You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Team for Sheff Utd
November 16 2026 5.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Team for Sheff Utd


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
YoDougie Flag London 13 Aug 19 12.21pm

Originally posted by Fatherken

only 2 changes from Saturdays game
Wilf for Ayew although unlucky as he played a very good at the weekend
Anyone for PVA

Well, I'm glad we have a natural back up for him to compete for that spot

 

pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 13 Aug 19 12.36pm

Originally posted by Fatherken

only 2 changes from Saturdays game
Wilf for Ayew although unlucky as he played a very good at the weekend
Anyone for PVA

I'm good thanks.

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 13 Aug 19 12.39pm

I am looking forward to seeing Camarasa play and I would hope that against one of the newly promoted teams, or at least in the second half, we'll play a more attacking side. Certainly seemed to be the case last weekend.

Camarasa for McArthur? Unfair to McArthur. Or Max? Again unfair. Then maybe for Ayew.

I am keen to see Max Meyer have a good run of games.

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 13 Aug 19 1.15pm

Conservative he certainly is, too conservative perhaps yes. He also seems extremely loyal to players in general.
However you making out he is a nitwit who barely knows what he is doing is extremely harsh.
Still and forever deserves credit for keeping us up after my compatriot messed us up a few seasons ago and I doubt anyone could do a better job with the current squad.

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Not the Hodgson we've come to know! He's not a horses for course man, he's a "if I play exactly the same way 38 times in a row, I'll get a result 33% of the time and we'll stay up" kind of boring coach.
He'll start the same 11 again, perhaps dropping someone for Wilf.

Injury or disobedience are the only factors that make him change a starting player.


 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 13 Aug 19 1.53pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Not the Hodgson we've come to know! He's not a horses for course man, he's a "if I play exactly the same way 38 times in a row, I'll get a result 33% of the time and we'll stay up" kind of boring coach.
He'll start the same 11 again, perhaps dropping someone for Wilf.

Injury or disobedience are the only factors that make him change a starting player.

Most of what you say I agree with.

Hodgson has spent much of his career with limited resources and has found a way to win a certain number of games so until Palace shake the money tree for him why would you change that. Yes it's percentage football but his record kinda speaks for itself.

Most managers have a certain way of playing both Klopp and Guardiola will only play one way regardless of the results, they are fortunate to be at clubs that back their style with money.

 


One more point

PatrickA Flag London 13 Aug 19 3.01pm

Agree about Roy’s conservative approach which has given him a long and relatively successful career.
He’s unlikely to change now.
There is a nagging part of me that would like to see him exploring a formation which involves Zaha, Camarasa and Meyer but I just don’t see him accommodating them all in his starting line up.
A manager such as Brendan Rodgers would probably attempt to do this but the system would probably be too open for Roy.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 13 Aug 19 3.16pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Agree about Roy’s conservative approach which has given him a long and relatively successful career.
He’s unlikely to change now.
There is a nagging part of me that would like to see him exploring a formation which involves Zaha, Camarasa and Meyer but I just don’t see him accommodating them all in his starting line up.
A manager such as Brendan Rodgers would probably attempt to do this but the system would probably be too open for Roy.

Yes, eventually I would like to see Camarasa and Meyer as the wide midfielders and Townsend up top with Wilf, but that is just my opinion.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 13 Aug 19 7.32pm

Originally posted by Nobbybm

Oddly enough, Luka said the opposite of this in an interview last week:

“Roy is a very experienced manager on one side – he loves to play on results. He uses his team to get as many points as he can get from every single game. Roy tries to adapt to the opponents to get the points.

Marco Silva has one kind of philosophy. He tries to use that philosophy in every single game – he doesn’t love to change, to adapt to the opponent. He has his philosophy and plays his way – the same."

I was surprised.

Ray Lewington gave a very revealing interview to the effect of Hodgson is a creature of habit and values obedience above everything else.

Danny Murphy and other former players hsve said his training sessions were always the same.

Luka is proving he's obedient and trotting out the party line I reckon. Anyone with working eyes can see Roy's inflexibility.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 13 Aug 19 7.35pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Most of what you say I agree with.

Hodgson has spent much of his career with limited resources and has found a way to win a certain number of games so until Palace shake the money tree for him why would you change that. Yes it's percentage football but his record kinda speaks for itself.

Most managers have a certain way of playing both Klopp and Guardiola will only play one way regardless of the results, they are fortunate to be at clubs that back their style with money.

I was calling for his head last season, but after yet another summer of the board proving it's bargain basement or f*** all I admit I see no merit in sacking the Wodge. He's perfect for the board's ambition of scraping survival on zero investment. I just can't buy into it and can't pretend to be happy about it.

1 draw down, another 37 to go.

 

EddieMac Flag 13 Aug 19 7.40pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

I was calling for his head last season, but after yet another summer of the board proving it's bargain basement or f*** all I admit I see no merit in sacking the Wodge. He's perfect for the board's ambition of scraping survival on zero investment. I just can't buy into it and can't pretend to be happy about it.

1 draw down, another 37 to go.

I think he is a marvelous manager Chris and that we are blessed to have him. Also you may think I am mad but I dont find our football remotely boring or defensive. We are rigid and stick to a system but we are nothing like Newcastle, Brighton or Burnley last year.

Our main issue is that we just have no one to stick the ball in the back of the net and that can't be blamed on Roy.

I hope he's with us for a few more years,

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 13 Aug 19 7.54pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

I think he is a marvelous manager Chris and that we are blessed to have him. Also you may think I am mad but I dont find our football remotely boring or defensive. We are rigid and stick to a system but we are nothing like Newcastle, Brighton or Burnley last year.

Our main issue is that we just have no one to stick the ball in the back of the net and that can't be blamed on Roy.

I hope he's with us for a few more years,

Opportunity missed as far as I'm concerned . His absolute refusal to drop out of form players (PVA especially) or adapt to opposition (Brighton and Watford especially) means that we missed our best opportunity to challenge for a top 8 finish last season. I agree regarding the strikers to an extend, but it's also clear that finishing isn't being worked on enough in training. Nor are set pieces which we've become criminally wasteful with.
This season, the board failed to get a striker (Maupay I think is going to prove a "what could've been" player) nor have we any sensible, premier league standard, options at right back. Without this backing Roy is our best option. Going to home games is going to remain a no go for me!
Ideally a new manager comes in after Roy's contract runs down, having secured our survival with a few games to spare, and the board back him in the market.

Cynically, Roy will get an extension, one more quality player will go and not be replaced and it's a continuation of the funeral march to the inevitable relegation, just like Stoke, West Brom, Fulham etc who's boards took the same approach in years gone by.

Still though, roll on celebrating 8 seasons of clinging on whoop whoop!

 

Wilbraham413 Flag 14 Aug 19 3.51am

I'd like to see Camarasa in for JMac. The rest of the lineup can stay the same.

Camarasa and Meyer might be able to actually get the ball to our forwards.

Ideally, we'd have better options up front than Ayew and Benteke, but we don't. I may be willing to try Wickham over Benteke, but he was crap when he came on against Everton. Wickham is the size of a pro wrestler. I think he's taking something other than vitamins.

 


2017 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Middlesboro
2018 Jan. (Sako) Palace 1 - 0 Burnley
2019 May (Batshuayi, Batshuayi, OG, Van Aanholt, Townsend) Palace 5 - 3 Bournemouth
2020 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Newcastle

sprites Flag Auckland 14 Aug 19 4.14am

Originally posted by Wilbraham413

I'd like to see Camarasa in for JMac. The rest of the lineup can stay the same.

Camarasa and Meyer might be able to actually get the ball to our forwards.

Ideally, we'd have better options up front than Ayew and Benteke, but we don't. I may be willing to try Wickham over Benteke, but he was crap when he came on against Everton. Wickham is the size of a pro wrestler. I think he's taking something other than vitamins.

One of our best, most consistent and hardworking players over the last few seasons? Wouldn't recommend it.

 

dannyboy1978 Flag 14 Aug 19 7.18am

Originally posted by Willo

Hodgson will of course take account of how Sheff Utd set-up and this might influence his thinking.

In the Championship, Sheff Utd were very adventurous with their centre-halves coming forward and overlapping which of course was unique and they engineered overloads in wide areas so if they still deploy such tactics in the PL we could well be tested down the flanks unless of course we play 2 up front and occupy their central defenders.Sheff Utd used to play 3 central defenders in the Championship.

The prem is all about counter attacking, that system could fail miserably

 

YT Flag Oxford 14 Aug 19 8.49am

Originally posted by sprites

One of our best, most consistent and hardworking players over the last few seasons? Wouldn't recommend it.

It's all about the next game, of course.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

EddieMac Flag 14 Aug 19 9.04am

Originally posted by sprites

One of our best, most consistent and hardworking players over the last few seasons? Wouldn't recommend it.

I agree and I thought he was excellent on Saturday against Everton. I am struggling to see where Camarassa is going to get a run in this team witchout a complete change from Roy. I wouldnt be holding my breath on him starting anytime soon.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 14 Aug 19 9.16am

I think Roy does tweak his set up before games, but always within his framework. Most managers are the same. What is Klopp fundamentally changing from one match to the next? Not much.

Roy sets things up so that we have attacking periods in a game (usually with good penetration) and spells where we defend as a team. It suits us.

We need to be careful what we wish for.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 14 Aug 19 9.24am

Originally posted by EddieMac

I agree and I thought he was excellent on Saturday against Everton. I am struggling to see where Camarassa is going to get a run in this team witchout a complete change from Roy. I wouldnt be holding my breath on him starting anytime soon.

Were you at the game Saturday?

I love Jimmy Mac as much as the next guy. Always works hard, been fiercely loyal to the cause and often produces bits of class beyond what you'd usually expect of him.

Was awful on Saturday though.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

EddieMac Flag 14 Aug 19 10.01am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Were you at the game Saturday?

I love Jimmy Mac as much as the next guy. Always works hard, been fiercely loyal to the cause and often produces bits of class beyond what you'd usually expect of him.

Was awful on Saturday though.

He was awful on Saturday was he?? I will have to disagree with you on that. He had a job to do and he did it very well. Breaking up play in the middle of the park. He did no wrong on Saturday.

I think his days are numbered due to his lack of pace but he is a solid player. If anyone is going to replace Jimmy Mac then it is going to be James Mccarthy. If he can stay injury free then a lot of people are going to be very surprised with what he have signed. He is a hard tackling no nonsense type of player which is what we havn't got.

 

Omph Flag Liverpool 14 Aug 19 10.22am

Originally posted by EddieMac

He was awful on Saturday was he?? I will have to disagree with you on that. He had a job to do and he did it very well. Breaking up play in the middle of the park. He did no wrong on Saturday.

I think his days are numbered due to his lack of pace but he is a solid player. If anyone is going to replace Jimmy Mac then it is going to be James Mccarthy. If he can stay injury free then a lot of people are going to be very surprised with what he have signed. He is a hard tackling no nonsense type of player which is what we havn't got.

Agree on McCarthy. This was the player Kouyate was supposed to be but he never quite came through. If he can win enough ball in the centre of the park that could make a deal of difference to the side. One of the chief beneficiaries would be Meyer/Camararasa in the ten slot if we play that system with Benten up top and Wilf and Townsend wide. It would give us another point of attack.

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Team for Sheff Utd