You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Have a groan about a loan
November 16 2026 6.32am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Have a groan about a loan


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
matthau Flag South Croydon 27 Feb 19 3.23pm

Originally posted by Nobbybm

Apart from Chelski's transfer ban - they can't sign anyone which is probably why they wouldn't sell Batshuayi (or anyone else decent) at the end of the season.

Subject to appeal isn’t it?

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 27 Feb 19 4.23pm

Originally posted by matthau

Subject to appeal isn’t it?

Yes. So not a ban at all in practice.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Maine Eagle Flag USA 04 Mar 19 6.21pm

Excellent goal, really really excellent goal from Michy at the weekend. How many times of late have we seen a true poacher's goal smashed into the back of the net by one of our centre forwards - not often.

However he also showed when given time and space he sometimes makes the wrong decision with the 1 on 1.

Problem with this all is that the better this guy does with scoring goals, the less chance we have of signing him permanently. Same with RLC, as soon as he got the nod to go to the World Cup, we had no chance. In the end they didnt even sell him at all, let alone to us.

I hope a serious conversation has been had with Chelsea about this to establish if we really have a chance at getting him or not, given their embargo and our financial constraints.

When we are safe, if we play him ahead of players we will actually have next season its a mistake as not only are we helping another team in the same division, but we are denying game time to our players.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 04 Mar 19 6.39pm

Amigo Loans. I thought they were my friend. Not so.

 


COYP

cryrst Flag The garden of England 04 Mar 19 7.25pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Excellent goal, really really excellent goal from Michy at the weekend. How many times of late have we seen a true poacher's goal smashed into the back of the net by one of our centre forwards - not often.

However he also showed when given time and space he sometimes makes the wrong decision with the 1 on 1.

Problem with this all is that the better this guy does with scoring goals, the less chance we have of signing him permanently. Same with RLC, as soon as he got the nod to go to the World Cup, we had no chance. In the end they didnt even sell him at all, let alone to us.

I hope a serious conversation has been had with Chelsea about this to establish if we really have a chance at getting him or not, given their embargo and our financial constraints.

When we are safe, if we play him ahead of players we will actually have next season its a mistake as not only are we helping another team in the same division, but we are denying game time to our players.

Not when each place in the league is worth x millions.
Play your best; even on loan players.
Our own ahould step up if they want a game.
Sod em.
I pay good money so i want the best i can see.

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 04 Mar 19 7.29pm

Originally posted by cryrst

Not when each place in the league is worth x millions.
Play your best; even on loan players.
Our own ahould step up if they want a game.
Sod em.
I pay good money so i want the best i can see.


Couldn't agree more

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 04 Mar 19 7.53pm

Originally posted by cryrst

Not when each place in the league is worth x millions.
Play your best; even on loan players.
Our own ahould step up if they want a game.
Sod em.
I pay good money so i want the best i can see.

I guess you are right Football is a business not a game played to placate football fans. I do however understand the point that we should not be used to inflate the price of footballers we might want to buy!

Edited by Brinscall Eagle (04 Mar 2019 7.54pm)

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 04 Mar 19 8.27pm

Originally posted by Brinscall Eagle

I guess you are right Football is a business not a game played to placate football fans. I do however understand the point that we should not be used to inflate the price of footballers we might want to buy!

Edited by Brinscall Eagle (04 Mar 2019 7.54pm)

It is a game to placate and entertain the fans as you say fans.
Ive been there when we were crap and payed hard earnt dollar without the hope of watching superstars.
Now i have the chance i want to watch them in my teams colours.
I dont give a toss if they move on.
Their loss as well.
Carpe diem.
As they say.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 04 Mar 19 8.41pm

Originally posted by cryrst

Not when each place in the league is worth x millions.
Play your best; even on loan players.
Our own ahould step up if they want a game.
Sod em.
I pay good money so i want the best i can see.

Do we really want to start next season with a bunch of forwards completely out of form and unable to score goals?

Its a bit of short term thinking IMHO, which Parish is famous for.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 05 Mar 19 10.01am

Originally posted by Pete53

A loan is better than nothing - if there is no prospect of finding a permanent signing then at least a loan can help tide you over.

Mind you, having said a loan is better than nothing names like Bamford, Adebayour, Sanoga, Flammini, Remy, Ameobi, Jerome suddenly challenge my own assertion.

You shouldn't include Jerome with that lot, he didn't score a lot of goals, but he was a very good player.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 05 Mar 19 11.38am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Do we really want to start next season with a bunch of forwards completely out of form and unable to score goals?

Its a bit of short term thinking IMHO, which Parish is famous for.

We started this season with a bunch of forwards not on form.
Whats new; and they were our own!

 

steven_t92 Flag Orpington 05 Mar 19 11.49am

Originally posted by Brinscall Eagle

I guess you are right Football is a business not a game played to placate football fans. I do however understand the point that we should not be used to inflate the price of footballers we might want to buy!

Edited by Brinscall Eagle (04 Mar 2019 7.54pm)

The only way we could bring in Batshuayi was on loan, there's no way we could afford the 35mil they probably want for him - otherwise he'd be permanent already.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 05 Mar 19 12.00pm

Originally posted by steven_t92

The only way we could bring in Batshuayi was on loan, there's no way we could afford the 35mil they probably want for him - otherwise he'd be permanent already.

Benteke and Sakho were only slightly less, and we have Zaha and AWB as saleable assets, but the key thing for me is getting Benteke and Wickham off the books.

I’m not saying I want it to happen, because the could be consequences, like hamstringing ourselves in future windows, but it isn’t impossible. His contract demands might make it difficult, although I doubt many top 6 clubsxwant him, apart from spurs, but they’re not going to pay him handsomely anyway.

 


COYP

southnorwoodhill Flag 05 Mar 19 12.38pm

Bats has had limited game time and already some are saying we should purchase. Let's see how he gets on eh?
I do take into consideration the fact that he has scored 2 already.

 

Adamoc123 Flag Ennis 05 Mar 19 12.45pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Bats has had limited game time and already some are saying we should purchase. Let's see how he gets on eh?
I do take into consideration the fact that he has scored 2 already.

Reasonable approach given Benteke scored 17 in his first season for us.

 


The First 90 Minutes Are The Most Important!

Nc412760 Flag Oxford 05 Mar 19 12.56pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Benteke and Sakho were only slightly less, and we have Zaha and AWB as saleable assets, but the key thing for me is getting Benteke and Wickham off the books.

I’m not saying I want it to happen, because the could be consequences, like hamstringing ourselves in future windows, but it isn’t impossible. His contract demands might make it difficult, although I doubt many top 6 clubsxwant him, apart from spurs, but they’re not going to pay him handsomely anyway.

£40m for AWB, £60m for Wilf, (£5m for Benteke!) a big summer transfer kitty after owners have taken some out. Should be enough to secure Bats plus others. Love them to stay but realistically this must be in the Chairman's plans.

 


First game aged 7: 16/12/72 CPFC 5-0 MUFC - Palace for life!!!!!

Midlands Eagle Flag 05 Mar 19 1.09pm

Originally posted by Nc412760

Should be enough to secure Bats plus others.

If Batshuayi does well do you think he would want to stay permanently or is he putting himself in the shop window for a bigger club

 

Charlie Croker Flag Hampshire 05 Mar 19 1.25pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Excellent goal, really really excellent goal from Michy at the weekend. How many times of late have we seen a true poacher's goal smashed into the back of the net by one of our centre forwards - not often.

This season in the league? None at all. All our league goals from strikers have been from the loanees. I know that CB & CW have generally spent more time in the treatment room, but the focus now really should be on permanent players for 2019/20 that can score. CB has lost his mojo so either needs to be moved on OR given real competition for a spot in the team. If we can get Michy (although I think others will be interested, or Chelsea will take him back) that would be ideal, along with possibly a fit again Wickham as 3rd choice.

Edited by Charlie Croker (05 Mar 2019 1.26pm)

 


“My experience of life is that it is not divided up into genres; it’s a horrifying, romantic, tragic, comical, science-fiction cowboy detective novel. You know, with a bit of pornography if you’re lucky."

Maine Eagle Flag USA 05 Mar 19 3.23pm

Originally posted by cryrst

We started this season with a bunch of forwards not on form.
Whats new; and they were our own!

Yeh I agree, would be good to avoid that though?

We have started the last few seasons really slowly with a string of very poor performances.

I am not calling for us to sign the guy necessarily, just to clarify we have an option there or are priced out/they don’t want to sell anyway.

If we cannot get him in the door permanently then let’s not forget, we still have a problem there unless Bakary Sako is the answer. Case in point he is another one who needs game time.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 05 Mar 19 3.58pm

Batman seems to suit us - I don't believe he will ever be our player though. It seems a shame that no matter how many chances they get - Wickham is going to be injured and Benteke poor. Sorloth seems unlikely to ever be Premier League standard but he is on loan so is playing. So giving game time to the two strikers we have seems pointless as they don't seem likely to improve to me and presumably Roy also.
From this we will eventually have to buy sometime.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Have a groan about a loan