with roy can be lacking.
Everton away a prime example.
Lack of subs in time on at least this occasion pretty sure cost us points.

Missed pen on the hour at 0-0 when we were well on top with good possession and Jordan Pickford was MOTM.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 22 Feb 19 8.31pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

I found Sutton's comments interesting about training and how Roy was ahead of his time.

With most things in life, and people, there are highs and lows (cue me mentioning Harry Kane on corners).

There are many things I dont agree with regarding RH but he has us playing some excellent football lately. He is mostly not to blame that from games where have 28, 30, 25 shots we only score 1 goal or even none. His job is to deploy players and a system to create chances and limit them at the other end.

He has failed to improve some players like Sorloth, but has succeeded with others, such as Schlupp.

He is finally making subs and it is now patently clear that the lack of substitutions was sitting squarely and Parish's door, not Roy's.

All in all it is mightily disappointing that his speech at the end of last season has not come to pass (kicking on) but I think this is more down to the losses in our midfield ranks, coupled with abysmal finishing, than anything else.

If he is still around next season and assuming we have a strike force who can score goals this will be the best squad of players ever seen at Selhurst Park.

With those players another relegation fight would be inexcusable.

..here we go again Kane has scored two goals resulting from corners both against Panama who could not and had not a clue how to defend.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 22 Feb 19 8.32pm

Corners are overrated.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 22 Feb 19 8.34pm

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER

Seems like not many members agree with your jaundice opinion of Hodgson, in fact none so far.

Yes, he is very badly wrong.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 22 Feb 19 8.48pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC


Maybe that washes once motivationally: "it's ok lad, you did as you were told and it didn't work out, we'll work on it for next time" but every week?

It's pure belligerence. Basically Wodgson and his staff are valuing obedience over talent as it protects their authority and therefore their jobs. There is some merit in this, but the balance should be loyalty and talent.

We would easily be top ten if he didn't wait 15-20 games for players to come good or just keep picking the same trusty carthorses over a bit of flare.

And in terms of respect within the game? I've heard plenty of ex players on podcasts and in the media who speak negatively about his style.

He's extremely one dimensional and predictable, no matter how good the passing and positional discipline has looked at times.

Edited by ChrisGC (22 Feb 2019 9.30am)

Following a game plan is what every single manager does and you can only be accurately critical at the end of the season after all the games have been played, we could still finish in the top ten very easily and that will cover your comment above in lovely scrambled egg.

 

becky Flag over the moon 22 Feb 19 9.34pm

Aside from his football tactics (of which I have no complaint except the same as everyone else about late subs), has anyone else ever noted how warmly he is greeted at the start of the match by virtually every other manager? Not just a shake of hands in passing, but always a hug, a pat on the arm and a few words is the norm, accompanied by genuine smiles on both sides.

A very well liked and respected gentleman our Gaffer!

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 22 Feb 19 10.16pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Following a game plan is what every single manager does and you can only be accurately critical at the end of the season after all the games have been played, we could still finish in the top ten very easily and that will cover your comment above in lovely scrambled egg.

I hope you're correct, table doesn't lie though.

As for 'accurately critical' only at the end of a season: how many games did FDB get? I'm all for reasoned debate, so try not to chuck in stuff like this. No manager gets weighed up at the end of a season and judged on the balance of things, otherwise Mourinho and Wagner would still be in a job.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 22 Feb 19 10.18pm

Originally posted by becky

Aside from his football tactics (of which I have no complaint except the same as everyone else about late subs), has anyone else ever noted how warmly he is greeted at the start of the match by virtually every other manager? Not just a shake of hands in passing, but always a hug, a pat on the arm and a few words is the norm, accompanied by genuine smiles on both sides.

A very well liked and respected gentleman our Gaffer!

Predictable line up, same tactics every week and no plan B to worry about, oh and more often than not they get the 3 points. What's not to love?

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 22 Feb 19 10.34pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

..here we go again Kane has scored two goals resulting from corners both against Panama who could not and had not a clue how to defend.

Er, think you missed the point mate.

It was Harry Kane TAKING corners under RH.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 23 Feb 19 9.39am

Originally posted by monkey

Peter Taylor as well, Trevor Francis, although he did give us 5-0 win against the weed and he did sign Andy Johnson, so I’ll let him off

Not to mention the great Alan mullary (probably the worst) and Alan Smith, even Big Mal, most fans loved him, my self included, but he did get us relegated in successive seasons.

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 23 Feb 19 9.49am

Originally posted by cryrst

Im sure that doesnt go unoticed and is appreciated.
Some games are boring though and in game management with roy can be lacking.
Everton away a prime example.
Lack of subs in time on at least this occasion pretty sure cost us points.

Agree some of the games can be a tad boring.

I pine for the days of Pardew when you would regularly see four or five goals a game. Trouble was they weren't scored by us.

Think he's doing a decent enough job. We are top of our mini league of six clubs fighting over the last relegation spot and in the quarters of the cup.

Happy days.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

davehuggins Flag 23 Feb 19 9.56am

If anybody believes we have ever (in the PL) this term played better and more control football under another manager please speak up. For me, I just wish RH was 20 years younger and willing to sign a new 5-year contract. Thanks Roy from me.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards berlinpalace Flag berlin 23 Feb 19 10.08am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Predictable line up, same tactics every week and no plan B to worry about, oh and more often than not they get the 3 points. What's not to love?

More often than not the opposition don’t get the three points by a ratio of almost 2:1. But let’s not let facts get in the way.

 

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Gaffer