This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Summer movements
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
dannyboy1978 01 Apr 19 10.16pm |
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Would you take £80m for both AWB and Wilf ' by bexleydave
Damn, thought it was another Susana Reid thread
|
dannyboy1978 01 Apr 19 10.18pm |
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Would you take £80m for both AWB and Wilf ' by bexleydave
30 mill and k walker in return Or 50 mill and moses in return.
|
thai-eagle chiang mai 02 Apr 19 2.36am |
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Would you take £80m for both AWB and Wilf ' by bexleydave
80 mill for the 2? If some Club gave us that PLUS 2 highly capable players in Return - would consider it!
|
Vaibow vancouver/croydon 02 Apr 19 4.22am |
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Would you take £80m for both AWB and Wilf ' by bexleydave
I echo others, it be easier to replace AWB than wilf. Creative flare, everyone wants it, it doesn't come cheap, thing is, had wilf played a blinding season, i would have assumed he be gone for sure this summer, but the way it has gone in the eyes of others, i can't see the big clubs lining up for him - he just isn't the finishing the chances he would be expected to at that level. Winning a pen and assist is dime a dozen in the top 4 clubs. I think wilf could be in for a shock this summer, when the big boys don't come knocking and i hope he just realises maybe palace is the club for him - be a legend at one club or be a nearly there at others. It's interesting tho as OGS took him to Cardiff, if he would have him now!?
AWB i would imagine we would sell north of 40 mil with sell on - that's going on a replacement and then rest in bank. Zaha is probably around the same, but to replace would cost the same unless Dougie has unearthed some gems, so...
This was once a quality forum....
|
Vaibow vancouver/croydon 02 Apr 19 4.28am |
|
|
AWB sold, we need some cash to invest and get those couple of players over the line. He's by far the easiest to replace as we have a good defensive unit for now.
Attack, someone to compliment Meyer so we have another option.
We can't sell Zaha, but all good things come to an end.
This was once a quality forum....
|
kev64 Cambs 02 Apr 19 5.27am |
|
Originally posted by PALACE FOR EVER
Should we sell Benteke?, to get money selling him, his contract ends 2020 & also as his wages are amongst the highest ones.
Who is going to buy a striker that has scored what 2 goals in 2 years ? and is on 100k plus a week. We couldn’t give him away .. £50 million down the toilet.
|
Den1923 02 Apr 19 5.07pm |
|
Originally posted by AERO
If we have to sell any of above it would be easier to replace Wan Bassaka . Then purchase a proven decent striker . Now that we are relatively safe we should and probably are getting things in place early.
not with SP in charge, you will have to wait until the last day of the transfer window at about 22:30 and then you will probably end up with a loan deal for a player no one else wants!
|
est1905 02 Apr 19 5.36pm |
|
Originally posted by Fatherken
The season is coming to a close so here are my thoughts on who will be leaving us or who should go this summer J Speroni will retire and should be made goalkeeping coach V Guaita will return to Spain and we will replace him with Butland J Jack transfer out A Wan-Bassaka will be sold [ I hope not ] to a top team like Man City or Arsenal J Puncheon his days are numbered and should be sold on J Ayew should return back to his club C Wickham a player I like but we can't keep paying him to only turn out a couple of times a season and keeping a slot blocked up for a fit player B Sako why did we bring him back needs to be move on to another club A Sorloth not good enough just transfer out M Batshuayi he would cost us to much for a forward who can't hold the ball up or head the ball W Zaha sad to say I think he will move on this summer I do hope I am wrong A Townsend again I hope not but I think he will go back to Newcastle
Eh? Unless you reckon we are likely to buy 10 quality players over the summer (which is more than unlikely) You plan/prediction has just relegated us. You cant lose that lot without replacing them. Which is why (whether any of us like it or not) it has to be done gradually with the most urgent changes to be done first along with the least important losses. Wickham and Punch will go. Bats might if we cant afford Chelsea's asking price. Just those three will be hard enough to replace in the summer. Thats not even including the 'what do we do about Benteke' conversation that the board will doubtless be planning.
|
Dunnec15 Cork 02 Apr 19 10.40pm |
|
|
Will be interesting to see if we can get a few of the relegated teams better players. Would love Tom Cairney and Mitrovic from Fulham, they would add alot of what we're missing I'd say.
|
jeeagles 02 Apr 19 10.51pm |
|
|
Don't think anyone would match our valuation of Wilf.
Not sure if a big club would take a punt on AWB yet. Likely to go for someone more established.
Luca is player clubs are most likely to be looking for.
Our players are on decent wages too.
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Apr 19 11.49pm |
|
Originally posted by Dunnec15
Will be interesting to see if we can get a few of the relegated teams better players. Would love Tom Cairney and Mitrovic from Fulham, they would add alot of what we're missing I'd say.
I think Aaron Mooy would be a decent purchase.
|
HKOwen Hong Kong 03 Apr 19 12.25am |
|
|
Benteke not in your list ?
Originally posted by Fatherken
The season is coming to a close so here are my thoughts on who will be leaving us or who should go this summer J Speroni will retire and should be made goalkeeping coach V Guaita will return to Spain and we will replace him with Butland J Jack transfer out A Wan-Bassaka will be sold [ I hope not ] to a top team like Man City or Arsenal J Puncheon his days are numbered and should be sold on J Ayew should return back to his club C Wickham a player I like but we can't keep paying him to only turn out a couple of times a season and keeping a slot blocked up for a fit player B Sako why did we bring him back needs to be move on to another club A Sorloth not good enough just transfer out M Batshuayi he would cost us to much for a forward who can't hold the ball up or head the ball W Zaha sad to say I think he will move on this summer I do hope I am wrong A Townsend again I hope not but I think he will go back to Newcastle
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.
|
Fatherken 03 Apr 19 8.11am |
|
|
in reply to est1905 comments of yesterday only 3 I would suggest are quality player the other 9 we have 1 retiring 1 homesick 2 out of contract 2 not champion standard 1 sick note 2 on loan
|
Phil’s Barber Crowborough 03 Apr 19 8.16am |
|
Originally posted by Dunnec15
Will be interesting to see if we can get a few of the relegated teams better players. Would love Tom Cairney and Mitrovic from Fulham, they would add alot of what we're missing I'd say.
It will be very interesting to see what Fulham do, as with their owner and his multi millions they won’t need to sell anyone if they don’t want to. Just off load a couple of the misfits that they bought last summer and that didn’t really feature or work out this season and they’d still have by far the strongest squad in the Championship next season.
Edited by Phil’s Barber (03 Apr 2019 8.17am)
|
Phil’s Barber Crowborough 03 Apr 19 8.23am |
|
|
He would be a fantastic signing but after two quality seasons for Huddersfield a significant number of clubs will be after his signature. I’m not going to hold out much hope of us getting him.
|
KAOS In a tree 03 Apr 19 8.44am |
|
|
In true Palace fashion and especially with SP & RH running things, I doubt there’ll be many comings & goings at all pre-season. If we finish where we are, or thereabouts, it will be deemed a satisfactory campaign. It’ll be another brick in the ‘we have a strong squad so don’t need to buy’ wall and if the likes of Wilf, AWB & others don’t leave then I’ll be more than happy with this tact ...
Roy gives us stability. With that comes rigidness and inflexibility which is frustrating but I’ll take this over uncertainty. Hope he’s in charge next season ...
|
JohnB 03 Apr 19 8.54am |
|
|
I think we'll only see 1 or 2 come in unless we let one of AWB or Wilf go for big money.
If either of them go, I would love to see us go for Mitrovic, Mooy, Daniel James if Wilf went and Jayden Bogle if AWB went.
|
MonsterMunch Cambridge 03 Apr 19 9.31am |
|
Originally posted by JohnB
I think we'll only see 1 or 2 come in unless we let one of AWB or Wilf go for big money.
If either of them go, I would love to see us go for Mitrovic, Mooy, Daniel James if Wilf went and Jayden Bogle if AWB went.
As a general question if we did have to let one of them go who would it reluctantly be? For me sadly it would have to be Aaron. A phenomenal defender already at his age he really is an amazing talent but he does play in a position that would have less impact on the team if he were to leave. Take Wilf out of our side, and..well doesnt bare thinking about. Bloody love AWB mind.
I mean we really arent a selling club any longer, so there is a high chance both will stay.. I just dont see where the funds required for the investment in the team is going to come from apart from player sales. We are up to our eyeballs in FFP.
Edited by MonsterMunch (03 Apr 2019 9.33am)
|
topcat Holmesdale / Surbiton 03 Apr 19 10.05am |
|
Originally posted by Fatherken
The season is coming to a close so here are my thoughts on who will be leaving us or who should go this summer J Speroni will retire and should be made goalkeeping coach Agree V Guaita will return to Spain and we will replace him with Butland I'd be happy with this but suspect that Guaita's not going anywhere. J Jack transfer out A Wan-Bassaka will be sold [ I hope not ] to a top team like Man City or Arsenal. Probably to Man U J Puncheon his days are numbered and should be sold on. Out of contract J Ayew should return back to his club Agreed C Wickham a player I like but we can't keep paying him to only turn out a couple of times a season and keeping a slot blocked up for a fit player. He's not going anywhere B Sako why did we bring him back needs to be move on to another club. Out of contract, we didn't need him as soon as we loaned Bats A Sorloth not good enough just transfer out. Agreed M Batshuayi he would cost us to much for a forward who can't hold the ball up or head the ball. Very good player but not in our price range W Zaha sad to say I think he will move on this summer I do hope I am wrong. Don't think anyone will come in for him A Townsend again I hope not but I think he will go back to Newcastle. Not sure why he would leave
Assuming AWB leaves, we will need two strikers, a right back and a left back as a priority. The RB and LB shouldn't be that difficult but lots of teams are after a decent striker and they are very difficult to find, and very expensive.
It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.
|
JohnB 03 Apr 19 10.15am |
|
|
I would sacrifice AWB over Wilf mainly because Wilf has a large sell on fee to Man U and would mean we would have less money to replace him and strengthen.
The only thing in favour of selling Zaha over AWB would be their respective wages giving us a bit more room FFP wise with Zaha's wage off the books.
I would only sell AWB though if we got a large fee with plenty of add ons for things like international appearances and sell on percentages.
I think people underestimate the importance of good full backs though and in the modern game they are one of the most important positions on the pitch.
You only have to look at the importance that someone like Pep put on bringing in full backs at Citeh to see how much more important they have become.
Ideal world, Chelsea come in and give us £50m plus Reece James and some add ons for various achievements. Never gonna happen though.
I'd like to see them both stay but ultimately if we are going to progress and strengthen the team, the only way is to either get outside investment or gamble and sell one of our star players.
|