You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > var
November 22 2026 7.32pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

var


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 13 Aug 19 11.44am

Originally posted by Willo

I have to say that I am a bit uncomfortable with the offside aspect of VAR whereby one can be given offside by the length of a toe.

In cricket, if an umpire in a LBW situation gives 'Not out' because he believes the ball is missing the stumps but technology reveals it would have just brushed the stumps, the 'Not out' stands'. I think that over half the ball needs to touch the stumps for the decision to be overturned.

Perhaps there should be a similar stance with VAR under the umbrella of a 'Clear and obvious error'.It cannot be a 'clear and obvious error' if the assistant deems a player is onside and it is revealed that he was offside by a hair's breadth.

Edited by Willo (13 Aug 2019 11.07am)

Completely agree.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 14 Aug 19 11.05am

Originally posted by YT

Sorry if I'm late to the party, but I thought var was only supposed to be used in four specific scenarios, and that those scenarios didn't include goalie not on line/defender encroaching at a penalty. What's happening?


Correct. That is a decision for the ref. and there is no referral to VAR for that.

 

Invalid user 2019 Flag 14 Aug 19 10.14pm

Originally posted by Ghostship

It is ridiculous that someone can have a goal ruled out as their shoulder was offside things like this make it a farce and in a close call like that advantage should go the attacking player.

You just know that at some point Palace will get screwed over by this

We'll be seeing plenty of this s*** all year. Maybe a year or two down the line VAR will be be used more sensibly, but expect this year to be a car crash.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 14 Aug 19 10.25pm

VAR was not designed to rule out what would pre-VAR been perfectly good goals.It was designed to eliminate clear and obvious errors.
I really do not think that supporters wish to see goals disallowed where fractions of an inch are involved.

 

pompeyeagle Flag Relocated to Shropshire 14 Aug 19 11.04pm

Like Gary Neville said imagine a whole season where every offside decision is correct. Surely that's a good thing.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 14 Aug 19 11.25pm

Originally posted by pompeyeagle

Like Gary Neville said imagine a whole season where every offside decision is correct. Surely that's a good thing.

When a margin is that tight, do we know for sure that the technology is accurate enough to rule definitively one way or t'other?
In cricket the umpires decision recognises the fact that there is a margin of error involved in the technology and gives the benefit of doubt to the umpire.

Edited by Willo (14 Aug 2019 11.26pm)

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 19 Aug 19 11.02am

Very Interesting Back page and article in the Mail on Sunday yesterday...

[Link]

Basically VAR is massively flawed and there is a 13cm margin of error, when it is making decisions on much smaller margins than this, for instance 2.4cm in the Raheem Stirling goal Vs West Ham.

It is utter bollox and not only are the decisions being made wrong, it is killing the atmosphere, the game and the enjoyment of it.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 19 Aug 19 11.07am

And as for the disallowed Jesus goal for Man City Vs Tottenham.

Since when has accidental handball ever been an infringement?!
It was only brought in this year because of VAR and the decisions over Goal or No Goal.

Furthermore accidental handball is only deemed an infringement when a goal is scored and not at other times during the game or when deciding on whether to award a penalty or not (Via VAR)

Utter nonsense!

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 19 Aug 19 11.24am

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

And as for the disallowed Jesus goal for Man City Vs Tottenham.

Since when has accidental handball ever been an infringement?!
It was only brought in this year because of VAR and the decisions over Goal or No Goal.

Furthermore accidental handball is only deemed an infringement when a goal is scored and not at other times during the game or when deciding on whether to award a penalty or not (Via VAR)

Utter nonsense!

I actually agree that goal should be disallowed. If the ball didn’t hit the Man City hand then the ball wouldn’t have been diverted to Jesus to score. Arms and hands aren’t used for football so teams benefiting with goals scored after the arm or hand has helped the goal happen is wrong. And no, clear accidental handball by the defender shouldn’t be a penalty, unless the shot is going on target.

However, with regards to the killing of atmosphere and football, sadly I agree. I thought it would be good to get the right decisions but it takes too long, it’s used for too Man things and it’s a sport that rests on a few goals and usually one very important goal. Tennis has hundreds of points, cricket has 10 wickets and rugby has a few tries per side with penalties thrown in and rarely are the games that tight by score line.

 


COYP

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 19 Aug 19 12.59pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I actually agree that goal should be disallowed. If the ball didn’t hit the Man City hand then the ball wouldn’t have been diverted to Jesus to score. Arms and hands aren’t used for football so teams benefiting with goals scored after the arm or hand has helped the goal happen is wrong. And no, clear accidental handball by the defender shouldn’t be a penalty, unless the shot is going on target.

However, with regards to the killing of atmosphere and football, sadly I agree. I thought it would be good to get the right decisions but it takes too long, it’s used for too Man things and it’s a sport that rests on a few goals and usually one very important goal. Tennis has hundreds of points, cricket has 10 wickets and rugby has a few tries per side with penalties thrown in and rarely are the games that tight by score line.

I can't argue with that Rudi.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 19 Aug 19 1.26pm

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

Very Interesting Back page and article in the Mail on Sunday yesterday...

[Link]

Basically VAR is massively flawed and there is a 13cm margin of error, when it is making decisions on much smaller margins than this, for instance 2.4cm in the Raheem Stirling goal Vs West Ham.

It is utter bollox and not only are the decisions being made wrong, it is killing the atmosphere, the game and the enjoyment of it.

Tho this is what every fan/media wanted because of Sky. Slo- mos so many different camera angles the the fans could see & witness. The ref got 1 view.

Now you've got it & already you don't like it. Be careful for what you wish for, springs to mind.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 19 Aug 19 1.30pm

It will not work well in its current format and it won't be long until fans have had enough.

The introduction was to prevent 'clear and obvious' errors, such as the Henry handball against Ireland and the Freddie Sears phantom goal, which in fairness don't happen too often, as fouls and handballs are usually subjective. Goal line technology is great as there is no grey area.

For the rare occasion there is a 'clear and obvious' error, a VAR system would be effective with a review system - 1 per review per captain per game.

The saddest part is that we will reach a point where we can't celebrate the goal because we're waiting for a confirmation 10 seconds later, by which point the moment of euphoria has passed.

People can live with minor refereeing errors, they tend to even themselves out over a course of a season anyway. I don't buy into the nonsense that bigger clubs get preferential treatment.

From what I've seen so far, there have been some horrendous refereeing decisions going against what everyone else can see - e.g. the handball decision given against PSG last season against United.

It works better in other sports due to the stop/start nature. Checking every goal/penalty decision is killing it for the fans.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 19 Aug 19 1.43pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

It will not work well in its current format and it won't be long until fans have had enough.

The introduction was to prevent 'clear and obvious' errors, such as the Henry handball against Ireland and the Freddie Sears phantom goal, which in fairness don't happen too often, as fouls and handballs are usually subjective. Goal line technology is great as there is no grey area.

For the rare occasion there is a 'clear and obvious' error, a VAR system would be effective with a review system - 1 per review per captain per game.

The saddest part is that we will reach a point where we can't celebrate the goal because we're waiting for a confirmation 10 seconds later, by which point the moment of euphoria has passed.

People can live with minor refereeing errors, they tend to even themselves out over a course of a season anyway. I don't buy into the nonsense that bigger clubs get preferential treatment.

From what I've seen so far, there have been some horrendous refereeing decisions going against what everyone else can see - e.g. the handball decision given against PSG last season against United.

It works better in other sports due to the stop/start nature. Checking every goal/penalty decision is killing it for the fans.

Good post. Totally agree.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 19 Aug 19 4.40pm

Originally posted by eagleman13


Tho this is what every fan/media wanted because of Sky. Slo- mos so many different camera angles the the fans could see & witness. The ref got 1 view.

Now you've got it & already you don't like it. Be careful for what you wish for, springs to mind.

TBF I don't think they did. I certainly didn’t want VAR and have always said as much. I’d much rather the game be played and officiated as it always has been.

Yes there will still be contentious decisions but work to improve the standard of the officials in order to reduce these mistakes to a minimum and just get on with it.

Goal line technology has been great but the rest of it is just a dogs dinner at the moment.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 19 Aug 19 4.41pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

Good post. Totally agree.

Ditto

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 19 Aug 19 9.35pm

f***ed it again.
Keeper moved off his line.
Surely they could see that.
New rules broken and not pulled up.
Not hard to see and the ref can blow straight after the kick.

 

Invalid user 2019 Flag 19 Aug 19 9.48pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

It will not work well in its current format and it won't be long until fans have had enough.

The introduction was to prevent 'clear and obvious' errors, such as the Henry handball against Ireland and the Freddie Sears phantom goal, which in fairness don't happen too often, as fouls and handballs are usually subjective. Goal line technology is great as there is no grey area.

For the rare occasion there is a 'clear and obvious' error, a VAR system would be effective with a review system - 1 per review per captain per game.

The saddest part is that we will reach a point where we can't celebrate the goal because we're waiting for a confirmation 10 seconds later, by which point the moment of euphoria has passed.

People can live with minor refereeing errors, they tend to even themselves out over a course of a season anyway. I don't buy into the nonsense that bigger clubs get preferential treatment.

From what I've seen so far, there have been some horrendous refereeing decisions going against what everyone else can see - e.g. the handball decision given against PSG last season against United.

It works better in other sports due to the stop/start nature. Checking every goal/penalty decision is killing it for the fans.

100%. It's an undeniably useful technology that is going to be seriously overused, and may well upend the season in one way or another.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 19 Aug 19 10.10pm

Originally posted by dollardays

100%. It's an undeniably useful technology that is going to be seriously overused, and may well upend the season in one way or another.

Upend football

 

Invalid user 2019 Flag 19 Aug 19 10.18pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Upend football

I doubt you're far wrong. I think they'll make serious changes to it at the end of the season though, but it will have made a farce of things in the interim.

 

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 20 Aug 19 11.28am

Maybe it is their way of getting us to appreciate the ref and assistant refs more.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > var