You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Best three replacements if Roy steps down
November 16 2026 6.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Best three replacements if Roy steps down


Page 2 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
davehuggins Flag 07 Apr 19 2.41pm

Could see Rafa saying yes, done a brilliant job at Newcastle and IMO is a high quality PL manager. If he is promised funds and a good salary why not?

 

hastingseagle67 Flag 07 Apr 19 2.56pm

Originally posted by black eagle.

So who would your three suggestions be?

Read the first post on the thread

 


has resisted writing a single post on the Ross McCormack thread !!!

Park Road Flag 07 Apr 19 3.14pm

Originally posted by hastingseagle67

Are Benitez and Mourinho serious suggestions? I am not mocking, but would like to understand the thought process that people would think managers of that level would come to Palace.

Probably not... But I'm a bit of a dreamer.
Mourinho's new project could be to transform a club he has a soft spot for - into a world class outfit...
He's seen it, done it, and he's getting close to his twilight years, so maybe it's the right time...

 

PeatlingPalace Flag Peatling Leicestershire, UK 07 Apr 19 3.56pm

Originally posted by hastingseagle67

Are Benitez and Mourinho serious suggestions? I am not mocking, but would like to understand the thought process that people would think managers of that level would come to Palace.

Is Newcastle to Palace a different level?

I suggested Benitez because I think he has proved himself with no funds (and has obviously already done it with funds/big teams). So with our limited budget I think he could be the perfect manager and may even make players like AWB think twice about leaving

And for the record I really like Roy and think what he has achieved for us has been excellent. This is the first premier season where I have not been sweating over all the fixtures & permutations from the start of April

Ok home form has been a bit s***, but away form has been magnificent. We are Palace and I think mid table is currently our level. We wont get in the top six, so for me 7th to 10th is the target. There have been times this season when we have played the best football I have seen in my 44 Palace years

My only complaint about Roy is that he is too loyal to players not in form (e.g. Benteke or Schlupp) but he has limited options in our squad and players respect is critical for a manager.

 


When they kick out your front door. How you gonna come ?

TheArmaniCode Flag 07 Apr 19 4.10pm

One thing to keep in mind is Parish doesn't like managers like Mourinho or Benitez who are very independent and like to do their own thing. It's the same reason he never went after Dyche a couple years ago. He wants someone that's gonna work with the vision HE has for the club.

Imo someone like a Daniel Farke would be the ideal choice - plays good football and good at bringing through young players. Obviously, he won't come to us now Norwich are going up, but someone in that mould would be ideal.

Basically, like FdB only not a stubborn prick.

Edited by TheArmaniCode (07 Apr 2019 4.10pm)

 

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 07 Apr 19 4.38pm

Originally posted by hastingseagle67

So lots of people would like Roy to go but not many have a realistic replacement in mind. Here’s mine.

1. Chris Wilder (Sheffield United) best manager in the Championship by far.

2. Christian Streich (SC Freiburg) - almost a younger version of Roy doing wonders with a small club in the Bundesliga and has a good record of bringing through young talent.

3. Steven Gerard (Rangers) bit of a punt being so inexperienced but his playing career should command a great deal of respect. As our feeder club (Chelsea) May have to hold onto their players, Liverpool could be our go to club to pick up young talent and his connections may help us. Question is, is premier league with us more appealing than Europe with Rangers.


0
Definitely agree regarding Chris Wilder,i think Sam Allerdyce said he would be his choice to take over from him.

 

Evan147 Flag Coulsdon 07 Apr 19 4.55pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Dean Kiely our next manager' by Midlands Eagle

Not saying we should be in any rush to get rid of Roy but when he does leave why not give the job to someone who is young, hungry and probably looking for a managerial carrier. Knows the players and the club and wolves have proven a goalkeeper as a manager works. Would also allow Julian a job as goalie coach possibly?

 

Aray Flag South London 07 Apr 19 6.06pm

Interesting thread.

I've still got a soft spot for Slavisa Jokanovic. I remember wanting him when Parish was trying to replace SA and hoping Fulham wouldn't get promoted so he'd be free.

I know Fulham had a poor season but I don't think its fair to pin it all down to him. He didn't have good enough defenders and they bought far too many players.

There must be other young smart managers out there - the thing is after FdB I think Parish will be very risk adverse when he makes his next decision. He certainly will not push Roy out after a mid-table finish.

 

xomnea Flag 07 Apr 19 6.50pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Dean Kiely our next manager' by Midlands Eagle

About 15 years ago when he was still playing for Charlton, I met him at a golf club I worked at on a Saturday as a youngster.
I tell you this story as I can’t even muster an opinion on the farcical idea we’d consider him for the top job.

 

jjsperling Flag 08 Apr 19 5.40am

So many people on this thread saying that they want managers from the championship or the Scottish Premiership. Why would you want that. Roy offers us stability. To be fair I do agree that we should be far higher up the table and that we might benefit from a different manager. But that manager must be a step above Roy not below.

For Me,

1. Rafa
2. Laurent Blanc
3.Claude Puel
4. Slaven Bilic

Edited by jjsperling (08 Apr 2019 5.40am)

 

hastingseagle67 Flag 08 Apr 19 8.33am

Originally posted by PeatlingPalace

Is Newcastle to Palace a different level?

I suggested Benitez because I think he has proved himself with no funds (and has obviously already done it with funds/big teams). So with our limited budget I think he could be the perfect manager and may even make players like AWB think twice about leaving

And for the record I really like Roy and think what he has achieved for us has been excellent. This is the first premier season where I have not been sweating over all the fixtures & permutations from the start of April

Ok home form has been a bit s***, but away form has been magnificent. We are Palace and I think mid table is currently our level. We wont get in the top six, so for me 7th to 10th is the target. There have been times this season when we have played the best football I have seen in my 44 Palace years

My only complaint about Roy is that he is too loyal to players not in form (e.g. Benteke or Schlupp) but he has limited options in our squad and players respect is critical for a manager.

Yes I would say that Newcastle are on a different level to us. Not the playing staff so much at the moment, but infrastructure, stadium, fanbase, history and global identity without a doubt. The only way I could see Rafa coming to us would be if the Americans sold to an Abramovich type. If that were to happen along with investment in playing staff, Trophies, European football and a giant leap in support, then we might be on the same level as Newcastle. Incidentally, I would hate for any of that to happen as I like being a smaller friendlier club.

 


has resisted writing a single post on the Ross McCormack thread !!!

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 08 Apr 19 8.57am

There was quite an interesting discussion on 5 live about managers the other day suggesting that the top managers often only move clubs after a period of unemployment. Pep was on a sabbatical before going to City, Klopp was unemployed before Liverpool etc.

Clubs seem increasingly unwilling to shell out composure for managers despite being happy to pay big bucks for players.

So our next manager as indeed Roy was may not have a club.

 

hastingseagle67 Flag 08 Apr 19 9.11am

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

There was quite an interesting discussion on 5 live about managers the other day suggesting that the top managers often only move clubs after a period of unemployment. Pep was on a sabbatical before going to City, Klopp was unemployed before Liverpool etc.

Clubs seem increasingly unwilling to shell out composure for managers despite being happy to pay big bucks for players.

So our next manager as indeed Roy was may not have a club.

Although not in my top three choices, one that I'd consider is David Wagner who as you say is currently without a club. He has some premier League experience and I have heard that he is respected amongst the sports journalist community. I would be slightly worried that he walked away from Huddersfield when the going got tough though.

 


has resisted writing a single post on the Ross McCormack thread !!!

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 08 Apr 19 11.33am

Originally posted by hastingseagle67

Yes I would say that Newcastle are on a different level to us. Not the playing staff so much at the moment, but infrastructure, stadium, fanbase, history and global identity without a doubt. The only way I could see Rafa coming to us would be if the Americans sold to an Abramovich type. If that were to happen along with investment in playing staff, Trophies, European football and a giant leap in support, then we might be on the same level as Newcastle. Incidentally, I would hate for any of that to happen as I like being a smaller friendlier club.

If you were to read the sniping that goes on on this board on a regular basis and between different factions of supporters you would think we are anything but a friendly club, however I understand your sentiment.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 08 Apr 19 4.44pm

Graham Potter would be a decent bet. Young and on the way up - ideal for Palace. If he can bring McBurnie with him so much the better.

McBurnie looks a bit strange but is developing into a really decent No9.

 

est1905 Flag 08 Apr 19 4.54pm

Originally posted by hastingseagle67

Although not in my top three choices, one that I'd consider is David Wagner who as you say is currently without a club. He has some premier League experience and I have heard that he is respected amongst the sports journalist community. I would be slightly worried that he walked away from Huddersfield when the going got tough though.

Of losing....

 

est1905 Flag 08 Apr 19 5.06pm

I just don't understand the obsession with Wagner. He did well in the Championship to scrape into the play offs. His first season in the Premiership he did very well. That's largely because he and his team were an unknown quantity, were written off and under estimated by many people and they had a game plan which for a while worked.
Once they had been figured out it was always going to be game over because Huddersfield have not got the quality to turn a game and their tactics became transparent.
As soon as this became clear (as well as the fact that excessive fouling, diving, etc was no longer having any impact) Wagner walked, presumably to protect his reputation as a manager that hasn't been relegated. Problem is though that they were rock bottom when he left and although results may not have improved since he left performances certainly have so I'd say Wagner most definitely must take a large slice of responsibility for Huddersfield's relegation.
Don't get me wrong, I think once they'd been figured out even Pep would not have been able to save them but that still doesn't mean he has done anything to warrant being in demand in the best league in the World

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 08 Apr 19 5.06pm

Originally posted by hastingseagle67

Although not in my top three choices, one that I'd consider is David Wagner who as you say is currently without a club. He has some premier League experience and I have heard that he is respected amongst the sports journalist community. I would be slightly worried that he walked away from Huddersfield when the going got tough though.

I would agree with this. There was a really good interview with him in the times on saturday. Well worth reading.

 

est1905 Flag 08 Apr 19 5.08pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

I would agree with this. There was a really good interview with him in the times on saturday. Well worth reading.

Oh well, if he interviews well........

 

KAOS Flag In a tree 08 Apr 19 5.10pm

Personally I don’t think we have to look that far for Roy’s replacement. We are blessed with options proper Palace people waiting in the wings:

Frank De Boer – warrants a 2nd chance for being Dutch and those Jim Bergerac chinos
Alan Pardew – warrants a 2nd chance for being a flash c*nt & that dance @ Wembley
Dougie Freedman – loyalty personified and his transfer dealings of late have been first class
Jim ‘The Racist’ Cannon – just the kind of character who would spark up an international dressing room
Julian Speroni = he’s got no FA coaching bags, he’s not even our goalkeeping coach BUT he bleeds red & blue and has an eaterie in the main stand

 

Page 2 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Best three replacements if Roy steps down