You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > James McCarthy
November 16 2026 5.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

James McCarthy


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
FairweatherEagle Flag London 08 Aug 19 9.44pm

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

Sick note for Everton bit I agree with but not bang average.. nearly every Everton supporter you speak to will tell you that IF he stays fit he is a quality player.

This is the impression I get too from Everton fans. We'll have to see if he's still got the same level of mobility as he did in his prime.

Absolutely awful signing video though - the club actually deleted it! Still floating about somewhere on the internet though.

 

YT Flag Oxford 08 Aug 19 9.51pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

3 million quid, Coulsdon Eagle.

That is 3 Sorloths.
Get a grip man. Jordon Mutch was more expensive.

You absolutely cannot sign proven experienced premier league players for 3 million.

This is a good signing, despite the risk, because of the cost.

It is not a "shocking signing" this is fanciful. Its not Neymar but again, it is 3 million pounds. He is 28 years old. Yes he has had injuries but calling him bang average is also pretty nonsensical. He is a well respected proven premier league footballer.

I think you might think you support Barcelona, you dont.

When Palace sign players like McCarthy, they aint bang average son, they are Palace average.

Arithmetic never your strong point, then?

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Maine Eagle Flag USA 08 Aug 19 10.40pm

Originally posted by YT

Arithmetic never your strong point, then?

I did a mathematics class at college here but had my now ex wife do it for me - remote learning, baby!

Good shout.

3 million - you can only get 1/3 of a Sorloth for that!

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 09 Aug 19 12.17am

People that are claiming it's 3m are wrong its a deal up to 8m so again we have gone and over paid.

total for this window is around 11-12m if you include fees and add ons doesn't look like good business again.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

coulsdoneagle Flag London 09 Aug 19 12.17am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

You like a good thrust, Willo.

Some fans are never happy. I am the first to criticize Parish and have for years, but there is nothing wrong at all with this signing and time will prove me correct.

People who slate a signing like this dont understand football to my money.

Oh and you are bang on about a right back but dont forget Wardy can do a job there.

You talk about people not understanding football and then you go on to say Ward can do a job there. Joel is a hero but would struggle in the championship. He is nowhere near PL quality, on top of that the only cover we have is playing a CB out of position.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 09 Aug 19 3.30am

Originally posted by Sansbup

"One Jimmy Mac, there's only one Jimmy Mac"...... D'oh.

Ha. Genuinely quite funny.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 10 Aug 19 5.50pm

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

You talk about people not understanding football and then you go on to say Ward can do a job there. Joel is a hero but would struggle in the championship. He is nowhere near PL quality, on top of that the only cover we have is playing a CB out of position.

Played pretty well today, didnt he.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 12 Aug 19 3.27pm

Originally posted by Sansbup

"One Jimmy Mac, there's only one Jimmy Mac"...... D'oh.

James McArthur, James McCarthy ... just imagine if we still had Paddy McCarthy and Alex McCarthy.

 

becky Flag over the moon 12 Aug 19 4.00pm

Originally posted by Pete53

James McArthur, James McCarthy ... just imagine if we still had Paddy McCarthy and Alex McCarthy.

Just nickname one 'a*se and the other 'elbow' - sorted!

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 12 Aug 19 4.15pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

You like a good thrust, Willo.

Some fans are never happy. I am the first to criticize Parish and have for years, but there is nothing wrong at all with this signing and time will prove me correct.

People who slate a signing like this dont understand football to my money.

Oh and you are bang on about a right back but dont forget Wardy can do a job there.

I am certainly not alone in thinking that a right-back was a priority.
Ward is an honest professional who can do a job there but he will be viewed as a weak link by PL teams.

If before the season started I had predicted that Ward would be first choice at right-back, we would not be signing any strikers and would spend aprox £7 Mill in the transfer window many would have concluded that I had either taken leave of my senses or engaged in a wind-up to stimulate debate on HOL !

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 12 Aug 19 4.27pm

Originally posted by Willo

I am certainly not alone in thinking that a right-back was a priority.
Ward is an honest professional who can do a job there but he will be viewed as a weak link by PL teams.

If before the season started I had predicted that Ward would be first choice at right-back, we would not be signing any strikers and would spend aprox £7 Mill in the transfer window many would have concluded that I had either taken leave of my senses or engaged in a wind-up to stimulate debate on HOL !

Plenty would have believed you. I'm not even sure we spent 7 mil. The fees are probably in installments. Having one right back and Kelly seems ridiculous, but we went nearly a season with no left back so we had to even things out.

 


Red and Blue Army!

YT Flag Oxford 12 Aug 19 4.56pm

Originally posted by Willo

I am certainly not alone in thinking that a right-back was a priority.
Ward is an honest professional who can do a job there but he will be viewed as a weak link by PL teams.

If before the season started I had predicted that Ward would be first choice at right-back, we would not be signing any strikers and would spend aprox £7 Mill in the transfer window many would have concluded that I had either taken leave of my senses or engaged in a wind-up to stimulate debate on HOL !

Which doubtless would have evolved into another 'Willo thread'!

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 12 Aug 19 5.04pm

Originally posted by YT

Which doubtless would have evolved into another 'Willo thread'!

Heaven forbid!

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 12 Aug 19 5.14pm

Originally posted by grumpymort

People that are claiming it's 3m are wrong its a deal up to 8m so again we have gone and over paid.

total for this window is around 11-12m if you include fees and add ons doesn't look like good business again.

Forever trustworthy eh grumpymort

If you are correct, I assume that we only pay £8m if McCarthy plays plenty of games. If he does, that would indicate he was a good signing and a strong player. If so, £8m is fine.

If he proves to be a sicknote our exposure is £3m.

So it DOES look like good business.

In any case the fee was undisclosed. However:

''BBC Sport journalist David Ornstein has said on Twitter that Crystal Palace are only paying £3m to bring Everton midfielder James McCarthy to Selhurst Park, in what is a surprise update given other contrasting reports. However, Ornstein has disagreed with the Daily Mail – and another report by Sky Sports – by saying the deal is actually worth £3m. Whether that is simply the upfront fee with further add-ons included is unclear.''

Perhaps you can enlighten us as to the exact nature of the deal please grumpymort. We can then update Wikipedia.

 

YT Flag Oxford 12 Aug 19 5.58pm

Wouldn't it be good to at least let the man put on a Palace shirt a few times before we judge him?

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 12 Aug 19 6.02pm

Originally posted by YT

Wouldn't it be good to at least let the man put on a Palace shirt a few times before we judge him?

That’s what I hate about you YT. You always come on here and start talking sense

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 12 Aug 19 6.38pm

Does anyone know how he played today?

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 12 Aug 19 6.40pm

Originally posted by DANGERCLOSE

Does anyone know how he played today?

There is a link to a review on the landing page

Apparently well.

 

lush1076 Flag leatherhead 12 Aug 19 7.15pm

He was ok. Tired in the second half.
Camarasa was good first half but again got tired in the second.
Cahill was good and looked match fit.
McGregor caught the eye as the stand out youngster.
Lokilo was sloppy in possession.
Daly may struggle with his size to make any impact.
Pierrick was quiet.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 12 Aug 19 7.21pm

Originally posted by lush1076

He was ok. Tired in the second half.
Camarasa was good first half but again got tired in the second.
Cahill was good and looked match fit.
McGregor caught the eye as the stand out youngster.
Lokilo was sloppy in possession.
Daly may struggle with his size to make any impact.
Pierrick was quiet.

I looked at this without knowing the u23 today.
I thought it was a pop at Roy's use of new players on Saturday.
Although it could easily fit a Saturday opinion

 

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > James McCarthy